Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “A Fatal Grace: A Chief Inspector Gamache Novel” as Want to Read:
A Fatal Grace: A Chief Inspector Gamache Novel
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

A Fatal Grace: A Chief Inspector Gamache Novel (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache #2)

4.12 of 5 stars 4.12  ·  rating details  ·  13,988 ratings  ·  1,576 reviews
Winner of the 2007 Agatha Award for Best Novel!

Welcome to winter in Three Pines, a picturesque village in Quebec, where the villagers are preparing for a traditional country Christmas, and someone is preparing for murder.
No one liked CC de Poitiers. Not her quiet husband, not her spineless lover, not her pathetic daughter—and certainly none of the residents of Three Pines.
Audio CD
Published July 29th 2014 by Macmillan Audio (first published January 1st 2006)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Susan Anderson
Where to begin with all the richness that A FATAL GRACE gave me. Reading it, I wondered how I had lived so long without discovering the work of Louise Penny, a first-rate writer. Her creation in this book is so real, her writing so lyrical, her characters so unique and the book's structure and meaning so complex that I began mumbling to myself, taking my sweet time reading the book in order to savor its mix of flavors, its innuendoes and subtleties, having at times to stop and scratch my head. I ...more
Myrna looked out the window and wondered whether their peace, so fragile and precious, was about to be shattered. Since CC de Poitiers had arrived there'd been a gathering gloom over their little community. She'd brought something unsavory to Three Pines, in time for Christmas.

 photo e9a96ea2-7610-4531-aabc-0691e09da972_zpsfd5cefab.jpg

It is Christmas in Three Pines- and once again Chief Inspector Armand Gamache and his team are called to investigate another murder...

No one liked CC de Poitiers – not her daughter, not her husband, not her lover, and cer
This is the second book I've read in this series and just as good as the other one I have read. I'm not reading them in order, which is fine with me since it's usually a few weeks after I finish one before I start another in the series. I really love Louise Penny's writing style and the way she develops these characters. Here are two of my favorite lines from this book:

"There at the back stood CC de Poitiers wearing a fluffy white sweater made of either cashmere or kittens."

"Now she sat in front
Lewis Weinstein
I started reading this book immediately after finishing Still Life, with high expectations. At first, I was disappointed. The initial chapters seemed to lose the edge established by the prior book, the returning characters from the village of Three Pines seemed far less interesting than before.

Then Inspector Gamache came on the scene, late in my judgment, but once he made his appearance, the story took off, with an accelerating pace that lasted all the way through. The Three Pines characters, n
3.5 stars.
The 2nd in the Gamache series did not get quite as high praise as the first, but I will continue with this series. I think this one bogged down a bit for me and perhaps since the victim was not very likable I am not sure I was as invested in finding out "who dunnit".

That said, I love Gamache and his team. I love the way he methodically plods to the conclusion and I try to figure the mystery out right along with him. This one came to me rather early but I could not figure out all th
Better than Still Life but that says something since I liked that one very much. Many of the same characters are back and Armand continues to charm. He is the kind of leader/mentor I would aspire to be when I find myself in that role. The setting in small village Quebec works well and the plot is interesting and sublime. As a whodunit you can deduce many of the interim mysteries but the final is hard to decifer until the very end. Her descriptions are lavish and picturesque. Looking forward to r ...more
Richard Reviles Censorship Always in All Ways
This review has been revised and can now be found at Expendable Mudge Muses Aloud.
Chad Sayban
It is winter in the cozy town of Three Pines, Quebec and once again Chief Inspector Armand Gamache and his team have been called upon to solve a murder. However, the victim – CC de Poitiers – isn’t mourned by anyone, not even her husband and daughter. To compound the situation, Poitiers was murdered right in front of the entire village in an extraordinary way, yet nobody saw who did it. Gamache must once again use his patience and intellect to find a killer in a town where everyone knows everyon ...more
Anne Mowat
What Louise Penny does is create a small, intimate world, while creating a sense of place so pervasive you feel you know it. Canada is rarely featured in best-selling books, and to have it so celebrated is wonderful. It is Quebec, to be sure, but the Quebec of Anglo-culture, and so, it is the Canadian Quebec.

Most powerful, for me, is the way she builds quiet characters of amazing strength and depth. These are not cartoon-brilliant people. They are, for the most part, fully-fleshed out, but rath
Mary Beth
I really enjoyed this second book in the series and the quirky characters are back and we are becoming friends. I missed them.
It is Christmas time in Three Pines and gives a nice winter environment. Gamache actually deals. with two murders in this book. One deals with a homeless person and the other murder deals with a mean unjoyous woman, Cc de Poitiers. Working with his partner Beauvoir and newcomer Lemieux, Gamache investigates the crimes, learning more and more about the residents of Three
It took a little while to get started, but what a great finish! I really enjoyed the second in the Inspector Gamache series. The village of Three Pines and all its inhabitants comes alive under the pen of Louise Penny. I'm also enjoying getting to know not only Gamache, but all of his team. The villagers and the team are all recurring characters. Many are quirky and odd, which makes me like them even more. I'll definitely be continuing with this series. Penny understands a great breadth of human ...more
I am intrigued by this mystery series, set in the oh-so-quaint village of Three Pines. Unfortunately, I didn't enjoy this second installment of the series as much as the first.

