Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Carl's Christmas” as Want to Read:
Carl's Christmas
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

4.23  ·  Rating Details  ·  517 Ratings  ·  57 Reviews
A family's faithful dog and the baby left in his charge share an adventure-filled Christmas Eve.
Hardcover, 32 pages
Published October 1st 1992 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux (BYR) (first published January 1st 1990)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Carl's Christmas, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Carl's Christmas

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 747)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Dec 04, 2015 Mouse rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
I don't normally review kids books on Goodreads but every so often one comes along for good or bad that deserves mention. This book....I just don't know where it should go?!?!?!?!?
First off, it's not much of a book as there's hardly any reading... I guess it would be considered a picture book? I don't know? I got it for my 5 year old kid and I had to make up the story to which he started to get behind. No problem, I'm one of those Geek dads that can spin a yarn with my overly active imagination.
Jenna Kennedy
Dec 01, 2014 Jenna Kennedy rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This is one of my favorite books from when I was growing up. It was given to me as a gift and I still have it and read it to this day! Alexandra Day centered this book on the models of her own dogs who helped her create such realistic illustrations which portray emotion and action. Carl and baby go on yet another adventure, and this time it goes further than just their home. They go outside into the blustery weather where they encounter a man dressed as Santa and lots and lots of snow. The cool ...more
Em Ramos
May 01, 2016 Em Ramos rated it it was amazing
La razón por la que tiene 5 estrellas, es sencilla, este libro es el primer libro que he leído, y el cual he leído muchas veces.
Cuando yo nací, mis papás decidieron volver a México, Guadalajara. Desde que tengo recuerdos, y por lo que me dice mi mamá, siempre he vivido con perros.
Pero esta vez es diferente, teníamos un perro. Le llamábamos Greco, y escribo esto por el. Este libro lo leía en su regazo, bueno, miraba los dibujos. (En ese entonces no sabía leer, tenía como 2 años o 3). Greco a pe
Julia Brumfield
A beautiful book that is primarily a picture book that follows a Rottweiler that is left to take care of a family's baby while the parents go out (I'm none too happy with that idea)....

Basically we follow from page to page as Carl takes the baby out without a coat but a hat to run some errands around Christmas. He does a generous act and then when they get home settles down when there is a ruckus out the door that he must attend to. Who can it be? You will have to get the book to check out alt
Dec 27, 2009 Cherise rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: kids
There is only one page with words, the rest of this book is told by the wonderful pictures. I love Carl books and my son and I really enjoyed reading this together. We laughed at the pictures and thoroughly enjoyed the "story."
Kelsy O'Halloran
Genre: Children's Christmas
Target Audience: Primary (K-3rd)
I chose this book because Rottweiler's are sometimes misunderstood, but in my nonfiction book the author points out the importance of training. It shows a dog's love for his small human and their big Christmas Eve adventure. The dog in the story, Carl, is a Rottweiler. I think that dogs are so popular among kids and a child's bond with their dog is unlike any other. A love for dogs and animals in general can be fostered into an interest
Oct 19, 2014 John rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This almost wordless picture book has great illustrations that makes the reader laugh and wonder. A great section durring christmas time, this story is great for less-sure readers. The story only has one sentence on the first page and then the rest is told for thru the pictures. The illustrations show a dog being left in charge of a baby during the Christmas season and the dog and baby go on an adventure through the streets.
Amy Rae
Nov 03, 2014 Amy Rae rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Let's be real here: is there a single Carl book that isn't a delight to look at? (I'd say "read," but these books are nearly textless, as you ought to know--if you don't, clearly you need to go out and read one.) The absurdity of parents leaving their dog in charge of the baby, and all the adventures that ensue, makes for a charming, beautifully illustrated story.
Nov 30, 2015 Cathi rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Except for two sentences on the first page, this book has no words, so the readers get to savor the wonderful pictures and come up with their own story, which is a lot of fun. Our kids have loved this book for over twenty years, and I love the CARL books, too!
Jul 16, 2014 Kaethe rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: read-aloud
Now I would never leave a toddler in the care of a dog, even a very clever dog, except possibly in a back yard that was fenced in, and only then for thirty seconds. Probably. Otherwise they'd eat all the dog's food and drink all its water. Still, in the world of the highly improbable, these are fun wordless stories.
Dec 24, 2013 Dolly rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: parents reading with their children
Gorgeous illustrations create a fun, almost wordless, story that is silly, yet a bit alarming for a parent to read. The dog, Carl, acts as a guardian for the little girl and they have a fun Christmas adventure. Having a dog act as a babysitter makes for a funny story, but it's not something a parent can laugh at lightly.

