Los propios dioses (Solaris)
by
Isaac Asimov
-The Gods Themselves
Published
October 30th 2007
by La Factiora De Ideas
(first published 1972)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
What’s a man supposed to do? Here is a novel that is greatly revered by critics and fans alike. It received both the Nebula and Hugo awards for best novel (1972 and 1973 respectively). Asimov himself identified this as his favourite. And yet…
I normally really enjoy Asimov’s works. Foundation, especially, is one of my favourite SF novels. I am going to go against what appears to be the norm by not giving this novel four or five stars. It’s a novel I respected rather than enjoyed.
I can certainly r...more
I normally really enjoy Asimov’s works. Foundation, especially, is one of my favourite SF novels. I am going to go against what appears to be the norm by not giving this novel four or five stars. It’s a novel I respected rather than enjoyed.
I can certainly r...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Aug 19, 2007
Richard
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Science Fiction Fans; Newcomers and Old-timers
Shelves:
read-at-least-twice,
favorites
Isaac Asimov rarely wrote about either aliens or sex. In response to critics who complained about these omissions, he wrote a book about alien sex. Rather, a book whose middle third is mostly about alien sex. (Mostly.) The other two thirds of the book tell one of the "purest" and "hardest" science fiction stories I've ever read.
By pure, I mean that there's a single, science-related "what-if," and that the story hinges upon that. (In contrast to, for example, a space opera such as Star Trek, in w...more
By pure, I mean that there's a single, science-related "what-if," and that the story hinges upon that. (In contrast to, for example, a space opera such as Star Trek, in w...more
May 06, 2012
sologdin
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
speculative,
geocentric-aliens
Read this as a kid, and didn't get it. Upon rereading, it's kickass.
The first section belabors very well a nice joke from Kuhn's Structure of Scientific Revolutions, proposing a change to the physics of the universe, building an elaborate Tesla-style economics on them, and then exposing how no one wants to alter the physics, even when faced with certain death, because that would require alteration of the economics.
The middle section switches to some weird aliens with trilateral sex lives, simila...more
The first section belabors very well a nice joke from Kuhn's Structure of Scientific Revolutions, proposing a change to the physics of the universe, building an elaborate Tesla-style economics on them, and then exposing how no one wants to alter the physics, even when faced with certain death, because that would require alteration of the economics.
The middle section switches to some weird aliens with trilateral sex lives, simila...more
Chosen as my leadership institute award-winning novel in the genre sci-fi. The Gods Themselves is a 1972 science fiction novel written by Isaac Asimov. It won the Nebula Award for Best Novel in 1972 and the Hugo Award for Best Novel in 1973.
This book is a real page turner! I seem to have put aside all of my other books to fully engage this one. The plot is imaginative, especially when one considers that it was written before computers. The character development is excellent!
After finishing the...more
This book is a real page turner! I seem to have put aside all of my other books to fully engage this one. The plot is imaginative, especially when one considers that it was written before computers. The character development is excellent!
After finishing the...more
I just reread this book for the umptieth time over many years, and was struck once again by what a fine piece of work it is. This is one of the best pieces of pure science fiction every written. It isn't the best STORY, of course -- Asimov himself has better ones, as do many other science fiction authors from the post WWII era. But only a handful of other stories such as Forward's Dragon's Egg come to mind as being such excellent science fiction.
I am a physicist, mind you. The amazing thing abou...more
I am a physicist, mind you. The amazing thing abou...more
Another "one off" from a major sci-fi master. Totally unrelated to any of his other stories, this one is a mind-bender. A trans-universal thriller in which everything depends upon a near-impossible cooperation between physicists here on earth, and beings in another existence so alien and bizarre it disrupts your basic understanding of what it might mean to be alive and conscious.
Bonus: alien "marriage" and reproduction so inventive it's not even sexy. But it is kind of sweet, and romantic in its...more
Bonus: alien "marriage" and reproduction so inventive it's not even sexy. But it is kind of sweet, and romantic in its...more
Who knew that a novel written in 1972 could touch on global warming, woman empowerment, lax views on different sexual orientations, and foreign policy...all with very pristine and at times technically beautiful scientific writing.
Some of my favorite quotes from this year come from this book:
"Now then, young man, don't ask me to stop the Pumping. The economy and comfort of the entire planet depend on it. Tell me, instead, how to keep the Pumping from exploding the Sun."
"There are no happy endings...more
Some of my favorite quotes from this year come from this book:
"Now then, young man, don't ask me to stop the Pumping. The economy and comfort of the entire planet depend on it. Tell me, instead, how to keep the Pumping from exploding the Sun."
