The Mayor of Castro Street: The Life and Times of Harvey Milk
by
Randy Shilts
The Mayor of Castro Street is Shilts's acclaimed story of Harvey Milk, the man whose personal life, public career, and tragic assassination mirrored the dramatic and unprecedented emergence of the gay community in America during the 1970s. His is a story of personal tragedies and political intrigues, assassination in City Hall and massive riots in the streets, the miscarri...more
Paperback, 380 pages
Published
March 15th 1988
by St. Martin's Griffin
(first published 1982)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
This is a fantastic book. I give it three stars for writing, four for reportage and five for being incredibly inspiring.
There were passages throughout that I wanted to mark and post here, but I didn't. The appendices include several superb speeches by Milk; the man was both a practical and philosophical adherent of making cities human. The book is not just about his on-the-ground life, but his ideas, too. And they were grand ideas, but always with a human face. Milk believed in humans, not just...more
There were passages throughout that I wanted to mark and post here, but I didn't. The appendices include several superb speeches by Milk; the man was both a practical and philosophical adherent of making cities human. The book is not just about his on-the-ground life, but his ideas, too. And they were grand ideas, but always with a human face. Milk believed in humans, not just...more
Feb 15, 2010
Buck
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
All LGBT people
Shelves:
gay-literature,
biography-memoir
I thoroughly enjoyed this biography. Shilts manages to capture the spirit of Harvey Milk as well as the reality of him.
Beyond the biographical material, the background information in the book is invaluable to students of LGBT history. Milk's frequent tension with moderate Gays and moderate Liberals still echoes to this day.
The information on the 1977 Dade County ordinance repeal fight could be a handbook for exactly how the Prop 8 and Prop 102 campaigns were mismanaged in 2008 by the same moder...more
Beyond the biographical material, the background information in the book is invaluable to students of LGBT history. Milk's frequent tension with moderate Gays and moderate Liberals still echoes to this day.
The information on the 1977 Dade County ordinance repeal fight could be a handbook for exactly how the Prop 8 and Prop 102 campaigns were mismanaged in 2008 by the same moder...more
Apr 07, 2009
Michael
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
non-fiction,
politics
I initially became interested in reading this book after seeing the 2008 motion picture Milk. I ultimately decided to purchase and read the book after watching the 1984 documentary The Times Of Harvey Milk on YouTube. Both did an excellent job of providing insight into the life and times of Harvey Milk but I felt that in order to get the whole story I needed to read this book. I was not disappointed. The author did a superb job of not only detailing the particulars of Harvey Milk's life but also...more
After watching Milk, I realized there was a lot I didn't know about this time in history, even though I had seen the documentary in the mid-nineties and remember a paragraph or two from my American History book. I approached this book thinking it would be informative and somewhat dry, but was surprised at how in depth, accessible and fun to read it was. It's apparent that Shilts did a great deal of research and was able to get at Milk from many angles, which rounded him out as a figure -- Shilts...more
Having recently watched both the documentary and the more recent film, I was curious to learn more about the life of Harvey Milk. This book provides it. The Mayor of Castro Street is a fascinating look into Milk’s life and all-too-short political career , as well as a detailed (and sad) history of gay rights in the Twentieth Century. Thirty years later, it’s humbling to see how far we’ve come--and how far we have yet to go.
Minor complaint: Since it was republished to tie-in with the 2008 film, I...more
Minor complaint: Since it was republished to tie-in with the 2008 film, I...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Feb 08, 2009
Kate
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
anyone interested in city politics or political movements, gay issues
Recommended to Kate by:
Sean Rowley, thanks for the suggestion!
Shelves:
favoritereads
I loved the other book I read by gay journalist Randy Shilts, "And The Band Played On," so I knew "The Mayor of Castro Street" would be excellent. I was inspired to read it after seeing the movie "Milk."
