Unfortunately I was unable to finish this book – which is not something that happens to me very often. I hadn't heard of Under a Blood Red Sky until I saw it in the library and I thought I'd give it a try as I love historical fiction set in Russia.

However, right from the beginning of the book I felt we were being asked to accept things that weren't plausible. The whole plot was just too far-fetched for me. The other (bigger) problem I had with this book was that I couldn't connect with any of t More...

I have nursed a slight obsession with Russia for years, so I was naturally intrigued by this, despite my concern that it might turn out to be a syrupy romance. I needn't have worried - it's a fantastically enjoyable, fast-paced adventure packed with unexpected twists and complex characters. And although this is primarily a novel about love and friendship, the attention to historical detail is extraordinary, making the book's depiction of life in Stalin's Russia incredibly vivid and believable. T More...

Awesome! Absolutely loved this in depth story about a split Russia in 1933 under Stalin's reign. In a Siberian women's labor camp we get to know two women, Sofia and Anna. Anna came from a well-to-do family and tells Sofia stories of Vasily, a family friend and revolutionary who she has been in love with since childhood. Sofia escapes the labor camp to find Vasily, their only hope in saving a dying Anna. Sofia finds the village where Vasily is now living under a different name. These are difficu More...

Imprisoned in a Russian labor camp during the 30's, Sofia is subjected to physical abuse and near starvation--finding comfort only in her friendship with Anna. Anna was once a privledged daughter of a doctor shares stories of parties, warm foods, and lavish clothing, and the love she has for a revolutionary named Vasily. As Anna succumbs to the sickness that the brutal winters bring, Sofia knows she must escape the camp to save her friend. Finding herself in a small village, Sofia tries to inter More...

Whoa. Great book. I actually described the plot to my family at dinner yesterday and my husband sarcastically said, "It sounds really boring." My six-year-old son replied,"No it sound really exciting!"

I didn't know much about Russia in the 1930s or even anything about the Russian Revolution except for what happened to the Tsar's family. This book has given me a picture of what it might have been like to live in Russia in that time period. Sofia escapes from a Siberian Gulag in order to save a f More...

Best lines:

Now she could see clearly the look of loneliness in his young face, the need for something that felt like love even if it wasn't.

But he wasn't hers. She was stealing him. An ache started up in her chest.

A tiny worm of jealousy squirmed into being,, and she stamped on it again and again until it was nothing but a green lifeless smear. Sofia would never betray her.

She plunged under the surface of the water, a cold black world where you couldn't tell which way was up and which way was do More...

This author wasn't new to me as I've read her book The Russian Concubine. Part of me really liked her first book while another part of me felt something was missing and again I feel that. I do have to say that I liked this book a bit more, I think. I originally got this book because I did enjoy her other book and felt that this one being set in Russia would be more to my liking.

Now, I think what I felt was missing was the real sense of something being in jeopardy. There are times when Sofia or A More...

Kate Furnival wrote The Russian Concubine, a book that I reviewed a while back that I really loved. So when I saw The Red Scarf on the bookshelf of course I snapped it up. It's the story of Anna, a girl who's been in a Russian forced labor camp for some time and is sick. Anna's best friend Sophia knows Anna's about to die so she escapes the camp (it wasn't completely easy) and goes in search of Anna's lost love, Vasily.

Here it becomes Sophia's story. She manages to track Vasily down and live in More...

I started reading this book and was hooked. The storyline, involving a young woman trying to escape (and rescue her friend from) a labor camp in Siberia, was immediately appealing. Well-developed characters, fast-moving plot, detailed historical setting, skillful interweaving of past and present, it had it all.

Unfortunately, the book only went downhill from there.

At face value, it looks good, and The Red Scarf has a lot of potential--so much that I was sorry to see how quickly it devolved. Fur More...

I'm glad I read this book, why I don't know. I had a VERY Russian uncle so I got to giggle through out this story as things reminded me of him & how he talked & how absurd it sounded. Not much to say except I felt the hard times of Sofia & Anna a little on the light side for me. I read things were difficult & sad off the pages but never really felt it. I don't know if that even makes sense. I'm usually not too surpised by twists in stories, but I'll admitt I had "Whoa, what the?! More...