Still, the dog was adorable and I loved the retro feel of the book. We enjoyed reading this book together, even if I felt the need to discuss with our girls the utter wrongness o
Sep 03, 2015 Robbie rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
I registered a book at!
Dec 22, 2014 Jae rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Lovely illustrations and a nice way to tell a story but smh at leaving your BABY I'm the care of your DOG?? A+ great parenting 10/10 would recommend?
A beloved Classic Christmas book from my childhood! It's almost wordless but words would be extraneous in this beautifully painted tale. The story is completely unbelievable considering parents leave a dog in charge of a baby and then the baby rides the dog all over town and no one sees fit to stop them, but tales like this happen in so many fantasy books and no one batts an eyelash at it. I think it is the realistic style of illustration and lack of "once upon a time" that throws the suspension ...more
Anna J.
Oct 16, 2013 Anna J. rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: eng-261
Carl’s Christmas by Alexandra Day is entirely wordless except for its title and first page. It is a story about a mom and dad leaving their baby home with their dog. The dog decides to take the baby around to different parts of the city to show him the delights of Christmas before taking the baby home. The baby falls asleep and Santa comes and the dog ends up being the Christmas present for the baby. Though beautifully illustrated, the book was confusing in that I did not understand what it was ...more
Aug 09, 2012 ErynnMarie rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Like all of the Carl books that I've read, the story is sub-par (neglectful parents have their shortcomings made up for by a super attentive Rottweilier). It's cute in some ways, but not if you think about it too hard (like I just did). But I'm a sucker for beautiful illustrations, and these books have some of the best I've seen. Every page is a cornucopia of beautiful scenery and top-notch watercolor-manship. I would collect these.
*This was my first Carl book, and by far my fav so far. Probably
Dec 06, 2012 Pam rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Carl books by Alexandra Day are all gorgeously illustrated and I enjoy that fact that they feature a well behaved loving Rottweiler as I adore these stable proud dogs and abhor the bad reputation they have gotten. I like how Alexandra Day lets the illustrations tell the story with few or no words. Despite all the positives, I really dislike the premise that these books are built on that a dog can be left along to care for a child. Children are unpredictable and often physically cruel, and for th ...more
Dec 27, 2015 kelli rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
really sweet illustrations
3 1/2 stars. Cute and fun.
Dec 18, 2015 Karrie rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
The kids love Carl
Meg McGregor
Sep 13, 2015 Meg McGregor rated it it was amazing
Carl is the babysitter every Mother needs!

It just wouldn't be the Christmas season without visiting Carl and Maddie and sharing in their adventures on Christmas Eve!

This is primarily a picture book so little ones who cannot read can still read the story all by themselves.

But it is so much more fun when reading with someone else, isn't it?

Carl is such a great babysitter he could probably put me out of business.

Good thing he lives where there is snow and I live in Las Vegas.
Amie Anderson
Oct 16, 2013 Amie Anderson rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: eng261
Carl's Christmas is an almost wordless book about a dog who takes care of his human baby sister when her parents go out on Christmas Eve. He takes her all over town, and after they return home, he witnesses Santa's arrival. I thought the book was rather strange in that the baby's parents left her with the dog; it was just too unrealistic for my taste. The genre is wordless books and the only theme I could think of was Christmas. The book is probably best suited for children ages 4-7.
Linda Lipko
Loyal to his family, Carl's owners leave him alone to watch the baby. If you can get past the idea that adults would leave a baby with a dog, this is a delightful tale of the meaning of Christmas.