This time around, Penny seems to be painting her characters with a broader brush. Several characters seem much more comic-boo-caricaturish than they did in Still Life. Also, Dead Cold feels like a "middle" book, with ongoing subplots that don't particularly get anywhere and leave readers with a sense of incompletion.

On th

Inspector Gamache is becoming an old friend who I look forward to visiting again and again. The quirky residents of a Three Pines add to these stories and I would love to have dinner with my personal favorite Ruth who is just cranky enough to be interesting.

My one drawback for this story was the description of the daughter of the victim as fat and grotesque. The fat shaming was a bit much and caused my husband, who was listening to this book with me, to walk away from the story.

I am hooked and w
Many of my reading friends have read A Fatal Grace, the second in Louise Penny's Three Pines Mystery Series, later books becoming A Chief Inspector Armand Gamache Novel. Few have had much to say about it other than giving it 4-5 stars. This could be due to its publication date, perhaps a bit pre-GR or just that it's a good mystery and that's that.

I could immediately see Penny's growth as a writer. I found it far better plotted and much more engaging than the first in the series. From what I'm h
Lynn G.
The second in author Louise Penny's Inspector Gamache series, A Fatal Grace A Fatal Grace (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #2) by Louise Penny, reacquaints the reader with the friendly villagers of Three Pines and members of the Quebec Surete. As before, a murder in Three Pines brings them together once again.

While each book in the series is a stand-alone there are references to past events that link the books and serve as an understory that will be fleshed out and resolved in future volumes, including the machinations between and amongst members of the Sure
Kathy Davie
Second in the Chief Inspector Armand Gamache cozy mystery series and revolving around Gamache and a small cast of villagers from Three Pines in Canada.

And winner of the 2007 Agatha Award for Best Novel!

My Take
An excellent cozy, cottage mystery with Québecois Christmas traditions as Gamache, a Miss Marple and Hercule Poirot wrapped in one with his easy, laidback style, and the core cast of village characters from Still Life , 1, get jolted by yet another murderous mystery. Hmmm, what are the chan
I really enjoyed Dead Cold and am happy to report that the 5 stars I rated the series’ first book wasn’t a fluke. Book 2 is just as good. Dead Cold is a police procedural or who done it but it is so very much more. There are layers and layers to the story. There is the primary crime to be solved but there are numerous sub plots woven expertly into the story. Even if you figure something out before the end, it doesn’t matter. The pleasure for me is the journey, reading the words, getting to know ...more
Carolyn Hill
I am hooked on Louise Penny, even though I'm not a particular fan of murder mysteries. Many people enjoy mysteries for the puzzle, and this book certainly has a gigantic one, but I tend to read mysteries more for the characters and setting, which is what makes me want to return to Louise Penny's books. Sure, you want an intriguing plot, but what brings a novel of this genre to the next level is the humanity of its characters. Penny not only has an understanding of human nature, she imparts a cer ...more
Laura de Leon
I find it hard to describe what it is I like so much about this book as well as the first book in the series-- difficult enough that I never reviewed Still Life.

I find them very comfortable books-- not sweet books, not cozy books, but books where I just seamlessly slip into their world. The village of Three Pines is a vivid place, with interesting characters.

There is an emphasis on art in both of these books-- the first featured painters, and many of the characters continued into A Fatal Grace,
Superior writing. Superior mystery.

One reason I love Louise Penny so much is that her mysteries are so human, so emotional. Her stories aren't like a Dell book of logic puzzles, with correct answers but without a soul. No. Her stories are about the seeds of emotions sprinkled, germinated, and fully expressed.

Here's an excerpt from a moment between Chief Inspector Armand Gamache and his wife Reine-Marie:

'Voila. It's good to be home.' He took her in his arms and kissed her, feeling her soft body
DEAD COLD (Police Procedural-Canada-Cont) – Ex
Penny, Louise – 2nd in series
Headline, 2006- UK Hardcover
*** Chief Inspector Armand Gamache and his officers have been called back to the town of Three Pines. CC de Poitiers, an extremely unpleasant woman, has been murdered in public at the height of a curling match. Figuring out how she was killed is as much a mystery as uncovering who killed her.
*** Penny’s books are deceptive. On one hand, they seem a simple traditional mystery, set in a small tow
Nikki Magennis
I am not averse to familiar tropes or carefully crafted set ups that hook and lead and set up a read according to well known methods. But there were too many icky, pat set ups and characters in this for me to persevere with it. I mean, I could feel my sentimental glands being milked right from the first pages. The book is set in a cosy American village that I found so sickly aspirational it repelled me instantly. And descriptions (flashback) of children with faces pressed up against Christmas wi ...more
There is a long history behind the mystery Inspector Gamache has to tackle in this second addition to this series. The same old gang returns for another great ride into this, Three Pines, adventure centered around the Holiday Season. Hot cider, decorations, caroling, and special winter smells are so well described by Louise Penny that you are just enveloped into the whole feel of Christmas magic and the joys of good friends, food and laughter.

