A Live Coal in the Sea (Camilla #2)
Madeleine L'Engle's first adult novel in four years -- now in paperback! With 23,000 copies sold since May 1996, this "haunting domestic drama" "(Publishers Weekly)" examines the powers of faith and mercy in one family's confrontation with a legacy of evil.Best known for "A Wrinkle in Time --" the children's classic that has sold more than 2 million copies since 1962 -- Ma...more
Paperback, 336 pages
Published
April 11th 1997
by HarperOne
(first published January 1st 1996)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,634)
I have not encountered many works by Madeleine L'Engle but I have been very pleased with what I have read. L'Engle tells this story as different characters recollect details from their past, primarily the main character Camilla who tells her granddaughter some stories of their family's past. This narrative style gives depth to the story as gradually the mystery of their family is unveiled. This story tells a heart-warming tale of mercy even in the face of the greatest mistakes and shame. An intr...more
I received this book as a wedding present, and at the time, it got lost in the swilr of events and ended up sitting on the bookshelves for several years.
Having just recently finished it, I understand why it would be a wedding present. The book covers several marriages in different stages over the lifetime of its protagonist, Camilla Xanthakos, a college astronomy professor.
The events that shape her life and the lives of those around her are pretty extreme: infidelity, brainwashing in the Korea...more
Having just recently finished it, I understand why it would be a wedding present. The book covers several marriages in different stages over the lifetime of its protagonist, Camilla Xanthakos, a college astronomy professor.
The events that shape her life and the lives of those around her are pretty extreme: infidelity, brainwashing in the Korea...more
This was a strange story - not at all what I was expecting, but then again I don't think I have read any other adult books by L'Engle. I mainly picked it up as the central character is a female scientist, although her work is very much background. The book however does have some very interesting mediations on science and religion, and how - at least in the persons and lives of the main family in the book - they can be reconciled, or at least harmoniously co-exist. The deep dark secret of this fa...more
I've known and loved L'Engle as a intelligent writer of children's books for quite some time. When I saw "A Live Coal in the Sea" at my library I was intrigued enough to bite. I am so very glad I did.
A classic family saga with a complicated history and a question of parentage that has sent a splinter through three generations. L'Engle gives even the worst characters in the story enough compassion that you are unable to choose a scapegoat. In doing so you are forced into the search for mercy alon...more
A classic family saga with a complicated history and a question of parentage that has sent a splinter through three generations. L'Engle gives even the worst characters in the story enough compassion that you are unable to choose a scapegoat. In doing so you are forced into the search for mercy alon...more
I think way back when I was a teen and looking for the L'Engle books I had missed, I saw this one and passed it over. The teen romantic in me wanted Camilla to end up with her first love, and that she would marry someone else seemed like a betrayal.
I know more now (thank goodness) and so when I rediscovered this sequel to "Camilla," right after I had finished re-reading that book with an adult perspective, I was thrilled. Here it was, the "Camilla" for adults. I had to read it right away.
It's no...more
I know more now (thank goodness) and so when I rediscovered this sequel to "Camilla," right after I had finished re-reading that book with an adult perspective, I was thrilled. Here it was, the "Camilla" for adults. I had to read it right away.
It's no...more
Oct 19, 2009
Snail in Danger (Sid) Nicolaides
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
genre-deficient
When I learned from Wikipedia that there was a sequel to Camilla, I squeed. And then I requested the book from the library. This is a really excellent book, even if you hadn't read the sequel. It made me think of Cyteen and The Chosen and Pamela Dean (something about the dialogue at the beginning). The only flaw is that the reveal at the end was pretty obvious. I saw it coming for about half the book. (Also I'm not sure I believe/was persuaded by the resolution ... but anyway.)
I "accidentally" picked up this book just a few short weeks after finishing Camilla by Madeleine L'Engle. I had no idea I'd be running into the same characters in A Live Coal in the Sea! As is so typical of L'Engle, you never know who you're going to run into in her stories! Often her novel characters cross paths, even when the books are not written as a series or sequels.
