Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation Will Change the Way the World Learns
Selected as one of the "Best Books on Innovation, 2008" by "BusinessWeek" magazine
Named the "Best Human-Capital Book of 2008" by "Strategy + Business" magazine
A crash course in the business of learning-from the bestselling author of "The Innovator's Dilemma" and "The Innovator's Solution."..
"Provocatively tit
...moreHardcover, 238 pages
Published
May 14th 2008
by McGraw-Hill
(first published 2008)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
768)
The authors posit that the reason why traditional schooling fails so many is that by nature, the structure of schools encourage standardization rather than customization (and customization is what produces truly effective learning environments). Using available data, they predict that in the next 10-12 years fully half of all high schoolers will attend classes online in order to maximize the marketplace's ability to offer them opportunities not available in the traditional face-to-face format. ...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Good exposition of Christensen's "disruptive innovation" theory - explaining how initially annoying products grow to take over markets and throw out older established companies. This book applies the theory to schools and education, with mixed success.
I got the clear impression that these authors were outsiders to the culture and complexity of schools and educational theory. So it's great to have their theory applied to the problem, but a little shaky in the details. For exam...more
I got the clear impression that these authors were outsiders to the culture and complexity of schools and educational theory. So it's great to have their theory applied to the problem, but a little shaky in the details. For exam...more
There is an idea I've been hearing over and over again in many different contexts, and this book brings it up again in the context of education.
It has been said that there is no perfect Pasta Sauce.... For years the companies that produce past sauce had been trying to perfect the single perfect pasta sauce through extensive research and taste testings, and to then market it accordingly. Of course, we not realize that there are, in fact, three! Regular, Spicy, and Extra Chunky. ...more
It has been said that there is no perfect Pasta Sauce.... For years the companies that produce past sauce had been trying to perfect the single perfect pasta sauce through extensive research and taste testings, and to then market it accordingly. Of course, we not realize that there are, in fact, three! Regular, Spicy, and Extra Chunky. ...more
This is a very good book until the last chapter where it seems to draw a conclusion that the only way to fix education is with charter school type approaches. For example, we could all have a perfect house with an unlimited budget to build a new one but eventually it would show faults! We can't just build new houses. Although Hercules cleaned out the Agean stables- if they didn't remedy their ways it would fill up with filth again. Sometimes we don't step out of the box- we create new boxes! Per...more
Margaret
added it
Some random thoughts:
1) The idea that a disruptive technology begins NOT in competition with the traditional technology, but filling a niche that was previously empty is fascinating and a bit liberating. It is liberating in that it acknowledges that the new technology is not doing, and perhaps at that point, CAN'T do what the traditional one does. Many people criticize online learning because it can't replace real interactivity of a classroom and that many online courses are ju...more
The author of The Innovator's Dilemma applies his theory of disruptive innovation to education, showing why it's so hard to change the current school system and predicting that a computer-based learning model will break out into mainstream use by 2019.
Christensen's theory makes a lot of sense: he claims that a well-established organization CAN'T successfully change its own fundamentals, because the gain from massive change is always much smaller than the gain from incremental change. ...more
Christensen's theory makes a lot of sense: he claims that a well-established organization CAN'T successfully change its own fundamentals, because the gain from massive change is always much smaller than the gain from incremental change. ...more
Clayton Christensen offers a believable and intuitive approach to fixing our staggering American educational system. In a nutshell: people learn in different ways (no surprise here; it's a well-documented theory). Teachers too often teach one way (or two or three--the point being, teachers standardize. I understand. I've been a teacher most of my life. One of us and many of them in a classroom). His solution: Use 21st century technology and Web 2.0 to individualize lessons to suit needs.
...more
...more
Fascinating look at disruptive innovation in education
The very real value of this useful and, at times, pleasantly surprising book comes from the way the authors apply their expertise in innovation to the field of education. By approaching public education’s crisis with new eyes – and conceptualizing education as a product or service like any other – Clayton M. Christensen (The Innovator’s Dilemma), Michael B. Horn and Curtis W. Johnson provide insights that escape the tired loops of...more
The very real value of this useful and, at times, pleasantly surprising book comes from the way the authors apply their expertise in innovation to the field of education. By approaching public education’s crisis with new eyes – and conceptualizing education as a product or service like any other – Clayton M. Christensen (The Innovator’s Dilemma), Michael B. Horn and Curtis W. Johnson provide insights that escape the tired loops of...more
Christensen has some genuinely good ideas and places the historical demands of public schools accurately. Everyone learns differently - absolutely. Current models does not allow this to come through - agreed. However, his ideas near the end seem to champion avoid "the problems of democracy" via mayoral control. He cites NYC Bloomberg-Klein fiasco as if their power-wielding "reforms" were successful; moreover, more credit needs to be given to educators. There have been many di...more
Glenn
added it
According the Christensen, the education system in the US and globally is undergoing a sea change. The move from traditional (schools, paper, teacher/student) to digital (virtual schools, ebooks, user-networks) is growing at an accelerating pace. This book applies theories and models from earlier books INNOVATORS DILEMMA and INNOVATORS SOLUTIONS to education and the business of education to provide a glimpse into the future.
