reviews
Feb 12, 2009
I hate giving this such a low rating, because I'm a huge fan of the manga. But I had a few issues with it. First of all, if you don't read the manga, I wouldn't bother. This book would ONLY be entertaining to those who are familiar with the story.
The three stories that appear in it are in true xxxHOLiC fashion; strange, creepy, and thought-provoking. The writing itself (though this could also be chalked up to translating issues) is a bit too passive for my tastes. You'll be reading p More...
The three stories that appear in it are in true xxxHOLiC fashion; strange, creepy, and thought-provoking. The writing itself (though this could also be chalked up to translating issues) is a bit too passive for my tastes. You'll be reading p More...
Oct 20, 2011
Spin-off-и по извести манга заглавия има всякакви и от най-различен характер, но лично за мен това е първи сблъсък с точно подобен тип spin-off и съм приятно изненадана до някъде. В интерес на истината, ако не бях толкова запалена по поредицита на CLAMP, XXXHolic нямаше и да погледна тази новела. Убедена съм, че на голяма част от феновете на мангата тя може да не се хареса особено много, но лично аз се радвам, че успях да я прочета и въпреки това горещо ще я препоръчам на всеки фен на XXXHolic,
More...
Mar 14, 2011
I wish I could give this a higher rating, but I can't in good conscience. This book is essentially broken up into three stories. The first two are quite good and keep the spirit of what we see in the anime/manga series. The third story is the biggest let down. My biggest issue with it was that it bends the rules of the canon a little too much for my liking. Some fans may not like that only Watanuki and Yuko are the only familiar faces, but for this book I think it works well enough. These two ar
More...
Mar 04, 2010
I was surprised when I first learn that xxxHolic has a written novel so I decided to pick it up. I realy like the morals in each of the 3 stories and I have to say that the description of Yuko-san was, somewhat, more cruel and mysterious in Watanuki's view compare to the Yuko-san expressed in the manga and anime.
But overall, this is another great book written by NisiOisiN and I'm looking forward to read more work from him
But overall, this is another great book written by NisiOisiN and I'm looking forward to read more work from him
Dec 10, 2008
This is a very odd one. It feels sort of incomplete, as though not all of the story's being told. Not a problem exactly, but you're left to your own devices to fill in some blanks. It has a surreal kind of feeling, but the characterizations are thin enough that it's a bit hard to care too much. Enjoyable, but certainly not stellar.
Jul 31, 2009
This book was a new way to see the xxxholic series. You got a chance to view the story from the point of view of characters that you never normally would. Additionally it was less comical then usual because you got to see inside Watanuki's head, which gives him more depth then he has in the graphic novel.
Nov 12, 2008
This is a novel written by NISIOISIN, also, based on Clamp's xxxHolic manga. It is also disconcerting to me to read in written words about characters I'm used to learning about through manga/graphic novel form. (Like NISIOISIN's novel about L.)
Like in the manga, this book does teach lessons about people and relationships. Some parts were a little convoluted, (like when Yuko is trying to explain) but I got the overall drift. Good lessons, too... It's a bit shocking to see how.. More...
Like in the manga, this book does teach lessons about people and relationships. Some parts were a little convoluted, (like when Yuko is trying to explain) but I got the overall drift. Good lessons, too... It's a bit shocking to see how.. More...
Jul 25, 2011
I thought this book was really good and i liked the story however it was a little hard to read towards the end and felt like i was dragging myself through mud. If you like the Anime you will enjoy this book.
Nov 19, 2010
I loved Death Note: Another Note, and of course I love this. Thank you NisiOisiN.
Feb 05, 2010
This was quite a bit of a disappointment....I am a big fan of both the manga and anime of xxxHoLic, but this book really fell flat. It was confusing to the point where I couldn't understand it, and the stories were un-engaging and lacked imagination. The only half-way decent one was the second story about the girl and her dead friend. The writing style was lacking and the vivid CLAMP characters were not used to their full potential. All-in-all boring, I only finished because I am such a big
More...
Nov 07, 2008
I was actually impressed, because I learned a few more things about characters that you don't get from the manga. Though I had a strange sense of deja vu when I read the first story, because I'd just seen the anime episode adapted from it!
Nov 15, 2008
So the idea that Watanuki hates Domeki because spirits are trying to keep him away from the exorcist is an interesting one. But overall this was a really weird book and not nearly as compelling as the manga.
May 24, 2010
Kapan2 beli buku aslinya ah ^_^
Dari beberapa cerita yang ada, baru baca 1... Walaupun bukan Ohkawa (CLAMP) yang menulis, tapi kerumitan dan 'twisted plot'nya sama.
Dari beberapa cerita yang ada, baru baca 1... Walaupun bukan Ohkawa (CLAMP) yang menulis, tapi kerumitan dan 'twisted plot'nya sama.
Feb 10, 2012
Feb 09, 2012
Feb 08, 2012
Feb 07, 2012
Feb 05, 2012
Feb 04, 2012
Feb 04, 2012
Feb 02, 2012
Feb 01, 2012
Jan 31, 2012
Jan 29, 2012
Jan 26, 2012
Jan 25, 2012
Jan 24, 2012
Jan 24, 2012
Jan 22, 2012