It was very interesting to read about how Harvey Milk, one of the first openly gay people to be elected to public office in this country, was essentially non-political and in the closet for much of his life. But he moves to San Fransisco jut as the city is being transformed by a flood of gay newc...more
It was very interesting to read about how Harvey Milk, one of the first openly gay people to be elected to public office in this country, was essentially non-political and in the closet for much of his life. But he moves to San Fransisco jut as the city is being transformed by a flood of gay newc...more
The Mayor of Castro Street: The Life and Times of Harvey Milk by Randy Shilts is by far one of the most remarkable books I have ever read. For those of you who have seen Sean Penn in Milk, the movie only provided glimpse into the complex man and the times he lived in. Randy Shilts goes beyond and tells not only of story of Harvey Milk but the rich history of the modern day GLBT movement.
The details of early homosexuality of how gay and lesbians were treated in San Francisco offer insight on a s...more
The details of early homosexuality of how gay and lesbians were treated in San Francisco offer insight on a s...more
In this book Randy Shilts tells the story of Harvey Milk and his path from a closeted gay man with conservative values (he supported Goldwater) who stumbled through a good part of his life without direction until he moved to San Francisco and found his calling in advocating for gay equality and striving toward his vision of a a time and place where gays and straights could coexist peacefully. Though most widely known for his gay advocacy he was a populist who, among other things, pushed for dist...more
Jan 18, 2010
Allison Hepler
added it
This biography was as much about the history of gay life (read: male) from the 1950s through 1980. Harvey Milk moved geographically and politically from an Esat coast banker to a West coast gay activist, and it reads like a very canny political "how to" book. After many failed elections, Milk was finally elected to San Francisco City Council, only to be assassinated, along with Mayor George Moscone, by former city official Dan White. The appalling aspect of this book, and the one less developed...more
Dec 01, 2009
Grendelkhan
added it
Harvey Milk was certainly a character. Profoundly imperfect, late-blooming in terms of involvement with the gay community... and absolutely irreplaceable in terms of gay history.
I first heard of Harvey Milk in terms of his absence, reading "And the Band Played On" by the same author, in which it was frequently lamented that the gay movement was without a leader in the wake of Milk's assassination.
Reading about the man himself, I was initially disappointed. He was hardly heroic in terms of his li...more
I first heard of Harvey Milk in terms of his absence, reading "And the Band Played On" by the same author, in which it was frequently lamented that the gay movement was without a leader in the wake of Milk's assassination.
Reading about the man himself, I was initially disappointed. He was hardly heroic in terms of his li...more
I first remember watching the Academy Award winning documentary The Times of Harvey Milk back in the late 80s when I was in high school – surreptitiously, so that my parents wouldn’t notice (being the poor homophobes they were). And it astounded me then, as it still does today when I finished Shilts’ stunningly detailed biography, that Dan White got off on two manslaughter charges. The “Twinkie Defense” my posterior!
But getting back to my review.
The life of Harvey Milk is not nearly as dramatic...more
But getting back to my review.
The life of Harvey Milk is not nearly as dramatic...more
In-progress review, about 2/3 through the book: This is really interesting and it's great to see how the movie meshes with the book that it was based upon. Turns out the movie - obviously - condensed a lot of Harvey Milk's life. It actually gives a great account of gay life in NYC and San Francisco in the mid-20th century, and expands on the gay political history of the USA. I deliberately say gay rather than LGBT because the author makes clear that Harvey Milk didn't really associate with any/m...more
I had to read this book before the movie came out, and since it had been on the back burner of to-read books ever since I saw the documentary The Times of Harvey Milk in college nearly twenty years ago I picked it up. I think Shilts is an excellent journalist. He captures the scene of San Francisco and the repression of homosexual life at that time astonishingly well. Perhaps, because he himself is homosexual, Shilts is able to tap into the essence of Harvey Milk's inner character. I recommend r...more
I have to say this is probably one of the best biographical pieces I have ever read. This book is incredibly well written. It is emotionally charged, during some scenes I was quite moved. Harvey Milk was a brilliant and great man. This book truly does him justice. I enjoyed the thorough tracing of his entire life.
I would recommend this to anyone interested in LGBT rights, or in the politics of the 60's and 70's. It provides an interesting look at how the LGBT community demanded things early on...more
I would recommend this to anyone interested in LGBT rights, or in the politics of the 60's and 70's. It provides an interesting look at how the LGBT community demanded things early on...more
After seeing the movie and the extras on the DVD of "Milk", I decided to read this book. Of course it added many more facts to the story that I was unaware of. The journalistic reporting style got to be a bit tiresome after a while.
