Breakheart Hill
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Breakheart Hill

4.04 of 5 stars 4.04  ·  rating details  ·  410 ratings  ·  51 reviews
From the author hailed as "an important talent, a storytelling writer of poetic narrative power" ( "Los Angeles Times Book Review" ) comes a dazzling novel of psychological suspense. "This is the darkest story I've ever heard." With these haunting words, Thomas H. Cook begins a tale of love and its aftermath, of a town sent reeling from a moment of passionate betrayal. At...more
Paperback, 320 pages
Published July 1st 1996 by Crimeline (first published June 1st 1995)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Stieg LarssonThe Shadow of the Wind by Carlos Ruiz ZafónThe Name of the Rose by Umberto EcoThe Girl Who Played with Fire by Stieg LarssonThe Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield
Best Literary Mysteries
213th out of 566 books — 1,429 voters
To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper LeeFried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe by Fannie FlaggNew Yesterdays by Jim L. WrightForrest Gump by Winston GroomLooking for Alaska by John Green
Alabama Books
99th out of 142 books — 80 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 750)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
"You’ll think you know who (and maybe you do) and you’ll think you know why (and I suppose it’s possible); but trust me, you won’t have guessed everything. Breakheart Hill is one of the best written and most marvelously crafted books I’ve read in a long, long time. It’s dark and it’s sad and it’s very, very good. Read it.” – Mystery News

I picked up Thomas H. Cook’s 1995 novel Breakheart Hill at the second hand store. On the cover was the tagline “a mesmerizing tale of love and betrayal” and I th...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
This is a tale of unrequited love and the ripple effect on a small, Southern community after a moment of passionate betrayal. Thomas H. Cook is a master of suspenseful, dark and cerebral crime fiction. Shocking final pages!
Beth Crawford
Well, I definitely liked the last few pages. What I didn't like was the plodding, repetitive first 18 chapters. Because I'm stubborn, I kept reading because others liked the book and I didn't want to let it get the best of me! Some of the writing was good, but some of the characters and their actions and thoughts did not not ring true to me for 16 and 17 year olds. In chapter 17 a few of the characters attend a children's play and the author writes, "The play was a modern contrivance, fractured...more
Absolutely breath-taking.
A wonderful lyrical novel of depth, that delicately sketches beauty and the darkest of human pain. The prose is intoxicating and the plot has you holding your breathe. It tears you up to read it and it left me gasping at the end.
This is literary crime fiction of such power that it deserves its own sub genre. One of the most profound and moving books I've ever read in any genre.
Just beautiful.
Gotta go now and buy EVERYTHING Cook's ever written...10/10.

Kathleen Hagen
Breakheart Hill, by Thomas H. Cook, A-plus. Narrated by George Guidall, produced by Recorded Books, downloaded from

Ben grows up in a small southern town in the early 1960’s. He feels confined as a teenager and can’t wait to leave the town. Then a new girl comes to town, Kelly. She and Ben co-edit the highschool paper. We see the ins and outs of highschool life for a whole year. Then Kelly is killed by a blow to her head. The sheriff believes that Ben knows more than he’s willing to...more
After reading several of his much later works, I have come back now to read his earliest.

Although highly gifted in his expression and especially within his core revelations of teen-age male souls, all their perceptions and all their self-identity and angsts- he did get BETTER with the years and practice. FOR SURE.

Because I totally agree with another poster that this beginning and middle were plodding and redundant to a point of near stagnation.

But a good base story and town feel here, and his ex...more
Max Read
“A fascinating story of unrequited love, bigotry, tragedy and mystery”

“Breakheart Hill” was written by the master story teller, Thomas H. Cook. The novel is fictional literature in the mystery/love story genre. Mr. Cook has written a significant number of books, short stories and novels and has been nominated or won several literary prizes for his work. One of Cook’s most recent novels that have been reviewed at Amazon is “The Quest for Anna Klein”.

