Mating in Captivity: Reconciling the Erotic and the Domestic

Mating in Captivity: Reconciling the Erotic and the Domestic

3.79 of 5 stars 3.79  ·  rating details  ·  605 ratings  ·  112 reviews
" Why does great sex so often fade for couples who claim to love each other as much as ever?
Can we want what we already have?
Why does the transition to parenthood so often spell erotic disaster?
Does good intimacy always make for good sex? "

Ether Perel takes on these tough questions, grappling with the obstacles and anxieties that arise when our quest for secure love c...more
Hardcover, 272 pages
Published September 5th 2006 by HarperCollins Publishers (first published 2006)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Opening Up by Tristan TaorminoThe Good Vibrations Guide to Sex by Anne SemansThe Clitoral Truth by Rebecca ChalkerThe Ultimate Guide to Anal Sex for Women by Tristan TaorminoGuide to Getting It On! by Paul Joannides
Best Nonfiction Sex Books Ever!
11th out of 72 books — 27 voters
The Five Love Languages by Gary ChapmanThe Dance of Anger by Harriet  LernerIf the Buddha Dated by Charlotte KaslThe Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work by John GottmanThe Good Vibrations Guide to Sex by Cathy Winks
Sex, Love & Intimacy
106th out of 115 books — 37 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,523)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Taka
Interesting, but not very practical--

The main argument of the book is this: intimacy begets comfort and boredom, distance unpredictability and excitement. Pretty commonsensical stuff, but when applied to marriage, it can be a powerful principle.

Most couples experience an increase in boredom as they become intimate and comfortable with each other and they start to yearn for the excitement. This transition is not only emotional but biological: a man's testosterone levels plummet after his wife giv...more
John Ryan
Do you feel lost, frustrated, confined or disappointed with your sex life? Does sex feel like a chore? Has the rugrats' arrival sucked that sexual impulse out of ya? Or maybe relations has morphed over the years from what seemed spicy and fresh into a short menu of the same ol' sauces and meats? Do you wonder if this is the inevitable result of being married/together with the same person for years? That you just have to "grow-up" and accept it?

Esther Perel, in "mating in captivity: unlocking ero...more
kareem
If you're in a long-term relationship, or ever want to be in one, you must read this book.

It tells you how to have the security, stability, comfort, etc that are requirements for a healthy a LT relationship while at the same time creating the uncertainty, mystery, and risk that are requirements for passion.

The author is a therapist in NY and draws on cases to illustrate her points. It's engaging, the topic is fascinating, and Perel has some refreshingly smart suggestions for maintaining or rec...more
Mike Smith
This book challenges the assumption that sexual desire and eroticism inevitably decline in a long-term committed relationship. Author Esther Perel is a couples therapist with over 20 years of experience. Raised in Belgium and trained in Israel before moving to the U.S., Perel brings an outsider's perspective to the strange mix of attitudes and behaviours that characterize American (and, by almost certain extension, Canadian) relationships.

Her basic premise is that we crave both the security and...more
E.C. McCarthy
This book is so much more erotically charged than the "50 Shades" fictional nonsense. Perel offers great insight into human desire -- for love, sex, connection, space -- and how we tend to thwart the very intimacy we crave by applying judgement to our desires. I haven't read a better reason to be hopeful that long term relationships can maintain, even increase, passion and desire than this --

"The counterargument to the law of diminishing returns is the principle that consistent investment leads...more
Jeffrey Otto
Reconciling Cliche and Popular Sociology

On a crowded bus last week, my eight year old son couldn't help but inquire about the title of Esther Perel's debut book, "Mating in Captivity : Reconciling the Erotic and the Domestic." What's "mating" mean, dad? And "cap-tiv-i-ty?"� With numerous ears besides his own eager to hear my reply, I resorted to cheap humor that passed by him as surely as hot sex passes by Perel's patients throughout this book. "Mating."� I told him, "is finding someone to love...more
Emily Jane
I wanted this to be the answer to the last couple of fights I've had with my partner. The subtitle is "Reconciling the Erotic and the Domestic", and so I'd hoped that this would help me understand why it is we fight with the one we love most, and how to prevent real problems before they happen. This is, after all, what the book promises to do.

But, unfortunately, it really falls short. Because while the author gives numerous anecdotal accounts of how this couple or that was able to reignite the f...more
Mo Tipton
I'm still not entirely sure what I think about this book. On one hand, it's incredibly fascinating. Perel offers page after page of marvelous insights as to why it can be so hard to sustain passion in a long-term monogamous relationship, and so much of what she said seemed original in comparison to other books I've read on the topic.

