Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Drowning Pool (Vintage Crime/Black Lizard)” as Want to Read:
The Drowning Pool (Vintage Crime/Black Lizard)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Drowning Pool (Lew Archer #2)

4.01 of 5 stars 4.01  ·  rating details  ·  2,980 ratings  ·  102 reviews
Lew Archer, a private detective, is hired by Maude Slocum to investigate a poison pen letter, but when Archer arrives he discovers her mother-in-law drowned in the family pool.
Paperback, 244 pages
Published June 3rd 1996 by Vintage Books (first published 1950)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Drowning Pool, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Drowning Pool

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Stieg LarssonAnd Then There Were None by Agatha ChristieAngels & Demons by Dan BrownRebecca by Daphne du MaurierIn Cold Blood by Truman Capote
Best Crime & Mystery Books
291st out of 5,028 books — 11,248 voters
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Stieg LarssonThe Shadow of the Wind by Carlos Ruiz ZafónThe Name of the Rose by Umberto EcoThe Girl Who Played with Fire by Stieg LarssonAnd Then There Were None by Agatha Christie
Best Literary Mysteries
99th out of 946 books — 2,104 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
This is a swimming pool:
Swimming Pool
What is it good for? You can use it to show your social status (I challenge anybody to find a mansion of a really rich person without one). You can drown the old ladies in one - the kind which everybody hates and who sits on piles of money her close relatives can really use. Finally you can just swim in there. Let us talk about the second case.

Lew Archer is a private detective who makes his humble living mostly collecting evidence for divorce cases. This time a frightened
Bill  Kerwin

This is the second book in the Lew Archer series, and with it MacDonald has produced the first of his many first-class mysteries. Archer is hired to to track down a writer of blackmail letters, but soon the waters become murkier: someone drowns in an actual pool, and Archer's investigation of the murder reveals how the survivors are caught in an undertow of family wounds and crime.

Archer shows us three effective portraits of women: an upper class lady who tightly controls her passions, her haunt
Cathy DuPont
I’m such a fan of hard-boiled; can’t seem to get enough of it. This is only my second Ross Macdonald and enjoyed it as much as the first. That translates to a lot, mucho, beaucoup, πολλά, multus, הרבה, viele!

It’s the writing, I know, so clean, sparse is the word I like to use. The dialogue is on target, always, the plot is such that the reader is never sure who the bad guys are since they keep flipping, excepting Lew Archer, P.I., of course, private investigator extraordinaire.

While other P.I.’
An easy read, full of descriptions of seedy places and seedier goings on, Archer is always quick with a quip and a smart simile or metaphor but it all feels so perfunctory; twist here, contrivance there, two-faced dame, crooked police, lying client, woman in peril, a couple of thugs for the protagonist to beat up, corporate mogul villain, two separate plots tie magically together by the end. Not a classic by a mile.
Ed [Redacted]
Another good, very good in fact, novel from Macdonald. About equal in quality with The Moving Target. The plotting is adequate, the story moves along nicely. Good dialog, etc. etc. The best thing about the first two novels is the character of Lew Archer. Archer is the epitome of the hard boiled, tough talking, wise cracking private detective. For an example, I will turn to a page randomly for a wisecrack*.

Archer, upon confronting someone he had shot in one arm earlier in the book, "I swung the
Jayaprakash Satyamurthy
This is the second novel by Ross Macdonald I've read and I'm not really impressed. He can write - there are some great descriptions, some witty observations and quips, even a few similes that aspire to Chandlerian status. But the plot is all over the place and I'm not sure the prose makes up for it as it does in Chandler's best novels. There's a lot of woman-hating dressed up as condescending chivalry and Macdonald's depiction of a pair of crypto-gays (he never comes right out and says that's wh ...more
Sep 17, 2011 Mike rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Anyone
More Ross Macdonald. More Lew Archer. More great American crime/detective writing.

I've read three novels and a collection of short fiction my Mr. Macdonald (nee' Kenneth Millar) now and I remain impressed. I'm still shocked that I had been unaware of this author (except for one excellent short story) for so long - thank you Goodreads! Whether he is writing in s style that reminds one of Dashiell Hammet (some of the early short fiction) or in his fully-developed style of later years, he is an exc
Ben Winch
I can see why this is a classic – on the level of craft it’s quite formidable – but it just didn’t sock me in the guts like Goodis or Thompson, and its debt to Chandler is a little too obvious. Still, I’ll bet Macdonald’s dependable: I’ve only read one other Archer novel but it was much like this one, dull and brilliant in equal measure, and so smooth I slid to its end without pause. In places, true, he overplays his hand, gets a little too poetic and lapses out of character, but when he gets it ...more
Nancy Oakes
Maybe a 3.75 on this one. The Drowning Pool is Ross Macdonald's second book in his Lew Archer series, but it's my first foray into this author's work. After this book, I think that Archer is a guy I will enjoy reading more about. With eighteen series novels and two short story collections, there's a lot about this world-weary gumshoe to explore.