In this book Camilla's granddaughter, Raffi, confronts Camilla about whether she is or is not truly her grandmother. From the...more
In this book Camilla's granddaughter, Raffi, confronts Camilla about whether she is or is not truly her grandmother. From the...more
This book was one of the best books by a modern christian author that I have read in a very long time. I loved the themes of grace and mercy, hanging on through a tough marriage, accepting people as they are, ministry life, the loss of children, death, struggling with faith and what God actually promise us.
The book dealt with tough issues in a more realistic way than most of the other "christian" novels I have read. It was a simplistic reality, but still not everything turned out happy and I li...more
The book dealt with tough issues in a more realistic way than most of the other "christian" novels I have read. It was a simplistic reality, but still not everything turned out happy and I li...more
I generally prefer L'Engle's fantasy stories and Crosswicks journals to her more contemporary stories, so I started reading this book one evening around 9, planning to read until I fell asleep.
I finished it in tears at 2am.
The title comes from a quote: "All the wickedness in the world which man may do or think is no more to the mercy of God than a live coal dropped in the sea." The novel shows how this is true in the intertwined stories of two families; great evil is done on both sides, and ma...more
I finished it in tears at 2am.
The title comes from a quote: "All the wickedness in the world which man may do or think is no more to the mercy of God than a live coal dropped in the sea." The novel shows how this is true in the intertwined stories of two families; great evil is done on both sides, and ma...more
An ambitious book by the author of A Wrinkle In Time (a personal childhood favorite); this story of interconnectedness, mercy, forgiveness and a belief system able to embrace the wonders of both clear-headed science and an Almighty God, is admirable in concept if not entirely successful (IMO) in its execution.
I'm not entirely comfortable with the ending. I wonder at Camilla's troubled son Taxi's joy in discovering, finally, his blood father's identity. Why, with all the transience of emotion in...more
I'm not entirely comfortable with the ending. I wonder at Camilla's troubled son Taxi's joy in discovering, finally, his blood father's identity. Why, with all the transience of emotion in...more
A bit of a soap opera, written by a woman whom I am guessing is brilliant in science and really does make math patterns in her head to relax, as she has one of her characters do. I like the quotes she adds to the story such as this one, "He who would do good to another must do it in minute particulars. General good is the plea of the scoundrel, hypocrite, and flatterer, for Art and Science cannot exist but in minutely organized particulars." (Blake) I am also thinking that this book should be re...more
The heartbreak of a family ripped apart from each other is very real in A Live Coal in the Sea, but the hyped-up drama of the "mystery" surrounding Taxi's parentage is drawn out in such a way that the real story and the real pain are obscured by the hyped-up suspense building and, if not glossed over, then sped through. Such a shame, because that real story at the heart of this novel is very strong, and the book could have been so much better. The twist at the end, however, is very well done, an...more
Another one on the list of adult novels by Madeline L'Engle that I never knew existed....
Hidden secrets and family history are revealed little by little in A Live Coal in the Sea, leading to an ending I didn't expect. Camilla is a professor at a small college. L'Engle delves into family history as the big family secret finally gets explained to Camilla's granddaughter. In this way, it is reminiscent of A Severed Wasp in how the story was told.
The characters were compelling enough to keep me read...more
Hidden secrets and family history are revealed little by little in A Live Coal in the Sea, leading to an ending I didn't expect. Camilla is a professor at a small college. L'Engle delves into family history as the big family secret finally gets explained to Camilla's granddaughter. In this way, it is reminiscent of A Severed Wasp in how the story was told.
The characters were compelling enough to keep me read...more
I rarely ever read adult books (I love middle-grade and teen lit and read that almost exclusively) and this book reminded me why.
Though I did end up liking the characters and actual story, there were some themes/situations that I really did not care for and I wish I hadn't read them.
