From Hell: Une autopsie de Jack l'Éventreur (From Hell #1-11)
Popular Answered Questions
I hated every goddamn minute of it.
I hated the cramped, schizophrenic writing that made my eyes cross. I hated the stark, sketch-y drawing that were so vague you couldn't ever tell who was who. I hated the gore and the period-"appropriate" racism and classism. I hated all the characters—the flippety-gibbet women and the cold cruel calculating men and everyone in between. I hated the inexplicable worlds-within-worlds twistiness of the myriad occult subplots. I h ...more
At the heart of the tale is Jack the Ripper. It is the truest telling of Jack the Ripper that I've ever read. It matters not a whit whether Dr. William Gull is actually Jack the Ripper. Nor whether Queen Victoria set the ball rolling with her orders. Nor whether Abberline actually fell for one of the prostitutes. Nor whether the Freemasons had their hands all over th ...more
From Hell is dense, multi-layered, and overflowing with an obsessive connect-the-dots tone that fancifully associates the events to everything from Aleister Crowley's childhood to Hitler' ...more
I read this not with a notion that by the end I'd come t ...more
FROM HELL by Alan Moore is a monster of a hard cover (comic) book depicting the gruesome Whitechapel murders committed by the notorious Jack The Ripper and investigated by Scotland Yard in the late 1800's.
While a work of fiction, this book includes a greatly expanded and detailed Appendix with factual notations as well as educated speculation (from the author) for each chapter and a period map of London giving the reader much food...more
I think one should approach this not as a comic, or even a graphic novel, but as a prose novel. It's a very dense read, and requires a lot of your time and attention. But I don't say this as a criticism. Once you get past the first 100 pages or so, it turns ...more
Here is what I consider to be Alan Moore's personal best work. When I finished "From Hell" I had a profound, inescapable feeling that I just learned something very important about mankind and human nature on such a level that it was difficult to quantify. The work is at once clinical, unsympathetic and uncomfortable, yet these reactions are so int ...more
So in what I think is a first since opening CCLaP last year, I got a chance recently to not only read a book for the first time but also watch a movie based on it for the first time in the same week; in this case, it was the "Jack The Ripper" conspiracy tale From Hell, with the original 1999 graphic ...more
I didn't read the appendix/Commentary though. I feel that a clock looses a bit of its lustre if you open its face and see the mechanisms and cogs at work.
There's an interconnectedness to time in From Hell that I thought was really interesting, which takes full advantage of the graphic novel format. Conversati ...more
I am so not surprised that this moron wrote the book WATCHMEN was based on. That movie was hands down the worst thing I've ever seen. After the opening credits of Bob Dylan singing "The Times They Are A Changing" while random super heroes get busted, I knew I was in for something truly awful. A story so mean ...more
Komiksový svět má asi málo větších legend než Alana Moora. Ten je podepsaný pod takovými díly, jako V jako Vendeta, Strážci nebo Liga výjimečných. Pokud někdo podává svou prací nepopiratelný důkaz o tom, že komiks nemusí být pouze pro děti, je to právě Moore ...more
Creo que es indiscutible que Alan Moore es un genio de la novela gráfica, y en esta en concreto el dibujo de Eddie Campbell complementa su trabajo a la perfección.
La historia de Jack el Destripador siempre me ha provocado cierta fascinación, y he leído ya varios libros sobre el tema. Esta novela gráfica, aunque desde luego tiene mucho de ficción, recrea el Whitechapel de 1888 y el Otoño del Terror a la perfección. Y la teoría que A ...more
The truth about this book is that the Ripper murders are almost tangential to the point of the work itself. The story, which is largely fictional though based on fact, is about the cover-up con ...more
This book is a much better introduction to comics as literature for a newcomer to the medium. Moore's writing is intricately layered, matche ...more
From Hell is about the Jack the Ripper. Saying it's about Jack the Ripper isn't the full story, it's much more. It not onl ...more
I've read quite a bit of JTR lore. This is by far my favorite. We're all familiar, in some way, with his spree, so actually seeing it depicted in pen and ink made it so much more real. Less academic. Campbell does not shy away from his subject matter. I've read Moore's "notes" on illustrations for other GNs, so I know how exacting he can be, but still, Campbell is so incredibly graphic, it g ...more
For a Jack the Ripper enthusiast this is a wonderful piece of fiction exploring one of the more prominent suspects and naming the one that I think all the conspiracy theorists would love most of all. After all you couldn't make a better story than one with Royal scandal and the intervention of the Q ...more
I really wanted to like it. I love Jack the Ripper speculation and I've always loved comics, so I had hoped this would be right up my alley. Sadly I was disappointed. I will admit that Alan Moore wrote a great story. The sheer amount of research he must have conducted about London in 1888 and Masonic ritual must have ...more
From what I do remember (or think I remember), this was one of the best Re-Jack stories and investigation ever done. Moore went above and beyond in his research and speculations.
Add the mystical element, and I for one am not that great of believer in mysticism, but in this case, Moore makes it seem completely credible.
Some have critisized Cambell's artwork as being "bad". However, I would venture to say that his ...more
Just a jackknife, has macheath, yeah.....and he keeps it, out of sight
When the shark bites, with his teeth, dear....scarlet billows start to spread
Fancy gloves, though, wears macheath, yeah..so there's not a trace, hmmmm of red
|2016 Reading Chal...: From Hell||1||18||Feb 21, 2015 08:10AM|
|The Dead Tree Soc...: Finally done reading this one!||1||4||Dec 30, 2014 07:22AM|
|Graphic Novel Rea...: Official 16th Book Club Discussion: From Hell by Alan Moore - April 2013 (may contain spoilers)||5||55||Apr 24, 2013 03:25AM|
With Alan Moore he created the towering opus From Hell, later adapted by Hollywood. Among the multitude of solo works he has produced, the epic series Bacchus brings th ...more