Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Bras & Broomsticks (Magic in Manhattan, #1)” as Want to Read:
Bras & Broomsticks (Magic in Manhattan, #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Bras & Broomsticks (Magic in Manhattan #1)

3.73 of 5 stars 3.73  ·  rating details  ·  7,407 ratings  ·  506 reviews
From the author of the acclaimed Milkrun comes a tale of teen angst with a twist. Hoping to make her wishes come true by drinking a magic potion, Rachel is aghast when her younger sister--not her--suddenly has magical powers.
Paperback, 310 pages
Published June 13th 2006 by Delacorte Press Books for Young Readers (first published 2005)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Shiver by Maggie StiefvaterHush, Hush by Becca FitzpatrickSpeak by Laurie Halse AndersonEvermore by Alyson NoelCity of Bones by Cassandra Clare
YA Novels by Goodreads Authors
97th out of 1,402 books — 2,654 voters
Harry Potter Boxset by J.K. RowlingThe Hunger Games by Suzanne CollinsThe Twilight Saga by Stephenie MeyerThe Mortal Instruments Boxed Set by Cassandra ClareVampire Academy Collection by Richelle Mead
Series Reading List
128th out of 1,237 books — 2,987 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Not bad.. just not for me...

Can't seem to connect with the MC and her narrative is not working for me. I loved Mlynowski's book Gimme a Call, but this one is just not my style.


(Note: Did not finish this book. Got to the point where Rachel is plotting to break up her dad's impending wedding with the STBSM by using her sister's new found powers as a witch, and she's also contemplating on how else she can benefit from this situation.)
AWESOME!!!!! So interesting so AWESOME!!!!!!

u guys gotta read it! (NOW!!!)
The only thing that gets this book two stars is that, rather than sticking to the done-before theme of teenager-suddenly-finds-out-she's-a-witch, Mlynowski switches things up a bit and gives us teenager-suddenly-finds-out-that-her-younger-sister-(and her mother)-is-a-witch.

Why did the magical powers skip Rachel, and go straight to her younger sister, Miri? Her mother explains that it could be because Miri is more mature than her older sister. Rachel demonstrates her lack of maturity throughout t
You’ve heard this all before – self-absorbed teen girl wants desperately to be A-list, finds a way to get in with that group, starts treating her other friends and family like crap because she must maintain her status or die. Lots of conniving and manipulation and lies, then it all falls apart, girl left with only her wits and a lot of apologies to make all around. Ends abruptly.

That was the general plot line. Except that there's witchcraft. I can’t STAND to read things like this. I know that ba
Alison Lin
Rachel is the main character in this book. it is told in a first person perspective. Miri, Rachel's sister just figured out that she is a witch. Rachel also figured out that her mom was a witch but never told anyone about it. Rachel and Miri tried to get STB(Soon-to-be-step-mother) to say that she hates them and her dad with the truth spell but it didn't work. All she said was how much she loved her dad and the sisters. I think that this book is similar to another book i read which is called Tr ...more
First off I have to start by saying that Sarah Mlynowski is a genious. I have read many books of hers in the past, though most of them have been her women's fiction, this was my first YA novel of hers and even though I rated it at 3 stars, I still really enjoyed it, but I think it lacked in a few aspects.

I thought this book started off great. The characters in this story are awesome. I really liked Rachel as the main character and Miri is quite possibly the coolest young witch around. I even lov
This book is an insult to every witch series involving teenagers that has ever existed.

Typical book involving teenagers being told not to do something, doing it anyway, and not caring about the consequences. Rachel is the most shallow, selfish character I've ever had the misfortune to read about. Her mind is nowhere I ever want to be again.

Such a waste of a potentially interesting idea.
Jennifer Wardrip
Reviewed by Me for

Being fourteen is hard work--and nobody knows that better than Rache Weinstein. She's got a major crush on the two most popular guys in school, Raf and Mick; she's been dumped by her best friend since preschool, Jewel, and instead has hooked up with not-so-popular Tammy; she's got the rhythm of a baboon and so didn't get to audition for her school's all-important fashion show; she's a quasi B-lister instead of a coveted A-lister; her dad is getting ready to mar
Sometimes I ask myself why I like Sarah mlynowskis books. Because I do. I like them A LOT. It's not as I can identify with the main character. She's often a girl who doesn't overthink like I tend to do, who's rather confident and very much of a teenage girl stereotype. She knows she looks good , she's incredibly selfish and she's ready for fun.
Which is not me at all. If anything I'm more like Miri.