"There are no happy endings...more
Jan 29, 2011
Tancredi
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
sci-fi,
statunitensi
- Possibile che uno debba credere solo a quello che desidera?
- Sì, finché gli è possibile. E talvolta anche oltre.
La mia prima volta con Asimov: e non poteva andare meglio!
Volendo iniziare con questo mostro sacro della letteratura fantascientifica ho preferito cominciare da un romanzo singolo, anche se peculiare e un po' differente dalla produzione mainstream. E in effetti è stata una buona idea.
Neanche gli dèi è un capolavoro di una certa e ormai vecchia parte della fantascienza. In questo ro...more
- Sì, finché gli è possibile. E talvolta anche oltre.
La mia prima volta con Asimov: e non poteva andare meglio!
Volendo iniziare con questo mostro sacro della letteratura fantascientifica ho preferito cominciare da un romanzo singolo, anche se peculiare e un po' differente dalla produzione mainstream. E in effetti è stata una buona idea.
Neanche gli dèi è un capolavoro di una certa e ormai vecchia parte della fantascienza. In questo ro...more
L'originalità di questo romanzo, che va di pari passo con la sua atipicità nell'ambito della produzione di Asimov, è la descrizione compiuta e particolareggiata di una razza aliena non filtrata attraverso i paradigmi degli esseri umani. Una descrizione che deve essere affrontata senza alcun pregiudizio, come per il romanzo Flatlandia di Edwin Abbott Abbott, in quanto in entrambi gli esseri mostrati sono così distanti dalle nostre concezioni da non consentire paragoni efficaci.
Come elementi class
...more
Prima di iniziare a leggerlo mi ero imbattuta in qualche recensione su anobii che lo definiva quasi un romanzo con a base l'amore (?) mentre la recensione sul retrocopertina lo presentava come un romanzo di fantascienza misteriosa (e mi aveva molto incuriosita): probabilmente mi ero creata delle false aspettative. Alla fine ho appurato che d'amore non ce n'è nemmeno l'ombra e che quanto detto sul retrocopertina era vero solo in parte. Il primo capitolo mi ha appassionata, tanto che mentre leggev...more
I'm still chewing this one over. While I liked the story and the underlying physics problem - there were a few things that bothered me. One was the seemingly abrupt conclusion of the alien story-line. While there were hints as to what they might do, there was no final indication of their fate and that was a bit frustrating. This was probably my biggest complaint. The second was much smaller and really just a minor plot-point, but Asimov suggested that moving the Moon out of orbit wouldn't have a...more
SUMMARY: A parallel universe initiates a method of transferring free unlimited energy between our universe and theirs. But a few people think the transfer could result in the ultimate destruction of our star.
COMMENT: The story is divided into three sections. The way they're put together they could have been released as three separate short stories. I'm pretty sure I read the first section as a kid, but it was so long ago I didn't remember much about it so it was new to me.
The story has aged very...more
COMMENT: The story is divided into three sections. The way they're put together they could have been released as three separate short stories. I'm pretty sure I read the first section as a kid, but it was so long ago I didn't remember much about it so it was new to me.
The story has aged very...more
Como já há muitos reviews em inglês e eu não tenho nada de original para dizer (e também para manter a língua portuguesa ativa nesse site), escreverei em português.
Considero The Gods Themselves um bom livro. Independentemente de qualquer outra característica, foi um livro eu li em dois dias em duas ou três maratonas agradáveis de leitura. Asimov consegue manter o leitor sempre interessado, sempre querendo a página seguinte. Quantos livros conseguem isso?
Mas qual é o ponto do livro?
Há a objetivid...more
Considero The Gods Themselves um bom livro. Independentemente de qualquer outra característica, foi um livro eu li em dois dias em duas ou três maratonas agradáveis de leitura. Asimov consegue manter o leitor sempre interessado, sempre querendo a página seguinte. Quantos livros conseguem isso?
Mas qual é o ponto do livro?
Há a objetivid...more
One of Asimov's must reads.
The story could be cut into 3 distinct parts, the FIRST part had very interesting mystery and conflict and drew his characters quite well. I enjoyed it.
The SECOND part made the book difficult to put down, a very unique/difficult type of character was portrayed here and Mr. Asimov did a wonderful job giving life to them. I strongly felt this was my favorite part and sympathized greatly. I also found my self betting the pages what would be the conflict resolution, and th...more
The story could be cut into 3 distinct parts, the FIRST part had very interesting mystery and conflict and drew his characters quite well. I enjoyed it.
