Witness
by
Karen Hesse
The Barnes & Noble Review
Karen Hesse's Newbery Award-winning skills are put to great use in Witness, a poetic tale about friendship, fanaticism, and the deadly undercurrents of racial prejudice. The story takes place in a small Vermont town in the year 1924, revealing the devastating impact of the Ku Klux Klan on this pastoral, insular community. At the heart of the ta...more
Karen Hesse's Newbery Award-winning skills are put to great use in Witness, a poetic tale about friendship, fanaticism, and the deadly undercurrents of racial prejudice. The story takes place in a small Vermont town in the year 1924, revealing the devastating impact of the Ku Klux Klan on this pastoral, insular community. At the heart of the ta...more
Paperback, 161 pages
Published
March 1st 2003
by Scholastic Paperbacks
(first published July 5th 2000)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
this is the way this conversation should have gone down.
"so, i want to write a kid's book about the KKK coming to town and the town's reaction to it from all different perspectives"
"okay, i am listening"
"it will be set in vermont..."
"wait - what?? vermont?? not in the south?"
"no, in vermont. the green mountain state"
"okay, your call. keep 'em guessing, i like it. why pick on the south all the time, sure. everyone thinks vermont is so liberal - we will show them!!"
"okay - and i am going to have s...more
"so, i want to write a kid's book about the KKK coming to town and the town's reaction to it from all different perspectives"
"okay, i am listening"
"it will be set in vermont..."
"wait - what?? vermont?? not in the south?"
"no, in vermont. the green mountain state"
"okay, your call. keep 'em guessing, i like it. why pick on the south all the time, sure. everyone thinks vermont is so liberal - we will show them!!"
"okay - and i am going to have s...more
At first, I found Witness difficult to get into, and I was a little skeptical of Karen Hesse's chosen format, namely, writing the book somewhat like a play, insofar as characters switching off in dialog, but poetry because the "dialog" consisted of free verse poems of varying length. Towards the end, I not only grew to appreciate the literary merits of this format, but also grew to like it. Telling the story in this way allows Hesse to convey turmoil that the encroaching Ku Klux Klan, because th...more
I first read this in elementary school and loved it, then read it again recently for my Young Adult Literature class and loved it even more. It reads almost like a play, with each character (all residents of a small Vermont town in 1924) telling their version of events (the Ku Klux Klan rolling in and starting to recruit) in free verse. Characters include the local preacher, a twelve-year-old black girl, the town doctor, the sheriff, a six-year-old Jewish girl, and a woman who runs liquor. Amazi...more
I have read "Witness" by Karen Hesse, and I believe that it was a very good book. "Witness" is about a town in Vermont where the KKK decides to live in. In the front of the book is a character guide, for the book is written in short, narrative poems by a certain character. I enjoyed this format because it made the book easy to read, but also made you think much more about what the characters were really saying and meaning. The main characters were Leanora Sutter (an African-American girl), Esthe...more
“Testing the Conscience of a Town”
Set in 1924 Vermont Hesse’s starkly brilliant novella about the KKK’s attempt to infiltrate this independent New England state packs a terrific punch to the reader’s social consciousness. You will be challenged both emotionally and intellectually by the multiple narratives of a large cast of characters in this dramatic presentation. It helps to make frequent references to the Rogues’ Gallery of many players at the front of the book—in an attempt to memorize na...more
Set in 1924 Vermont Hesse’s starkly brilliant novella about the KKK’s attempt to infiltrate this independent New England state packs a terrific punch to the reader’s social consciousness. You will be challenged both emotionally and intellectually by the multiple narratives of a large cast of characters in this dramatic presentation. It helps to make frequent references to the Rogues’ Gallery of many players at the front of the book—in an attempt to memorize na...more
Apr 08, 2013
Marissa Cunneen
added it
My favorite scene was very heart wrenching because it was when Esther wanted to see her mother again, but she couldn’t because unfortunately heaven really is too far away. She came up with an idea, as a six year old that if she could take a train all the way to heaven it would stop and let her off with her mom. So she stood on the train tracks waiting and waiting for a train determined to make it stop and let her on! Other citizens had no idea what she was doing but I guarantee they knew it was...more
This book originally caught my attention because of the content. I find KKK stories fascinating. I was not expecting the poetry format but thought I would enjoy because I love other poem format books like Crank and Impulse by Ellen Hopkins. First off I loved the pictures of the characters in the beginning of the book. I think its great to give a face to character especially in books written in verse because you do not get the detailed descriptions of characters like you would in novels.
