What Went Wrong? The Clash Between Islam & Modernity in the Middle East

What Went Wrong? The Clash Between Islam & Modernity in the Middle East

3.39 of 5 stars 3.39  ·  rating details  ·  1,272 ratings  ·  147 reviews
For centuries, the world of Islam was in the forefront of human achievement -- the foremost military and economic power in the world, the leader in the arts and sciences of civilization. Christian Europe was seen as an outer darkness of barbarism and unbelief from which there was nothing to learn or to fear. And then everything changed. The West won victory after victory,...more
Paperback, 186 pages
Published January 7th 2003 by Harper Perennial (first published 2001)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,313)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Lena
Jul 30, 2007 Lena rated it 5 of 5 stars Recommends it for: People interested in Politics, History, and Cultures
Excellent book, although a little hard to read at times. It sheds light on the current day conflicts between Western culture and Middle Eastern culture by presenting the history between the two. Basically, the Middle East was more technoligically advanced while Europe was in the "dark ages", and therefore Middle Easterners developed a predjudice against the "backward" Europeans. But even though Europe caught up with and even passed the Middle East in technology, Middle Easterners never let go of...more
Eric
In this sleek and informative book, noted Middle East scholar Bernard Lewis examines the interaction between the Islamic world and the West. It's a fascinating and illuminating book.

At one time, the Muslim world was the richest, most powerful, and culturally advanced civilization on the planet. The Muslim empire encouraged education and learning, treated its minorities reasonably well, traded with its neighbors, and conquered every army it faced.

Because of its obvious superiority, the Muslim wo...more
Valdeir
Interesting and informative book. I began reading this book with a negative view of the author because of previous work I've seen from him, mainly excerpts and small articles. They presented to me a person who was very racist towards Middle Easterners and who firmly believed in Western Imperialism Supremacy over the Middle East region. After reading this book, I have changed my view point into a more positive because of how he delivered his information. Even though I still noticed a certain supr...more
Louise
What went wrong? The Middle East, once a power to be reckoned with, is now noted for its poverty, political weakness and the under-education of its people. Some say it is the fault of outside powers. Professor Lewis looks deeper, seeing this not as a cause but a symptom. He explores why the region was vulnerable to those outside powers.

He notes that some have considered the causes to be military, economic and/or political weaknesses. Attempts to modernize in these areas have met with military fa...more
Dale
Not the best of Bernard Lewis

Published January 24th 2002 by Oxford University Press, USA
Hardcover, 192 pages


I've read two other books by Lewis and found both of them to be much more comprehensive and satisfying than this one. My dissatisfaction stems from the title. The title What Went Wrong? implies a discussion of how the Islam world went from being the most advanced culture on the planet to one of the most insular and, in many ways, most backwards cultures on the planet. While such a discuss...more
Sam Norton
Before I even start to read this I just want to say "Wow!" It takes a lot of fortitude (though not necessarily an equal amount of brains) to title your book about Islam "What Went Wrong." I'm pretty sure this is exactly what Edward Said is talking about in "Orientalism."



-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Just as I expected, an extremely judgmental look at the Middle East and Islam. This is absolutel...more
Bojan Tunguz
As many other readers have suggested, this is not Bernard Lewes' best work, and it is a bit of a failure in one important respect: it doesn't answer the rhetorical question from the title. Lewis is much better at describing historic events and finding out insightful and important tidbits of information than he is at deeper analysis. This is quite understandable, since he is a historian of the old school and neither political nor social scientist. Nonetheless, this is a fascinating and interestin...more
Roger Burk
This is a capsule history of Islamic civilization in the Middle East from about 1500 to the present, with an emphasis on how from the late 1600s it fell further and further behind the West in wealth, culture, and military might. Lewis puts the blame on a myopic and inward-turning culture that took hold in the region. When European universities established chairs of Arabic and Persian, no European language was studied in the Ottoman or Persian realms. Europeans travelled often to the East and wro...more
Jon
I picked this book up because a) subject matter is fascinating to me in my endeavor to understand the Middle East better and b) it claimed to be a New York Times Bestseller. I found it to be alarmingly boring. Evidently it was an aggregate of a series of lectures that Bernard Lewis performed and therefore far too scholarly for my tastes. The writing was exceptionally dry. His conclusion in my opinion is spot on and does tie the preceding chapters together well, but the bulk of this book did not...more
Will
"The changed relationship may be seen in a simple example, that traditional Middle-Eastern indulgence, a cup of coffee. Coffee originally came from Ethiopia. It was brought up both shores of the Red Sea, through Arabia and Egypt, to Syria and to Turkey, and then exported to Europe. Sugar came from Persia and India. For a long time, both coffee and sugar were imports to Europe, either through or from the Middle East. But then the colonial powers found that they could grow coffee and sugar more ab...more
Scott
Very interesting, though dizzyingly fast tour through about 800 years of Middle East history and the interactions between Islamic and Western cultures. The book focuses on comparing the Islam of the past - at the forefront of freethinking tolerance and scientific inquiry - to the present - a culture that long ago fell behind its Western neighbors/competitors in terms of innovation and human rights. It's a massive topic that the book blazes through in about 160 pages, which leaves a lot of explan...more
Arjun Mishra
Overall, this was an enjoyable and engaging book. Middle-Eastern history is fascinating and new to me. I have started reading Bernard Lewis because I found him all over Samuel Huntington. Chapters 4 and 5 on secularism and civil society are illuminating and the two best chapters. However, I had many quibbles and problems with the book.

