Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Return of the Crimson Guard (Malazan Empire, #2)” as Want to Read:
Return of the Crimson Guard (Malazan Empire, #2)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Return of the Crimson Guard (Malazan Empire #2)

4.03  ·  Rating Details  ·  6,724 Ratings  ·  205 Reviews
The returning mercenary Crimson Guard are sworn to oppose the Empire. Some elite Avowed scheme to open paths to power. Ascendants, ancient powerful entities, seek to exploit all sides for gain. "Traveller", a swordsman, and his companion Ereko, confront successive enemies until the last from which none have returned. "Old Hands", generals and mages from the previous Empero ...more
Hardcover, 702 pages
Published September 11th 2008 by Bantam Press (first published 2008)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Return of the Crimson Guard, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Return of the Crimson Guard

Gardens of the Moon by Steven EriksonA Game of Thrones by George R.R. MartinThe Blade Itself by Joe AbercrombieThe Black Company by Glen CookDeadhouse Gates by Steven Erikson
Military Fantasy
60th out of 245 books — 462 voters
The Way of Shadows by Brent WeeksGraceling by Kristin CashoreThe Hero of Ages by Brandon SandersonThe Painted Man by Peter V. BrettLast Argument of Kings by Joe Abercrombie
2008 DGLA Fantasy Book Nominees
51st out of 97 books — 226 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Okay, so this is book #2 in the Malazan Empire series which is written by Esslemont as opposed to Erikson. They created the world of Malazan together and so the books share a timeline and I had been told that it's best to read this book before venturing into Erikson's 8th book (Toll the Hounds) as there are major spoilers in Toll the Hounds for the events of this book. I was fairly hesitant heading into this, I must admit, because honestly the first Esslemont book was pretty poor in comparison t ...more
Oct 27, 2011 seak rated it it was amazing
I have to warn you that I'm a huge Malazan fan, so take this review as you will. The Malazan world fulfills all of my childhood wishes to become Spider-man mixed with Wolverine's claws, Donatello's brain and ninja skills, and throw in Silver Surfer's surfboard too.

I realize some of those are moot with the inclusion of the others...but I was a kid. :)

This world is filled with the knarliest people doing the craziest things and I love it. Everyone (main characters that is) is either the best at wha
TS Chan
Oct 30, 2015 TS Chan rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
*3.5 stars* (rounded up because LEGENDARY)

Esslemont definitely writes in a more direct manner than Erikson and that makes it easier the book easier to read, even though the introduction of new characters had my head spinning again for the first one-third of the book. Notwithstanding, I really liked some of these new characters (Kyle, Ereko, Rillish & Rell) after a time.

The timeline of Return of the Crimson Guard seems to run parallel to Reaper's Gale, i.e. post events in The Bonehunters, wit
“It is better to fail in originality than to succeed in imitation.”
― Herman Melville

So what happens when you fail in imitation? For me, you get a book like Return of the Crimson Guard. Esslemont tried his best to mimic Erikson's style for his first large Malazan contribution. What Erikson was able to pull off with masterful coherence, Esslemont struggled with for the entire book, making for a story that really stressed my patience.

There were some parts of this book that were really cool and wel
Sarah (Tail-Kinker)
Aug 08, 2011 Sarah (Tail-Kinker) rated it it was amazing
What will I do if Esslemont and Erikson stop writing in the Malazan world? Throw a tantrum, most definitely. I haven't had an author or series challenge me and excite me this much except Frank Herbert with Dune.

It was great to read about Westeros and learn more of the world Martin created (FINALLY) in A Dance with Dragons, but you just can't top Erikson and Esslemont for sheer epic storytelling scale and character creation. I've never read authors that can make you care about a character in jus
May 29, 2011 Terence rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Malazan Empire fans; sprawling-epic-SF fans
Shelves: sf-fantasy
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Chris Hawks
Apr 01, 2013 Chris Hawks rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: owned
Gotta say I enjoyed this one a lot more than I thought I would. Another solid entry in the history of the Malazan world, and (in my opinion) loads better than Night of Knives. I didn't have the issues with characterizations that a lot of other people apparently did, and found most of the plot threads quite enjoyable. Still, the book has its issues: Individual plots (or entire prologues) that didn't seem to relate to the rest of the book, and sections (like in NoK) that were far too vague, even i ...more
Oct 28, 2015 Nelson rated it liked it

"Return of the Crimson Guard" is the second Malazan novel by Ian C. Esslemont and it is a far better book than "Night of Knives" but It lacks some things that make the Erikson's novels great.