I did fi...more
I did fi...more
Witness by Karen Hesse was a very interesting book. This book caught my eye just like Crank did and this is because of the way the book is written, in poems. Unlike Crank, this book made it harder for me to stay caught up with the story. I found myself going back and reading pages multiple times until I was fully able to understand what was going on. I almost feel like this book had no ending, after I had finished the book I was still very confused and I was wondering if even the characters stor...more
This book was very interesting. I liked the writing style the author used and the way the words were easy to read. The thing I disliked the most was I was confused. I couldn’t keep track of who the characters were. There were so many stories I found it hard to keep them separate. I wanted the stories to connect in a way and I was hoping to find that but I found it really hard to know how they connected. If each story was its own book, I think this would have been better. If the stories went in m...more
As I was looking at the three novels offered for us to read I thought I would like this one the best. I liked the style it was written in, or at least the visual appeal of the words and how easy it seemed to read. For the most part I was wrong. Throughout the majority of the novel I was just plain confused. There were so many stories and so many characters I struggled to keep each of them separate. I was expecting that by the end each of the characters stories would connect and there would be an...more
The book is about a small town in Vermont that already has the presence of racism and discrimination. Shown by the dislike of Leanora and the Sutter family, things escalate with the appearance of The Ku Klux Klan. The organization based on hatred split the inhabitants of the town. Some of the characters embrace the arrival of the KKK and some disapproved of it. We see the effects of the KKK through the eyes of the main characters of the book. One of the main characters, Leanora Sutter, was direc...more
Witness by Karen Hesse is a book is not your average book. Hesse’s books differ from the standard young adult books because Hesse wrote her book from 11 different perspectives as opposed to one. The Witness is also written in verses instead of just general narratives. To me, the Witness would best be taught in a 7th or 8th grade classroom. I feel like 6th graders would not be able to differentiate the 11 perspectives in the book. The Witness could easily be tied into a history (context) or poetr...more
Alright so I read this book a few years ago ( about 3-4 ) and I absolutely fell in love with it. Since I was about 10 then, I had to re-read some parts to understand what was going on. When I did, it came down to these main parts:
PLOT: With this book there wasn't just 1 main plot. You get taken through many different scenarios based on what character you're reading. The quote " I am nothing yet I am everything" really goes into effect with this book since even though the problems with each chara...more
PLOT: With this book there wasn't just 1 main plot. You get taken through many different scenarios based on what character you're reading. The quote " I am nothing yet I am everything" really goes into effect with this book since even though the problems with each chara...more
Witness was definitely written in a unique format, and I think there is definitely some value for teaching this book nearby or possibly in a poetry unit. I do, however, think there are other books YA books written in a similar format which better explicate poetic form and diversity. The book obviously has a value in terms of the issues presented. There are some really unique transformations seen in story’s characters as the tale progresses. The variance in perspective is a really nice element. H...more
Witness by Karen Hesse is a very original novel. The novel paints a picture of a small Vermont town in 1924 plagued by the Ku Klux Klan. While the plot is somewhat original in its own right what makes this novel so creative is the way it is presented.
Witness is narrated by not 1 but 11 different characters all of which have vastly different perspectives on the events taking place. Also Witness is not written in prose form but rather in verse. As far as the way it is structured I find it comparab...more
Witness is narrated by not 1 but 11 different characters all of which have vastly different perspectives on the events taking place. Also Witness is not written in prose form but rather in verse. As far as the way it is structured I find it comparab...more
This book was not a bad book to read. It speaks about how the Ku Klux Klan impacted the lives of the citizens living in Vermont in 1924. The town was actually torn apart by the split in opinions and their views about the KKK’s decisions and tactics towards racism among the people living there. The story line was told in a narrative format with a poetic theme to it. It has short snippets of thoughts and views of some of the characters. The most focused characters were two little girls who became...more
As a future teacher of English, I am growing concerned over the ability of students to comprehend difficult literature, and infer what happened from what they just read. When I say "difficult to read" I mean exactly that. "Witness," present itself in various forms of writing, none of them especially conducive to easily figuring out the flow of the action for the average middle school student. By having them work through this, it leaves them more prepared for attacking other "difficult to read" w...more
This book was not necessarily what I expected: I thought that Hesse would place far more emphasis on the actions of the Klan, rather than the community's response to it. But ultimately that focus just serves to paint a more nuanced portrait of a town being torn apart by racism and hate:
I thought that the story of Sara Chickering was an important look at how a child's being born into a home filled with injustice causes them to grow into an adult harboring prejudice-and how that can be conquered...more
I thought that the story of Sara Chickering was an important look at how a child's being born into a home filled with injustice causes them to grow into an adult harboring prejudice-and how that can be conquered...more
Witness by Karen Hesse is a very interesting book. It is written in prose, so it really is not as long as it originally seems to be. This is one of the reasons that middle grades students probably would not mind reading this book. While the short poems that constitute as “chapters” make reading the book a rather quick task, it can be difficult at times to keep up with the characters and what is going on in the story since the book jumps from character to character so quickly. However, if the rea...more
