Thelonious Monk: The Life and Times of an American Original
"The piano ain't got no wrong notes!" So ranted Thelonious Sphere Monk, who proved his point every time he sat down at the keyboard. His angular melodies and dissonant harmonies shook the jazz world to its foundations, ushering in the birth of "bebop" and establishing Monk as one of America's greatest composers. Yet throughout much of his life, his musi...more
Hardcover, 416 pages
Published
October 6th 2009
by Free Press
(first published December 15th 2008)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
785)
some super sweet sweetheart gave this to me for a gift - i'm hella enjoying it!
this is a really well researched book. it dispells lots of myths that have amassed over the years about this great american composer. critics mis-read thelonious, seeing him as some sort of hermetic freak of nature who just fell out of the sky with a highly idiosyncratic style.
nah. monk was a genius who was highly studied, and could play a variety of musics. he CHOSE to play the way he did, wh...more
this is a really well researched book. it dispells lots of myths that have amassed over the years about this great american composer. critics mis-read thelonious, seeing him as some sort of hermetic freak of nature who just fell out of the sky with a highly idiosyncratic style.
nah. monk was a genius who was highly studied, and could play a variety of musics. he CHOSE to play the way he did, wh...more
Monk's neighborhood in 30's NYC is a lively place where all the women are beautiful, all the men are accomplished, and all the children are WAY above average. At least, that's how Robin D.G. Kelley paints it. Are we trying too hard to send an "empowering message" to an "underserved community?" This portrait comes along after an exhaustingly labyrinthine stroll through Monk's ancestry and the tangled lives of his post-slavery predecessors. I knew Monk was a family man, but I d...more
This Monk biography is more compendious than the other couple I have read, but not necessarily more illuminating or entertaining. Kelley provides a lot of detail but is not much of a storyteller. Furthermore, although he tries to refute some of Monk's reputation for unreliability, childishness, and flat-out wierdness, he does little but reinforce these impresions with his descriptions of Monk's actual lateness to the bandstand, propensity to wander the neighborhood high and drunk, and disappea...more
Hard to rate -- if I'm going on exhaustive research and attention to detail, I'd give it 5 stars. It reads a little slow and tends to get into a play by play of "how the shows went over" a bit too much, I thought, but generally this was an incredible, interesting read. It's sometimes hard to connect the thoughtful, reasonable man portrayed throughout this book with the character you see spinning around in "Straight, No Chaser," and the interpretive gap still has me a bit of...more
Thelonious Monk (1917-1982) rose from a humble beginning as the son of day laborers in Rocky Mount, North Carolina to become one of the legendary—though misunderstood and underappreciated—composers and musicians of modern jazz. The subtitle of this masterful biography claims that Monk is an "American Original", which has been applied to countless other public figures. In this case, however, the author is absolutely correct; "The High Priest of Bebop" was unlike anyone else, i...more
Rating: 3* of five
I wish I'd never read this book. I now don't like Thelonious Monk, who comes across in these pages as a self-centered snot whose mental illness could and should have been medicated to ameliorate its nasty effects on those around him; and I flat don't like the selfishness and effrontery of the man.
His music is great. I will do my damnedest to forget the rest.
I spent 451pp hoping that soon I'd get past the building distaste for the man whose talent I...more
I wish I'd never read this book. I now don't like Thelonious Monk, who comes across in these pages as a self-centered snot whose mental illness could and should have been medicated to ameliorate its nasty effects on those around him; and I flat don't like the selfishness and effrontery of the man.
His music is great. I will do my damnedest to forget the rest.