So I'm a huge fan of all things Russian, comes from being a history nut and daughter of a Russian teacher, so I absolutely loved that part. The portrayal of the people inside the Siberian labor camps and the struggle of the youth on the outside to reconcile consciences with the Comrade attitude, makes this book. What stops this book from getting a higher rating is the fact that it pulls in the supernatural and that some twist just don't make any sense and it just glosses over parts that the auth More...

I just rated THE MAMMY a five star novel, and this novel is written so much better. However, it's like comparing apples and oranges. THE RED SCARF is a wonderfully rich look at the Russian Revolution. The characters are layered, colorful, and believable. Although the author occasionally falters with a few "lucky incidents" along the way, I found this novel a culturally enriching experience.

(THE MAMMY was culturally enriching as well...but on a much lighter note.)

I found this book to be the best I read all Summer. I boughtthe book in an airport bookstore while I was away for a work conference. I began reading it on my plane ride home and found that I could not resist finishing it. I love historical fiction and have been interested in the Russian gulag camps since I read "One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich" in the tenth grade. Like Solzhenitsyn's piece, Furnivall created a detailed setting that allowed the reader to understand the brutal working condi More...

This book was off to a slow start for me, but once it picked up speed; we were off and running.

This is a story about the friendship between two women who meet in a Labor Camp in Soviet Russia in 1929. Through thick and thin, and everything this camp and life tries to throw at them they remain true to each other. Sofia and Anna are inseperable, but when Anna falls ill Sofia knows she won't last another winter in the camp. Together the come up with a plan...Sofia will escape, find help and come b More...

Okay, I confess, I picked up this book, and devoured it because of its obvious semblance to 'The Bronze Horseman' by Paullina Simons..

Yes it's backround is set in Russia, during Stalin's reign. Yes, there is relentless suffering, starvation, and those whom grasp onto almost anything, in an attempt of survival during a horrific time. Yes, It is a love story... But that is where the similarities end.

Sofia and Anna, are best friends, torn from their families, and all they've known and loved, thro More...

I don't want to insult any creative writers that may read this, but I have to say this book reminded me a lot of fan fiction. The characters were so completely blank that it seemed impossible that the writer gave birth to them. This book just didn't come alive for me. I hope you all know I'm not a book snob. I really do like reading everything (including fan fiction), and I am terrible with grammar. Yet, even I noticed some mistakes with editing. There is something seriously wrong with a book wh More...

When thinking about trying to summarize The Red Scarf for a review, I found it very difficult. Kate Furnivall has written such a completely intertwined story that pretty much every moment from beginning to end is significant. As I write reviews, in most cases I like to be sensitive and not give away pertinent information to anyone who may be reading the review. I might give away names of characters or a side plot or something, but not something that will ruin the entire book for the reader. Belo More...

Set against the backdrop of Stalin's Russia in 1933/1934, The Red Scarf is a testimony to the will to survive, the need for redemption, and a steadfast love. Sofia and Anna, two young women enslaved in the Davinsky Labor Camp in Siberia, live under the most brutal conditions...bone-numbing cold, little food, and unending work days. Sofia lives through it by the grace of God and her deep friendship with Anna. Anna, once a privedged girl, weaves tales of her forgotten life and shares, with Sofia, More...

I love good historical fiction, so this book fits the bill. It is the story of two women, Anna & Sofia, who meet in a Stalin-era Siberian work camp. Both women have been sentenced to the work camp because their fathers were declared enemies of the state -- one was a prosperous doctor; the other, a minister. The camp is brutal and the guards harsh and degrading. When it becomes obvious that Anna will not live through another harsh Siberian winter, Sofia, at great peril to herself - escapes th More...

Sofia Morozova’s determination to save her friend and fellow prisoner Anna is what drives her to escape from the Soviet labor camp where she is held and trek through the wilds of Siberia. She promises Anna that she will return for her. Sofia eventually makes it to the village of Tivil, where she is looked upon with suspicion, but slowly is accepted among the people. She begins to fall in love with a man who has a direct link to Anna’s past, testing Sofia’s commitment to her friend. Furnivall giv More...