In this book, there is more action, more characters, the scale is bigger, the stakes are higher and there's more of everything, really. More jumping between storylines way too often, More chapters where nothing happens, and more character I don't know about and I won't be knowing by the end of the book.

David Sven
Apr 29, 2012 David Sven rated it really liked it
Shelves: fantasy, dark-fantasy
A solid contribution to the "Malazan Universe" created in Steve Erikson's 10 book series. This book borrows heavily on that world and intersects various plot lines from the Malazan books - so you will need to be 5 to 7 books into the Steve Erikson's books to understand or appreciate "Return of the Crimson Guard."

So the old and bitter enemies of the Malazan Empire "The Crimson Guard" are regrouping after many years of absence. Bound and driven by an eternal vow to see the Malazan empire destroyed
Kurt Criscione
Dec 07, 2011 Kurt Criscione rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fantasy, favorites
I good addition to the Malazan world, surprising events and though i found Ian's use of some of the characters to be too different from the way they were portrayed by Erikson... (Nil and Nether seem far to different from the way they were in Bonehunters and House of Chains, Mallick Rel was still a slimy piece of shit... buta capable piece and he actually got the job done wereas in Erikson he's just a disgusting character you want to hate. I guess its all a matter of interpretation).

A lot of othe
Feb 09, 2012 Traci rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fantasy
Don't even try to read this without having at least started the main Erikson series. Even if you have read the first Empire book Night of Knives.

For those of you who have read those other books but haven't read this one yet I highly recommend it. Although read Night of Knives first. Where I thought NoK felt like an add on or tie in book I could almost believe that this one fit right in with the Fallen books.

There are differences but I don't think I have read another author who comes closer to an
Jošua Vrajević
Sep 14, 2015 Jošua Vrajević rated it it was amazing
Mar 14, 2014 Nate rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: owned
This is the problem with having two authors both doing their own thing in the same world/series; there's a chance that one of them is just not gonna be as good in that world as the other and it's gonna mess with the quality of the whole series. For me, this is what's going on with the Malazan books. To put it bluntly, Esslemont is just not nearly as good a writer as Erikson. Esslemont falls short for me in every field that Erikson excels--the prose, characterization and invention are all weak. E ...more
Captain Sir Roddy, R.N. (Ret.)
Return of the Crimson Guard is the second "Malazan Empire" novel written by Ian C. Esslemont, and boy does he hit his stride with this contribution to the Malazan world! As some of you may know, Esslemont is the co-creator of the Malazan world with his friend and co-author, Steven Erikson. Esslemont did a great job with his first novel, Night of Knives, but he really pulled out all the stops in this novel. This is a big, meaty 700+ page novel that you just can't put down.

Return of the Crimson Gu
Jan 02, 2013 Lori rated it it was ok
About 1/3 of the way through. ICE has definitely matured in his writing since NoK. This one is dense, and somewhat wandering like Erikson, but not as well written, none of the complexity of characters. While Erikson hints at things and gives us baffling clues that slowly come together, ICE presents them as characters speak. Plus I'm not having all those deep thoughts of philosophy that imbibe the main Malazan series.

But! BUT! I love this world. ICE definitely succeeds in drawing us in to the poi
Joshua Simon
Apr 06, 2012 Joshua Simon rated it it was amazing
4.5 stars, rounded up to 5

I have to say that Esslemont's second effort is a huge improvement over Night of Knives. Below are my pros and cons:

- Excellant battle sequences (individually and on a grand scale) that were just as gripping and exciting as the main Malazan books written by Erikson.
- Big improvement in characterization over Night of Knives, especially since Esslemont used characters already introduced by Erikson in this book.
- Good worldbuilding as usual.
- Plot worked well with
Jul 14, 2008 Karlo rated it liked it
Shelves: fantasy
Story-wise: The plot moves forwards in leaps and bounds regarding the events between the Crimson Guard and the Malazan Empire. Needless to say, the resolution is climactic.

