Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Top Secret: The Truth Behind Today's Pop Mysticisms” as Want to Read:
Top Secret: The Truth Behind Today's Pop Mysticisms
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Top Secret: The Truth Behind Today's Pop Mysticisms

3.40  ·  Rating Details  ·  52 Ratings  ·  20 Reviews
America may be the land of plenty, but in the midst of our Walmarts, enormous supermarkets, and other signs of material surfeit, it seems that many are experiencing a gnawing spiritual hunger. New religions, spiritualities, and religious therapies attract throngs of believers to megachurches, Yoga classes, and the bestseller bookshelves. The latest popular fad in spiritual ...more
Hardcover, 370 pages
Published March 1st 2008 by Prometheus Books
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Top Secret, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Top Secret

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 157)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Britt
Dec 29, 2009 Britt rated it really liked it
Worth flipping through for the section titles alone. My favorite: "Nine Principles in Amber." (Get it?)

Based on the chapter titles, section headings, and and blurbs, I was expecting a very skeptical, snarky attack on various woo-woo hucksters, but instead Price focuses on relating "new-age" ideas to older (not always ancient) traditions, often in a positive, affirming manner.

However, he shows little patience for those who claim new insights—or, as you might guess from the title, to be revealing
...more
Lauren Kinney
Oct 10, 2012 Lauren Kinney rated it it was ok
I've so wanted to read a serious critique of New Age and spiritual discourse as touted by Oprah et al. It's a lucrative industry, in part because these spiritualities run deep when a huge percentage of Americans report themselves to be "spiritual, but not religious."

I was excited about this book for its subject matter, but I was disappointed. The author claimed that he would not scorn followers of the works he critiqued, since after all these works are fulfilling an important function for many
...more
Kenny
Mar 26, 2009 Kenny rated it really liked it
Shelves: non-fiction
Price deconstructs (for the most part) popular spiritual movements of the day, with special emphasis and criticism for home-grown (American) inventions and their poseurs. Joel Osteen, everybody involved in A Course on Miracles, and Oprah-type hucksters like Neal Donald Walsh and Wayne Dyer get extra attention and are lambasted.

Eastern religions, however, seem to hold a special place in the author's heart. However, his dissection of Buddhism and Hinduism are welcome, as is his explanation of the
...more
Marjanne
Jun 19, 2008 Marjanne rated it liked it
Recommends it for: anyone interested in religion
This book is basically a critical look at several 'self-help' books. Some of these include "The Secret", "A Return to Love", and "Conversations with God". For the most part this book was interesting, though there were parts I felt like I was slogging through. If you don't actually want to read all of the books the author critiques then you may be interested to read this book. I liked that he has a sense of humor. When discussing religion people tend to be too serious.
I did learn a lot about Gno
...more
Jay Ant
Sep 12, 2015 Jay Ant rated it liked it
If you're going to hold a wienie roast, then light that fire Hiroshi! I would have enjoyed the unedited manuscript more. Price gave his pros and cons in an even tone like he was holding back. Judging by his headings, this could have been a real laugher, but his attempts at fair play left me flat. So, meh.

I had the wrong attitude due to his former titles. I expected some Christian-refutation-Jesus-shoe to drop, but it never manifested, as I imagined it might.

A tough read--much of it twice--while
...more
Jc
Jun 10, 2008 Jc rated it really liked it
A nice description of the philosophical and psychological problems in today's mystical/spiritual movements, such as Oprah's favorite "The Secret," and Deepak Chopra's pseudo-Buddhist nonsense. Bob gives some of these systems more credit than I would, but he does have some interesting ideas. The book is definitely for those who have some experience looking at these movements critically.
Ken
Jul 01, 2011 Ken rated it it was ok
Really pretty boring. Imagine your most boring college professor. Okay, not quite that bad, but close. As much as I wanted to like it, I had to abandon it halfway through.
Mike Kruse
Apr 26, 2008 Mike Kruse rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: anyone who read "The Secret" or some similar pap.
Finally, someone takes the New Thought / New Age gurus and breaks down what they're really saying. And most of it (but not quite all) amounts to crap.
Alan
Jun 16, 2014 Alan rated it it was ok
Shelves: religion
Thin on the ground. Links popular figures to their roots, ok, but sees that as somehow discrediting them. I am not surprised that there isn't much secret. Used to be said that only fat people have diet books, so who has spiritual books? And why so many? Author harbors a liking for more traditional religions, and better behaved expounders.
Steve Dustcircle
Sep 24, 2014 Steve Dustcircle rated it really liked it
Dr. Price does what he does best--destroying silly beliefs with fact, dressed with a little snarkiness.