It's tempting for those invested in the current system to di...more
It's tempting for those invested in the current system to di...more
In this Clayton M. Christensen book, Bro. Christensen and his co-authors tackle how we learn and how education is going to change in the next decade or so. Technology disrupts learning, just as it has business and health care. I'm not sure I like all the possible changes, but I do know that our nation's schools are broken and many people are not learning by the methods of the past. Reading this made me think a lot about my own education, my own curiosity to learn, and how/if my grandchildren ...more
I'd actually give this book a 3 because it's business-speak, a style of writing I loathe; but if I do that, no one will read it. Full of useful, common-sensical observations and some excellent suggestions for radically altering US schools (they use the word "revolutionize," though I refuse to; their ideas are good but not THAT good), they advocate school change through computer technology and, more importantly, by applying the lessons of change in the computer industry. What I can't te...more
I strongly agree with Clayton Christensen's central thesis - that students should be taught individually, based on their individual strengths, learning styles, and interests. They should be able to start at their own level and proceed at their own pace, for optimum learning. I was grateful to experience a learning environment like that at my elementary Montessori school, but most public schools can't replicate the incredibly low teacher-student ratios we had (about 7:1). How can a teacher wit...more
Strange to be reading this book, whose theme is built on the foundation that instruction needs to be highly individualized because students learn differently, right after Why Students Don't Like School which makes it clear that everyone learns in basically the same way. In Disrupting Class, Christensen briefly cites Gardner, and moves on. In the latter book author Daniel Willingham, a cognitive psychologist, thoroughly backs up the statement that we all learn in essentially the same way, debunki...more
We need to find ways to help people learn better.
Everyone agrees with that statement.
Who doesn’t remember hours, days, years really, wasted listening to the drone of an instructor relating information one has already acquired? And an equal amount of time attempting to comprehend information an instructor is sharing that is so beyond one that there is no hope of understanding it?
I hoped this book would have powerful ideas for action leading to change. Instead...more
Everyone agrees with that statement.
Who doesn’t remember hours, days, years really, wasted listening to the drone of an instructor relating information one has already acquired? And an equal amount of time attempting to comprehend information an instructor is sharing that is so beyond one that there is no hope of understanding it?
I hoped this book would have powerful ideas for action leading to change. Instead...more
Just finished the "disrupting class" book. I think Wikinomics or Friedman's work hits the issue more directly. However, I think Christensen et al. did paint a good picture for the need of using computers to do new things. Not just "shove paper down wire" as Richardson and November put it.
Two good discussion quotes:
p. 84 "Teachers have implemented computers in the most common-sense way-to sustain their existing practices and pedagogies rather than...more
Two good discussion quotes:
p. 84 "Teachers have implemented computers in the most common-sense way-to sustain their existing practices and pedagogies rather than...more
Incredibly interesting book detailing the ways that technology can best be utilized in education. Specifically, it talks about using disruptive innovations that brings to the market a product or service that is different and competes against nothing. The overall goal is to improve student-centric learning under the philosophy that students have wildly different learning styles and our current (monolithic) education system teaches a one-style-fits-all approach when it should have a more modular a...more
I really liked the first 4 chapters of this book. I would give those chapters 5 stars. The problem with this book is the last chapter. I like the research and the ideas. I even think it is plausible that online education has a very definite place in education. It would certainly allow for very talented teachers to be in many places at once (i.e. the Khan Academy). Secondly, if you had a kid with a learning disability they could get their lessons from a teacher with that specialty. Or if the scho...more
Corin
added it
If education needs to be more individualized, then how can computer-based learning be the only solution? Different programs can only go so far if some children learn best by movement or collaboration or...
IOW the author undermines a good premise by using his own preferred method (flexible as it is, it's not flexible enough) as a one size fits all -- and right after he argues against one size fits all!
I was disappointed by this book.
I also disliked the use of footnotes at the end of each chapte...more
IOW the author undermines a good premise by using his own preferred method (flexible as it is, it's not flexible enough) as a one size fits all -- and right after he argues against one size fits all!
I was disappointed by this book.