The story is complicated and jumps back and forth from the past of Camilla Dickinson's life to the present, with no warning, with scenes in the present of her granddaughter Raffi visiting her and also some phone con...more
Though I did end up liking the characters and actual story, there were some themes/situations that I really did not care for and I wish I hadn't read them.
The story is complicated and jumps back and forth from the past of Camilla Dickinson's life to the present, with no warning, with scenes in the present of her granddaughter Raffi visiting her and also some phone con...more
I love Madeleine L'Engle's Wrinkle in Time series so I thought I'd give one of her adult books a try.
Pros- she develops her characters thoughtfully. They are three-dimensional characters with faults and strengths and each character is shown doing things within and outside of their moral scope, much like in real life. She has a remarkable ability to incorporate her spirituality and beliefs without being offensive or overbearing and without the book reading like a crappy religious novel.
Cons- thi...more
Pros- she develops her characters thoughtfully. They are three-dimensional characters with faults and strengths and each character is shown doing things within and outside of their moral scope, much like in real life. She has a remarkable ability to incorporate her spirituality and beliefs without being offensive or overbearing and without the book reading like a crappy religious novel.
Cons- thi...more
I wanted to read this because I like the young adult novel, 'Camilla.' This was the follow-up to Camilla's life after the first book ended with her about 16 years old. I enjoyed the writing style and story of Camilla and thought that it was set in the 1960s, since I could identify with some of the events, although I didn't grow up in a city.
The first difference with 'A Live Coal...' is that this novel is an adult fiction, not young adult. In my opinion, the writing is sometimes not up to adult s...more
The first difference with 'A Live Coal...' is that this novel is an adult fiction, not young adult. In my opinion, the writing is sometimes not up to adult s...more
I wanted to like this book, because Madeline L'engle will forever be one of my favorites. I never read Camilla, but I have read And Both Were Young approximately a million times, and some of my earliest book-reading memories involve the Wrinkle in Time Series. There were things to love about this book- some of it was deliciously soapy, for one- but there were other things that couldn't help but turn me off of it.
SPOILERS BELOW:
*
*
*
*
This book came out in 1996, not 1969, and as such I'm not thrill...more
SPOILERS BELOW:
*
*
*
*
This book came out in 1996, not 1969, and as such I'm not thrill...more
Synopsis:
Camilla Dickinson shares the complex story of her life with granddaughter Raffi, whose father’s erratic behavior and insinuating remarks have prompted her to question her identity. The choices, actions, and sufferings of previous generations, and their far-reaching ramifications, are brought to light as Camilla and her close friend Luisa share their memories with Raffi. Through the process, Raffi learns not only the facts about herself and her family, but also the truth that love and me...more
Camilla Dickinson shares the complex story of her life with granddaughter Raffi, whose father’s erratic behavior and insinuating remarks have prompted her to question her identity. The choices, actions, and sufferings of previous generations, and their far-reaching ramifications, are brought to light as Camilla and her close friend Luisa share their memories with Raffi. Through the process, Raffi learns not only the facts about herself and her family, but also the truth that love and me...more
As it is officially summer and I am trying to breeze through as many novels as possible before I start graduate school and have (yuck!) required reading, I thought I might try Madeline L'Engle. I read "A Wrinkle in Time" as a young adult, although really should probably reread it as a grownup, because I have no recollection of it. But remember absolutely LOVING her novel "A Ring of Endless Light" and reread it a few years ago and found it even more apt and delightful as I did when I was 12. So I...more
This story is a tangle of past and present as Camilla tries to explain their family to her granddaughter Raffi. The emphasis of the story is about the power of mercy and change, people's ability to transform into something better than they once were, to overcome their own demons. I read this immediately after reading L'Engle's
Certain Women
, and my main criticism of that novel was that the transition from present to past was often not smooth enough, it was too bogged down in unrealistic dialo...more
Everyone knows Madeleine L'Engle, right? Admit it. You've all read A Wrinkle in Time, and you all thought it was cool. Most of you probably went on to read the other three books in the series. (Some of you probably sought out the other books in the two series that crossed over with the Time books, and you don't need to read this review, because you've probably already read this book.)
