reviews
Jul 21, 2010
Fangirl says: OMG WHERE ARE YOUR EYES, JOHN!?!
Ok, so I'm not a comics fan. I like exactly three kinds of comics: Donald Duck, Peanuts and Calvin & Hobbes, which, you know, really doesn't make me part of the "graphic novel" fandom (that's not what it is called. I think.) I'm just not interested in the genre, nothing against it, but, things to do, books to read, no time to look at pretty pictures. (and I do think that many graphic novels are very pretty).
However, More...
Ok, so I'm not a comics fan. I like exactly three kinds of comics: Donald Duck, Peanuts and Calvin & Hobbes, which, you know, really doesn't make me part of the "graphic novel" fandom (that's not what it is called. I think.) I'm just not interested in the genre, nothing against it, but, things to do, books to read, no time to look at pretty pictures. (and I do think that many graphic novels are very pretty).
However, More...
2 comments
like
(2 people liked it)
Jul 11, 2011
I'm going to have to get used to the way John is drawn. They've really gone overboard with the square -ish contours and deep lines of his face to make him all gruff and haggard. He's kinda blond as well.
Begins with several cameos of John reminiscing about Mary dying and then him going to the fire marshal and police to try and figure out what happened. He isn't getting anywhere so he gets drunk and into a bar fight, where some chick intervenes.
Who More...
Begins with several cameos of John reminiscing about Mary dying and then him going to the fire marshal and police to try and figure out what happened. He isn't getting anywhere so he gets drunk and into a bar fight, where some chick intervenes.
Who More...
Mar 16, 2010
I'm a big fan of the Supernatural TV series, but the tie-ins leave a lot to be desired. Case in point: Origins, the first series of comics released.
It's readable, which is more than I can say for most of the novels, but I don't find the lineart or coloring at all pleasing to the eye (something that's luckily addressed in Rising Son, which is far superior), and the story never pulls me in. Some of the story flaws exist because of the comic's release date - much of the history that More...
It's readable, which is more than I can say for most of the novels, but I don't find the lineart or coloring at all pleasing to the eye (something that's luckily addressed in Rising Son, which is far superior), and the story never pulls me in. Some of the story flaws exist because of the comic's release date - much of the history that More...
0 comments
like
(1 person liked it)
Jan 12, 2010
As a fan of the TV show, I was interested to see what this graphic novel offered. Overall, I enjoyed the experience thoroughly.
The main character is John Winchester, Sam and Dean's father. The story starts shortly after his wife's murder and follows him as he learns about the existence of demons and starts down the path of becoming a hunter. There's some interesting twists thrown in for good measure, and some references to things that come later on too.
I found the writing to More...
The main character is John Winchester, Sam and Dean's father. The story starts shortly after his wife's murder and follows him as he learns about the existence of demons and starts down the path of becoming a hunter. There's some interesting twists thrown in for good measure, and some references to things that come later on too.
I found the writing to More...
Apr 29, 2011
Supernatural: Origins is a prequel comic book to the TV series Supernatural regarding John Winchester's journey to becoming a hunter after the death of his wife. Plotwise, this comic book doesn't do much other than providing more character development, which the show pretty much covers except for John I guess, and showing the growth of the characters into super badass hunters. That being said, it's still entertaining enough to read, and if you've got the money to spare it's an excellent addition
More...
Nov 10, 2010
As the title suggests, Origins is a look into John Winchester’s beginnings as a hunter and picks up only a few days after Mary’s death in the Pilot episode. John begins to investigate her death, sensing that it wasn’t a normal electrical fire which claimed her life. During his interrogations he catches the attention of Missouri Mosley, the town psychic. Missouri opens John’s eyes to the truth—that we live in a world full of dark things that go bump in the night and it was one of these which kill
More...
Feb 16, 2010
The story of how John Winchester became a hunter after the tragic firey death of his wife has always been an intriguing one not answered through the canon of the show. This version of the story, involving characters either only briefly mentioned or shown in the show, was intriguing. Too bad it was completely overwhelmed by the awful artwork.
I actually laughed the first time they show little Sam and Dean in a panel because they are drawn in such a way that it makes me wonder if the More...
I actually laughed the first time they show little Sam and Dean in a panel because they are drawn in such a way that it makes me wonder if the More...
Dec 31, 2008
I really enjoyed this despite the fact that I watch SPN for the Winchester brothers and not Papa Winchester. It is very insightful about how the Winchester family have ended up as they are. I particularly like the little side stories with Dean and Sam.
The thing that lets this graphic novel down, however, is the fact that none of the characters look how they do in the show. Maybe this is a copyright thing but then that doesn't explain why the colour plates have the correct characteri More...