I am continually enchanted by the repartee and, laug
3 stars - It was good.

I only recently discovered Louise Penny and am falling in love with her writing style. She has a very eloquent way with words and uses them to create beautiful passages. Her books so far have been pleasant escapes that make you think, rather than being fast paced thrillers (I enjoy both, just clarifying for others considering this one). As a bonus there are two touching segments within this story that dog lovers will enjoy - Penny's fondness for dogs definitely shows in th
Martha Stewart wannabe CC de Poitiers has invaded the tranquility of the picture postcard village of Three Pines, buying up the somewhat creepy mansion in which Inspector Gamache’s last bloody case was brought to a close. Moving in with her henpecked husband and gifted but unloved daughter, CC manages to cast a pall even over the idyllic Christmas Eve service. She’s also shamelessly purloined the ideas of the villagers to publish in her new book as her own. So when CC winds up dead by electrocut ...more
Pretty much, I was bored by the beginning, entertained through the middle, and found the end to be tied-up quickly and hastily and not-really with a whole lot of sense.

This time, though, I sussed the whole thing out pretty quickly, which is always fun for me. I wasn't put off the trail by the many other paths thrown at me. Yay, I'm becoming so clever.

Questions I have:
-Is there always going to be a suspicious rookie (as in, the rookie has suspicions not that the rookie is acting suspiciously) who
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
It's Christmas time in Three Pines. CC de Poitier is a new resident in the village, having moved into the mansion on the hill with her husband and daughter about a year ago. She's published a new Le Bien manual on how to live, and is hoping to branch out with a catalog of products with a New York firm. At the village's curling match on Boxing Day, CC suffers a fatal electrical shock, and Chief Inspector Armand Gamache and his team is called in from Montreal. They discover that a curious sequence ...more
Sue Smith
I really love the easy writing style of Louise Penny - this book was a joy to read. I not only found myself completely wrapped up in the mystery of the murder and the mechanics of the who-dunnit that go along with it, but I found that I really wanted to find this little spot of paradise and rent a room in the B & B and have one of those fantastic breakfasts they were going on about, or have a happy hour with a warm mug of hot buttered rum by that crackling fire. Then be sure to find that won ...more
This second mystery outing involving Chief Inspector Armand Gamache and the Canadian village of Three Pines improves on a solid debut, which actually fell a bit short of expectations for me, especially given all of the glowing advance praise. This time around, we get another interesting murder and another reason to spend time with the varied and interesting people in the small Twin Pines community. In fact, the way that Penny handles characters is very reminiscent to me of Jane Haddam and her Gr ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Suicide? 3 47 Jun 09, 2014 08:23PM  
Billy Williams-isms 3 68 Jan 16, 2013 07:26PM  
Cruisin' thru the...: Sandy's 2012 Cozies Challenge 18 63 Jul 29, 2012 07:31AM  
Questions...Clara, El, Nichol, Lemieux... 3 104 Apr 01, 2012 06:13PM  
CBC Books: January '12 - A Fatal Grace (aka Dead Cold) by Louise Penny 5 77 Jan 10, 2012 12:04PM  
  • And Justice There Is None (Duncan Kincaid & Gemma James, #8)
  • All Mortal Flesh (Rev. Clare Fergusson & Russ Van Alstyne Mysteries, #5)
  • Death of a Cozy Writer (A St. Just Mystery #1)
  • Dressed for Death (Commissario Brunetti, #3)
  • Elegy for Eddie (Maisie Dobbs #9)
  • Blackfly Season
Many of Louise Penny's books are published under different titles by UK/Canada and US publishers.
She lives with her husband, Michael, and a golden retriever named Trudy, in a small village south of Montreal.

Her first Armand Gamache novel, "Still Life" won the New Blood Dagger, Arthur Ellis, Barry, Anthony and Dilys Awards.

* Agatha Award: Best Novel
o 2007 – A Fatal Grace – Winner
o 2008 –
More about Louise Penny...
Still Life (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #1) Bury Your Dead (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #6) The Brutal Telling (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #5) A Rule Against Murder (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #4) A Trick of the Light (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #7)

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

“When someone stabs you it's not your fault that you feel pain.” 232 likes
“I was tired of seeing the Graces always depicted as beautiful young things. I think wisdom comes with age and life and pain. And knowing what matters.” 75 likes
More quotes…