Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Circumstantial Evidence: Death, Life, and Justice in a Southern Town” as Want to Read:
Circumstantial Evidence: Death, Life, and Justice in a Southern Town
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Circumstantial Evidence: Death, Life, and Justice in a Southern Town

4.25  ·  Rating Details ·  102 Ratings  ·  13 Reviews
A piercing, provocative true story that is also a commentary on our system of justice, centered around a wrongful murder conviction that bares the dark side of the American soul. This book highlights a case that was front page news--featured on "60 Minutes, " in The New York Times in 1993. HC: Bantam.
Paperback, 512 pages
Published August 5th 1996 by Bantam (first published August 1st 1995)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Circumstantial Evidence, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Circumstantial Evidence

In Cold Blood by Truman CapoteHelter Skelter by Vincent BugliosiThe Devil in the White City by Erik LarsonThe Stranger Beside Me by Ann RuleColumbine by Dave Cullen
Best True Crime
231st out of 673 books — 999 voters
The Devil in the White City by Erik LarsonReclaiming History by Vincent BugliosiHomicide by David SimonHelter Skelter by Vincent BugliosiIn Cold Blood by Truman Capote
Edgar Award Winners - Fact Crime
23rd out of 54 books — 3 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Feb 24, 2016 Fishface rated it it was amazing
This one is worth seeking out and reading, probably over and over. I doubt you'll get the whole story the first time -- there is just too much to take it. This case happened in the same small Alabama town where Harper Lee grew up and where her fictional classic TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD was based (thinly disguised). That story -- a case of a false rape accusation against a black man in the Thirties, and the attempts to keep him from being prosecuted, then killed by a lynch mob -- has absolutely ...more
May 01, 2008 Jarome rated it it was amazing
Peter Barley takes you into a world, I know most of us have no idea about. By the time I finished this I felt so angry and sick to my stomach at the bold stupidity that human beings can display, that it took me a while to get over it. Once again, don't read this if you don't like hard truth. Truth about the side of people that just makes you sick. I think what bothered me the most (I should say what made me feel the most ashamed as an african-american male) is the fact that there were black ...more
Oct 18, 2015 Charity rated it it was amazing
I ordered this book after hearing Bryan Stevenson speak in Kenosha. He's a lawyer who advocates legally for death row inmates and is featured in this book because he helps the main accused murderer fight his death row sentence because he was wrongly accused.