The SECOND part made the book difficult to put down, a very unique/difficult type of character was portrayed here and Mr. Asimov did a wonderful job giving life to them. I strongly felt this was my favorite part and sympathized greatly. I also found my self betting the pages what would be the conflict resolution, and th...more
Isaac Asimov es uno de los grandes escritores de ciencia ficción (y de muchísimas otras materias). Sus historias abarcan gran cantidad de temas, y es considerado uno de los padres de la robótica con sus tres leyes. Sin embargo, su obra fue criticada en algunos aspectos, como por ejemplo que no hubiera extraterrestres en sus historias, o que no tratara demasiado temas sociales, o que no tratara la sexualidad de sus personajes. Este libro fue la respuesta de Asimov a esas críticas. En él se pueden...more
It's like everyone says. First section is great depiction of scientists behaving badly, second section is really great depiction of aliens and parallel universe, then he runs out of ideas in third section, turns into boring lookitthat lunar travelogue and smirky gaping at bare breasts, same weird 'gentlemanly ' thing that Heinlein could have patented. Ike had no idea how to end this book. And by the way -- what exactly happens to the dying para world when our universe decided not to blow itself...more
Contro la stupidità umana neanche gi dèi possono nulla... forse
Pubblicato nel 1972, Neanche gli dèi rappresentò per Asimov il ritorno alla narrativa dopo un decennio dedicato esclusivamente alla saggistica e alla divulgazione scientifica. La storia è divisa in tre parti e ha una struttura piuttosto articolata. Le premesse sono queste: nell’anno 2070 un radiochimico non troppo brillante, Frederick Hallam, scopre per puro caso l’esistenza di una sostanza teoricamente “impossibile”, o almeno imposs...more
Pubblicato nel 1972, Neanche gli dèi rappresentò per Asimov il ritorno alla narrativa dopo un decennio dedicato esclusivamente alla saggistica e alla divulgazione scientifica. La storia è divisa in tre parti e ha una struttura piuttosto articolata. Le premesse sono queste: nell’anno 2070 un radiochimico non troppo brillante, Frederick Hallam, scopre per puro caso l’esistenza di una sostanza teoricamente “impossibile”, o almeno imposs...more
The title of this book is a part of a longer title, which is used to split up the three sections of the book, being 'against stupidity the gods themselves contend in vain'. I believe that that is actually an Ancient Greek saying, who to me is not surprising at all. Nope, as it turns out I am incorrect, it was in fact a saying of a German Poet named Friedrich von Schiller, but it is not the saying or the meaning of the saying that I really want to write about here, though I must admit that it is...more
May 12, 2012
Perry Whitford
rated it
1 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Are you kidding me!
An interesting idea from Asimov about an energy transfer between ourselves and a parallel universe of very different beings who exist under completely different universal laws. This "energy pump" could result in our starts becoming swiftly heated up, resulting in a succession of super-novas and the Milky Way turning into a quasar.
The consequences of this are investigated across three defined sections: the first on earth; the second (and most interesting) on the papa-planet, where a hierarchical...more
The consequences of this are investigated across three defined sections: the first on earth; the second (and most interesting) on the papa-planet, where a hierarchical...more
This novel tells the story of two parallel universes with different basic physical laws. The two universes can draw an apparently limitless amount of power from each other -- but a few people on either side believe there is a potentially catastrophic risk from doing so.
This novel didn't work so well for me, I think mostly because I just wasn't that interested in details of the society and inhabitants of the other universe, and the book spends a lot of real estate on describing it. It's really to...more
This novel didn't work so well for me, I think mostly because I just wasn't that interested in details of the society and inhabitants of the other universe, and the book spends a lot of real estate on describing it. It's really to...more
Apart from Digital Fortress and Deception Point, Dan Brown's first and third novels, this is the first contact I've had with science fiction literature, and I am glad I decided to start with this one. I might have enjoyed it more if I knew a lot more about physics and other sciences, but don't think that can stop you from enjoying this book - I can say for sure that didn't stop me at all, but it may be a better read for those that understand the technical parts as well.
I really recommend this bo...more
I really recommend this bo...more
“God’s Themselves” kept me interested clear through. After reading the dedication, I was hooked – Asimov accosts Robert Silverberg at a sci-fi convention for referring to a radioactive isotope (plutonium-186) that could not exist. He then tells Silverberg that to show him real ingenuity, he would write a story about it (leave it to a biochemist!). This story ended up as “The God’s Themselves.”
