Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Night in Question” as Want to Read:
The Night in Question
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Night in Question

4.16  ·  Rating Details ·  3,801 Ratings  ·  250 Reviews
A man is shot dead while standing in line at the bank, another is fired for printing an obituary of a citizen as yet undeceased. A young woman visits her father following his nervous breakdown, and a devoted sister is profoundly unsettled by the sermon her brother insists on reciting. Whether in childhood or Vietnam, in memory or the eternal present, these people are revea ...more
Hardcover, 224 pages
Published October 8th 1996 by Knopf (first published 1996)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Ahmad Sharabiani
The Night in Question, Tobias Wolff
عنوان: شب مورد نظر؛ نویسنده: توبیاس وولف؛ مترجم: منیر شاخساری؛ تهران، چشمه، 1388؛ در 147 ص؛ شابک: 9789643625399؛ موضوع: داستانهای کوتاه از نویسندگان امریکایی - قرن 20 م
داستانهای: اموات، شب موردنظر؛ گلوه ای در مغز؛ قربانی؛ برف؛ میلر دیگر؛ زنجیر؛ رویای لیدی؛ شب موردنظر؛ شعله ی آتش؛
Maciek
I liked this collection - the first one I've read by Tobias Wolff, a writer that I always meant to read but somehow never did. Wolff is mainly a short story author, which is a declining profession in this day and age - instead of being published in various magazines as they were ages ago, short stories seem to be retreating back to literary journals which hardly anybody reads and fat anthologies which people purchase and put on their shelves. There's real perspective of the short story actually ...more
Glenn Sumi
Apr 02, 2016 Glenn Sumi rated it really liked it
Shelves: short-stories
I was familiar with some of these stories from magazines, anthologies like The Best American Short Stories series, and The New Yorker podcast. And I’m a big fan of The Vintage Book Of American Short Stories, which Tobias Wolff edited and which contains some of the best short fiction from the past half a century. (Note to self: I need to finish that book some day and review it properly.)

But I’d never read a Wolff book all the way through. My loss. This is a very strong collection of 15 stories.
...more
Rick Strong
Apr 13, 2013 Rick Strong rated it it was amazing
I discovered this collection of short stories in the small library in my co-op's laundry room, and what a happy chance meeting it has been. Every story in this collection made me say to myself: Damn, I wish I could write like that! Clear, unpretentious, economical, wry, emotionally authentic, and with unexpected twists and developments that knocked me on my mind's ass and made me think about the stories for hours after reading them. The last story in the book, Bullet In The Brain, stays with me ...more
Conor
Apr 04, 2016 Conor rated it really liked it
Shelves: short-stories
Loved this collection of short stories. I kept thinking of how much of it reminded me of other narratives that I have enjoyed--"Smorgasbord" reminded me of Lorrie Moore, with its weird, unexplained quirkiness and strong femininity, "The Chain" recalled a Coen brothers script, and "The Life of the Body" felt like a George Saunders story (though this last comparison should not be too surprising, given that Wolff served as a mentor to Saunders). Really good stuff, and better than the long-form memo ...more
Andrea
Jun 02, 2007 Andrea rated it it was amazing
All because of "Bullet in the Brain." The first time I encountered this story was at a Tobias Wolff reading, and those were shimmering minutes (especially the last half of the story). A few years later I was lucky enough to see the premiere of Word for Word's theatrical (and word-for-word) adaptation of the piece. I think of this story often, and it reminds me again and again to be present, to be present, to be awake and to enjoy.
Alix
Jan 05, 2015 Alix rated it it was ok
I was surprisingly disappointed by this book. A good story should have, in my opinion, either a great idea, a nice twist, or a certain atmosphere that makes it unforgettable. These stories failed to leave an impression on me. There were a few that stood out from the lot, such as "The Other Miller", or "The Night in Question", but even from those I expected more. The style felt unnatural, strained and overly polished, as if the writer worked so hard on his craft that he forgot to enjoy it.
Mercedé Khodadadi مرسده خدادادی
کوتاه و دلنشین
داستانها لزوماً پایان خاصی نداشتند، اما خوب بودند
Martha
Nov 16, 2013 Martha rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
واقعا مجموعه داستان فوق العاده ای بود. لذت بردم بیشتر از شیوه روایت که محشر بود...یک دنیاتشکر مجدد ازمهران نجفی برای اینکه این اثر را پیشنهاد کردند.با اجازه رعنا ولیلی دوستا خوبم میخوام از شیوه شان استفاده کنم و هر کدام از داستانهای این مجموعه را ستاره باران کنم.:)داستان قربانی واقعا داستان جذابی بود...شیوه سادستیک راوی در روایت محشر بود که در داستانهای دیگه به نوبه ی خود با تفاوت هایی تکرار شد.داستان قربانی 2ستاره ناقابل با اغماض می گیرد.داستان برف 3 ستاره؛ واقعا داستان دوست داشتنی بود. من واقع ...more
John
Jan 16, 2013 John rated it really liked it
All of Wolff's stories, with the exception of maybe three, are exquisitely crafted. Putting on my pompous hat, I'd say Wolff masterfully distills the essence of the hidden miracles of everyday experience, effectuating something wonderfully blah blah blah, etc. etc. Gems include: "Two Boys and a Girl," "Smorgasbord," the eponymous story, "Firelight," and the first one about the obits writer. I'd even name the last one as a gem, too, if I were to re-read it.
Nick
Aug 25, 2013 Nick rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition

REVIEW

I had never heard of Tobias Wolff before randomly finding this book in a thrift store, but a little internet research pre-read told me I should have. It turned out he was heavily lauded and showered with awards and adoration, and also published some semi-classics, such as In Pharoah's Army. Fortified with this information, I actually held off on the book, secure in the fact that it would be an interesting read for a later day, and also looking forward to challenging the esteem of such a pr
...more
Shaun
Apr 19, 2013 Shaun rated it it was amazing
Wow. This is definitely a 6 or 7 star book/collection of short stories, IMO. Strong, memorable characters? Yes. Interesting and engaging plot lines? Yes. Lots of wisdom and insight? Yes. Plenty of humor and even a few laugh-out-loud moments? Yes. And perhaps the most important, a moment capable of giving you the shivers? Yes.

Excerpt from Sanity and referring to books written on sexual technique:

"People write about technique," she said, "as if it's the whole ball game, which is a complete joke. Y
...more
Matt Evans
Mar 24, 2012 Matt Evans rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I’ve grown weary of a certain type of fiction. Fiction that presents itself as fiction. Better said, fiction whose language strives (w/o precision) for poetry’s vague enchantments, and whose stories and details are of the kind that fruity old professors speak about in succulent terms, terms like pieces of brownly broiled chicken, these professors smacking their lips maddeningly on nothing but their ideas of something juicy. Somewhere a saucy Shakespearean actor shouts the word, “acting,” pronoun ...more
David Haight
Oct 09, 2012 David Haight rated it it was amazing
I came across Tobais Wolff as a result of Carver and Cheever. I have to say that I am very happy that I did. Clearly someone who has mastered the short story form, Wolff writes about the small conflicts of every day life with a sharp eye, keen wit and palpable sensitivity and unlike Carver he isn't awash in booze and constant anguish (which isn't a critique of Carver who I love). The stories range from the heartbreaks of unrequited love as a teenager to class struggle to a man biting a dog's ear ...more
Jacob
Jul 09, 2010 Jacob rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2010-2011
September/October 2011

An obituary writer discovers that one of his subjects is still alive, a soldier takes advantage of a bureaucratic mix-up, boys get side-tracked in their airplane-building project, and one man's retaliation against a dog attack leads to unforeseen but devastating consequences. And others. I haven't read Wolff before, so I don't really share the admiration and excitement expressed by other reviewers (really, I just bought it because there was a train on the cover), but I like
...more
Dustincecil
Feb 01, 2017 Dustincecil rated it liked it
3.5 stars... Just OK to me. I appreciated the variety of characters presented here, but ultimately wanted more from this collection...

I think maybe the Wolff boys just aren't my cup of tea.