The thing that lets this graphic novel down, however, is the fact that none of the characters look how they do in the show. Maybe this is a copyright thing but then that doesn't explain why the colour plates have the correct characteri More...
Jan 28, 2012
I don't really like these illustrations. None of the characters (except Ellen and maybe Mary) look anything like they do on the show. As other have also mentioned in reviews, much of the backstory that happens in this volume is contradicted in the latest two seasons of the series. And I prefer the version that has unfolded on screen.
I've never been a huge fan of graphic novels or comic books. I think they cause my ADHD to flare up. My eyes are always jumping all over the page More...
I've never been a huge fan of graphic novels or comic books. I think they cause my ADHD to flare up. My eyes are always jumping all over the page More...
Oct 19, 2011
I'm a huge fan of the Supernatural TV series, and I did enjoy this, but I wasn't so sure about the way John Winchester was drawn. The drawing was in general very good, but I couldn't quite get use to how he appeared here. It's definitely a recommended read for people who love the show, and gives a little more in the way of character development. The plot was okay, but not as strong as I would have liked. 3 stars.
Aug 28, 2011
I didn't like it, maybe because I hate John Winchester. But I think the plot was almost non-existent. Yep, there are some interesthing things in it, for example how Winchester Daddy became a hunter, but the story isn't elaborated or compelling. And the drawings... well let's just say, I saw better. I only liked the Sam and Dean scenes which were very rare. If you're a fan, it's readable once...
May 18, 2009
I didn't really mind the artwork (a lot of people seem to have problems with it) and I quite liked seeing how the family started out down the track of being hunters.
The plot was good and felt like a TV episode in comic form. Nothing really bad to say about it at all :)
The plot was good and felt like a TV episode in comic form. Nothing really bad to say about it at all :)
0 comments
like
(1 person liked it)
Jun 22, 2011
The illustrations weren't particularly good, they seemed to use gradients in place of actual detail so it was hard to distinguish one character from the next, and the proportions of the children were the same as the adults, which made them look weird. The plot was also lacking interest, it didn't quite fit with the way the series portrays events.
Dec 26, 2010
Story is very reminiscent of the pacing and twists of the TV show. I believe the author has been a producer on the show, and it shows in the care he takes with the characters and the plot. I wish the art was a lot better but there's something to be said for style.
Apr 21, 2010
Terrible artwork, and I prefered the backstory as given in the John Winchester's Journal book, even though that contradicted aired canon. This focused too much on John and didn't include enough insight into how what he was doing messed Dean's mind up at such a young age.
Jan 01, 2009
Not thrilled with the artwork, but I always appreciate any addition to the Supernatural mythos. Small insight into the gruff and driven father, creates more questions than it answers, but it warmed my heart to see tough little!Dean.
Sep 29, 2011
It follows the original TV series quite closely and is a good refresher course on Dean & Sam's childhood years with their old man.
May 13, 2010
The origin story was mediocre at best and I found the artwork to be lacking as well. With all the talented artists out there... it should have been better. An overall disappointment since I love the TV series.
Jan 01, 2011
Thank God for generous mothers that are merciful come Christmastime - my fandomania couldn't keep waiting for these volumes!
Nov 24, 2009
I do love a good back story. However, I really disliked the art in this one. No clear definition of faces and I am a face girl.
Aug 01, 2009
John Winchester is epic, and young Dean is heart-breakingly adorable. Epic, epic, epic.
Oct 10, 2007
I love the show Supernatural and thought this was an interesting glimpse at the story behind the strong characters of Dean and Sam Winchester. While the story focuses on John Winchester's struggle with his wife's death, it is fascinating to see how the boys were raised. The story shows us the first time John meets the cryptic psychic Missouri (the brothers run into her during season 1). The short vignette at the end between Dean and Sam is heartbreaking and helps to show how all of the layers
More...
Dec 07, 2010
good story, but some of the drawings (specifically Sam) looked really weir.
Jun 04, 2011
The beginning of the journey that has become my Thursday night obsession. This graphic novel accompaniment to the Supernatural series is just a great insight into the John Winchester. It's a side of him that you did not get to see in the series, but a great perspective to see.
Sep 05, 2008
Well done comic tie-in. I'm not usually a fan of the 'Mignola' style artwork, but it really worked here. (Possibly utilized in order to dodge paying for the actors licenses?)
Jun 29, 2010
This is still as distressing as I remember it being the first time round. Sam is all little and babyified and Dean is so messed up and silent and scared. and asdfdwsdfgh John.