Not only was Gods Themselves great sci-fi but Asimov gave some great commentary on our times as reflect...more
Not only was Gods Themselves great sci-fi but Asimov gave some great commentary on our times as reflect...more
Isaac Asimov má klan věrných fandů a já do něj nepatřím. Přesto jsem postupem času přelouskal větší část jeho románové tvorby. Roboti mě nudili hodně, Nadace o něco míň. Tahle knížka, pojmenovaná citátem ze Schillera (Proti hlouposti ani sami bohové nic nezmohou), mě mile překvapila. Z mého hlediska je tím nejzajímavějším, co jsem od Asimova četl. Skládá se ze tří nesourodých částí, zdaleka nejlepší je prostřední. Popisuje svět těžko představitelných inteligentních tvorů v „paravesmíru“, který s...more
I read this when I was a boy, back before I shifted from sci-fi to fantasy and when I was still high on my parents' enthusiasm for Asimov. I still consider it a classic and one of Asimov's finer novels, largely because, as one reviewer noted, it's one of his few books that can be read as a stand-alone. I liked the idea of a scientist desperately trying to appear knowledgeable about a subject he couldn't truly understand or explain (especially after encountering SO DANG MANY scientists who do exa...more
Yawn...This is a Star-Trek style SF parable about our own problems with energy and the environment. While the notion of physical laws diffusing from one universe to the another is an interesting thought, Asimov fails to run with this interesting idea. Instead, he gives us a tedious 1/3 of the book told from a bizarre (and not so well thought-out) alien perspective. This large part of the book strikes me as filler. Asimov says in the introduction that this novel grew out of a short story which wa...more
I thought I'd be reading this into the recycling bin, but despite 92 pages falling out one night, I still have them all, so they're going on to someone else... who knows how many will be able to read it before it is too far gone to read?
I haven't read so very much Asimov, fewer than ten novels, but this is my favorite so far. I liked this book quite a bit, right from the first paragraph. There came a point near the end where I was almost hoping it would end in catastrophe; even though no charact...more
I haven't read so very much Asimov, fewer than ten novels, but this is my favorite so far. I liked this book quite a bit, right from the first paragraph. There came a point near the end where I was almost hoping it would end in catastrophe; even though no charact...more
Feb 04, 2011
Jonathan Cullen
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
meh
I read Issac Asimov's The Gods Themselves a few years ago while lying in the sun on a beach so I'm not sure if any positive feelings I have are linked to the quality of the novel or my tan.
The novel is divided into three parts. The overall story revolves around aliens from a parallel universe (the para-Universe) who exploit a difference between the physical laws in their para-Universe and our Universe: in our Universe plutonium 186 decays into tungsten 186 and in the para-Universe tungsten 186...more
The novel is divided into three parts. The overall story revolves around aliens from a parallel universe (the para-Universe) who exploit a difference between the physical laws in their para-Universe and our Universe: in our Universe plutonium 186 decays into tungsten 186 and in the para-Universe tungsten 186...more
I’d been looking forward to this book ever since I bought it in exchange for Ark in Phuket Town, being a big fan of Isaac Asimov and having read a good percentage of his total output during the endless summers of my school days. The central concept of this sci-fi is that a new method of power generation has been discovered by exchanging material from this universe with another governed by differing physical laws. Unfortunately, this exchange leaks the laws of each universe into the other, weaken...more
sometimes i love a good ol' sci-fi book. this one was pretty good! in the future, mankind finds a source of infinite clean power. not only was it basically an accident, but it's also coming from a parallel universe. the man who "discovered" this source is hailed as a hero by the world, with the exception of two men who figure out that this power will ultimately destroy us.
i really enjoyed the 3 sections of the book. it's told from the men on earth's side, the para-men's side, and then finally t...more
i really enjoyed the 3 sections of the book. it's told from the men on earth's side, the para-men's side, and then finally t...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Artist's Read: Part 2: The Gods Themselves | 6 | 5 | Jul 19, 2012 07:33pm | |
| Artist's Read: Part 1: Against Stupidity | 7 | 5 | Jul 18, 2012 11:55am |
Isaac Asimov was a Russian-born, American author, a professor of biochemistry, and a highly successful writer, best known for his works of science fiction and for his popular science books.
Professor Asimov is generally considered the most prolific writer of all time, having written or edited more than 500 books and an estimated 90,000 letters and postcards. He has works published in nine of the te...more
More about Isaac Asimov...
Professor Asimov is generally considered the most prolific writer of all time, having written or edited more than 500 books and an estimated 90,000 letters and postcards. He has works published in nine of the te...more
Share This Book
15 trivia questions
2 quizzes
More quizzes & trivia...
2 quizzes
“Author's Notes: This story starts with section 6. This is not a mistake. I have my own subtle reasoning. So, just read, and enjoy.”
—
12 people liked it
“There are no happy endings in history, only crisis points that pass.”
—
11 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...
























Feb 23, 2013 12:55am
Mar 28, 2013 02:56pm