Larry Bassett
Oct 09, 2011 Larry Bassett rated it it was amazing
Shelves: short-stories
I am attracted to the idea of short stories so sometimes I have gone on a run of buying used short story books. So it makes sense that I might occasionally go on a run of reading short story books. I am not familiar with this author and had no special reason that I can recall for picking out The Night in Question.

But the first story intrigues me so I think I will read on. A writer has recently landed a job as the obituary man for the local paper but is fired when one of his subjects turns up ali
...more
Paul
Dec 17, 2009 Paul rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2009
Hmm. I don't know. I really don't. These stories are all well-written; Wolff has poise, control, restraint, his characters are efficiently and fully formed, the situations are both believable and resonant/touching, and he doesn't (for the most part) rely on style or unorthodox voice to drive his stories (not that there would be anything wrong with doing so). And yet, though. I think the problem I had most often with these stories was that so often he creates such a compelling context/etc. for th ...more
Roberta
Dec 20, 2011 Roberta rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Ci sentiamo obbligati a sorridere delle passioni dei giovani, e di ciò che ricordiamo delle nostre personali passioni giovanili, come se non fossero altro che una serie di dolci inganni con cui ci siamo baloccati, prima di mettere giudizio. Non parlo solo della passione che i ragazzi e le ragazze provano gli uni per gli altri ma anche delle altre passioni, la passione per la giustizia, la passione di fare ciò che è giusto fare a costo di rigirare il mondo come un guanto. Tutte queste passioni a ...more
Derek
Feb 18, 2008 Derek rated it it was amazing
The only thing stopping me from saying "Flyboys" is the best story in The Night in Question is the absolute perfection of "Bullet in the Brain," and the only thing stopping me from saying "Bullet in the Brain" is the best story ever is, well, I don't know. I had the awesome pleasure of getting to hear Tobias Wolff read that story (as well as some of Old School) when he gave a reading in Pittsburgh a few years ago. I had liked the story before, but after his reading I loved it, and I can't say at ...more
Katherine
Mar 30, 2010 Katherine rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fiction
"'I'm a survivor,' I said. But I didn't think that claim would carry much weight in an obituary" (11).
"Through the crazed Plexiglass she could make out some small islands and the white glint of a shit in the apex of its wake" (34).
"Like being in a speedboat, only better. You can't go downhill in a boat" (37).
"At night, after he'd prepared his classes, he drank wine and read nineteenth-century novels. He didn't like modern fiction, its narcissism, its moral timidity, its silence in the face of gr
...more
Hutarch
Jan 05, 2009 Hutarch rated it really liked it
These stories exhibit Wolff's strengths: brisk narrative flow, memorable characters that come to life in a few strokes, the odd nugget of wisdom, and pithy metaphors.

I love Wolff, and this collection is no disappointment. There are some fine stories here; my favorite is the title story. In it, Wolff is able to tell a one-scene story that magically, it would seem, conjures up the full lives and histories of a brother and sister and their family history. I also really like "The Life of the Body."