“Breakheart Hill” is narrated in the first per...more
Jeffrey Chase
5 stars, definitely! I loved this book. Ben Wade is a high school kid, in love with the new girl, Kelli Troy. She is beautiful and mysterious, a smart girl, and someone Ben sees marrying later in life. And so, during the school year, he does what he can to win her favor and her heart. But, does her heart belong to another? Ben needs to know, and his strongest desire is to be the man she approves of and loves in kind.
It is set in the small town of Choctaw, during the 1960s, in a southern state,...more
L.L. Thrasher
I first read Breakheart Hill several years ago. I was a few chapters into when I took it with me to the hospital where my daughter was having surgery. I finished the first half in the waiting room and I finished the rest of it the next day. Two days later I read it again. I don't know how many times I've read it since, but when I received a Kindle Touch last Christmas the first thing I did was download Breakheart Hill.
Wowww, this was SO good! I could hardly put it down, and finished it in two nights time. Definitely my favorite by Thomas H Cook that I've read thus far. Cook weaves a clever mystery, the setting is rich, and the characters are full of depth and intrigue. This all leads up to a shocking climax that I never saw coming. Just fantastic. Loved it!
I think I was one of the few who read this book and was genuinely confused as to what happened at the end. I still find myself searching for a spoiler or an explanation, so if anyone is willing to provide, please let me know! Other than this, I do enjoy Cook's writing style and character development and will definitely read another novel from this author.
David B
Town doctor Ben Wade narrates the sad history of Kelly Troy, a bright, intelligent girl who moves into a small Southern community, both shocking it with her outspoken views on segregation and charming it with her natural vivacity before she is tragically attacked on top of Breakheart Hill. Ben falls deeply in love with her, and author Thomas H. Cook is very good at depicting the black mood he falls into when his love is not returned. The narrative moves back and forth in time, skillfully manipul...more
I read this book years ago but every now and then it catches my eye on the book shelf and i read it haunting and stays with you long after you've finished.
This was so haunting and wrenching that after reading til 1:00 a.m. I couldn't sleep and had to take a sleeping pill! More later.
Compelling mystery about a first love gone wrong. Suspenseful.
I think this one might be better than The Chatham School Affair. Thomas H. Cook is the best mystery writer in my opinion and this book is insanely good. The characters, the twists, the relate-able plot(to an extent) were more than I could ask for from this book. I always get sucked into his world for whatever book I am reading. His prose ties in perfectly and at the end I feel as if people really existed and the tragedy that happened actually happened. His books always haunt long after I am done...more
Feb 17, 2014 Frances rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: my mystery group
A coming-of-age story in a small Southern town with first love, passion, jealousy and a brutal murder with a long-held secret. The narrator holds on to the story and the guilt and gives up only little bits at a time. The murder and its secrets are examined many years later by the narrator who is the well-respected town doctor but was a young kid jealously in love with the murder victim and a major part of the story.
This is a beautifully written book that recreates a small town and it people with...more
Suzn F
This is the third book I've now read/listened to by this author and so far I've found every one of his books to be so very interesting and engaging. This story revolves around the questions and secrets surrounding a young girl's murder and a young boy's (who as an adult becomes the small town physician) unrequited love for the girl. This book has mystery and meat. The small town politics and antics that often populate Mr Cook's stories serve as a backdrop for this book. It is the old south that...more
Georgina Hynd
I had to remove myself for a while after reading this story to decide whether or not I liked it. It was an odd sensation and one I couldn't convey to my husband as I told him it wasn't for him mere seconds after closing its pages for the final time. That suggestion still stands, it's definitely not one for him, but it's one now, many hours on, that I've found myself saying 'ok I understand why Cook went the way he did now'. I've lived for 298 pages inside the head of a man who's been carrying an...more
This is a terrific book ... especially if your heart is broken, or you are interested in how that can affect a large, connected group of people. It is also a murder mystery, with a great deal of complexity. The dates of events are not realistically spaced, and the writer shows a shocking gap in knowledge of 1957 Chevyrolets, but the book is otherwise fabulously well-written. It is set in early 1960s small-town northern Alabama, and from my knowledge of small-town Kentucky in the early '60s, I'd...more
David Bonesteel
Town doctor Ben Wade narrates the sad history of Kelly Troy, a bright, intelligent girl who moves into a small Southern community, both shocking it with her outspoken views on segregation and charming it with her natural vivacity before she is tragically attacked on top of Breakheart Hill. Ben falls deeply in love with her, and author Thomas H. Cook is very good at depicting the black mood he falls into when his love is not returned. The narrative moves back and forth in time, skillfully manipul...more
Misha Crews
It's virtually impossible to give this book the review it deserves without providing rampant spoilers. So I'll just say that I started the first few chapters believing (foolishly) that I knew where the story was headed, that I knew whodunnit and why. And I ended up reading the last chapter with my mouth hanging open, catching flies and not caring, because the truth was much more shocking, much more tragic, than I would ever have let myself believe.