But I do like them. Oh god do I like them. Maybe because they're different from me. Probably becau
Bethany Miller
3.5 stars

Bras & Broomsticks by Sarah Mylnowski hilariously blends the supernatural with the realities of the popularity contest that is present in every high school. Rachel can't believe her luck when she finds out that her little sister Miri is a witch. Though she's miffed that her little sister inherited this power from their mother and she did not, she quickly thinks of ways that she can use her sister’s power to her own advantage. Primarily, she wants to become more popular and get Raf,
In one word, the plot was tired. This book has been done so many times, with so many variations of the one simple plot structure: Girl is a loser. Girl finds a way to make herself not a loser with careful scheming and manipulation. Girl drops her true friends for popularity. Everything fails miserably in the end. Girl's new life falls to pieces. Old friends are nice and come back to her in the end.
The only twist on this old story was the magical aspect, and even that didn't really make it all t
Emily Hunholz
I have never disliked a narrator more than I disliked Rachel, the whiney, self-absorbed, superficial teenager who finds out that her sister Miri is a witch. Rachel convinces her sister to use magic to improve her own life, and surprise, surprise, everything gets messed up. Because of Rachel’s selfishness, she dumps her best friend and sabotages her dad’s wedding. Every time she hurts someone else, she has an excuse for why it’s okay. I found myself hoping for bad things to happen to Rachel, and ...more
I read these books when I was younger and I had totally forgotten how much fun they are! Rachel must be, without any doubt, the most selfish girl ever - But she does indeed have some hilarious thoughts about her life, boys and her friends - Such a great book, can't wait to read the rest the books!!
This review was originally posted on my blog LoveThyBook

Sarah seems like such a fun and nice person, she has written many YA books, ones I have never heard of till now, but I already ordered some more because I just like how simple and fun they are.

As I write this review I am watching Sabrina the Teenage Witch, because I just need to satisfy my younger inner self at the moment, and my weird interest in witchcraft. I loved this show, and this book really reminded me of it, mostly just because of
Ian Wood
This is the complete review as it appears at my blog dedicated to reading, writing (no 'rithmatic!), movies, & TV. Blog reviews often contain links which are not reproduced here, nor will updates or modifications to the blog review be replicated here.

I was going to rate this warty, but my son overruled me! He claims it's a worthy read!

This audio CD is read by Ariadne Meyers and she does an acceptable job, but is occasionally annoying.

Quite frankly, this one seemed a bit young for me, but I'v
Jessica Ramspeck
Bras and broomsticks starts out with the main character Rachel finding out that her sister and her mom are witches, then the book goes on to explain that her dad is getting remarried to a mean woman with an annoying little girl that Rachel and Miri (her sister) have to accept as their sister. Throughout the book Rachel and Miri try to get their dad and mom back together. This book is so amazing for three reasons, the first one being that it is written from a self obsessed teenagers perspective, ...more
I read this book back to back with the sequel. First, the magic in this book actually plays a much smaller role than I expected and seems less creatively handled than I would have liked. Nonetheless, I thought the trick of narrating the story from the sister of the witch rather than the one with powers was clever. Overall, a decent young adult novel, but not great and no especially interesting narrative voice or plot twists.
Reading challenge #11: A book with magic

Because Rachel’s think life’s not fair, she tricks her sister (whom she thought already well gifted without being a witch) to make her passed the dancing test to become a substitute in the fashion show. Everything seemed brighter for a while when she got accepted and finally made it to the A-list circle. And to put a cherry on top, she’d been asked to go to the Spring Fling by a boy of her dream. The only drawback is her father’s marriage still going on. W
Trite, predictable, and with a main character so shallow that if you filled her with water, you couldn't get a puddle out of the deal. Spilled milk has more depth. I weep for the state of teen fiction that this not only got published, it's the first of a multi-book series.
Rachel's little sister, Miri, is a witch. (Apparently it runs in the family - her mom's one too. ) Rachel tries to use this to advantage by having her sister cast spells to break up dad's pending wedding to wicked stop mom, make her popular, and possibly get some boobs.

This review was originally posted on my blog LoveThyBook

Sarah seems like such a fun and nice person, she has written many YA books, ones I have never heard of till now, but I already ordered some more because I just like how simple and fun they are.

