reviews
Jan 24, 2010
A fascinating insight into the British military mind. I almost put it down around page 50 as unrealistic--which of course, it can't be--and then persevered. The problem for me was that the British Naval strategizing and decision making is quite different from what we Americans believe to be good military leadership. Admiral Woodward struggled over decisions, plodded to the inevitable end, worried about losing boats and helicopters over men, often had to check in with Britain to confirm--or appro
More...
0 comments
like
(1 person liked it)
Jun 09, 2009
Good book, a nice one to read after The Battle for the Falklands by Hastings and Jenkins. It is clear that Woodward intended this book to be read by future naval officers, as he spends a lot of time describing his decision making process and the agony of making tough decisions. (for example, denying air support to 4 pinned down SAS troops because his Sea Harriers could not be risked) He strives to be as objective as possible, including some fairly harsh self-criticism. The ground battle is
More...
Jul 27, 2011
What a task to walk into! Throughout Woodward remained detached, analytical and seemingly unaffected by adversity in a very unusual war in miniature. The, "Boys Own" stuff was left far behind when the realities cut in. I was surprised by the need for tight timing of the operation due to the weather. While successful, the losses particularly of the screening vessels was hard to bear. The book is the story of the Naval part of enterprise and is not intended to cover the land war in any g
More...
Nov 30, 2008
had to read this for a professional course i took recently, but frankly i didnt finish it. takes him a long time to get to the war. lot of (highly uninteresting) personal background.
Feb 26, 2011
A must read for every naval officer before they deploy. It really focuses on what is important when conducting combat operations at sea.
Nov 05, 2009
A top down look at the Falklands campaign...obviously to be a text for futer commanders for its devotion to the decision-making processes...an enlightening read and I look forward to the Hastings and Jennings work!!!
Feb 03, 2012
Dec 24, 2011
Nov 23, 2011
Nov 21, 2011
Oct 07, 2011
Jul 29, 2011
Jul 25, 2011
Jul 24, 2011
Jul 21, 2011
Jul 14, 2011
Jul 03, 2011
Jun 28, 2011
Jun 06, 2011
May 25, 2011
May 08, 2011
Apr 17, 2011
Apr 17, 2011
Apr 15, 2011
Mar 29, 2011
Feb 28, 2011
Mar 17, 2011
Jan 02, 2011
Dec 24, 2010