I spent 451pp hoping that soon I'd get past the building distaste for the man whose talent I...more
The brilliant pianist and composer Thelonious Monk has been the subject of many profiles, but none have had the depth of Kelly's book. Often prevailing wisdom of Monk focused superficially on so-called personality quirks rather than the inherent musical genius that Monk brought to the table. Kelley wipes the slate clean and presents Monk as a man and musician in three dimensions. Paralleling his musical development from community dances to Minton's and then eventual stardom with his personal lif...more
Reading this book felt like living Monk’s life. You finish wondering if there could possibly be any gaps in his history – or the history of where he lived, who he knew, or the African-American experience of the time. You’ll definitely enjoy reading this book if you love jazz and want to read about every significant jazz musician who played from the 1930s through the 1970s. Even Monk’s lesser-known sidemen get significant backstories. Plus it feels like every rehearsal, every gig, every jam s...more
It is scarcely possible for me to convey the pleasures of this book. It is exhaustive in its presentation of known facts, and yet concise; it is highly resistant to the pervasive mythology (much of it pernicious) that has polluted Monk's aura, and--vitally important--the man can WRITE. As he is an historian with a distinguished track record in that field, he comes to this job (which is clearly a labor of love for him) far more completely equipped than many who assay the field of jazz biography (...more
Robin Kelley did an insane amount of research for this book. It goes quite beyond the normal amount of detail for a biography. Sometimes he over does it. I didn't really need to know about the background of Monk's mother's pastor for a year, but Kelley deserves a lot of recognition for his work here. I certainly know a lot more about Monk than I did before, and I will be coming back to this book whenever I acquire more recordings of Monk, just to refresh myself with the circumstances of each...more
Robin D.G. Kelley worked some 14 years on this biography, and it shows. Monk couldn’t have hoped for a better biographer than Kelley – a scholar, musician, historian, and clearly a fan – and Kelley’s given us a portrait that’s at once loving, meticulous and poignant. Kelley’s skills are all at their best when he combines his musical and historical insights, for example, in the early chapters on Monk’s San Juan Hill neighborhood as it and the jazz scene developed.
Much as a I loved th...more
Much as a I loved th...more
This book is, if nothing else, an amazing piece of scholarship. The author often pins down month-by-month, week-by-week, sometimes day-by-day, Thelonious Monk's activities. But it is that extreme attention to detail that is also the book's weakness, or at least for me its frustration. After several chapters of reading how Monk played so many weeks at the Five Spot, then went on tour to cities A B C D E F etc, what his spirits were like for the tour, how long it was before his next two week gig a...more
Thorough is not the word for this book. Painstakingly detailed kind of understates the research performed by Kelley. The first part of the book is a chore to get through as the book describes at length Monk's ancestors and the political climate of the South in their times. All fine in itself but really wondering when Thelonious was going to get into the picture. When he does, you start reading about his elementary school grades (which actually are funny). I love Monk and this is surely the ...more
Well written, and certainly an interesting read. A little too much detail for me. I got the sense that, if I was a super-super fan of Monk's, when I was reading 4 straight pages that were just about the grades and teacher comments he got when he was 8 years old in the third chapter, I would have looked at the nearly 500 pages left to go and would have said, "Bring it on." Instead, I looked at all those pages left in the book and wondered if I really wanted to dive into that many tediou...more
I've read a couple other Monk bios and this one is by far the most thorough and well-researched.
There is some important, even revelatory information in this book that I've never seen elsewhere (for example, the fact that Thelonious Monk Sr., Monk's father, spent the last twenty yrs of his life in a mental institution).
It's good, and I imagine that it will be considered 'definitive' soon enough. I can't help but think that the book is too literal-minded to really unde...more
There is some important, even revelatory information in this book that I've never seen elsewhere (for example, the fact that Thelonious Monk Sr., Monk's father, spent the last twenty yrs of his life in a mental institution).
It's good, and I imagine that it will be considered 'definitive' soon enough. I can't help but think that the book is too literal-minded to really unde...more
Kelley provides careful (over 100 footnotes for nearly every chapter) and complete biographical coverage, making every single rehearsal, recording date, tour, and even spontanous playing by Monk come alive. He comes at Monk from so many angles, and he knows enough about music to confidently talk about genious in simplicity and Monk's dedication to the melody, in spite of his noted harmonic adventures. I am happy and exhausted (but never bored) upon finishing. Flipping to the footnotes about re...more
The thing about Professor Kelley's writing is that it's so carefully crafted, and he packs so much information into a page, that you can't read on cruise control- you have to be absolutely focused, and fully engaged with every word. Otherwise, you end up saying to yourself "what the fuck did he just say?" or "say what?" or simply "huh???" and having to go back a paragraph or a couple of pages. This book took a long time to read, and was at times difficul...more
Thelonious Monk: The Life and Times of an American Original by Robin D.G. Kelley is a meticulously researched and engaging read that seeks to put the record straight with any chaser. Popular notions about Monk tend to emphasize his lack of formal training, his bizarre behavior and unique fashion sense. Drawing upon a wealth of family documents, Kelley masterfully weaves a story that captures Monk's genius and his humanity with compassion and profound appreciation.
As an educator, I...more
As an educator, I...more
I'm a longtime admirer of Thelonious Monk as composer and performer, but I gave up when the fact that Monk bought a 1957 Buick--meaningful as an index of his slightly more comfortable economic situation--was followed by a quotation of Buick's advertising slogan that year. I mean, OK, graduate research assistants are wonderful people and scholarship would be at a loss without them, but does everything they produce have to make it into the book?