I also disliked the use of footnotes at the end of each chapte...more
I found this book to be OK. I have a feeling it might become the "next big thing" in education world for awhile. Many of the authors ideas made me think: "whatever". Without funding they simply cannot happen. It isn't that they aren't good ideas, having started a charter school in 2000, I've actually used some of them in practice...but they do go against the status quo in education...and are likely going to be slow to develop if they develop at all.
The author spent...more
The author spent...more
Laurie
added it
There are some good ideas in the book, but it's a struggle to read because of jargon and business terminology. I wouldn't have finished it if I hadn't been reading it for a book club at work. It is true that computer-assisted instruction is better than no instruction at all, and may even work better for some students. But for my discipline, foreign languages, it's sad to contemplate people learning online in isolation, or twittering on their phones, rather than getting together with people wh...more
Very interesting application of Christensen's theory of disruptive innovation to the school system. I think he does a good job of listing many of the reasons the structure of the school system makes progress, adaptation, and individualization difficult. He has identified online learning as a potential disruptive innovation that could fulfill a need that the traditional school system cannot, and he had strong arguments and some innovative ideas for how it could become more pervasive. It will be i...more
So, this is an interesting book. If you're wondering about the movement of education in the last 10+ years, the metanarrative if you will, then this book would definitely interest you. If you're curious about what reforms work and why, then this book would provide some interesting details. I find myself, often, in both of these situations, so I really enjoyed this book. I did wonder, throughout, how much the borrowed from the much heralded economic title, 'The Innovator's Dilemma'. This boo...more
http://www.edutopia.org/stw-online-learn...
The summary of what schools need to work on is perfect.
The author believes that the computers that fill the schools have not been utilized beyond word processing. Unless high schools do something different I believe he is correct.
The author speaks of sustaining innovation and disruptive innovation and noncomsumables and a large number of failed business ventures and how this realtes to schools not embracing the possiblities of ...more
The summary of what schools need to work on is perfect.
The author believes that the computers that fill the schools have not been utilized beyond word processing. Unless high schools do something different I believe he is correct.
The author speaks of sustaining innovation and disruptive innovation and noncomsumables and a large number of failed business ventures and how this realtes to schools not embracing the possiblities of ...more
The authors make a compelling case to support their claims that computer and web-based learning will inevitably change the nature of education in the next ten years. This change will be for the better as learning can become more student-centric with the teacher functioning as a learning facilitator.
Some acute observations are those regarding "intellectual cliques" (p. 37), which highlight how various subjects tend to cater to particular intelligence types/learning styles; ...more
Some acute observations are those regarding "intellectual cliques" (p. 37), which highlight how various subjects tend to cater to particular intelligence types/learning styles; ...more
Clayton Christensen, the author of The Innovator’s Dilemma, makes a compelling argument for how innovation, almost always by definition disruptive, could bring profound change to the resistant world of public education. Christensen argues that education finally needs to solve the problem of how to reach every student in terms of his or her individual interests, needs, and learning styles and paces. Historically that has proved impossible. Schools are designed to deliver a monolithic instructiona...more
i forced my poor travel companion to engage me in numerous discussions as i teased out the very interesting theories and predictions in this book (thank you rtw). definitely not the light and fluffy writing that books on education can sometimes be; instead, it is filled with interesting anecdotes/analogies to business which i appreciated and enjoyed learning about in their own right. makes me want to reconsider a career in education...
---
I was inspired to write a longer review for ...more
---
I was inspired to write a longer review for ...more
Very interesting. Basically the take the principles from Innovator's Dilema (a business school classic) and apply them to improving the education system. The book is extremely well researched, entertaining, and full of well thought out ideas. I like that they don't just explain the problem , but they actually provide step-by-step solutions that are backed up by data. If you're at all interested in education or innovation in general you would probably enjoy this.
Okay, I will admit that this was not bad. I still have a hard time taking advice about teaching and education from someone who has never taught. Anyway, there is some valid stuff in here, mostly about how online courses are going to improve and start to be used more often. Books like this always have motivational material for teachers, but this was seriously bogged down with lame business metaphors. If you like business and teaching, this is for you! I really liked the ideas, but I'm not th...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Clayton M Christensen is the Robert and Jane Cizik Professor of Business Administration at the Harvard Business School, with a joint appointment in the Technology & Operations Management and General Management faculty groups. He is best known for his study of innovation in commercial enterprises. His first book, The Innovator's Dilemma (ISBN 0-06-052199-6), articulated his theory of disruptive tec...more
More about Clayton M. Christensen...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...











view 1 comment
