Lew Archer is called upon to investigate an anonymous poison pen letter sent to his client, Maude Slocum. Maude's beyond worried about her mother-in-law,
Phillip Thurlby
Dec 11, 2013 Phillip Thurlby rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Lovers of Classic Crime
For me, as should be the case for all crime writers and readers, I use the holy grail that is Raymond Chandler as a measure of an Author's quality.

This is unfair for most authors as the quality that Chandler created in his Marlowe Mysteries is something beyond the reaches of much less than a deity. However, one of the closest contenders is Ross MacDonald.

I first read this book when I was in University and I will admit that its brilliance escaped me at the time. I knew it was good, but I could no
I’m still fairly new to the world of Ross Macdonald and Lew Archer, but I’ve greatly enjoyed what I’ve read so far. This one starts with poison-pen letters and speeds quickly to dead bodies, femme fatales and gangsters. Of course, this being Macdonald, there’s a lot more psychological insight than one would normally find in this type of thriller. Pacy, well plotted with great descriptions and synonyms, this book is up there with Chandler – and, in my world, there’s no higher praise than that.
Sean Brennan
I actually prefer the writing of MacDonald to Chandler, albeit Marlowe and Archer are not just cut from the same cloth they could possibly have been separated con-joined twins. MacDonald himself can finish the review, because this single paragraph contains all you one needs to know. Excellent.

I felt like a lonely cat, an aging tom ridden by obscure rage, looking for torn-ear trouble. I clipped that pitch off short and threw it away. Night streets were my territory, and would be till I rolled in
M.L. Rudolph
1950. Maude Slocum opens this tale at the doorway to Lew Archer's office. "Thirty-five and still in the running," the detective surmises. Maude is scared. She's intercepted a letter to her husband calling him a cuckold. Who would send such a letter and why? She hires Archer to find out.

Archer drives north of LA to the fictitious community of Quinto, next to the oil town of Nopal, where the Slocums live on property awash in oil. Slocum's mother-in-law refuses to let the big oil company ruin her l
Victoria Mixon
Mystery writer Ross Macdonald was the husband of mystery writer Margaret Millar, which automatically makes their household my dream household. And I've read and liked Macdonald's The Undeground Man.

But I'm afraid The Drowning Pool doesn't measure up. For all the great potential tension in unexplained secret relationships, the father-who's-not-a-father (that "secret" isn't really a secret), not to mention that wonderful ancient hacienda, there's too many weaknesses in this one for a pro: too much
I don’t want to say I disliked this novel, but I was overall unimpressed with it compared with others I've read lately. Lew Archer is a tough, smart character, but he’s not as rough or interesting as Mike Hammer or Philip Marlowe for example. The story really got going about a third into it, but up to that point I was actually bored. The prose isn't always on-par with the best hard-boiled writing in my opinion.

The story follows private eye Lew Archer, he's contacted by Maude Slocum who wants him
Ross Macdonald's reputation is that he took the noirish, hardboiled private detective story pioneered by Dashiel Hammett and refined by Raymond Chandler, to psychological depths they only hinted at. A Euripides to their Aeschylus and Sophocles, as it were. If that's true, then that transformation took place in his subsequent Lew Archer novels. In The Drowning Pool he's still in Chandler mode, though there are hints of what's to come.

A beautiful woman, Maude Slocum, walks into Archer's office and
Unlike the recent Thompson book The Grifters (set in the same time period and locations) which I found a bit too Dostoevsky-like, Ross MacDonald delivers well crafted, excellently plotted novels that leave one little to doubt as to the skill of this author. Many a writer of mystery/crime novels have MacDonald on their favorites reading list (I researched this, and in fact came to MacDonald because of this).

Unlike Burke who brings a certain sense of literature to his Robicheaux novels, MacDonald'
If, like me, you had hardly given mystery a second glance while you were forming your literary taste, you should read this book (or any of MacDonald's Lew Archer novels - this is actually the second). There are so many incredible books out there to be digested, I didn't feel I had the time or mental space to waste on detective fiction. But if you know me, you'll know I've changed my tune in recent years. And if you want to change your tune, too, you could do a lot worse than start with Ross MacD ...more
Trixie Fontaine
Definitely entertaining and there were things I appreciated a lot that I didn't anticipate, but those things (an environmentalist sensibility) set me up for disappointment with the save-a-ho agenda ("get a DECENT job"???) which I would have accepted without batting an eyelash given the genre and age of the book if it hadn't been for the relatively progressive thoughts in other arenas.

