Lives on the Boundary: A Moving Account of the Struggles and Achievements of America's Educationally Underprepared

Lives on the Boundary: A Moving Account of the Struggles and Achievements of America's Educationally Underprepared

3.83 of 5 stars 3.83  ·  rating details  ·  520 ratings  ·  65 reviews
Remedial, illiterate, intellectually deficient—these are the stigmas that define America’s educationally underprepared. Having grown up poor and been labeled this way, nationally acclaimed educator and author Mike Rose takes us into classrooms and communities to reveal what really lies behind the labels and test scores. With rich detail, Rose demonstrates innovative method...more
Paperback, 288 pages
Published July 26th 2005 by Penguin Books (first published 1989)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Killing Kennedy by Bill O'ReillyKilling Lincoln by Bill O'ReillyHeaven is for Real by Todd BurpoThree Cups of Tea by Greg MortensonThe Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank
Non-fiction for Fiction Lovers
22nd out of 22 books — 21 voters
Animal Farm by George OrwellSpin Doctor by M.C. LewisCommon Sense, The Rights of Man and Other Essential Writings ... by Thomas PaineThe Prince by Niccolò MachiavelliThe Declaration Of Independence And The Constitution Of The U... by Thomas Jefferson
Must Reads For Politics
13th out of 50 books — 33 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 822)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Lbsantini
This is one of those must-reads for educators and exactly why I didn't want to read it. But I could no longer be a contrarian when my boss gave it to me as a gift. It is a brilliant book that calls for a more socially repsponsible and truly democratic philosophy of education.

In the second chapter Rose talks about how students categorized as slow, remedial, voc. ed or deficient "protect themselves by assuming the implied identities" of such labels--the "I don't care. Screw this bullshit. I just w...more
Chuck
'Lives' is an educator's book. Your reaction to it will depend on what point you are at in your career. If you are just getting started, it's an absolute "must read"--it lays out the human stories of those students who are "underprepared" or "unprepared" for college, and it uses these stories to point out some very solid issues underlying their struggle. It also has some great "how to" teaching moments.

It's doubly credible because Rose writes of himself--he was one of the 'underprepared,' and so...more
Evin Hughes
I feel the purpose of Rose’s book is in the title; he has attempted to create “A Moving Account of the Struggles and Achievements of America’s Educationally Underprepared.” I agree that at the beginning, Rose seemed to be carrying out his purpose for the book by giving us examples of students—a study on students in higher education—with all the statistics that he gives, but then it becomes more. He carries out the purpose of the book by narrating his own personal experiences as a “marginalized”...more
Michael
In his literacy narrative Lives on the Boundary (1989), Mike Rose explores issues of class and educational disparity in regards to literacy. He explains the lack of excitement and engagement he experienced when he was in vocational school, and by chance, he found out he was supposed to be in college track. Once there, education was different and he found the excitement and (luckily) mentorship to push him to go to college. Rose's narrative helps him to question the meritocracy myth of "self-reli...more
Natalie
One of the best books I've read (granted, I'm not an education professional) on the lost/postponed potential of a good portion of American youth who just don't happen to fit narrow definitions of academic ability. A child of Italian Immigrant parents living is South L.A., once labeled as "slow" and who later graduated from LMU with a background in English & poetry, Mike Rose wrote a book that is both poignant and at times vividly poetic. It is difficult in today's climate to shut out the con...more
Maria
Apr 16, 2011 Maria rated it 3 of 5 stars Recommends it for: teachers
Recommended to Maria by: Dr. Flachmann
It took me some thought before I arrived at a ranking for this book: Portions of the text were thought provoking and encouraged me to rethink some of my teaching strategies; other portions caused me to wonder if the author had lost track of his title and the purpose of his book. The first four chapters of the book are a memoir of his life and recount his challenges as a young man in South Los Angeles and his struggles within a curriculum that seemed designed to prevent him from academic achievem...more
Terry
I have to say I think this book is really.... marketed incorrectly. It's really one man's autobiography, or more specifically, one man's intellectual autobiography. While there's nothing wrong with that at all, I feel like the book is pushed as an analysis of, as the subtitle says, the "educationally underprepared". The book is really about Mike Rose, and only incidentally about the educationally underprepared, and as worthwhile a read as that is, the book thus also disappointed me.

I'm also a w...more
Daniel
Jan 24, 2009 Daniel added it
Excellent; his salient point being that "intelligence" is more socially constructed than a biological reality, suppressive educational structures, policies and socioeconomic conditions being the primary catalysts only perpetuating the educational plight of the underprivileged. He mostly gets at this in the final chapter, by which point it's mostly an adumbration of everything he's hitherto said.

One thing I don't get (and he never really says) is how he became an "intellectual", or "organic", if...more
Kristen
This book gave some great insights into the struggles and negative aspects of America's educational system- mainly discussing the pyschological and educational problems with classifying students into levels of skill and the problems with teaching grammar isolated from writing and reading. I found the book to be a relatively slow read, though interesting. It basically detailed the author's educational, teaching, and life history and meandered along the way. It addresses some crucial points and I...more
Paul Haspel
What happens to those in our society whose education has left them underprepared for the demands of modern life? In Lives on the Boundary, UCLA education professor Mike Rose adopts a unique approach in order to offer his answers to that question. Rather than adopting the conventional strategy of the education scholar -- weighty declarations of universal principles, defended in a footnote-heavy manner -- Rose tells his own story in order to lead the reader toward the conclusions Rose wants to dra...more
Mary
I've always thought Rose was a bit of a hippie-dippy, representing the antithesis of the empirical sort of composition studies the economist in me craves. Still, he's doing something for people that the rest of us claim to be rooting for. What good is it for me to champion obscure contrastive rhetorics if the heirs of those rhetorics are denied entry to the academy? I remember being mad when Sharon Crowley as RSA keynote speaker implicated students, administrators, state legislatures as racist,...more
Krys
The three stars are not to indicate the mediocrity of the entire book, but merely an average composed of the scores I would give for the various chapters.