This is a truly great literary mystery. Written...more
Thomas H Cook explores in this book teenage love as its central theme. The destruction it causes,how lives of the main characters spiral out of control when spurned love breeds hate which results in tragedy. One has to admire Cook's minute observation of human relationships and the fragile base on which it is based and even a minor jolt could topple it over completely. The small town and the high school and various characters associated with it come alive in Cook's poetic,literary writing. The a...more
Annie Pate
Wow! Absolutely fantastic book! Loved it!
What I learned from this book is not to recommend it to people, because they either like it or hate it, and there's no predicting.

Me, I reread the entire book immediately upon finishing the last page - and you'll note the number of 5-star reviews here.

My friend Joe, however, who shares much of my taste in reading, threw it against the wall (since my head wasn't around as a target) - he hated it and couldn't believe that I liked it.
Liked it….kept looking for time to get back to it….will read more Thomas H. Cook!
Shock ending. Well written, although at times I felt it had a bit too much of the "had I but known" strain. Lyrical prose and clear depiction of time and place (small town Alabama in 1962). Haunting in its exploration of what led up to an act of violence and its tremendous destructive impact on numbers of lives.
I think T H Cook is my fav author at the moment, i love it when i find a different author than what i usually read, he writes really well i am not usually a crime reader, but he writes from a different perspective, from a lover, or husband view.
I will try and get through all his books...oh goody....
William Herschel
This is one of his older books. I can't get into it though. Far too unbelievable and not captivating.

I liked some of the descriptions though, felt like you were in the town but... I don't know.

Also, I learned a new phrase. "Nothing to be afraid of, he's just Jesus in disguise". I like it.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 24 25 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Burrowers Beneath
  • The Book of Q: A Novel
  • The Evil Genius
  • Beowulf and the Critics (Medieval & Renaissance Texts & Studies, Vol. 248)
  • The Midden
  • Beyond the Blonde
  • Silver
  • Daughter of God
  • The Thieves Of Heaven
  • The Four Last Things (Roth, #1)
  • Crawling Chaos: Selected Works 1920-1935
  • Jungle Tales of Tarzan (Tarzan, #6)
  • Lucifer's Shadow
  • Before the Fact
  • Harlot's Ghost
  • Ghosts (The New York Trilogy, #2)
  • La verdad de las mentiras
  • Phantom Lady
There is more than one author with this name on Goodreads.

Thomas H. Cook is the author of over twenty books, including works of true crime. His novels have been nominated for the Edgar Allan Poe Award, the Macavity Award and the Dashiell Hammett Prize. The Chatham School Affair won the Edgar Allan Poe Award for Best Novel in 1996. His true crime book, Blood Echoes, was nominated for the Edgar Alla...more
More about Thomas H. Cook...
Red Leaves The Chatham School Affair Master of the Delta The Last Talk with Lola Faye Sandrine's Case

Share This Book