Jack Maggs

Jack Maggs

3.64 of 5 stars 3.64  ·  rating details  ·  1,750 ratings  ·  134 reviews
The Booker Prize-winning author of Oscar and Lucinda returns to the nineteenth century in an utterly captivating mystery. The year is 1837 and a stranger is prowling London. He is Jack Maggs, an illegal returnee from the prison island of Australia. He has the demeanor of a savage and the skills of a hardened criminal, and he is risking his life on seeking vengeance and rec...more
Paperback, 357 pages
Published February 22nd 1999 by Vintage (first published 1997)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
The Book Thief by Markus ZusakCloudstreet by Tim WintonThe Thorn Birds by Colleen McCulloughTomorrow, When the War Began by John MarsdenA Town Like Alice by Nevil Shute
Best Modern Australian Literature
39th out of 239 books — 287 voters
The Book Thief by Markus ZusakJasper Jones by Craig SilveyTomorrow, When the War Began by John MarsdenPicnic at Hanging Rock by Joan LindsayWhisky Charlie Foxtrot by Annabel Smith
Aussie Authors
115th out of 115 books — 15 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
mark monday
a tidy, pleasant entry within the wildly popular Victorian Mystery subgenre. or in this case, the slightly pre-Victorian Mystery subgenre. what is it about this era that holds so much fascination for readers? the most obvious guess is that the fans of these fictions always know that they will be enjoying luxurious expanses of gothic description, built on a foundation of cosseted repression meets wondrous discovery. Jack Maggs does not fail to satisfy on that level - and it is about a tenth the s...more
Brian
A post-colonial reworking of the story of Great Expectations, Jack Maggs is the tale of a transported convict who returns secretly to England to see Henry Phipps, the adopted son whose education he has financed. Unlike Great Expectations however, the convict's story is the central narrative of the book, rather than that of the young gentleman he has secretly fostered. Jack Maggs has known very little kindness in his life and this does not change when he finally meets up with Henry. He returns to...more
Bettie
Dedication: For Alison

Author's Note: The author willingly admits to having once or twice stretched history to suit his own historical ends.

Front quote ia a lengthy extract from Du magnétisme animal (1820) by Armand Marie Jacques de Chastenet, Marquis de Puységur.

Opening: It was a Saturday night when the man with the red waistcoat arrived in London. It was, to be precise, six of the clock on the fifteenth of April in the year of 1837 that those hooded eyes looked out the window of the Dover coach...more
Shawn Lahr
What a fun book to read! I was thoroughly caught up in the story and in the weirdness of Carey's Dickensian characters. I was especially delighted to dislike Percy Buckle at first, then to like him and think him nobel for saving poor Mercy Larkin--I thought he would be a kind of traditional Dickensian minor hero--then to despise him even more for learning what he does to her, and finally to laugh at him as he encounters his injured front door. And yet, somehow, I feel pity for him as Mercy sees...more
Amelia, the pragmatic idealist


To be fair, this is probably a really good book, and if I ever read it again, I might just like it.

Trouble is, I read this book when I was 12. Ummm....that was a mistake on my part (and my parents, haha), but still--quite disturbing! And pretty sure I won't be reading it again for awhile, just because every time I think of it, I always remember "that scene." :[
Anyway, the moral of the story is--parents, check what your kids are reading! And kids, I don't care how mature you are, some stuff just...more
Subiaco Library
The story goes that Peter Carey read Charles Dickens‘s Great Expectations and felt that the convict character Magwitch, as an example of an early Australian, was treated badly. Carey also thought that perhaps Dickens‘s had known a person like Magwitch and had unfairly exploited his misfortune. An inspired Carey set out to write Jack Maggs. Maggs is a Magwitch type character and there is also Tobias Oates, writer and practitioner of magnetism (hypnotism), who is an analogue of Dickens.

At first I...more
Kenneth Dumas
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Barb
I have not read Dickens...*gasps noted*...it's true. So, I cannot make any clever comparisons between the two authors' works or make any comment on Carey's depiction of the obsessive author in this novel being like Dickens, I really don't know enough to say.

What I do know is that I loved this book. The writing is wonderful, the characters are complex and the story is bittersweet, in other words the perfect recipe for a great novel.

