The Unsettling of Amer...
The Unsettling of America: Culture and Agriculture
Since its original publication in 1977, The Unsettling of America has been recognized as a classic of American letters.
In it, Wendell Berry argues that good farming is a cultural development and spiritual discipline. But today's agribusiness takes farming out of its cultural context and away from families, and as a nation we are thus more estranged from the land - from th
Hardcover, 228 pages
Published
June 12th 1982
by Random House, Inc.
(first published 1977)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Oct 16, 2007
David
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
anyone who has felt emptiness in shopping malls
maybe you'll find this at a garage sale in a beat up box for twenty-five cents. you'll pull it from the box. rub two dimes and five pennies together. you'll read it and research rain barrels. you'll sell that book to some used bookstore. you might. and a thin bookstore employee will set it on a shelf where some manicured hand might find it and bring it back to her loft. maybe she'll turn the pages and sigh at her consumption. maybe. or maybe she wont. maybe she'll walk more. and ride her bicycle...more
Every once in a while, a book comes along at the right place and at the right time, and that book has the power to change your life. This was that book for me. It moved me out of the city and into the country, and inspired me to grow food for people. It changed the way I view my relationship to the earth, and my responsibility to it. Don't read this book if you want to live comfortably with your current worldview.
This book is the classic that all Wendell Berry readers should read first. It goes through his ecological ethic and his belief that morality and ecology are inseparable; that our disconnection from the earth and our disconnection from each other are part of the same problem. This quote from his essay Think Little is a perfect introduction to his philosophies. See [http://www.msu.edu/~kikbradl/little.html]
------------------------
Most of us, for example, not only do not know how to produce the bes...more
------------------------
Most of us, for example, not only do not know how to produce the bes...more
I was eager to read this book for a couple of reasons: 1) Nick's really into W.Berry, and 2) I happened upon an Amazon review of a more recent book of his, and the reviewer wrote that she and her husband had passages from "The Unsettling of America" read at their wedding. Cool!
I found myself agreeing with WB a ton, so much so that I revived my practice of jotting down favorite passages into a little notebook. I especially loved the section in which WB discusses "The Odyssey" as fundamentally ab...more
I found myself agreeing with WB a ton, so much so that I revived my practice of jotting down favorite passages into a little notebook. I especially loved the section in which WB discusses "The Odyssey" as fundamentally ab...more
I appreciate Berry's keen observation on the link between culture and agriculture, the body, mind and the earth. I find myself agree with him on many issues. However, his obliviousness on the unbearable oppression on women in any agricultural society (or better patriarchical society) makes me angry. It is true that industrialization destroyed the meaning of household and human's meaningful connection to earth and further oppresses women. But such sexual oppressions are not brand new, it is merel...more
(clipped from note to friend) this goes back so far for me - living on the farm and then in the little farm house in SE Ohio. the years of critical thinking were just beginning. i loved WB's ideas so much AND i was also beginning to read feminism - i had just read the Women's Room. I got michael to read it too. Michael: see - it is all about individual integrity (WB). Jude: but how can any offspring of an innately unequal union achieve integrity?(WR) It was wild. I remember going to see WB in Ob...more
I have just finished my third reading of this powerful essay. I am a recent discoverer of Wendell Berry. It amazes me how much of what he writes resonates deeply with my experience.
When I discover an author I enjoy, I often try to catch up on his past work. With Mr. Berry this is no easy task since he is a hard working writer with a 50 year head start on me. After devouring 6 of his books, I realized that he is deserving of study in addition to pleasure reading. So I have began to study what he...more
When I discover an author I enjoy, I often try to catch up on his past work. With Mr. Berry this is no easy task since he is a hard working writer with a 50 year head start on me. After devouring 6 of his books, I realized that he is deserving of study in addition to pleasure reading. So I have began to study what he...more
May 03, 2009
Julia
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
foodie-stuff,
whole-earth
So if you've read anything that Barbara Kingsolver or Michael Pollan have written about food recently (which is quite a bit), you'll find that reading Wendell Berry is like going straight to the source, but about the larger picture of food production, agriculture, communities, society, and life in general. Berry wrote "Unsettling" in 1977, and it is absolutely terrifying and surreal how prescient he was then, and how important what he said still is for us today. Berry is a holistic thinker--inte...more
Sep 04, 2011
Katherine
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Katherine by:
Scripps Book Club
Shelves:
read-non-fiction
A series of essays written in the late 70's on the ethical and moral impact on our culture of large scale agriculture and the general divorce of most people from the land and the source of their food and visa versa. The consequences of cutting the millenium old "cycle of life". A lot of what he says rings true and certainly did for me and many others in our more idealistic youth. My main issue with the book and the ideas is how changes can be made to restore the "balance" in the real, current wo...more
Feb 24, 2010
blake
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
anthropology-sociology
A great, although uneven, criticism of the reigning agricultural and cultural mentality in the U.S. It's impressive that Berry wrote this more than 30 years ago since the argument seems just as timely today. The first two and last two chapters were the strongest. In between, he gets into an abstract discussion on the relationship between our connection to the land, ourselves, and other human beings. The vagueness of some of his terminology and expressions in these chapters resulted in my losing...more
This book was a gift to me from my friend Geoff some years ago, and my first full length Wendell Berry read -- though I had read essays. It was a very difficult book to read, mainly because it was about farming and agriculture, a subject I know little about.
