Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Knowledge of Angels” as Want to Read:
Knowledge of Angels
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Knowledge of Angels

4.02 of 5 stars 4.02  ·  rating details  ·  877 ratings  ·  93 reviews
Praised by Ursula K. Le Guin as a "disturbing and beautiful novel of ideas," Knowledge Of Angels is an absorbing read that explores timeless conflicts between tolerance and moral certainty, between loving kindness and murderous cruelty. Capturing the mood of William Golding's haunting medieval love story, The Spire, Knowledge Of Angels is a suspenseful fable set on a mythi ...more
Hardcover, 282 pages
Published July 25th 1994 by R&L Yeatman (first published 1994)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Knowledge of Angels, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Knowledge of Angels

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,505)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Ursula Le Guin reportedly described this book as "beautiful and disturbing", and I can go with that. I didn't expect to like this; Jill Paton Walsh has left me cold on several previous occasions. But slowly, slowly, I was drawn in by the (alternate?) world presented. The proofs of God's existence parts were tiresome to me, since I've done Religious Studies to A Level and the first year of a philosophy degree, but the story formed around the idea of proving the existence of God is beautiful.

E. Chainey (Bookowski)
Tam yorum ve inceleme için:

Bir ada hayal ettiğinizi düşünün. Ama bu ada bildiğiniz hiçbir yere benzemiyor. Ciudad bu adanın adı. Kardinal ise Severo adlı biri. Ada Hristiyanlık inancının baskın olduğu bir yer ve Hristiyan inancının dışındaki tüm inanışlara kötü gözle bakılıyor (bir yerden tanıdık geldi mi?).

Adada bir gün, yani aynı gün, adada yaşayanların bir kısmı dağda buz gömmek için (yazın satacaklardır) gittikleri yere yakın bir yerde vahşi bir kurt
This is a fable, unelaborately told and recounted with a truth and simplicity which makes it resonate and seem timeless. The author plays entertainingly, in the prologue, with post-modernist ideas of the way that novels capture time, and the characters are eternally in their own present, poised to undertake their tasks preordained by their author, at the will of the reader - the internal time of the book being somewhere in the 15th century, but the awareness of author and reader are firmly 21st ...more
An interesting exploration of the shades of faith and unfaith, their intersections and collisions. Of course, I related to the character representing the Enlightenment, up to one passage that just surprised the heck outta me. I don't believe the enlightenment included THAT as a matter of routine. Probably somebody in the Enlightenment advocated such things. Primacy of individualism and all that. The other atheist (wolf girl) also exhibits a deliberately shocking behavior at the same point in the ...more
George Neville-neil
A good book is one the effects you deeply. Although this is a philosophical treatise disguised as a novel, it, nonetheless, hits all the right intellectual chords while also pulling you in to the lives of the characters. I enjoyed going along for the ride and reading both the philosophy and the story itself. The characters are well drawn and lovingly crafted and even if you know the arguments on which it is based you will not be bored. Another point in its favor is that, even though it's written ...more
A great book that makes you think about why you believe what you believe. You cannot convince someone else that God exists or does not exist and no one can prove it to you. Is the knowledge of God innate or learned?

This is one of the most thought-provoking books that I have ever read and one of our best discussions for book club. I highly recommend this book!