Carl takes the baby outside on Christmas Eve as they visit stores, donate to the poor and bring home animals in need of shelter. Santa visits while the baby and the new found friends sleep in front of the fire place.

The illustrations are lovely.
Oct 01, 2012 Gabriella rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
As a child I always loved "reading" Alexandra Day's wordless picture books. Each book took me on a new adventure with Carl and the baby. Growing up I had a rottweiler so the books were so much more personal to me. As the author's pictures took me from page to page I was able to let me imagination take hold of me, since there were no words I would fill in the blanks. I was amazed at how the author could make me laugh without saying a thing.
Sadie Vargas
This book is very good also. This book only has about 5 words in it which is in the begging when the parents tell the dog to take car of the baby while they are gone. The rest if for your imagination to go wild on. For each picture you get to put your own words down and make the story come alive. In the end they are visited by Santa and they are all safe and sound in there own beds by the time the parents get back.
Kristine Hansen
Once you get beyond the fact that these so-called parents keep leaving the DOG in charge of a baby, these books are quite fun. Baby always gets quite the adventure, the artwork is absolutely amazing, and the books are enjoyable to read to see what happens next. I find myself in that weird conflicted area of not wanting to like these books and liking them all the same.
Chloe Dryke
Dec 12, 2014 Chloe Dryke rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: picture-books
I love all the Carl books, my mom used to make up stories along with the pictures when we would "read" them together. The illustrations in this book are beautiful. Carl must watch his human baby and they spend the day roaming around stores. This book would be great to have students to write their own narrations to as it has few words.
I generally dislike the premise of parents abandoning their children, as well as the idea that it's OK to leave young children unsupervised with animals. However, if you are able to set that aside for a moment to enjoy the magic of this book, it is truly lovely.
This is my favorite of the Carl books that I've read so far.
Wordless after 1st page.
This picture book is wonderful for teaching inferring or different points of view. The book begins with dialogue and leaves the reader with the opportunity to create the rest of the story based on the pictures alone. The Carl collection is one in which every teacher should stock up on.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 24 25 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Fraidyzoo
  • Peter Spier's Christmas!
  • The Trees of the Dancing Goats
  • Angelina's Christmas
  • Christmas Trolls
  • Little Dog Lost: The True Story of a Brave Dog Named Baltic
  • Fetch
  • I'll Be Home For Christmas (Toot & Puddle)
  • A Small Miracle
  • Bear's First Christmas
  • A Pussycat's Christmas
  • I Hatched!
  • The Jolly Christmas Postman
  • Emmet Otter's Jug-Band Christmas
  • A Boy, a Dog, a Frog, and a Friend
  • Squid and Octopus Friends for Always
  • Baby Bear Counts One: with audio recording
  • Christmas in Noisy Village
Alexandra Day is the pseudonym for Sandra Louise Woodward Darling. She is the author of Good Dog, Carl and the rest of the beloved Carl books, including Carl Goes Shopping, Carl’s Christmas, Carl’s Birthday and Carl’s Snowy Afternoon. Darling was born in 1941 in Cincinnati, Ohio, to a large and close-knit family. Painting was a popular family recreation, and almost every family excursion included ...more
More about Alexandra Day...

Other Books in the Series

Good Dog, Carl (1 - 10 of 12 books)
  • Good Dog, Carl
  • Carl Goes Shopping
  • Carl's Afternoon in the Park
  • Carl's Masquerade
  • Carl Goes to Daycare
  • Carl Makes a Scrapbook
  • Carl's Birthday
  • Follow Carl!
  • Carl's Sleepy Afternoon
  • Carl's Summer Vacation

Share This Book