He blames the "unsettling of America" on the mechanization and subsequent loss of the small family farm. "Agribusiness" and corporet farms arose to take the place of these farms, leading to the death of rural areas and the rape of the land. H...more
He blames the "unsettling of America" on the mechanization and subsequent loss of the small family farm. "Agribusiness" and corporet farms arose to take the place of these farms, leading to the death of rural areas and the rape of the land. H...more
Great collection of essays from the 70s most of which still resonate today. Berry comes across somewhat patriarchal but his messages about the importance of connecting with and valuing our land (understanding our food supply and cultivating an awareness/sense of place), not looking to technology for salvation/emancipating ourselves from our dependence on our cheap plastic consumer economy and its promotion of cheap fast labor instead of skilled, appreciating the knowledge of our ancestors, parti...more
About agriculture, ostensibly, but more profoundly about the ways in which modern society understands itself. In a move that is very conservative and conservatively Christian, Berry reminds us of our essential limited-ness as human beings. This is the real subject of the book: human beings are flawed and limited things, and the best we can do is to recognize how limited and flawed we are and work towards wholeness; that is, we must work to understand ourselves not as autonomous, but part of some...more
Absolutely fabulous collection of essays, even if you know nothing about agriculture. Goes to the roots (pardon the pun) of our current cultural and social malaise in fresh, creative, and insightful ways. My only complaint is how thin on theology it is, and how little he discusses the possible spiritual origins of some of the problems he explores.
Also, I do wonder how convincing this book would be to those who don't already share many of Berry's presuppositions, as I did (though I didn't realiz...more
Also, I do wonder how convincing this book would be to those who don't already share many of Berry's presuppositions, as I did (though I didn't realiz...more
Apr 11, 2013
Eddy Allen
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
arts-and-historical
The Unsettling of America has been recognized as a classic of American letters. In it, Wendell Berry argues that good farming is a cultural development and spiritual discipline. Today’s agribusiness, however, takes farming out of its cultural context and away from families. As a result, we as a nation are more estranged from the land—from the intimate knowledge, love, and care of it.
Sadly, as Berry notes in his Afterword to this third edition, his arguments and observations are more relevant tha...more
Sadly, as Berry notes in his Afterword to this third edition, his arguments and observations are more relevant tha...more
May 16, 2013
Patrick Walsh
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
environmental-issues-and-sustainabl
When I first started reading this book I was wondering if Wendell Berry's central premise, that a return to small-scale family-owned farms where some of the motive power is provided by animals such as horses and mules was not only possible but desirable, was not the impractical dream of someone longing for the remote past. Then I read an article in the New York Times that said there are 400,000 such farms currently operating in the U.S.
In addition to being a literary giant, Wendell Berry is also...more
In addition to being a literary giant, Wendell Berry is also...more
This is a wonderful, subversive book on culture, technology, and agriculture. Berry has in view the modern technological and industrial methods of farming that have wrecked havoc on our communities, our health, our land, and our future. Berry argues against the modern attempts to industrialize farming and create an urban leisure class, demonstrating their anti-human foundations and consequences.
Industrial farming has separated people from where they work and where they live, resulting in wrecked...more
Industrial farming has separated people from where they work and where they live, resulting in wrecked...more
A telling and insightful exploration of how business and politics combine, written from the perspective of the (now vanquished) non-corporate farmer. I thought it was clear, even if the arguments were not always compelling. The language, however, was both beautiful and precise - a rare combination, but one that was appreciated even if the book hadn't been dealing with such a topical and important subject.
The book isn't just about agriculture, it is about how the government abuses corporatist thi...more
The book isn't just about agriculture, it is about how the government abuses corporatist thi...more
Have you ever read an obscure book that no one you know has heard of, and felt that it was so good that it should be required reading for every human being? That's how I felt about this book.
Wendell Berry is a hero for many, including Barbara Kingsolver, who references many of Berry's ideas in her novel "Animal Vegetable Miracle". I've been meaning to get into his stuff for quite some time, and when I read this book it resonated with so many things I have believed or thought of, but never articu...more
Wendell Berry is a hero for many, including Barbara Kingsolver, who references many of Berry's ideas in her novel "Animal Vegetable Miracle". I've been meaning to get into his stuff for quite some time, and when I read this book it resonated with so many things I have believed or thought of, but never articu...more
This is a prescient but still relevant treatise on America's attitude towards agriculture and land-use. I read this book on a weekend that saw the sale of the oldest family farm in the United States; Tuttle Farm in NH had been past down from father to son since 1635. But alas... trends that upset Berry in the 70s have reaped their awful harvest, and it's barely edible. Big agribusiness, supported by big government, have won. While some of the specifics Wendell discusses are dated, his philosophy...more
This is a great book in which Berry argues that our inability to face both agricultural and cultural challenges responsibly causes Americans to be totally disconnected from our food, each other, and the Earth. This of course results in a new set of agricultural and cultural challenges; even so, we appear to be treating the symptoms (poorly, at that) instead of the cause. (The book somewhat surprisingly doesn't focus much on the details of the environmental impact and imbalance of irresponsible a...more
When I read Another Turn of the Crank in college, I remember finding it irritating. Who was this moralizing purist, this thinly veiled Christian claiming to know good from evil, and decrying reductionist thought? These days I've mellowed out a bit, and come to realize that authors who get under my skin like that are often the most interesting. Berry is no empty provocateur. If he pisses you off, there's something to be learned in considering why.
