Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Thus Was Adonis Murdered” as Want to Read:
Thus Was Adonis Murdered
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Thus Was Adonis Murdered (Hilary Tamar #1)

4.04 of 5 stars 4.04  ·  rating details  ·  2,238 ratings  ·  180 reviews
The first mystery in Caudwell's popular series featuring amateur investigator Hilary Tamar and a cast of clever and trouble-prone young London barristers. When a young man is found dead in Julia Larwood's bed, her barrister friends are the only ones who can uncover the truth of this masterpiece of murder.
Hardcover, 346 pages
Published March 19th 1981 by Collins (first published 1981)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Thus Was Adonis Murdered, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Thus Was Adonis Murdered

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
May 18, 2011 Sparrow rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: beach readers
Recommended to Sparrow by: Elizabeth
Anyone who can tell a pretty hilarious Shakespeare joke is okay in my book. And this book is full of really hilarious Shakespeare jokes. Poor Desdemona. Oh, man. L, as they say, OL. And the slapstick. Oh, the slapstick! She gets it just right in that dry, British way, where you feel like she’s describing something really elegant, but actually it’s almost grotesque. This book was wonderful. I totally love it. I would give it five stars, except my undying devotion for Gaudy Night is making it impo ...more
I always feel very clever when I find something brilliant and obscure, even when all I did was take a recommendation (thanks, Kate Nepveu!). A series of British mysteries, starring a brilliant but sometimes hapless collection of young barristers and an Oxford tutor who is either remarkably clever or remarkably nosy, depending on whom you ask.

What a delight. Rollickingly funny in places, with a particularly deft touch for letter writing. That distinctively British slant of straight-faced absurdit
"It's disappointing," said Ragwort, "that the young man has not turned out to be a homicidal maniac. But it can't be helped."
So a few book reviews ago I was all "I don't like amateur detectives!" and now here I am, head-over-heels for a amateur detective mystery series.

In my defense, Thus Was Adonis Murdered is no ordinary cozy mystery. It's the first of four books featuring a set of young London barristers and their friend Professor Hilary Tamar, the busybody esteemed Oxford don who, over drink
Book Review

Scholarship asks, thank God, no recompense but Truth. It is not for the sake of material reward that she (Scholarship) pursues her (Truth) through the undergrowth of Ignorance, shining on Obscurity the bright torch of Reason and clearing aside the tangled thorns of Error with the keen secateurs of Intellect

Thus was Adonis Murdered and thus is his murderer extracted from obscurity: from indistinctness into certainty, from the labor of chase to the methods of scholarship, from the top f
Ann Herendeen
Caudwell's four mysteries are so distinctive in voice and mood, the best word I can think of to describe them is "stylized." It's the sort of thing some readers adore and others probably hate (although it's hard for me to wrap my mind around that). Some readers may be put off by what one (admiring) critic called Caudwell's "distancing" techniques. Much of the action is told through letters, cables, narrations within letters within cables, etc.

"Adonis" is the first of the four books (Caudwell die
This is the first of four mysteries written by Sarah Caudwell, who passed away several years ago. The protagonists are young barristers in London, and the Oxford don (gender never disclosed) who assists them when they are faced with difficulties.

The books are very funny!! I mean, Jenny didn't like them, but whatev!


"The procedure for taking advantage of Italian waiters--equally applicable, so far as I am aware, in other areas of the Mediterranean--does not merit any long exposition. It c
Actually this was a DNF for me. I'm not sure why, I liked the premise and the characters mostly seemed okay. I think it might have been the language. it was very formal and very stilted my my inner ear. I also was easily confused when the reading of Julia's letters were happening. Someone would read a section, people listening would interrupt and comment and then back to the letters. Maybe it was that I didn't have enough long periods of time to read more than a few pages at a time. Either way, ...more
The writing style was very difficult at first. Caudwell is way too wordy with run on sentences in which I lost track, at first. Then, I either got used to her style or so absorbed in the characters and the story that I go over my irritation and really enjoyed the book. I laughed out loud at the tongue-in-cheek, very British wit with which she wrote. The solution was a bit convoluted and required a re-read to get it. All in all, an enjoyable book.
This is probably the most charming murder mystery that I’ve ever read and it was great fun from start to finish. I loved the format: although the murder takes place in Venice, the point of view is always that of barristers in London. (As an aside, I googled for the appropriate collective noun but with equivocal results. It could be a bore of barristers, or a cluster, or a boast, or a wiggery. The question remains open.) This group are a snobbish and insular bunch, yet somehow endearing in their ...more
Julia's intrepid friends--consisting of her colleagues in chambers as well as Oxford don and sometime sleuth Hilary Tamar are the recipients of Julia's letters from abroad and soon learn that she is suspect number one in the murder of the beautiful Ned Watson. They determine to track down clues and haunt the fellow Art Lovers until proof can be found to persuade the Italian authorities of Julia's innocence. Somehow just the fact that the murder was too tidy for Julia to be responsible is just no ...more
Julie Bozza
An interesting crime / 'amateur sleuth' novel, which holds the interest despite much of the action happening at a distance and being relayed via a series of letters. I didn't anticipate the details of the resolution and yet it was all perfectly plausible, so that makes it a winner on the crime drama front.