Still, I may give Ross MacDonald another shot because a) I vaguely recall reading a short of his that I loved (mi
Jul 22, 2013 Ann rated it 3 of 5 stars
Shelves: mystery
Lew Archer is right up there with Philip Marlowe and Sam Spade at the top of the Californian world-weary private eyes. In this novel from 1950 he is hired by a the curvaceous Maude Slocum, who has intercepted a letter threatening to tell her rich but weak husband about her indiscretions. Lew feels hamstrung by the fact that she refuses to give him any information, and shows up in her town to see for himself. He quickly realizes the Slocum household is toxic with secrets, resentments and greed, W ...more
Christopher Fulbright
These Lew Archer books are top notch and this one may be the best of the five or so that I've read in the series so far. Ross Macdonald has a way of using that fine old hardboiled style like casting an artful spell. People have done it before, but few people have done it better, so it winds up powerful magic indeed. Archer is a likable tough guy with a code of honor, and, in this book in particular, the character has a way of making insightful observations about people and life that really catch ...more
Nick Tramdack
The plot of this early Ross Macdonald novel isn't too different from many other 1950s private eye stories. What lifts it above the pack is Macdonald's voice - clearsighted, snappy, and somehow ethical at the same time... not that private eye Lew Archer considers himself better than others, but that he holds everybody to the same standard and comes out often worse. A kind of humanist noir.

You get "LITERARY" lines like: "her cheeks faintly hollowed as if she had been feeding off her own beauty" in
Jason Shaffner
Huh, probably the strangest ending (in a satisfying way) of any PI novel I've read. It gives nothing away to say it ends with a fistfight and a handshake between the combatants. Strange, but so is the book. Slow at first, a bit scattered throughout, yet somehow pleasant. Lew Archer novel and he's an interesting blend of thug, punching-bag, and Sherlock. I like him.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
This is the second in the Lew Archer series. I liked it quite a bit and I am seeing some parallels in MacDonald's works. There are some recurrent themes such as lost innocence of youth, escalating violence, and broken adults with twisted lives.
The Crime Scene Scene
The Drowning Pool is the second novel in the Lew Archer series by author Ross MacDonald. Archer is hired by a woman to investigate a libellous letter she has received. But he is soon drawn into a murder investigation when the mother in law who lives with them is found drowned in the pool at the house. Suspicion immediately falls on the chauffeur but Archer is not so sure.

Lew Archer is generally considered to be a bit of a rip off to Raymond Chandler's Philip Marlowe and the like.Read the full re
Rebecca McNutt
Ever seen that 2012 film Sinister? The one where SPOILER ALERT the family in 1965 is tied down to lawn chairs at night and drowned in their own backyard swimming pool?


Well, reading The Drowning Pool really had me thinking back to that. This little nostalgia-ridden novel is creepy as heck and a really intriguing, suspenseful mystery. I bought the movie tie-in edition from the Seventies, so now I want to track down the movie to watch because this book was great! It's chilling, the characters are c
A classic and a very good read!
#39: The Drowning Pool by Ross MacDonald:

She closed her eyes. From the places where it was pinned to the durable bone, the flesh of her face fell in thin slack folds. The folds made dark lines slanting downward from the corners of her closed eyes, the wings of her nose, the edges of her jaw, deep charcoal shadows cartooning dissolution.

I said goodnight and left her.

Synopsis: Lew Archer's hired by the middle generation of a really dysfunctional family, two generations of which are killed. Archer'
Rog Harrison
Over thirty years ago I had enjoyed the stories about Hammett's Continental Op and Chandler's Marlowe and these led me on to the Lew Archer series by Ross Macdonald. When I saw several of the Lew Archer novels in the library I decided to borrow them all. This is the second in the series and I am not sure if I have read it before. The plot is very complicated and I confess some of it did not not make sense to me. For example on page 49 of the 2012 Penguin edition he wrote,

"A fat man with a croppe
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Empty Copper Sea (Travis McGee #17)
  • The Big Knockover: Selected Stories and Short Novels
  • Playback
  • Night Has a Thousand Eyes
  • The Wrong Case
  • The Grifters
  • Double Indemnity
  • The Selected Stories of Patricia Highsmith
  • The Rise of Life on Earth
  • Shoot the Piano Player
  • The Big Clock
  • The Hot Spot
  • The Long-Legged Fly (Lew Griffin, #1)
  • Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye
  • Miami Blues
Ross Macdonald is the pseudonym of the American-Canadian writer of crime fiction Kenneth Millar. He is best known for his series of hardboiled novels set in southern California and featuring private detective Lew Archer.

Millar was born in Los Gatos, California, and raised in his parents' native Kitchener, Ontario, Canada, where he started college. When his father abandoned his family unexpectedly,
More about Ross Macdonald...

Other Books in the Series

Lew Archer (1 - 10 of 20 books)
  • The Name Is Archer
  • The Moving Target
  • The Way Some People Die
  • The Ivory Grin
  • Find a Victim
  • The Barbarous Coast
  • The Doomsters
  • The Galton Case
  • The Wycherly Woman
  • The Zebra-Striped Hearse
The Chill The Galton Case The Moving Target The Way Some People Die The Blue Hammer

Share This Book

“There was nothing wrong with Southern California that a rise in the ocean level wouldn't cure.” 30 likes
“He had pink butterfly ears. The rest of him was still in the larval stage.” 5 likes
More quotes…