I picked this up at the library along with The Jewel of St. Petersburg, not realizing they had anything to do with each other. I read Jewel first and thought it was good, although initially hard to get into. The Red Scarf, however, had me hooked from the beginning.

You don't have to read Jewel to read this book--the main characters are completely different--however, I was delighted to find that two minor characters from Jewel, one of whom is only mentioned in passing as opposed to "met," were the More...

OMG I finally finished this book. I feel as though I escaped a gulag and walked all across Siberia. Twice.

Seriously though, this story is epic in scope and spans the fall of tsarist Russia to the Bolsheviks and then the rise of the Communist state. First and foremost it is the tale of the friendship of Sofia and Anna who are interned at the Davinsky Labor Camp in Siberia. The two women cobble together a friendship against the backdrop of inhumane conditions, ill-health, crushing hopelessness, an More...

Yowza. And she does it again. LOVED it. The story is set in 1930s Russia, and is divided between Anna in the Davinsky Labour Camp, and Sofia, her friend who escapes and then tries to find help, in order to free Anna. The author paints a starkly realistic and vivid portrait of life in Soviet Russia; it's at times brutal, harsh, and yet also possessing moments of beauty. There is suspense, romance, magic, pain, and suffering, and redemption. The characters were well-drawn and I truly felt for them More...

This is not a happy, little read. It made me cry, that's for sure. But if you like a dark historical story, this is one that will suck you in and take you for a ride.

Two women struggle to survive in a horrific Siberian labor camp. One falls desperately ill and the other escapes to find the sick one's childhood love. Surely he can rescue her. We know so much about the Jewish holocaust. Most of us aren't as familiar with Russian revolution. I know I wasn't. Trust me, it was brutal.

There's fast m More...

Russian history is not for the faint of heart. After reading this novel you want to kiss Canadian soil. We meet Sofia and Anna who are imprisoned at the Davinsky Labor Camp in Siberia, 1933. Russia was then a place of ridiculous wealth and desperate poverty. When the poor people rose up and revolted, Stalin's violent Communist rule led to millions of the intellectual elite being killed and the families taken to forced labor camps. Anna has told Sofia about her childhood in Petrograd and about he More...

Fantastic book--set mostly in 1933 in Siberian Russia in a labor camp and in a small village hundreds of miles away, as well as flashbacks to 1917. Anna and Sophia become friends in the camp; Anna is very ill; Sophia escapes. She finds Tivol, the village where Vasily, Anna's childhood friend, has supposedly move to under a new name. Sophia and Mikhail fall in love, with Sophia guilty about betraying her friend. Then she learns that Mikhail is who killed Anna's father and Vasily's mother,but regr More...

This is an epic that expertly creates the atmosphere of the time and place, an admirable work of historical fiction that vividly transports the reader to a Siberian labour camp during the 1930’s. The novel portrays the hardships endured by the detainees while dramatizing the convictions that motivated the Soviet leaders and the resistance.

The story is the ultimate will to survive of Sofia and her friend Anna while incarcerated in a desolate work camp in the frozen Russian taiga. Their only relie More...

Communist Russia was not a happy place to live for the majority of its population and this novel really illustrates what some of the pressures and struggles those people faced. This story is focused on the love between two girls who met in a labor camp in Siberia. They were both political prisoners which were all too common during this time period. They found a bond which helped them survive 4 years in this labor camp. This novel begins after their first 4 years of an 8 year term.

Sofia is a stro More...

The book started out really good... I thought I was really going to love it.

The setting is a Russian labor camp in 1933; thousands of women have been forced into labor camps b/c they have not conformed to communist beliefs. The 2 main characters sofia & anna are struggling to survive. Anna is horribly sick and will not make it much longer. Sofia risks her life and escapes and promises to come back for anna.

HOwever, the book then revolves around Sofia's life in a town where there are many peo More...

This is a historical novel about communist Russia in the 1930's and the relationship between two women who meet in a death labor camp. The story takes many twists and turns as Sophia escapes to help her friend Anna who is sick. A great read.