Style-wise: ICE is no SE (sorry to say it). His first book (Night of Knives) kept the POV limited and personal, which was a nice change from Erikson. This book has a much larger scale, in trying to keep all the balls moving, he adopts the Erikson-type transition between plot threads. Unfortunately, his imagery and language are
May 11, 2015 Farès rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Nice reading with nice flowing descriptions and action.. no time to breath.
some desapointment as to the Taychrenn and Topper plots.. but It was still a great book that builded on the Malazan world. You need to have read at least 5 of the MALAZAN BOOK OF THE FALLAN to undersand completely what's going on here.
Tamer Abdelgawad
Jul 09, 2011 Tamer Abdelgawad rated it liked it
Esslemont gets credit for co-creating the Malazan Empire universe with Steven Erikson, but the two novels I've read so far by him, Night of Knives and Return of The Crimson Guard pale somewhat by comparison to Erikson's work. In general, the plots are less intricate and the characterization is much worse. Almost everyone in Esslemont's books is either a great hero/veteran whose main exploits happened off-screen (in the past), or a reluctant military grunt who performs above expectation. Within t ...more
Sep 28, 2013 Steve rated it liked it
For purely story telling purposes, I enjoyed Night of Knives more. As other reviewers have penned I will concur: any additions to the Malazan canon are well received at this point. I will right now almost tolerate substandard conflict and narrative if it fills a void in historically significant events
May 04, 2014 Matt rated it it was amazing
Shelves: own-it
An excellent addition to the Malazan universe. A good mix of familiar characters as well as plenty of new characters. It seems like Esslemont has caught on to the magic of Erikson's building up to a grand climax.
Duffy Pratt
Apr 09, 2015 Duffy Pratt rated it it was ok
Shelves: fantasy, shared-world
I would have liked to write a review of this book without comparing Esslemont to Erikson, but I can't. I love the Malazan world, and as a result, I enjoyed large parts of this book. Even so, it feels more like a gap filler than a fully conceived work of its own. This one covers the gap about what happens to Laseen and the Empire after she betrays Adjunct Tavore. And there are parts of it that I really liked - including the growth and development of a fledgling sapper who becomes Sergeant Jumpy. ...more
Oct 07, 2015 George rated it liked it
A much more improved work (compared to Night of Knives). Esslemont is coming into his own as an author here (compared to Erikson). This book is much more easy to read. There is a large focus on the Crimson Guard (which are an interesting group). I did not like how my perceived understanding of their vow was changed from MBotF. It was my understanding that their vow was one of loyalty to K'azz D'Avore. However, it turns out that their vow was annihilation of the Malazan empire. We've seen genocid ...more
Knižní Bandita
Dobrá knížka, ale dlouho jsem nečetl nic, co by mělo tak ploché postavy.

Kdyby si Esslemont místo pětatřiceti vybral tři čtyři postavy a každou provedl pořádným vývojem, byla by to hodně dobrá knížka. Zkrátka, trochu mi činilo problém se do těch lidí vcítit. Natož je od sebe rozeznat.

Je vidět, že když už si autor uvědomil, že postavy nemají žádný vývoj, postava si položí v hlavě pět otázek a zapochybuje o sobě. V dalším odstavci se už ale zase jede od znova. Dialogy, popis, dialogy (Kdo by řekl,
May 03, 2013 Brad rated it liked it
Shelves: fantasy, z-2013
I was kind of excited to see Esslemont's 2nd take on the Malazan universe. I appreciated that Night of Knives was much shorter than Erikson's novels and was looking forward to a simpler jaunt here. No dice. This book was nearly 1000 pages long, and it felt like it. There were a lot of really good parts, and there were several boring parts. It took nearly a month to read through it, which was unexpected.

Esslemont's writing has improved from his first book, but I felt like he was aping Erikson's s
Tiffany Shaw
Oct 09, 2008 Tiffany Shaw rated it liked it
Recommends it for: Malazan fans
Return of the Crimson Guard is the first full length Malazan novel by Stephen Erikson's partner in crime, Ian Cameron Esslemont.