On the other hand, I found it difficult to take the information presented in the book and figure out how to apply it in my own relationship. Perel's solutions invol...more
Crystal
I read this for school and it was awesome! Perel’s ideas transcend modern thinking and give a fresh approach to methodologies and a different lens for viewing relationships. This book challenges ideas about sex and sexual attitudes. The author was not born in the U.S. so it is not surprising she has some new ideas to bring to the table. I guess my review doesn't tell you much so just read this book, I think anyone could get something out of it.
Paolo Gianoglio
Ho letto questo libro nella sua edizione italiana, che per pigrizia non inserisco in GR. Premetto che non lo avrei mai letto se non fossi stato consigliato da un'amica terapeuta. Ciò anche a causa del titolo italiano (l'intelligenza erotica), che sebbene concettualmente non errato, ricalca la serie delle "intelligenze" tanto di moda dopo Goleman, e fa quindi pensare all'ennesimo espediente di marketing per vendere un volume in più. In realtà il titolo originale è (per l'appunto) più originale: M...more
Julie Flynn Badal
Perel's main thesis is well-taken: Increased intimacy in healthy relationships does not always lead to increased passion. In fact, intimacy can hinder passionate exchanges between partners. But I stopped reading this book in the third chapter because of its redundant nature. I didn't have the patience to read yet another case study that proves Perel's point but resolves very little.
Dr. Ben
Mating in Captivity is simultaneously a self-help sort of book and an analysis of U.S. culture, particularly with regards to long-term relationships and their relationship (or lack thereof) with the erotic. Perel brings up interesting points, particularly with regards to how people tend to desexualize their long-term committed partners by seeing them as totally known, unmysterious entities (she words it better than I do). That said, there are other points about the book that bugged me: Perel goe...more
The Book Maven
There were a lot of good tips and insights in this book. The author explores the question of why committed romantic partners often lose their sexual attraction for each other. The author's basic premise is that the security, stability, comfort, and familiarity that we seek out in romantic partnerships are actually the elements which kill off our erotic desires. For eroticism to thrive, the author contends, there needs to be mystery, separateness, other-ness; intimacy and familiarity are the comp...more
Laurel
my feelings about this book are all over the map. at times I fervently agreed and at others I had a knee-jerk feeling of dissent which I had difficulty articulating. I guess I don't buy fully into the premise that eroticism and passion are diminished by intimacy, but I'm humble enough to admit that my thoughts on this may change over the years. anyway for the thoughtful analysis and for the good suggestions contained within, I'm comfortable giving Mating in Captivity 4 stars while reserving the...more
Giorgos
Nov 18, 2012 Giorgos rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Giorgos by: Heather
After setting a framework that emphasises the balance between closeness and distance in sexually intimate relationships, much of the book's message rests on the premise that predictability and familiarity - engendered by excessive emphasis on bonding - kill passion. The solution? Individuals in relationships should ruthlessly preserve their individuality, in spite of the separation anxiety that might cause, and allow enough distance to preserve the "otherness" that attracted them in the first pl...more
The Center for Sexual Pleasure & Health
Mating in Captivity: Reconciling the Erotic and the Domestic has been translated into 24 different languages and examines issues of intimacy and sex in married and/or long-term couples. Perel is a practicing AASECT certified sex therapist in New York City and a well-known voice on couples and sexuality across cultures. She has been a guest on numerous television shows as well as featured in The Washington Post, The New Yorker, and Vogue, among others.

The book opens with a poem by D.H. Lawrence e...more
Lynda
The author is a European, kink-and-alternative-lifestyle-friendly relationship therapist. It was quite refreshing to have her non-judgmental viewpoint on most issues of sexuality. She maintains throughout the book that in order to develop intimacy between two people, there needs to be some separateness. Which is a problem in this American society where our mate is supposed to be everything to us. There's a struggle in finding another person erotic and sexy when there's too much comfort and secur...more
Joni
I read this several years ago and remember it being a paradigm shifter for me. The main thing I took away from it is that we expect too much from our spouse, who is, after all, only one person. He/she cannot be our "best friend," confidant, protector, object of our frustration, safety net, and also passionate lover.

I am now going back to re-read because I've been reminded of it while I am reading "Sex at Dawn: How We Mate, Why We Stray, and What It Means for Modern Relationships."

In that book,...more
Michelle
This is a good book for anyone who:
1. would like to be in a successful romantic relationship.
2. is in a successful romantic relationship.
3. would like to remain single forever.

My therapist recommended I read this book, I believe, because I am a little one-sided on the idea that "romantic relationships" and "true happiness" do not co-exist. I'm not sure reading this changed my mind, but the author, a NYC psychologist, definitely has many an interesting thing to say about relationships, why they...more
Shirley
This was gift from Helene so we could read it together, and because she knows I believe in women's empowerment to be able to talk about sex and love.