A fascinating look at one of the most unique American musicians ever. It's not perfect, as the author indulges in a bit too much mind-reading, but its strengths more than outweigh that one weakness. This book busts the myths of Monk's so-called weirdness, and sheds new light on his battles with mental illness (probably undiagnosed bipolar disorder). It also gives a great look into the life of a jazz musician in the years after WWII. It was pretty damn hard for those men (women - other than sing...more
Fascinating. The detail is astounding...he basically covers every month of Monk's life. De-bunks the primitivist, racist myths of the "instinctual" genius, and shows instead how his musical background became fodder for a one of a kind imagination. Definitely re-kindled my love for Monk's music, which was my first love in Jazz. And the detail on the sessions and sidemen enriches my listening.
A beautiful, loving biography of one of the half dozen most important American musicians/composers. Kelley's exactly the right biographer, deeply grounded in jazz and African American history. Kelley traces Monk from the legendary session at Minton's through his struggles for recognition to his brief time close to the top of the jazz world in the 1960s and then through his final decade of illness and withdrawal. "Play yourself" was Monk's mantra--he was never afraid of taking risks ...more
I was really excited to read this book--heard that it was coming out a while ago and was probably the first person to check it out of the library--but ultimately I'm a little disappointed. Nonetheless, it is an incredible example of meticulous research--Kelley provides a very detailed and thoughtful narrative of all aspects of Monk's life: his music, his family, his youth, his experiences with religion & spirituality, his (ab)use of drugs & alcohol, and of course, his struggles with mental illn...more
This was good, almost really good. Thelonius Monk was a very gifted and quirky character, and Kelley does a good job illuminating Monk's genius, eccentricities, and struggles with mental illness. In addition, the reader learns a great deal about key characters in Monk's life, most especially his wife, but also, other family members, fellow musicians, and, interestingly, the Countess Nica de Koenigswarter who was a patron and close friend.
It was cool learning more about Monk's music...more
It was cool learning more about Monk's music...more
It's a very good well researched bio. There's a few thing that bothered me, but all in all that's to be expected. I particularly didn't care for Kelley's continued use of the "Solfeggio" in reference to the grunting Monk would sometimes do while playing. I did like the fact that the author realized that Monk was well grounded in what came before him.
The first few chapters are a little chunky, heavy with information, so it's hard to feel the thread of the story, but once Thelonious comes into adolescence, the book comes into its own, presenting a readable and informative account that gives a clear look at Monk, specifying his gifts and his manias.
I have only started this book. Kelley paints a picture of Monk's southern upbringing and subsequent migration to New York which sheds light on the music he came to create. Traveling tent revivalists, gang warfare, and jazz club rivalries are some of the threads woven into the fabric of this bio.
Exhaustive, relevatory, and mournful bio of one of the most unique composers in classical music. Moves a bit slow at times--especially if you're not a die-hard Monk fan (I am). It'll be hard to top this if anyone tries later on, as many of the sources are "going away." Interesting sidelights include the women and children in Monk's life, his methods as a teacher and bandleader, and the effects of illness on creativity. Very rich read.
Wow; SUPER well-researched and documented bio; really exhaustive look at Monk's life. Gives a well-rounded picture of who Monk was, and works to dispel the myths around the High Priest of Bop. But it took a long time to read--so thorough that I found myself dragging through it a bit. Not in a way that was boring, though; still a compelling story.
An incredibly meticulous account of Monk's life and work. The detail (and notes) is exhaustive, but the style makes the book very readable. I was fairly familiar with Monk's life and work, but this book added a great deal more detail.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| How does book discuss his musical contributions to jazz? | 3 | 7 | Aug 21, 2011 07:10pm | |
| <a href="http://www.radioopensource.org/robin-kelleys-transcendental-thelonious-monk/"> Kelley's Monk</a> | 1 | 11 | Jan 02, 2010 06:11am |
Robin D.G. Kelley (b. 1962) is a professor of history and American studies and ethnicity at the University of Southern California. From 2003-2006, he was the William B. Ransford Professor of Cultural and Historical Studies at Columbia University. From 1994-2003, he was a professor of history and Africana Studies at New York University as well the chairman of NYU's history department from 2002-2003...more
More about Robin D.G. Kelley...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...






view all 3 comments









