I was inspired to read this book by the intriguing notion that we never discover the gender of the 'point of view' character, Professor Hilary Tamar. As a writer I wondered how that would be do
K.D. Absolutely
Jun 21, 2009 K.D. Absolutely rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: No one (please do not read this book!)
Recommended to K.D. by: 501 Must Read Books (I do not agree!)
Shelves: 501, mystery
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
I think I have a new favorite "go-to" book for a fun, humorous, feel-good and yet very well-written and smartly crafted book. The mystery itself is fantastic--there are cleverly placed clues introduced very naturally into the story, and some genuinely crafty but believable twists that make the whodunit pretty darn difficult to guess. But even more fun is the colorful cast of characters that are just bursting with wit, charm, likability and plain, old fun.

The most notable thing for me, though, w
4.5 stars. I was enchanted by this. It’s a comedy of manners, and also a pretty decent murder mystery. The writing is stylized to look like something you’d see in a Regency or Victorian novel, which seems a bit incongruous for a contemporary story published in 1981, but I thoroughly enjoyed it.

A group of young London barristers are concerned about their friend Julia, who has gone on holiday to Venice, alone. Apparently Julia is one of those people who trips over things and loses her way and forg
I FINALLY got my hands on this. *\o/* And it absolutely lived up to expectations. **\o/** Caudwell's novels are unquestionably the BEST when it comes to character and narratorial voice; she doesn't quite have Hilary down in this first of the series, but everyone else is so much themselves that I can overlook that. I love the sex-positivism, I love the literary flourishes, I love the devotion to food, I love the implicit feminism. I love Timothy, whom I do not recall from the other Tamar novels, ...more
Monica Fastenau
This book is amusing, entertaining, and very British, and it’s the perfect combination of friendly and intriguing to keep your mind off any troubles you might be experiencing. In this mystery by Sarah Caudwell, a young British barrister named Julia decides to go on an Art Lovers’ trip to Venice, where she is determined to make a romantic conquest of the beautiful Ned. She is a hapless, accident-prone woman with little common sense, and her barrister friends back in England are very amused by her ...more
I just really could not get into this series of books, as much as I wanted to like them. There are many, many people who have read them and loved them, but I just didn't. The writing quite honestly gave me a headache and was so heavy handed, I could barely understand what the mystery was supposed to be. That doesn't mean they aren't worth reading, just not for everybody. I do love the cover art on them though, being a big Edward Gorey fan is what induced me to pick up this book in the first plac ...more
cool, enjoyable mystery. the denouement wasn't perfect but it worked well enough and I think you can take a good guess at it from the clues although it requires a couple of guesses to actually solve.

the big appeal though is the character writing and humor. the writing is consistently funny-rarely laugh out loud but regularly brings a smile to my face. the characters are lively and the dialogue is great. also one of the main characters is a very active bisexual woman and two other major character
Such an old favorite. I love this series so much I keep giving away the first book to people to encourage them to read it. At some point I lost track of who had it so I bought myself a new one on amazon and it arrived today. I can't wait to slip back into it.

The "mystery" is not really the draw of the book, it's the wonderful, wonderful characters. I enjoy reading about them so much and they make me laugh out loud sometimes. British humor at its best!
Unbelievably charming writing; I could read this sort of thing all day and night. I imagine the quality of writing on display here would appeal only to a person of a certain level of erudition, which is a real shame; I'd prefer it get around rather more than it currently does.