As I write this review I am watching Sabrina the Teenage Witch, because I just need to satisfy my younger inner self at the moment, and my weird interest in witchcraft. I loved this show, and this book really reminded me of it, mostly just because of
3.5 Stars
A cute, funny book. It got a little frusturating and annoying in the end, but it was still a fun read. I would recommend this book to anyone who wants to read something light.
I read this book in Grade 6 but thought it was pretty boring!! I thought it was just a story that went on and on and nothing happened! I wouldn't recommend this to anyone
Sherri F.
Audiobook review...I'm 30 yrs over target audience, but I still liked listening to this one. I wish they had more like this when I was a pre-teen & teen. It was easy, funny & quick listening while multi-tasking around the house. Although during some of it, I was listening with my 14 yr old niece, but I seemed to like it better than her or my 19 yr old daughter.

I think the story was cute in addition to dealing with typical adolescent concerns...being cool, liking boys, wanting their pare
Rachel's younger sister Miri has always been kind of an exceptional sort of younger sibling. She's smart, serious, and levelheaded where Rachel is social, frenetic, and maaaaaybe a little bit superficial. It's really almost like Miri is the eldest--so of course when a magical family secret hits the fan, it's Miri who's the first to discover the secret, and the first to benefit. Any other sister might feel left out, but Rachel quickly seizes Miri's opportunity as a way to help herself out of her ...more
This was fun cute and light - just like the doctor ordered!
Nov 26, 2007 Mallory rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: girls
Very funny. Very well written. I couldn't put it down!
Life isn't fair. Especially, Rachel Weinstein's life. Not only is she not part of the popular crowd, but for fourteen years old she's rather "undeveloped." And as if that wasn't bad enough, Rachel has just found out that, not only is her mother a witch (literally!) but her younger sister Miri is also one. Yup, that's right...the witch craft gene passed Rachel, the older of the two girls, right up.

And the more familiar both Rachel and Miri become with Miri's new found witch-y abilities, Rachel re
So this book is an absolute crack up. Rachel Weinstein, the main character, is 14 years old. She has a crush on two guys, and wants to be popular. She can't dance and was just dumped by her best friend since kindergarten when her friend gets into the dance show. To top everything off, her dad is getting remarried to a horrible woman with a 5 year old daughter. But that's not quite bad enough, she just found out that her younger sister, Miri, is a witch. And so is her mother. Why did no one tell ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Q&A with Sara...: The Magic in Manhattan series 8 47 Jun 08, 2012 12:28PM  
  • The Salem Witch Tryouts (Salem Witch, #1)
  • Me, My Elf & I
  • Magic's Child (Magic or Madness, #3)
  • To Wish or Not to Wish (As You Wish, #3)
  • Hex: A Witch and Angel Tale
  • Dumped by Popular Demand (The Social Experiments of Dorie Dilts, #1)
  • Mates, Dates, and Inflatable Bras (Mates, Dates, #1)
  • Haint Misbehavin'
  • The Cupid Chronicles (Wedding Planner's Daughter, #2)
  • Sabrina the Teenage Witch (Sabrina the Teenage Witch, #1)
  • The Extraordinary Secrets of April, May, & June
  • A Taste for Red
  • The Princess & the Pauper
  • On Location (Secrets of My Hollywood Life, #2)
  • The Empress's Tomb (Kiki Strike, #2)
  • Top Ten Uses for an Unworn Prom Dress
  • Pulling Princes
  • Highway to Hell (Maggie Quinn: Girl Vs. Evil #3)
Sarah is the author of BRAS & BROOMSTICKS, FROGS & FRENCH KISSES, SPELLS & SLEEPING BAGS and PARTIES & POTIONS—all in the YA ‘Magic in Manhattan’ series, as well as GIMME A CALL and the upcoming TEN THINGS WE DID (AND PROBABLY SHOULDN'T HAVE). Along with Lauren Myracle and E. Lockhart, she also wrote HOW TO BE BAD.

Sarah’s five novels for adults, MILKRUN, FISHBOWL, AS SEEN ON TV, MO
More about Sarah Mlynowski...

Other Books in the Series

Magic in Manhattan (4 books)
  • Frogs & French Kisses (Magic in Manhattan, #2)
  • Spells & Sleeping Bags (Magic in Manhattan, #3)
  • Parties & Potions (Magic in Manhattan, #4)
Ten Things We Did (and Probably Shouldn't Have) Frogs & French Kisses (Magic in Manhattan, #2) Parties & Potions (Magic in Manhattan, #4) Spells & Sleeping Bags (Magic in Manhattan, #3) Gimme a Call

Share This Book