Lewis did not deal with the Middle East or Islam as monolithic since he divided it into Turkish, Arabic, and Iranian, but the book lacked nuance and detail in that...more
Khalid Ismail
In this book Bernard Lewis discusses the transfer of power from the Ottomans in the East to the Europeans in the West explaining in details the beginning of the inclination era in the Islamic empire after Vienna siege and the impact of peace treaty of Carlowitz on the political relations between the two sides.

It is really obvious that Lewis knows a lot of Middle East and Middle Eastern history more than the Middle Easterns themselves, but he is biased. Throughout the book, he indicates that the...more
Absurdfarce
While filled with rich historical detail this slender volume never really attempts to come to grips with the question contained in it's title. Professor Lewis describes an early Islamic culture open to others, noting in rich detail the role that this culture played in preserving many Greek and Roman classics when the western empire was overrun by the "barbarians". By the 18th and 19th century this culture had simultaneously fallen behind the surging West and turned inward. Attempts were made to...more
David
On this 10th anniversary of 9/11, I remember the impact that this book had on me in 2002.

1,000 years ago, Muslim culture was superior to that of Europe. The failed Christian Crusades were followed by Islamic conquest of most of the then-known world. By 1600, that superiority had been reversed ... why? The Ottoman Empire (the remnants of Muslim conquest that once included Spain, India and much of Southern Europe) dwindled, but lasted until nearly 1920.

The book details the decline of a once-grea...more
Daniel
This fascinating, insightful examination of the Middle Eastern psyche is a indespensible introductory guide to those desparate to understand why the West seems so hated by the Middle East, especially in light of events of the last decade.
Lewis examines the issues from a historic and economic perspective, with a keen insight on the shifting sands of power, knowledge and culture that ultimately led to the fall of the Middle Eastern nations from pre-eminence in the light of Western ambition, and ho...more
Muzaffaralirana
Good book with little biased view for Muslims, but a good book for reading the point of view of Christians or a Christian writer that what created the current scenario regarding the change in attitude of the West regarding the Muslims.
Alex
Bernard Lewis sometimes gets a little gleeful in his recollection of the breakdown of the great Muslim empire of the teen centuries A.D., but overall, he provides a great look into, to me at least, a history that is rarely or never discussed.

Coming into Lewis' book, I was ignorant to the rise of the Muslim empires and their subsequent decline as Europe and its monarchs came to power. Especially in these days of cultural rifts between the West and the Middle East, this book needs to be read by an...more
Shannon Quinn
This book was interesting and informative about middle eastern culture and how and why it is what it is today. It's organized in a way that makes it repetitive and boring. And while the first three chapters are on topic -- what went wrong -- it feels like the last third drifts and loses focus. The afterword, which explained that chapters 1-3 were taken from speeches given, and the last from separate writings, really explained why there was not a cohesive narrative. Maybe if I'd read that in the...more
David
As with and Bernard Lewis book, excellently researched with a sweep of history that allows him to connect dots separated by hundreds of years. However there was no point of view in the central question of the title-- what went wrong? For example, much detail on the Islamic worlds scientific preeminence in the early Middle Ages and then their retreat from it but no compact theory for why. It seemed that Lewis wanted to blame lack of church/state separation and suppression of women as the main cul...more
Chris
I'd give this book 3.5 stars. First off, the book is interesting and informative. It looks at a lot of ways that Islam has clashed with Modernity and Westernism over the past 1200 years or so. It's also a short book, providing a good overview and references if you are inclined to dig into an area more deeply. The problem is that the book delivers much less than it sells. I'm excusing the author completely for the what 9/11 did to the expectations for a book with this title (the book was complete...more
Carlos Alonso-Niemeyer
Lewis is one of the best authors to write about the Middle East. I admire the culture surrounding Islam. I had the honor to work with various persons who live in the Middle East and are proud of their culture and traditions. They are spiritual and enigmatic. This book provides a very good explanation of what has happened during the past 100 years.
One of the main reasons for some of the disparities between the west and the Arabic world is the fact that woman have not been able to participate in...more
Matthew Moes
This was an interesting book; food for thought... But there is no CLASH between Islam and modernity anymore than anything else is clashing - perhaps "clashing" is modernity - noisy, consumptive, disgruntled "clashing". At least, that's what Future Shock was about in the '70s. Personally I think Charles Le Gai Eaton is more on point about this issue in his book "Remembering God". In sum, we need alternatives. Modernity is not delivering on any of its glittering promises. The biggest mistake Musli...more
Arlene
I find this book very informative, and oddly readable.