First of all, there's plenty I agree with in this...more
First of all, there's plenty I agree with in this...more
Having spent five years at a land grant institution, I can safely say that everything Mr. Berry accuses agricultural education programs of is true, even today. All of my ag professors, save one, laughed at the idea of "organic" and "sustainable" and would only allow the non-regulated trend of "all-natural" a measure of respect, because... frankly... they make a ton of money off of false advertising.
I moved to the city after graduating, and took work on a small organic farm half an hour outside o...more
I moved to the city after graduating, and took work on a small organic farm half an hour outside o...more
"The Unsettling of American is Wendell Berry's probing and personal inquiry into the way in which we use the land that sustains us, and an expression of profound awareness that farming cannot be considered separately from the larger culture. His provocative suggestions for change are by turns passionate and eloquent, here is a book that gathers urgency for today's troubled society."
~~back cover
When I was doing my upper division course work at UC Santa Cruz, there was no graduate program offered...more
~~back cover
When I was doing my upper division course work at UC Santa Cruz, there was no graduate program offered...more
Berry makes some fantastic, insightful sociological observations about modern American culture and agriculture. Namely, its failings of community, conservation, consumption, specialization, and entertainment. I can't lay all the fault for the pattern of cultural or agricultural disintegration in our society as easily as he does on the doorstep of "agribusiness." I blame it on sin and than man is fallen, not just because we aren't all farmers any more. And, yes, this fingers into agribusiness and...more
My sister and I both read this book our Junior year of high school. I'm 26 now and she's 29...and we still talk about it. It discusses basically how we divorce ourselves from our actions and it's consequences on the earth by putting them in seperate spaces away from our daily lives. It seriously strikes a chord with me hearing common sense being put into words--we can't be surprised by the problems we are encountering in modern society knowing that we have chosen to live this way all along. Exce...more
Have I mentioned that Wendell Berry is my new hero? Well, he is. As I read I am frequently and utterly shocked by the fact that the guy wrote this over 30 years ago. You couldn't write something more insightful given knowledge of all that has transpired since. Oh wait, I am only on p.27, I need to stop raving.
I finished this book almost a month ago now. I was tempted to start over and read it again immediately, but I decided against it. I don't believe I have ever felt the need to go for a walk...more
I finished this book almost a month ago now. I was tempted to start over and read it again immediately, but I decided against it. I don't believe I have ever felt the need to go for a walk...more
Dec 08, 2009
Hans
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
history,
economics,
inspirational,
paradigm-shifting,
political,
social-commentary,
philosophy,
favorites
Social Critic extraordinaire. This book helped me understand how the role of agriculture permeates through almost every aspect of our lives. I had no ideas all the implications that might entail.
Like the battles of an individual soul, culture (the societal soul) also wages war against itself. The most recent and prominent contenders in this fight for the collective soul are between business and agriculture. One has its center of all relationships built on money and economics while the other has...more
Like the battles of an individual soul, culture (the societal soul) also wages war against itself. The most recent and prominent contenders in this fight for the collective soul are between business and agriculture. One has its center of all relationships built on money and economics while the other has...more
These essays should be required reading not only for university students but especially policy makers and leaders of the agribusiness and biotech sectors (though I doubt they could stomach it). While Berry´s focus is modern agriculture, the precepts of his philosophy are far reaching and deal directly with our moral responsibilities to the earth and one another. Despite the broad scope of his criticism, Berry´s style is plain spoken and easy to comprehend. A bit preachy at times but never small...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Wendell Berry is a conservationist, farmer, essayist, novelist, professor of English and poet. He was born August 5, 1934 in Henry County, Kentucky where he now lives on a farm. The New York Times has called Berry the "prophet of rural America."
More about Wendell Berry...
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“The soil is the great connector of lives, the source and destination of all. It is the healer and restorer and resurrector, by which disease passes into health, age into youth, death into life. Without proper care for it we can have no community, because without proper care for it we can have no life.”
—
20 people liked it
“If we do not live where we work and when we work we are wasting our lives and our work too.”
—
6 people liked it
More quotes…
Loading...































updated Oct 16, 2007 09:54am
Trudie
Oct 17, 2007 07:16am