I emphatically and desperately recommend this book for anyone whose heart is warmed by a bit of dry British humo(u)r.
First (and best) of Sarah Cauldwell's deliciously sarcastic books about a group of young lawyers in Lincoln's Inn, as told by Hilary Tamar, professor of medieval contract law. Sadly, Sarah Cauldwell died after writing only 4 books so savor them as you read! Makes me laugh
Frivolous but not lacking in charm or interest. More of a puzzlement than a mystery. Enjoyed the nod to the epistolary form of old.
I love this series. Brilliantly written, quirky mysteries penned by an author with a keen eye for social dynamics. Highly recommended.
Carey Combe
The epistolary style bugged me at the beginning, but I enjoyed the dry humour and the rather 'ghastly; characters. Worth trying her next...
The first paragraph of this book might be my favorite paragraph ever written. In a mystery. After 1945. LOVE her writing.
Elizabeth Smith
Such cleverness and irony. Fun on every page.
It is not often that one finds a funny mystery. This one was hilarious and good. It concerns a group of young lawyers in London and their professor who is in town doing research. One of the group goes to Venice on an Art Lovers tour and gets into trouble. They meet in a bar often. There are many wisecracks about her competence, about the law, and other people.

This is witty and clever and fun. Sarah Caudwell, herself a lawyer, died after only writing three mysteries. I am not sure the others are
Li'l Vishnu

‘Are you,’ I asked. ‘waiting for your husband?’

‘My husband,’ said Marylou, ‘has gone to Verona for the weekend to stay with a business associate.’ She made the expression ‘business associate,’ which I would previously have thought innocuous, sound decidedly pejorative. She didn’t make ‘husband’ sound all that flattering, either.
— p. 66

Well, I guess this was funny, in sort of a distant way. I did think it had some clever turns in it.

One thing that really struck me is how she suddenly made fina
Brenda Mengeling
Almost the entirety of Thus was Adonis Murdered consists of letters being read aloud and conversations about the letters. The story is told by a female Oxford don, who is visiting London to do some research on her subject, which is history of British law. She meets up with some solicitor friends of hers (some of whom were her students), and from them learns about fellow solicitor Julia's plight while vacationing in Venice. Julia is being held for the murder of a beautiful young man, who was part ...more
Moira Fogarty
Excellent good fun! I tried to read this once before and stopped after a pitiable four of five pages because the prose was too dense and academic for my state of mind at the time. If I had only had someone to urge me on to the completion of Chapter Two, which includes a hilarious letter from the accused, I would have seen the lighter side of Caudwell's tale of murder and art history, and persevered.

Alas, I had no such guide, and wasted several years having this book sit on my shelf unread and u
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Moving Toyshop (Gervase Fen, #3)
  • Miss Pym Disposes
  • Whom the Gods Love (Julian Kestrel Mysteries, #3)
  • Death at the President's Lodging (Sir John Appleby, #1)
  • Lord Peter (Lord Peter Wimsey Mysteries)
  • Trent's Last Case (Phillip Trent, #1)
  • The Poisoned Chocolates Case (Roger Sheringham Cases, #5)
  • He Who Whispers (Dr. Gideon Fell, #16)
  • In the Last Analysis (A Kate Fansler Mystery #1)
  • The False Inspector Dew
  • The Affair of the Blood-Stained Egg Cosy (Burford Family, #1)
Sarah Cockburn (1939-2000) wrote under the pen-name Sarah Caudwell. She was a mystery writer. The four books of her "Hilary Tamar" series are her only novels other than The Perfect Murder which she co-wrote with several other novelists, but she also wrote several short crime stories. She was the half-sister of Alexander Cockburn.

* Hilary Tamar Mystery
More about Sarah Caudwell...

Other Books in the Series

Hilary Tamar (4 books)
  • The Shortest Way to Hades (Hilary Tamar, #2)
  • The Sirens Sang of Murder (Hilary Tamar, #3)
  • The Sibyl in Her Grave (Hilary Tamar, #4)
The Shortest Way to Hades (Hilary Tamar, #2) The Sibyl in Her Grave (Hilary Tamar, #4) The Sirens Sang of Murder (Hilary Tamar, #3) Anne Perry Presents Malice Domestic (Malice Domestic, #6) Women Before the Bench

Share This Book

“On my first day in London I made an early start. Reaching the Public Record Office not much after ten, I soon secured the papers I needed for my research and settled in my place. I became, as is the way of the scholar, so deeply absorbed as to lose all consciousness of my surroundings or of the passage of time. When at last I came to myself, it was almost eleven and I was quite exhausted: I knew I could not prudently continue without refreshment.” 6 likes
“Julia's unhappy relationship with the Inland Revenue was due to her omission, during four years of modestly successful practice at the Bar, to pay any income tax. The truth is, I think, that she did not, in her heart of hearts, really believe in income tax. It was a subject which she had studied for examinations and on which she had thereafter advised a number of clients: she naturally did not suppose, in these circumstances, that it had anything to do with real life.” 5 likes
More quotes…