For example, the entire beginning of Lives is devoted to Mike Rose's backstory. And while his own story mirrors the lives of many of the students he later talks about, and is therefor relevant, it doesn't offer anything significantly different, especially in any way that demands three chapters.

Likewise, the end of the book veers into a lot of p...more
Tawny
Apr 04, 2008 Tawny rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Tawny by: Professor Elizabeth Wahlquist
Shelves: literacy
Favorite lines:
1. "Students will float to the mark you set. I and the others in the vocational classes were bobbing in pretty shallow water. . . . But mostly the teachers had no idea of how to engage the imaginations of us kids who were scuttling along at the bottom of the pond."
2. "Every person is, in part, 'his own project' and makes himself."
3. "Kids labeled as marginal have a literate capacity far richer than the numbers in their folders reveal. We set out to determine what a child knows in...more
BeckyTalbot
Blending analysis and memoir (an accomplishment in itself), Mike Rose shows that people who have been shut out of education--called remedial or illiterate--have vast knowledge that the educational structure doesn't tap. By example, he shows that teachers should be open-minded about what their students can accomplish and willing to take the time to work with students on writing and show students how to "pick the academic lock" so that they have the thinking tools to join university dialogues inst...more
KaryC
So interesting to realize how much socio-economic status prepares students for certain paths in life....This teacher worked with adult students as well and became the first person in many of their lives to tell them they weren't stupid or slow. If you pigeonhole a kid long enough, he'll start to believe it. Mike Rose points this out well, plus he writes well enough to make it an interesting read.
Bill DeGenaro
I've read this three or four times over the years and always appreciate Rose's insights about the harm that sorting and placing can visit on students at all levels. I'm teaching the book this semester as an example of a text that melds genres (memoir, critique, social commentary) with confidence and grace. Teachers and interested observers of American education should all have a look at "Lives..."
Tommy
This is the kind of education book that excites me about being a part of this profession. Through personal experience (his own and others'), Mike Rose takes a hard look at the disadvantages faced by students from working-class and immigrant backgrounds, proposing remedies that promote equity without disregarding the hard work that has to happen in order for all students to succeed. Recommended for anyone with an interest in American education (that's all of you, right?).
Sam
Rose goes deep on the descriptive end with his educational anecdotes. He doesn't jump to any easy conclusions, though sometimes it's hard to decipher a policy argument from his observations. Overall, though, his work is an important illustration of the need for qualitative research and observation to contrast with the abundance of quantitative analysis in education.
Mare Grohowski
Overall a great book, worth the high praise it gets. I see this book as a work of teacher research. I wonder if others have seen this connection (why or why not?). I loved the later chapters best (working with veterans, his chapter on remediation, his chapter on boundary crossing). I definitely plan to use this text in my work with student veterans. Glad I read it.
Tom
A rambling, discursive, semi-autobiographical about the author's journey of development as an educator to students challenged by their backgrounds in mainstream education. It seems a long, repetitive walk to get to the punchline that teaching English may be improved by divorcing it from the classic canon.
Roxanne
This is a terrific book. I love how Rose uses his own experiences as both a student and a teacher to discuss education in America. Rose's writing is accessible and entertaining--he has a knack for choosing the right stories to illustrate his points well--while still making a major contribution to the literature.
Karyn
Lives on the Boundary is mostly a collection of character sketches (of Rose's teachers and of his students), some of which are sappy and stereotypical. Interspersed with those are really compelling and fantastic ideas about pedagogy and what education should mean to people and what it can do for people. A good read for any teacher.
Lauren
Reading a review marking the 20th anniversary of its publication prompted me to pick it up. Thought provoking, food for thought about how so many people do not "get" education and the system's ineffective ways of teaching. Reads like an autobiography.
Kim
Rose paints a fantastic but depressing portrait of the American education system. Has very thoughtful and inspiring experiences about how a scary vicious cycle takes its toll on American students. Should be a must-read for ALL EDUCATORS, future and present!
Abigail
This is probably the most interesting education book I have read. Rose does a lovely job mixing in personal stories, teaching stories, educational beliefs, and other sources into a book that is interesting and informative.
Melissa
A great book (mostly memoir) for educators interested in class issues in public education and how first-generation college students struggle with class boundaries inherent in higher education.
Lenore
anyone who teaches should read this text. period. i read it for the first time during my undergrad.; again during MA work with Lisa Ede, and now I teach it in classes at U of Iowa.
Lisa Scherff
What can I say? Mike Rose is a wonderful human being, writer, and scholar. This book is a must-read for all literacy educators. I will use it this summer in my Teaching Writing Course.
Bruce
I actually skimmed some of the book along with reading generous portions of it, the reason being I was reading it specifically for help with my own teaching. More later.
Henry
Jul 13, 2011 Henry added it
Shelves: teaching
"Students will float to the mark that you set." (in my notes; was this from class or from the book?)

ch2, "I Just Wanna Be Average"
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 27 28 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Lives on the Boundary 1 12 Sep 18, 2009 08:04am  
Lives on the Boundary: A Moving Account of the Struggles and Achievements of America's Educationally Underprepared (Paperback)
Lives on the Boundary: The Struggles and Achievements of America's Underprepared (Paperback)
Lives on the Boundary: The Struggles and Achievements of America's Underprepared (Hardcover)
Why School? Possible Lives: The Promise of Public Education in America The Mind at Work: Valuing the Intelligence of the American Worker Back to School: Second Chances in Higher Ed Writer's Block: The Cognitive Dimension

Share This Book

Your website