Perel focuses on maintaining desire in a relationship, using the lens of the balance of security and autonomy - people often sacrifice all their autonomy and sense of self in a relationship, which is related to freedom and desire, thinking they must, in order to support the secure, intimate, love of the relationship, but actually, the freedom / des...more
Tim Pendry
Mar 23, 2008 Tim Pendry rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Anyone not entirely happy with their lot
Now this really could be a life-changing book if it hit the right person at the right time. The thesis is simple and powerful and the only problem with the book is that the personal stories pad out a simple message.

What Perel does is undermine the more dumb-ass aspects of the Anglo-Saxon approach to psychological fidelity and relationships in favour of a more European view that permits play, calculated deceit and fantasy in a way that is really quite shocking to contemporary femino-liberalism....more
Shannon
I saw this on a friend's facebook status when she asked for opinions on good books to read. Maybe this one was a joke...but I ripped off her list and read this one. It actually came to me at a great time in my life, considering I hadn't "mated" in quite some time since my boofriend was out of the country. It gave me a perspective on my relationship that I was able to relate to the relationships in the book. The things discussed in the book aren't the norm of conversation with friends, especially...more
Miller Sherling
Very interesting to get a non-American's view of Americans' marital sex/erotic lives. Gave me great perspective on just how much what I think of as personal is actually cultural. By this I do not deny that culture is a part of me, rather, it's good to be reminded just how much of me is from and of my culture. She writes well, & tells good stories. It's not science-based, rather it's anecdotally based, but every bit as useful because it provokes thought & taking a step back from issues th...more
Rosanne
Finally a book that aims to help but doesn't aim to tell you what to do. Perel explains why the fire sometimes (often) dies out in committed relationships, and offers examples of how some couples keep the fire alive, or stoke it every once in a while. The writing wasn't preachy. The book wasn't earth-shattering, but it was insightful. A good, quick read overall.
Luba Moshcovich
Interesting point of view on modern relationships. I particularly appreciated the discussion about presence of fantasies in sexual life of individuals and the issue related to monogamy in the society were we are constantly solicited into freedom of sex.
" erotism is a sexuality transformed by imagination..... It is the cultivation of excitement , a purposeful quest for pleasure" I think this quote resumes very well the whole idea of the book.
Rebecca
I think that this book offers some interesting insight on why things fall apart in relationships, and how people can get them back on track. Perel talks about how different couples she has meet with have dealt with different issues, what works, what doesn't, and how our desires are all different.

I found the chapter on dealing with the US's puritanical views on the erotic to ring true. I felt like it's important to recognize the way we were raised, and move forward. We need to find supportive lo...more
Emma
One of my favorite books. No to erudite to get through, Ms. Perel is a talented scholar and writer. A forerunner of the female sexuality movement with a lot of credentials she writes with aplomb about the melding of the erotic self with our every day self and illustrates that doing this is not only healthy but natural.
Eli Nunez
Enlightening. This is one of those books that make you better, educated, happier, confident and much more if you read this with a very very open mind. Doesn't give you advise nor tell you what's better, it just sets you free... I love it! Finished it in two days. Couldn't stop reading. Totally influencing my life right now.
Shane Moore
Reading this book I soon found myself questioning every aspect of my marriage. Apparently, I should be keeping my wife at a distance or we'll get bored with each other. Maybe I rely too much on verbal communication to express my feelings? Sure, things are great now, but am I setting the stage for an unhappy 2nd act? Would my wife be happier married to someone who doesn't speak English?

I quit. I don't need a book to make me second-guess and doubt the happiest aspect of my life.
Carrie
Super interesting analysis of married relationships and how difficult it can be to reconcile (or maintain simultaneously) friendship, parenthood and domesticity, on the one hand and passion and desire, on the other. Not your typical relationship book. I really recommend it.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 50 51 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Mating in Captivity: Reconciling the Erotic and the Domestic (Paperback)
Mating In Captivity
Mating in Captivity: Reconciling the Erotic and the Domestic (Kindle Edition)
Mating in Captivity
Mating in Captivity: Reconciling the Erotic and the Domestic (Audiobook)

L'intelligence érotique : Faire vivre le désir dans le couple Best Sex Writing 2010 Momentum: Making Waves in Sexuality, Feminism, & Relationships

Share This Book

Your website
“Love is a vessel that contains both security and adventure, and commitment offers one of the great luxuries of life: time. Marriage is not the end of romance, it is the beginning.” 5 people liked it
“Our partner's sexuality does not belong to us. It isn't just for and about us, and we should not assume that it rightfully falls within our jurisdiction.” 4 people liked it
More quotes…