The best part of the book were the photos and the appendices which contained Harvey Milk's speeches. He was quite an orator. The conclusion of the book seemed to be that if Harvey Milk had not existed, someone else would have filled that void eventually. I am not so...more
The best part of the book were the photos and the appendices which contained Harvey Milk's speeches. He was quite an orator. The conclusion of the book seemed to be that if Harvey Milk had not existed, someone else would have filled that void eventually. I am not so...more
I had seen and enjoyed the movie Milk before reading this book, but I enjoyed the book even more immensely. Although there was overlap between the two, the book paints a much more complex picture of Harvey - he was imperfect, he was flawed, he was human. And yet, he was an inspiring spirit who accomplished so much in such a short period of time (Milk had only been in San Francisco for six years and had been in office for less than a year when he was assassinated). The book also really conveyed t...more
Well-written biography of Harvey Milk. Shilts eschews the hagiographic approach adopted in the movie Milk to provide a more rounded view of Milk's life, his life's work and his legacy.
Shilts portrays Milk with all his fire and passion for life: both personal and political. We see his skill as a politician with an inate sense of theatre and of justice, who built a broad support base that included not just the gay population but small business, blue collar industry and other minority groups. We a...more
Shilts portrays Milk with all his fire and passion for life: both personal and political. We see his skill as a politician with an inate sense of theatre and of justice, who built a broad support base that included not just the gay population but small business, blue collar industry and other minority groups. We a...more
Loving it so far. It goes back earlier in his life than the movie did. He made quite a flip in his life--he used to be a super-closeted Republican investment banker, and went on to become pretty leftist, and one of the first openly gay elected officials in the country. It really makes you think about what a person can achieve in their life.
The first time I came across Randy Shilts' name was in reference to his work on the book, And the Band Played On...: Politics, People, and the AIDS Epidemic, which was the first book to investigate and document the AIDS epidemic in the gay community. Randy Shilts, the first openly gay reporter for The San Francisco Chronicle, published this book in 1984, most likely finishing his research on the life and times of Harvey Milk before jumping headlong into a book about the disease which would event...more
Four and a half stars, really.
I don't remember if I watched the 1984 documentary The Times of Harvey Milk when I was in high school, maybe it aired on PBS, or when I was in college, and a pretentious film lover, maybe I rented it from Aardvark Video, the local pretentious film video store. Whenever it was, I loved the movie, and found Harvey Milk to be a fascinating, charismatic man.
Then, two years ago, when Gus Van Sant's entertaining yet flawed movie "Milk" came out (is that redundant--aren't...more
I don't remember if I watched the 1984 documentary The Times of Harvey Milk when I was in high school, maybe it aired on PBS, or when I was in college, and a pretentious film lover, maybe I rented it from Aardvark Video, the local pretentious film video store. Whenever it was, I loved the movie, and found Harvey Milk to be a fascinating, charismatic man.
Then, two years ago, when Gus Van Sant's entertaining yet flawed movie "Milk" came out (is that redundant--aren't...more
4.5 stars. Oh so close to perfect.
Full of strong reporting, both of Milk's life, his time in politics and the city of San Francisco's rise to prominence in the LGBT community, Shilts does a wonderful job of balancing the man Harvey Milk and the icon he became to the movement. As much as I love Gus Van Sant's biopic (it's what spurred me to re-read this book) it doesn't quite capture how multi-faceted a man Milk was. He was media savvy, often hot headed and spontaneous and extremely passionate t...more
Full of strong reporting, both of Milk's life, his time in politics and the city of San Francisco's rise to prominence in the LGBT community, Shilts does a wonderful job of balancing the man Harvey Milk and the icon he became to the movement. As much as I love Gus Van Sant's biopic (it's what spurred me to re-read this book) it doesn't quite capture how multi-faceted a man Milk was. He was media savvy, often hot headed and spontaneous and extremely passionate t...more
Harvey Milk is a wonderful man and is rightly a hero of the GLBT movement. This book was a really interesting read in regards to who he was and his life as a whole, but I would say that if you've seen "Milk" you probably aren't going to get that much new stuff out of this. There are some changes made to the film to make the story a bit more Hollywood friendly, but the changes are minor and the film is very similar. I don't feel like I learned all that much reading this after seeing the film, but...more
2009 has been an incredible year for Harvey Milk. Last month, President Obama awarded him the Medal of Freedom and recently Governor Schwarzenegger honored Milk by designating May 22 as Harvey Milk Day in California. It is the year which saw 'Milk', a critically acclaimed film based on his life, win 2 Academy Awards bringing Harvey's heroic story to a new generation. A year which saw the biggest gay rights march on Washington in history be led and organized by Harvey's most talented protege and...more
May 26, 2009
Carly
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Carly by:
Dusty
Shelves:
2009
I didn't read the book until after I had watched the movie, and it was good to know a little bit more about the people in Milk's life--as well as the acknowledgement of some of Milk's less than admirable qualities.
