reviews
May 24, 2010
Gag! It got the basics of the Train Man story, but there were so many starbursts and hearts I felt like the book was hot pink even though it was printed in black and white. I did like the moment when Train Man explained that he felt he should walk the girl home, but she said no so he didn’t. And everyone said, Girls just say that to be polite, but you absolutely must insist on walking her home or you won’t have a chance. Unless, of course, she really means it and doesn’t want you to walk her hom
More...
May 20, 2011
my second-to-least favourite version of the story, mainly due to the art (my least favourite is the tv show, which i couldn't finish watching because of acute cringe). the redeeming feature of this redaction is that Hermes (named Mai here, which is - weird) comes across like a real, normal girl, probably because the manga is by a woman - but it's a shame that to achieve this, the otaku pov that never sees her as less than idealised is diluted. good cultural notes at the back.
Dec 17, 2009
Train Man (Densha Otoko) is a Japanese-based story of an “otaku,” which closely translates to an anime/video game fanboy, who finally found true love while rescuing a girl in the train. Lacking the know-how of love and matters of the heart, Ikumi Saiki, the male lead, must depend on his friends from an Internet forum for advices and dating suggestions! The thing I love about this book is that it clearly shows how love can bring out the best in people. After finding love, Ikumi gradually came ou
More...
Jan 06, 2012
This is a book I would *never* have picked up if it weren't for my teen book group. The story is sticky sweet romance (not my cup of tea), but I did love the explanation of the origin of the story that the author included at the end. We had a really great discussion of how the story (both the real story and the media sensation of it) affected Japanese culture. I recommend it as a book group selection.
Mar 20, 2009
I loved the movie, and figured I had to read the shojo manga in private. I was right. Sniffled my way through it. ^^; It's heartwarming, fluffy, made me giggle, and a total "awww! /gush" fest. /happy place
Jul 20, 2010
In a RARE moment for me, I will say the book is good but the movie is SO MUCH BETTER! The book is cute and rather trivial, but the movie is touching and deep and I sobbed through it. See the movie.
Nov 01, 2007
Ah, the heartwarming story of how the Internet helped a geek win the heart of a beautiful girl. Based on a series of anonymous posts on a Japanese message board, this possibly true tale has many incarnations, including a movie, a TV series, and several graphic novels. This version, a light and fun read geared toward females, is briskly paced with appealing character designs and dialogue. The English translation is clearly intended for those who are already familiar with Internet culture and cont
More...
Sep 12, 2007
Geek boy fantasy about snagging hot girl. Meh.
Not a bad manga, decent art and so on, but the story is so incredibly old I couldn't bring myself to be very interested. At least this geek boy undergoes the requisite makeover first, instead of just inexplicably gaining the girl's interest by being gormless and getting regularly beaten up by her soon-to-be-dumped boyfriend.
If anyone can rec me a story about a geek girl who snags a hot boy without having to undergo a makeover More...
Not a bad manga, decent art and so on, but the story is so incredibly old I couldn't bring myself to be very interested. At least this geek boy undergoes the requisite makeover first, instead of just inexplicably gaining the girl's interest by being gormless and getting regularly beaten up by her soon-to-be-dumped boyfriend.
If anyone can rec me a story about a geek girl who snags a hot boy without having to undergo a makeover More...
Nov 30, 2007
I'm recommending it for 7th and up because it's appropriate but the romance aspect may not appeal to that age. I thought this was a sweet story of first love with lots a appeal for both boys and girls. Good entre into manga for the uninitiated.
Feb 10, 2008
I love this book. Its probably the best manga I've read so far. It is about how a nerd finds a girlfriend and he uses a chatroom 2 help him out.
Jan 27, 2012
Jan 30, 2012
Jan 24, 2012
Jan 19, 2012
Jan 17, 2012
Jan 06, 2012
Dec 18, 2011
Dec 10, 2011
Dec 09, 2011
Dec 07, 2011
Dec 02, 2011
Nov 24, 2011
Nov 21, 2011
Nov 17, 2011
Sep 24, 2011
Sep 23, 2011
Sep 07, 2011
Aug 02, 2011
Jul 25, 2011