Though the cover shows only a handful of his victims, very few pop culture religious views escape Robert Price's ridicule. Kaballah, UFOs, Scientology, Osteen, Popoff, Wicca, sales gimmicks, et al. all receive a description and are reasonably put to the grave.

Price explains rationally why these pseudo-religions are bunk, how one can identify them, and where people can stick these ideas. Price i
...more
Elaine
Aug 19, 2013 Elaine rated it liked it
Not sure what Mr. Price's ground axe is supposed to cut. He seems pretty angry that spiritual leaders are human and that they tend to stand on the shoulders of other human spiritual leaders. A couple of his big reveals are that Pema Chodron wasn't born with that name and that her mentor was an alcoholic. His beef with Eckhart Tolle is that he is merely a gifted philosopher with a novel application of Zen. Mr. Price needs to get over his idolizing of spiritual mystics and get on with his own spir ...more
SmokingMirror
Gnostic and Kabbalah chapters.
Min
Jul 08, 2014 Min rated it liked it
Overall, the text is balanced in that the author doesn't give criticism without justification and praises when there is fruit amongst the weeds to be had. I have heard of most of these book, yet, my curiosity isn't strong enough to read them. I may not be able to have read them with as much philosophical knowledge but certainly view his conclusions as they would be my own.
He certainly dishes out more critiques to those texts he feels are lacking in logic and failing to offer helpful content.
Todd Martin
I can distill my thoughts about this book into a single word ... “bleah!”

'Top Secret: The Truth Behind Today's Pop Mysticisms' consists of a collection of academic, esoteric clap-trap wrapped in a populist cover. I have no idea who the target audience for this book might be. Perhaps cynical masters candidates in religious studies might find this book interesting, but almost no one else will.
Moira
Great - highly recommended. Analysis by a religious scholar of new age thought and spiritual practices. Covers The Secret, Deepak Chopra, Pema Chodron, Course In Miracles, Conversations With God, The Celestine Prophecy, Eckhart Tolle, Shakti Gawain.

My only wish would be a similar book written from a scientific perspective.
Lynn
Sep 10, 2009 Lynn rated it it was ok
Like his other book, A Reason Driven Life, the best I can say about this book is that it is better than The Secret, which I have read. This was boring, and it shouldn't have been. It is probably a little better than A Reason Driven Life though.
Lisa
May 30, 2011 Lisa rated it it was amazing
Books and theories that reek of 'New Age' set my teeth on edge, as do pretenders and charlatans who turn ancient tenets into trite slogans. This book, therefore, was most refreshing and had me chuckling most of the way through. Fantastic book!
Karla
Aug 09, 2010 Karla rated it it was amazing
This book is great in that it gives a big "F you" to all of the pop culture gurus de jour. Oprah needs to read it and memorize its passages. She's partly responsible for its contents.
Karen Jett
Jun 28, 2011 Karen Jett added it
Shelves: abandoned
This was difficult to read and had to be returned to the library before I finished it. I have not felt motivated to check it out again. Maybe later...
Veneta
Mar 22, 2013 Veneta rated it liked it
Shelves: half-way, psychology
scientific look behind some of today's popular spiritual ideas and new ageism concepts
Thomas L. Mull
Thomas L. Mull marked it as to-read
May 17, 2016
Kyle
Kyle marked it as to-read
Apr 20, 2016
Taneka
Taneka marked it as to-read
Mar 30, 2016
Mary
Mary added it
Mar 13, 2016
Claire
Claire marked it as to-read
Mar 01, 2016
Boudewijn
Boudewijn marked it as to-read
Feb 17, 2016
Steve Plekan
Steve Plekan marked it as to-read
Feb 10, 2016
Kristen
Kristen marked it as to-read
Jan 24, 2016
Barbara
Barbara marked it as to-read
Dec 24, 2015
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Share This Book