It's hard to believe, but compared to the book, I think the movie ends on a high note. (I cried both times when watching it...) But this book goes further into the aftermath of San Francisco, and the atrocities that were once forgotten for homosexuals were reinstated.
At times Shilts'...more
It's hard to believe, but compared to the book, I think the movie ends on a high note. (I cried both times when watching it...) But this book goes further into the aftermath of San Francisco, and the atrocities that were once forgotten for homosexuals were reinstated.
At times Shilts'...more
Enjoyed this book a lot, glad I got a chance to read it before I go see the movie "Milk". I really didn't know anything about Harvey Milk or the struggles he went through on the way to elected office in San Francisco. The book gives an excellent picture of the city & its political & social life in the 1960s and 70s. The beginning and end of the book are particularly interesting; I thought the middle dragged a bit. There's a lot of detail about the political in-fighting Milk had to engage...more
Randy Shilts is the s***. He depicted Harvey Milk's life richly, with knowledge he gained as a gay SF reporter during the 70s, and subsequent research. The myriad details never weighed down the story arc, but instead kept me riveted and reading further. Shilts wrote non-fiction like it was a really excellent screenplay, where every bit advances the plot while being valuable in and of itself. As an aspiring journalist, I'd say that's a great take-home message about writing.
That said, I'm still po
Sep 08, 2010
Spiros
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
anyone who wants to understand San Francisco politics
Amarcord: being summoned out of my intro social studies test by the teacher, Ms. Ruta, who told me about the assassinations. We were both in shock, which is kind of surprising, in retrospect. This book, written scant years after those events, is a brilliant evokation of those times.
Not merely a presentation of the real Harvey Milk, ears, nose, warts and all, Shilts gives us a down-the-rabbit-hole tour of San Francisco politics in the Seventies.
"He had spent the last years of his life clinging te...more
Not merely a presentation of the real Harvey Milk, ears, nose, warts and all, Shilts gives us a down-the-rabbit-hole tour of San Francisco politics in the Seventies.
"He had spent the last years of his life clinging te...more
The information was (almost by definition) fascinating, and it's clear that the author did his research very well. However, the writing style was somewhat frustrating, especially the chronology. Though the book followed Harvey Milk's life and the time immediately after it, it often went off on tangential subjects, jumping back many years in a confusing manner. There were some events, such as that fateful November 27th, which at times had very detailed descriptions of the timeline, and then sudde...more
May 04, 2010
Lord Beardsley
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Everyone with a brain and a heart in equal measure
This is one of the best biographies/non-fiction books I've ever read. I really think everyone (especially LGBT) interested in humanism, populism, equality, and democracy should read this book. It kept me gripped and fascinated through an entire 8 hour United Airlines flight (no small feet). A long-time hero of mine, Harvey Milk is now solidified in my pantheon of wonderful people. This man was and always will be, an inspiration. Let's hope that after reading this, we all can be inspired to do wh...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Randy Shilts was a highly acclaimed, pioneering gay American journalist and author. He worked as a reporter for both The Advocate and the San Francisco Chronicle, as well as for San Francisco Bay Area television stations.
More about Randy Shilts...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...










view 1 comment
