I think that the witness would be an alright resource to use in the classroom. The only issue that I would have with the book is that it’s in the form of a poem. I’m not positive if I could say that no child at that age would have seen a book like Witness before but, I think the book would be harder for them to grasp at first. The book wouldn’t give nearly as much information in the text as a novel would and the students would more than likely have to be fully involved the during the entirety of...more
I believe that Witness would be a great book to teach in a Middle grades classroom because even though it is not written in the typical sense of a book it still gives off the essence of a story and events happening. Written in free verse this book takes us back to 1924 when the Ku Klux Klan moves into a small Vermont town and tensions rise especially when it deals with Leanora (an African American girl) and Esther (a Jewish girl). There is only one issue I have with the book…The descriptions of...more
Witness, by Karen Hesse, is a story that takes place in a Vermont town in 1924. The tale follows 11 different characters as the Ku Klux Klan tries to take over the community. Each character has a unique way of speaking and an interesting personality. Two of the main characters are Leanora Sutter, a 12-year-old black girl, and Esther Hirsch, a 6-year-old Jewish girl. The book has a very interesting layout similar to a group of poems. The story follows the community as they experience episodes of...more
As soon as you open Witness, you have high expectations for a dialogue poetry novel that will make you think and get your creative mind exercising. My favorite books are those that use vantage point and playful perspective switching to tell a common or just simple story. Faulkner's The Sound and the Fury is a classic example of this, as well as Bronx Masquerade for YA readers, and Catch-22. I was a little nervous to read this for a potential teaching tool among YA students. Because books like th...more
Karen Hesse's novel "Witness" is a unique way to tell the story of people living in a small town infested with the Ku Klux Klan. It gets unique perspectives from both women,men,black, white, Jewish, and members of the Klan. While I read this book on my own, I did not really enjoy it because it became very cumbersome to keep up with all the separate characters, and I found myself continually keeping track of who was who and who they were connected to in the community. I did find it somewhat refre...more
My daughter Gavriella suggested this poetic novella of life in Vermont in 1924. Esther, a Jewish girl age 6, and Leanora, a "negro" girl, age 12, both from New York, confront prejudice and violence directed at them and their families as the Ku Klux Klan comes to a rural Vermont town. Set against an historically realistic background of prohibition era small time rum running, the Leopold and Loeb murder in faraway Chicago, the election of Calvin Coolidge, and the rise of the Klan in the 1920s, the...more
Like Hesse's Out of the Dust, this story is told in prose, only with several different narrators. I wasn't sure if I would like having so many different narrators, but it works. Hesse writes prose so well. She uses such vivid words and paints pictures in words for the reader. I loved Mr. Field - he was so spunky!
The verses when Leanora saves Esther from the train are so powerful. Leanora, ". . . but there was esther, looking up, still as a rock, gazing at that big train, rushing down on her, exp...more
The verses when Leanora saves Esther from the train are so powerful. Leanora, ". . . but there was esther, looking up, still as a rock, gazing at that big train, rushing down on her, exp...more
Although "Witness" never quite reaches the sames level of greatness as "Out of the Dust", Karen Hesse's poetry throughout is always of the highest quality. She gives voices to a whole range of characters, and even though I had to turn back to the (very helpful) cast of characters page during the first section to remember who was who, by the second or third section of the book I had a very clear idea of who each person was, what they did, and what they thought.
Tension builds slowly as we see a to...more
Tension builds slowly as we see a to...more
Witness is a true story. It takes place in Vermont and there are many things going on in the story. You get to see this from everyone's point of view. In the beginning, all of the characters are deciding whether to be a part of the KKK (Ku Klux Klan) or not. That was the major part of the story-the KKK. Leonora Sutter is a young teen, and she's also black. She only has one friend, Ester, who is six years old, and she's pretty much the only child that doesn't want to be involved with the KKK in t...more
Witness is a novel written by Anne Hesse. The book takes place in the 1920’s amidst the Prohibition. The book is characterized by the heavy influence of the Ku Klux Klan and how each of the characters feels about it. The readers see racism, unlikely friendships, hardships, and realizations throughout the novel.
The book is arranged into five acts, with about ten different speaking characters. Other characters are referred to by the main characters, like Ira Hirsh, but have no speaking parts. Eac...more
The book is arranged into five acts, with about ten different speaking characters. Other characters are referred to by the main characters, like Ira Hirsh, but have no speaking parts. Eac...more
Witness is a novel set in a small town in 1924 Vermont. It is told from eleven different characters’ points of view. The Ku Klux Klan moves into this town leaving the citizens to decide how they feel about the Klan’s presence. Each of the characters has their own perspective. While some immediately have doubts, fears, or anger, some are looking to the K.K.K as being of strong family values and hope for their community. However, after being asked to do some morally questionable tasks as well as t...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Review | 2 | 6 | Apr 09, 2012 09:41am | |
| ENGL 3390: Great ...: Overview of Witness | 21 | 24 | Feb 16, 2012 07:41pm | |
| ENGL 3390: Great ...: Witness Review | 1 | 6 | Feb 16, 2012 05:47am |
Karen Hesse is an American author of children's literature and literature for young adults, often with historical settings. Her novel Out of the Dust was the winner of the 1998 Newbery Medal and the Scott O'Dell Award for Historical Fiction. In 2002, Hesse was a recipient of the MacArthur Fellowship.
For more information, please see http://us.macmillan.com/author/karenh...
More about Karen Hesse...
For more information, please see http://us.macmillan.com/author/karenh...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...






view all 39 comments
