In fact, I bought this book, so I could loan it out to people.
Numa ilha, em plena Idade Média, são feitos prisioneiros um náufrago - cujos conhecimentos ao nível da ciência e forma de ver o mundo são superiores e contrários aos dos habitantes da ilha - e uma menina que foi criada por lobos. É um grande livro que fala da crueldade a que são sujeitos aqueles que são diferentes da maioria. Emocionei-me com a capacidade de amar e entrega de algumas personagens. Gostei das dissertações sobre religião. É um livro pequeno mas de uma grande riqueza, ao nível das i ...more
Cant understand the popularity of this book at all. What point does it make? That integrity is futile? The idea of isolating a child and expecting the word of God reminds me of 'The New York Trilogy' by Paul Auster. For some reason the descriptive passages of the landscape, of which there were many, did not build any clear images in my mind. Been reading Brothers karamazov and the religious discussion in K of A seems so flimsy and for show, almost like a nonsense in comparison, although I have t ...more
Kristi Thompson
A novel of ideas - debates between an agnostic and some dedicated christians - a philospher following Aquinas, and the devil incarnate in an inquisitor. And the feral child - who hadn't known god - and the reluctant nun. And some free love, and the utopian country of the agnostic, where engineers and artists are princes, and everyone believes as they wish...
A powerful novel about society and the individual. This carefully crafted novel really made me think about the tensions between the individual and a society and the way in which ignorance and fear can quickly turn to persecution of the most gentle person.
Imagine contemporary beliefs and morals and throw them headlong into 15th century pious, unshakeable religious views, and sit back and watch the fireworks. A very different, compelling read, and one which left me thinking about it for days afterwards - thought provoking - always the sign of a good book. A little ploddy during the many religious/counter-religious discussions; a great deal of detail is included which obviously took hours of meticulous research on the part of the writer, but I'm af ...more
Heavy on the theological arguments this fable but I don't think much that anyone with elementary curiosity has not already come across. It could go deeper I believe. The story itself is the winner here, the disguise in a way of those arguments, which is pretty cool I think. Especially the story of Amara, the wolf-child, and Josefa, the nun who is appointed her guardian. Actually, all characters are awesome and there's an urgency to the story that reads like a medieval thriller. The language is c ...more
Venetia Green
Deceptively simply written, this is primarily a book of ideas and not very simple ones at all! It explores, via the tales of two people who have never believed in God and are thrust into a theocratic society, the nature of belief and faith in God. We are provided with the elaborate proofs of God's existence only to have them deconstructed by an highly moral atheist and an amoral girl raised by wolves. I was not so keen on the introduction of the inquisition towards the end of the novel - inquisi ...more
Tuğçe Sevin
3,5 stars

review to come
Linda  Branham Greenwell
The story of a wolf-girl slowly intermingles with that of a man unjustly persecuted because of his beliefs.
A young girl, raised by wolves, is captured in the snow by men and brought into the human society. A kindly boy finds help from the Cardinal who in turn decides to perform a religious experiment with the wolf girl. She is brought to a secluded cloister where she is to be kept without any mention of God in her presence. In this way, the Cardinal tries to find out if there is actually a hig
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Simon Mcleish
Originally published on my blog here in June 1999.

Knowledge of Angels is not exactly a historical novel; though the island of Grandinsula is based on medieval Mallorca, it really exists only in the imagination of Walsh; there is no such country as Aclar. Yet the medieval atmosphere is pervasive; perhaps that is to be expected in a novel whose theme is the conflict between the modern and medieval worldviews.

Medieval Christendom was a society which was very inward looking, where foreigners were ge
Barrett Brassfield
I recently had cause to revisit this excellent novel by Jill Paton Walsh, originally published in 1994 and even after 19 years between readings this beautiful book has lost none of its power. At its heart, Knowledge of Angels is about whether or not we have innate knowledge of God, as opposed to the "reality" of God's existence being imprinted on our consciousnesses through education, indoctrination, and study. The author creates this island nation that exists sometime in the middle ages, an isl ...more
I had bought this book years (like, almost definitely over a decade) ago and kept it in my parents' summer place. Over time, I became less interested in angel topics, and also somewhat suspicious of whether it was promoting soft-core religion. However, a few months ago, I heard a really interesting discussion of it on the radio, and realized they were talking about the same book still sitting next to a bed in upstate NY. Since we'd be visiting my parents, I just decided not to bring a book with ...more
One of my favourite books, Knowledge of Angels isn't strictly speaking a historical novel - it doesn't have a precise enough location and date for that - but it uses a vividly-described, idyllic Mediterranean island, teetering on the edge of the Renaissance, as the setting for a compelling fable about faith, tolerance and understanding. The isolated island of Grandinsula is a devout country, ruled by its gentle and humane cardinal-prince, Severo; but the story begins with two discoveries which w ...more
Poetically beautiful, as far as historical fiction goes this is one of my favorites. I know that some attributes are not historically accurate (hence the fiction) but the authors ideals about the inquisition are tangible. Talk about putting one's convictions to the test (or should I say "to The Question"). This book asks the questions: How much can one person take before he/she brakes? Walsh makes you feel the Church’s desperation to purify the human race at any cost (one belief, one God); Is G ...more
David Tomlinson
Interesting throughout but I'm still not sure what I think of it. The story contrasts two opposing people and situations to illustrate the difficulty in proving or disproving a belief. Hat tip to the novel concept of angels having both morning knowledge and evening knowledge: the morning being how things should be and the evening being how things are. The conflicting, frustrating knowledge of both makes angels of us all.
Ashton Wenborn
This is one of those books which is not only enjoyable to read but stays with you even after you've finished. The subject matter, whether knowledge of God is innate and if nature or nurture has the biggest impact on development, is one which grabbed me from the start and kept me hooked throughout. In the book itself it could be argued that very little actually happens and Paton Walsh could easily have lost the reader in the long religious debates but manages not to as a result of her engaging ch ...more
This is a stimulating, troubling book--one of my all-time favorites. It's set a thousand years ago on an island in the Mediterranean that is ruled by a man who is a also a cardinal in the church. The plot centers around the coincidental discovery of a child who had been raised by wolves and an urbane atheist who is stranded on the island. Officials try to convert him so they don't have to execute him. It is a nifty way to learn the classical proofs for the existence of God as well as their refut ...more
Katrina Zartman
I enjoyed Walsh's descriptions of time and place. However, I was surprised by and uncomfortable with some "adult content" that she included. Some of the paragraphs were easy to skim over, because I wasn't compelled to follow the arguments that the characters were making.
Hugh Ashton
I think that this deserves 5 stars. Possibly 4.75 (1 through 5 is hardly a decent scale for rating, really - I'd prefer to click somewhere on a line between 0 and 100). But...