I learned that there is a difference between "modernity" and "westernization." It made sense to me for the first time that the Islamic world wants to "modernize" (build buildings, engage in commerce, have wealth and success), and yet resists western ideas of democracy, separation of "church" and state, and most of all equality of women. Previously, I was just confused by what appeared a chaotic value system visa-vie the western world; I knew...more
Jeffrey
Analysis of Islamic civilization since the Middle Ages and why these societies moved from the pre-eminent scientific, economic and military power in the world to fall far behind the European powers of the West. The book delves deeply into the difference between Eastern and Western concepts of the boundaries between religion and government/law; the sources of Eastern unwillingness to adopt new ideas from the West; and the gap in scientific and military innovation between East and West. A fascinat...more
Allison
A high rating because I feel like it's enlightening history to be aware of. It seems a little disjunct, as a book, but then I read the acknowledgements and it was given as public lectures at different times, between 1999 to 2001 and published in 2002. So it also has the disadvantage of being out of date already, but there's plenty in there to get your mind thinking, and as it was written by an expert in the field for more than seventy years. Definitely recommended for anyone who might be interes...more
Kristin
Perfect short summer read. Great if you're interested in supplementing other books on Islam and the West. Lewis is from the "old guard" so some of his premises or thesis may seem a little antique, but they are supported heavily with well researched material.

I gave it three rather than 4 starts because he focuses much of his evidence around Turkey; which as we know is far more "modern" than other Islamic countries in the Middle East. I'm not sure if his hypothesis would have been easily support i...more
Simon Cleveland
After reading `What Went Wrong? : The Clash Between Islam and Modernity in the Middle East', I was impressed with Mr. Lewis' level of detail and clarity of writing on topics such as religion and modernity. Now, after completing `The Middle East', I'm reminded yet again of his talent to construct detailed historical account of the political, religious and socio-economic aspects of life in that region. In this latest book, Mr. Lewis examines the major factors leading to the complexity of issues pl...more
Cameron Etchart
This book is an interesting look at why the Middle East (and the Muslim mindset) did not succeed on the world stage. It is an interesting book, although I would not have read it if not for being a required school book, I am glad I read it (albeit quickly). Sometimes the author's evidences are weak, although many are well thought out. I wished the last paragraph of the book (re how the failure affects modern terrorism/Middle Eastern relations/war) would have been a chapter, left me wanting the im...more
Chris
Lewis is incredibly insightful as he traces the (often one-way) flow of ideas between east and west up through the 20th century. Given Western propensities for meddling in Middle Eastern affairs, criticism to my taste needs to walk a thin, respectful line in order not to come off as victim blaming. Lewis treads this line well; through harbingers of culture and society such as music, literature, science, etc. he reasons why modernity has been slow in reaching the Middle East. Of the many factors...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 77 78 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
What Went Wrong? Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response (Hardcover)
أين الخطأ ? التأثير الغربي واستجابة المسلمين
What Went Wrong? Western Impact And Middle Eastern Response
What Went Wrong? (Paperback)
أين الخطأ ؟ التأثير الغربى واستجابة المسلمين (Paperback)

12314
Bernard Lewis, FBA (born May 31, 1916) is a British-American historian, scholar in Oriental studies, and political commentator. He is the Cleveland E. Dodge Professor Emeritus of Near Eastern Studies at Princeton University. He specializes in the history of Islam and the interaction between Islam and the West, and is especially famous in academic circles for his works on the history of the Ottoman...more
More about Bernard Lewis...
The Crisis of Islam: Holy War and Unholy Terror The Middle East The Assassins: A Radical Sect in Islam The Arabs in History The Multiple Identities of the Middle East

Share This Book

Your website
“Secularism in the Christian world was an attempt to resolve the long and destructive struggle of church and state. Separation, adopted in the American and French Revolutions and elsewhere after that, was designed to prevent two things: the use of religion by the state to reinforce and extend its authority; and the use of the state power by the clergy to impose their doctrines and rules on others. This is a problem long seen as purely Christian, not relevant to Muslims or for that matter to Jews, for whom a similar problem has arisen in Israel. Looking at the contemporary Middle East, both Muslim and Jewish, one must ask whether this is still true -- or whether Muslims and Jews may perhaps have caught a Christian disease and might therefore consider a Christian remedy.” 4 people liked it
“In 1940, we knew who we were, we knew who the enemy was, we knew the dangers and the issues," he told me when I pressed him for a reading of the struggle against Islamic radicalism. "In our island, we knew we would prevail, that the Americans would be drawn into the fight. It is different today. We don't know who we are, we don't know the issues, and we still do not understand the nature of the enemy.” 4 people liked it
More quotes…