Though Esslemont is definitely not as good a writer as Erikson, with more of a penchant for the level 1 hero (think Crokus in Gardens of the Moon) and few too many moments of plot convenience, he clearly has just as good a handle on the world and characters as Erikson does. It seems quite likely that the stylistic imperfections that Esslemont demonstrates here will be s
Jun 02, 2010 Rob rated it really liked it
...Esslemont’s second addition to the Malazan epic is a huge step forward compared to Night of Knives and a bold step as well. He puts himself in the spotlight with this tale of what goes on in the Malazan heartland. The books is a must read for Malazan fans, there is simply too much going on in this book that is important to the overall story. I think Esslemont (and Erikson) took a chance on this book by putting it so much at the heart of the story, and I think it paid off. Return of the Crimso ...more
Mar 26, 2012 Mike rated it really liked it
Given a little more room to breathe, the extra length of 'Return of the Crimson Guard' made for a much more satisfying read than 'Night of Knives', although I enjoyed that as well. 'Return' covers some pivotal events in the Malazan saga, and I feel like I should have read them in chronological order instead of by author, as these novels tie-in to each other perhaps more than any other. It's a strange effect to have one author completely skip events that are crucial to his own story because his f ...more
Patrick Samphire
Aug 01, 2009 Patrick Samphire rated it it was amazing
Perhaps the most remarkable thing about Esslemont and his co-creator, Steven Erikson, is just how similar in style their writing is. That means that they share many of the same strengths and weaknesses, but it also means that if you like Steven Erikson's Malazan novels, you'll like Esslemont's.

There are some slight differences. Esslemont is sometimes a slightly clumsier writer than Erikson, but he manages to avoid Erikson's occasional self-indulgences, producing a more streamlined novel.

This is
Oct 29, 2015 José rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Hard Fantasy fans
Shelves: fantasy, sagas-leidas
Reseña en español en el blog: Click Aquí

This book already has the feel of a Malazan book in terms of complexity, large amount of characters and epic convergences. It's way better than Esslemont's first book: there were some major plot twist that were awesome and totally unexpected along with the thrilling battles between armies and ancestral beings that are the trademark of the Malaz series.
If you are a fan of hard fantasy this is a must read, but I recommend reading Erikson's books first.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Fantasy and Sci-F...: Start of Book III - Epilogue & Final Thoughts 4 8 Nov 30, 2015 04:59AM  
Fantasy and Sci-F...: Book II - Start of Book III 3 14 Oct 24, 2015 12:14PM  
Fantasy and Sci-F...: Prologue - End of Book I 5 15 Oct 22, 2015 09:34AM  
Fantasy and Sci-F...: Thoughts Before We Start... 1 11 Sep 30, 2015 01:48PM  
Goodreads Librari...: This topic has been closed to new comments. mistake when adding a new book 8 22 Sep 24, 2014 05:14AM  
  • Bauchelain and Korbal Broach (The Tales of Bauchelain and Korbal Broach, #1-3)
  • The Books of the South (The Chronicles of the Black Company, #3.5-5)
  • The White Luck Warrior (Aspect-Emperor, #2)
  • Century of the Soldier
IAN CAMERON ESSLEMONT was born in 1962 in Winnipeg, Canada. He has a degree in Creative Writing, studied and worked as an archaeologist, travelled extensively in South East Asia, and lived in Thailand and Japan for several years. He now lives in Fairbanks, Alaska, with his wife and children and is currently working on his PhD in English Literature.

Ian C. Esslemont and Steven Erikson co-created the
More about Ian C. Esslemont...

Other Books in the Series

Malazan Empire (6 books)
  • Night of Knives (Malazan Empire, #1)
  • Stonewielder (Malazan Empire, #3)
  • Orb Sceptre Throne (Malazan Empire #4)
  • Blood and Bone (Malazan Empire #5)
  • Assail (Malazan Empire, #6)

Share This Book

“Battle is for an army to win or lose; war is for civilization to win or lose.” 4 likes
“You man that tiller day and night. Won't you rest?'
Ereko lightly laughed the suggestion aside. ‘No, lad. I am so old now that sleeping and waking have melded together into one and I know not which I inhabit.'
Watching the lad struggle through that, Ereko shifted course slightly to avoid a looming ice-spire.
'Truly? So old? As old as the mountains?'
Ereko raised his brows. ‘Goodness, no. Not that old. Only half so old, I should think.”
More quotes…