Not by any means everyone's cup of tea, but I enjoyed it. A sort of historical novel, set in a place that never existed, but a time which most certainly did. As a philosophy graduate, I was intrigued by the theology and philosophy inherent in the work, but there's also a story here. It's more heavily academical philosophy t
Bit too highbrow for me. The book concerns the question whether God exists and whether proof of God can be found in the known world. Lots of philosophical debates in the shade of olive trees. The ending left me feeling very unsatisfied indeed.
Emily Grace
This book was recommended to me by my philosophy teacher who said it was a fantastic work of fiction which explored poignant philosophical arguments. Unfortunately I did not enjoy the book as much as I though I would. I found the pace of the plot very slow going and yawn-worthy. The book is split into two different stories and I was only mildly interested in one of them. This made it quite difficult to find the enthusiasm to continue reading. However, the book is richly detailed and I would reco ...more
"he wondered ruefully why it is those who believe most passionately in a merciful deity who are themselves most murderous and cruel"

Perhaps more than a few prelates of various churches around the world should take note and read this wonderful book.

Compassionate and beautifully written it is also a superb advocacy of atheism as more than a negation of received wisdom but a perspective of wonder and humanity.

The lessons of the book can be readily applied to one of our currently most heated and di
Jan 17, 2008 R.Z. rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Progressive Christians
Recommended to R.Z. by: Manual
I couldn't put this down. Here is an isolated island of mixed folks probably in the fifteenth century, predominently Christian who rule with a iron hand. Drop in a stranger from the sea who is an atheist and a young girl who has been raised from birth by wolves, and the challenges to the prevailing theologial thinking becomes profound. The stranger and the wolf-girl never meet, but the thoughtful and caring ecclesiasts who deal with them are shaken to the core especially when the Inquisition ent ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 50 51 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Industry of Souls
  • Daughters Of The House
  • Beside The Ocean Of Time
  • Flying to Nowhere
  • The 27th Kingdom
  • The Orchard on Fire
  • Shadows on Our Skin
  • Reef
  • According to Mark
  • Reading Turgenev
  • A Five Year Sentence
  • The Bird of Night
  • Paradise
  • Jigsaw: An Unsentimental Education
  • An Insular Possession
  • The Good Apprentice
  • Rumours Of Rain
  • The Keepers of Truth
Jill Paton Walsh was born Gillian Bliss in London on April 29th, 1937. She was educated at St. Michael's Convent, North Finchley, and at St. Anne's College, Oxford. From 1959 to 1962 she taught English at Enfield Girls' Grammar School.

Jill Paton Walsh has won the Book World Festival Award, 1970, for Fireweed; the Whitbread Prize, 1974 (for a Children's novel) for The Emperor's Winding Sheet; The
More about Jill Paton Walsh...
A Presumption of Death (Lord Peter Wimsey/Harriet Vane, #2) The Attenbury Emeralds (Lord Peter Wimsey/Harriet Vane, #3) The Green Book The Late Scholar (Lord Peter Wimsey/Harriet Vane, #4) A Parcel of Patterns

Share This Book

“[A]fter all, the position of a reader in a book is very like that occupied by angels in the world, when angels still had any credibility. Yours is, like theirs, a hovering, gravely attentive presence, observing everything, from whom nothing is concealed, for angels are very bright mirrors. Hearts and minds are as open as the landscape to their view, as to yours; like them you are in the fabled world invisible.” 0 likes
More quotes…