For the rest of you, who wondered what L'Engle had been doing since then... A Live Coal in the Sea is her forty-s...more
For the rest of you, who wondered what L'Engle had been doing since then... A Live Coal in the Sea is her forty-s...more
As a tween and teenager, I read every Madeline L'Engle book I could get my hands on, and loved every one of them. This is the first of her books that I've picked up since then, and the first one I've tried that was intended for an adult (rather than young reader) audience. I made it through about thirty pages. The plotline seemed pretty bland, but the thing that really killed if for me and made me unable to keep reading was the dialogue, which was just not at all believable. Nobody talks like th...more
What I really liked about this book was the constant reminders of mercy and love in the midst of horrendous circumstances. The book deals with themes of sexual misconduct and how one person's sin can affect many generations. I do not always agree with L'Engle theologically, but the redemptive and hopeful tone of this book was refreshing. I should also note that this book has some foul language in it and I wouldn't recommend it for young readers because of its themes.
Wow, I suspected the ending, but I was still surprised (and relieved) to stumble onto it.
This was a very healing book. Even though the content was hard and felt like swallowing heavy rocks, I think it was good for me to read. Camilla is such a silent, strong woman. And I ached when Mac would retreat.
I think it's good for us young marrieds to read about couples who've made their marriages work through crappy times, hard times, dealing with pain. Not knowing what pain Nayt & I may need to en...more
This was a very healing book. Even though the content was hard and felt like swallowing heavy rocks, I think it was good for me to read. Camilla is such a silent, strong woman. And I ached when Mac would retreat.
I think it's good for us young marrieds to read about couples who've made their marriages work through crappy times, hard times, dealing with pain. Not knowing what pain Nayt & I may need to en...more
As with all Madeleine L'Engle books, this is beautifully written. There is a wonderful underlying theme of mercy and forgiveness in this novel. And, an interesting melding of science and divine faith. The charcters are flawed but likable. But, it's a story of one family's drama that seems almost unbearable but somehow gets resolved. Just a bit too easy an ending for all the build up. But worth reading for the gorgeous prose.
This was an easy read, but not a great one. My expectations were probably too high, since Wrinkle in Time was such a fantastic book. The writing feels a little stilted and old fashioned (the characters talk without contractions: "I can not imagine.." "You will not do that.." and there isn't really any plot progression. It's a story that is told through flashbacks to a girl. That's it. Once the memory has been told, the book ends.
This is probably the first L'Engle book I've read that I haven't rated 5 stars. I love her style and I love the issues she usually takes on, but I didn't really care for the characters or the situations in this book. It was a good reminder that yes, a lot of things in life are hard, but you get through it, and yet my problem with this book was that it didn't really highlight what the good things are. Ah well. Glad I read it anyway.
I loved every word written by Madeleine L'Engle in her youth novels, and most of her nonfiction as well. I cried when she died in 2007, feeling like a beloved "wise woman" had passed from my life. But I haven't been a huge fan of her adult fiction. For me, this book was too melodramatic (too much infidelity) and the important themes of love and mercy were overworked and did not ring as true.
My trouble with this one was keeping the characters straight. Taxi is too much like Zachary from her teen novels, Camilla reminded me too much of Poly--or was it Vicky? That's my main problem with Madeleine L'Engle--the stories have good ideas, but the characters are weak, and some of the events are embarrassingly contrived. This one held together better than most, though.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Madeleine L'Engle was an American writer best known for her Young Adult fiction, particularly the Newbery Medal-winning A Wrinkle in Time and its sequels A Wind in the Door, A Swiftly Tilting Planet, and Many Waters. Her works reflect her strong interest in modern science: tesseracts, for example, are featured prominently in A Wrinkle in Time, mitochondrial DNA in A Wind in the Door, organ regener...more
More about Madeleine L'Engle...
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...

Loading...