The story takes place in Alabama, where defendants are NOT provided legal council if they don't have a way to pay for it. I have to say, I didn't know that still went on in America. It's just so solidly classist (and by extension racist) tha
Ann Benefiel
Sep 02, 2014 Ann Benefiel rated it it was amazing
This true story has so many twists and turns that fiction could never top it. I read it on Kindle and had no idea it was over 500 pages when I started. I stayed up all night when I was only a few hundred pages in, thinking with each chapter that I was near the end. Every time the crime(s) seemed to be about sewn up, new characters would pop up or someone new would take over the case. I've always been interested in social justice and this is one of the best examples, along with John Grisham's ...more
Feb 23, 2016 Cindy rated it it was amazing
Highly recommend. This true story of racial injustice takes place in small hometown of Harper Lee. For years I've had an article about human rights attorney Bryan Stevenson on my bulletin board at work that discusses his views on "To Kill a Mockingbird". The article came from this book. No spoilers on his opinion or what happens to his client, Walter "Johnny" D. McMillian . I started this book and couldn't put it down. Five stars. And if you haven't seen the TED talk by Bryan please watch.
Mary Jane
Mar 03, 2014 Mary Jane rated it liked it
Good read about a real crime that occurred in the deep south. Actually, it was about several crimes - 2 murders and one man incorrectly imprisoned for one of the murders.
At times, the book was tedious. Indeed, the author had no choice as the reporting of this whole scenario took time and patience.
It is sad that this occurred in our country in 1986. And maybe still does today. Very sad, indeed.
Dec 29, 2007 Andrew rated it really liked it
Excellent true crime writing...This one stands out to me as an excellent insight to the legal process in the south. After reading Super Casino, I was looking forward to this, and it really delivered..
Nov 18, 2010 Kristin rated it it was amazing
I'm actually from Monroeville. I went to church with the morrisons though I didn't know who they were at the time. I hope the murders are solved because these families deserve justice!
Judy Libby
Nov 12, 2014 Judy Libby rated it it was amazing
The perfect follow-up to JUST MERCY. What a tangled web we weave. . . . So lucky not to have been born black, poor, and in Alabama!
Sep 03, 2016 Lelia rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2013
A sadly disturbing look at the legal hoops that must be jumped and the inequity of our justice system.
Monica Perez
Jan 12, 2009 Monica Perez rated it it was ok
A fine read. True crime. Interesting insight into the possible irreversible injustice of the death penalty in its application.
Gabriela rated it it was amazing
Apr 05, 2015
Patt Grumm
Patt Grumm rated it really liked it
Jul 08, 2016
Beth rated it really liked it
Dec 31, 2007
Lara rated it liked it
Aug 02, 2008
Teddie rated it really liked it
Sep 01, 2011
Margarita rated it liked it
Jan 06, 2009
Jeff Youngblood
Jeff Youngblood rated it really liked it
Oct 21, 2014
Jason Gonzalez
Jason Gonzalez rated it it was amazing
Jan 23, 2009
Mandi rated it it was amazing
May 15, 2013
Ann rated it did not like it
Mar 25, 2012
Lukas Prytikin
Lukas Prytikin rated it it was amazing
Oct 25, 2014
Nanci Schiman
Nanci Schiman rated it it was amazing
Sep 06, 2015
Chelsea rated it liked it
Jan 27, 2016
Michael rated it really liked it
Oct 11, 2014
Katy rated it it was amazing
Nov 08, 2013
Jaimee Warda
Jaimee Warda rated it it was amazing
Jul 20, 2013
Fran rated it really liked it
Sep 10, 2016
Elizabeth Bayley
Elizabeth Bayley rated it it was amazing
May 18, 2014
Shannon Washington
Shannon Washington rated it it was amazing
Dec 04, 2012
« previous 1 3 4 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Contempt of Court: The Turn-of-the-Century Lynching That Launched a Hundred Years of Federalism
  • Floodlines: Community and Resistance from Katrina to the Jena Six
  • A Wild Justice: The Death and Resurrection of Capital Punishment in America
  • We Are Not Afraid: The Story of Goodman, Schwerner, and Chaney, and the Civil Rights Campaign for Mississippi
  • Fetal Abduction: The True Story of Multiple Personalities and Murder
  • The Misbegotten Son
  • Living with Evil
  • Simple Justice: The History of Brown v. Board of Education and Black America's Struggle for Equality
  • A Sniper in the Tower: The Charles Whitman Murders
  • Alien Hand Syndrome and Other Too-Weird-Not-To-Be-True Stories
  • Dismembered
  • A Question of Freedom: A Memoir of Learning, Survival, and Coming of Age in Prison
  • OMG My Kids Said WHAT?
  • My Prison Without Bars: The Journey of a Damaged Woman to Someplace Normal
  • Gods of Mischief: My Undercover Vendetta to Take Down the Vagos Outlaw Motorcycle Gang
  • Let's Get Free: A Hip-Hop Theory of Justice
  • Under the Bridge: The True Story of the Murder of Reena Virk
  • In the Name of Love and Other True Cases (Crime Files, #4)
Pete Earley is a storyteller who has penned 13 books including the New York Times bestseller The Hot House and the 2007 Pulitzer Prize finalist Crazy: A Father’s Search Through America’s Mental Health Madness.
After a 14-year career in journalism, including six years at The Washington Post, Pete became a full-time author with a commitment to expose the stories that entertain and surprise.
His honest
More about Pete Earley...

Share This Book