S
...more
Anne
Jul 28, 2007 Anne rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Author of This Boy's Life, Wolff's writing is straight-forward and engaging, with characters who end up in situations that are not quite always what they seem, yet still always strangely familiar. This collection of short stories does not have a single narrative theme or subject matter - but rather is a collection of writing Wolff has earlier published in magazines such as The New Yorker and The Atlantic. My favorites included "The Other Miller" about an American soldier in Vietnam who is told t ...more
Michael Meyerhofer
May 22, 2008 Michael Meyerhofer rated it it was amazing
I've only read Tobias Wolff's short stories--both this book and the ones from "In the Garden of the North American Martyrs"--but this collection left me speechless. Story after story elegantly focuses on the everyday happenings of mostly "ordinary" people with a keen, often whimsical attention to detail that reminds me of eastern poets. Yet Wolff blends his take on things with a distinctly "American" flavor--an American writer at his best. Stories like "The Chain" and "Bullet in the Brain" are b ...more
Jesse
May 01, 2008 Jesse rated it it was amazing
What a masterful book of short stories. I agree with other reviewers who say that Wolff has matured and really found his voice. His first book of stories, while brilliant, had a tendency to peter out, while this collection contains stories that are well crafted and self-sustaining. He is a master at avoiding short story let down (defined as: the feelings of frustration that acompany the end of a short story; once you start to relate to a character and care about what happens to him, the story en ...more
Sara
May 01, 2011 Sara rated it it was amazing
It took me awhile to get through these stories and I'm glad to be done with them, but in like the best possible way. Wolff has a really brutal touch, and each story sort of curls up inside you as you read it, only to be ripped out once it's finished. I got into the habit of reading a few stories before going to sleep, and I think that's the best way to do it - that way each one can really settle into your bones. Dude's a genius, but I'm not sure I'll seek out his work again, there are only so ma ...more
Joshua Rivera
Nov 15, 2011 Joshua Rivera rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
The main story I loved from this book was Bullet in the Brain. I loved how Wolff displayed the character Anders from sarcastic ass when living to a young innocent kid who cherishes his life after the bullet entered his brain. It was a twist that I didn’t see coming, a twist that makes the reader hate Anders in the beginning to feeling sorry for him at the end. I learned how to better formulate character progression even if the character isn’t physically living and how to incorporate better twist ...more
Michelle
This collection didn't really "wow" me. I think it was because the stories seemed like they were trying too hard to shock the reader, and it just wasn't working for me. Some of the stories were very good, others were just eh. I wondered why they were included at all.

My favorite of the collection was called, "Chain." I also liked "Casualty" and "The Other Miller," both of which took place during the Vietnam War. I can't seem to get away from Vietnam stories lately. I don't normally read them, bu
...more
Carrie
Nov 13, 2009 Carrie rated it really liked it
So good.

I've been sitting here for a solid five minutes trying to nail down what it is about Wolff's style that I found so engaging, and I'm at a loss. I don't know that I could identify a throughline in these stories other than to say that they were each surprising in some way.

They are mostly really quick reads. I stayed up way too late because I wanted to finish reading it. I woke up, started to put the book in my bad, and was sad when I remembered that there was no more.
Timothy Limner
Apr 05, 2012 Timothy Limner rated it it was amazing
Excellent compilation of shorts capped off with possibly the best short story I've ever read, "Bullet In The Brain", a story of a jaded book critic that critiques everything and everyone around him. Of course, his mouth gets him in trouble and he gets shot in the head, but while the bullet travels through his brain he remembers a more innocent time from his childhood. Brilliantly written. I got a chance to go to a reading where Mr. Wolff read "Bullet..." and his delivery was amazing.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
my question plz reply 1 2 Dec 08, 2016 10:47AM  
Is Wolff our greatest living short story writer? 6 16 Jan 14, 2014 04:23AM  
  • Dancing After Hours
  • The Pugilist at Rest
  • Rock Springs
  • The Collected Stories
  • The Point and Other Stories
  • Emperor of the Air
  • The Ice at the Bottom of the World: Stories
  • The Watch
  • The Coast of Chicago: Stories
  • Among the Missing
  • Where You'll Find Me: And Other Stories
  • Airships
  • Will You Please Be Quiet, Please?
  • The Stories of Richard Bausch
  • Love and Hydrogen: New and Selected Stories
  • Harmony of the World: Stories
  • Out of the Woods: Stories
  • The Collected Stories
7371
Tobias Jonathan Ansell Wolff is a writer of fiction and nonfiction.

He is best known for his short stories and his memoirs, although he has written two novels.

Wolff is the Ward W. and Priscilla B. Woods Professor in the School of Humanities and Sciences at Stanford University, where he has taught classes in English and creative writing since 1997. He also served as the director of the Creative Writ
...more
More about Tobias Wolff...

Share This Book



“The bullet is already in the brain; it won’t be outrun forever, or charmed to a halt. In the end it will
do its work and leave the troubled skull behind, dragging its comet’s tail of memory and hope and
talent and love into the marble hall of commerce.”
9 likes
“I'm a survivor, " I said. But I didn't think that claim would carry much weight in an obituary.” 7 likes
More quotes…