It reminded me of 'Fingersmith' by Sarah Waters which is also s...more
Tony
Carey, Peter. JACK MAGGS. (1997; US 1998). ****. Carey, the Booker Prize-winning author of “Oscar and Lucinda,” has managed to write a novel reminiscent of the style of Dickens, set in the early 19th Century. It is the story of Jack Maggs, a criminal transported to Australia for his crimes of thievery, who returns to England, at the risk of being discovered and re-transported, to find his adopted son. Over the years, he has been supporting a young boy who was kind to him on the day before he was...more
Faith
The book I have to read for my English entrance examination... Took a while to get into this book, and get what it was about. After 50 pages I was still totally uninspired... But then it got better. When the background of the characters was explained it was easier to be interested in them and get what the book was about.

What is it about then? The book is set in London of 1839. Jack Maggs is a criminal who has been deported to Australia, but has now returned to the city of his youth to make up w...more
Michael Shilling
Apr 13, 2008 Michael Shilling rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: those who enjoy Victorian London as the deepest expression of slow-cured sorrow
Interesting to read a book about Victorians that is completely driven by dialogue, as opposed to the thick soup of expository language that is sometimes beautiful -- such as in Bleak House -- and sometimes awful -- such as in Bleak House. And on that note, Carey doesn't write like Dickens at all; with Carey, you don't the intense highs and lugubrious lows, but you do get to start a book you may actually finish.


Emily
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
James Barker
'Great Expectations' is one of my favourite of the classics, and ever since reading 'The true History of the Kelly Gang' I believe Peter Carey is unsurpassable at his best. So, this post-colonial re-telling of Pip's benefactor, the glorious Magwitch, should have been right up my street.

Well, it was and it wasn't.

Carey manages to get into the heart (and bowels) of Victorian London and his descriptive skill is as sharp as ever. The cast of supporting characters are appropriately Dickensian but ha...more
Phil
I really liked this book as I was reading it, and I found I liked it even more after we began discussing it in class today. Carey's style is Dickens-esque, but in such a way that draws our attention to the ackwardness of approaching Dickens as a modern reader--many of the slang terms his audience would have known are foreign to us today, many of the place names meaningless in post-blitz London (even more so for those unfamiliar with either contemporary or historical London), and his narrative pa...more
Julie
I loved this book! This is the story based on Dickens' Great Expectations, but told through the eyes of Jack Maggs (Magwitch in GE). Maggs meets young orphan Henry Phipps (Pip in GE) as a convict on his way to sentencing in Australia. Henry shows him kindness by giving him some food. Maggs remembers this single act of compassion and after serving his prison sentence and making a large fortune in Australia, sends a large monthly allowance which provides Henry with a very idle and rich life. Maggs...more
Joyce Huff
Jack Maggs is a richly intertextual work that alludes to - but does not directly retell - Great Expectations. This means that it can work as a stand-alone text. It also includes metatextual reflection on the process of writing, with Maggs and Oates both constructing competing versions of Maggs's life. This raises questions regarding how textual traces of the past survive to become history and who controls the process of history-making, questions which relate to the themes of colonization, gender...more
Becky
Although I guess it strictly falls into the dreaded "Historical Fiction" bracket, Jack Maggs has enough of a story that it doesn't really matter that much. Jack arrives from a ship, and quickly becomes involved with the lives of the household next door to the first house he visited. Instantly, their lives become more complex, as Jack's story is revealed and the unintended become seriously involved in his apparent downfall.

The characters are all pretty straightforward, and it's a bit of a slow s...more
Helen Kitson
The year is 1837. The place, London. Enter the brooding presence of Jack Maggs, recently arrived from New South Wales. He becomes a footman in order to be close to the house of Henry Phipps, and through his job he comes into contact with Tobias Oates, author and amateur hypnotist, who 'steals' his secrets. The novel features a cast of memorable characters, including Jack's employer, Percy Buckle, a former grocer who suddenly finds himself a wealthy 'gentleman', and Jack's foster mother who prepa...more
Leif Schenstead-Harris
Aug 08, 2009 Leif Schenstead-Harris rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: People who sort of like Dickens but feel weird about him too.
Not bad. Carey has his Victoriana fun while also poking at Dickens and the well-meaning but ultimately selfish middleclass white Victorian male. So I got to play "enjoy the drama" while keeping track of "how we have changed as readers in a society which values x". Or something like that. I'm not sure this would be enjoyed by someone without much knowledge of Great Expectations, Dickens, or Victorian society in general. I found GE assimilated surprisingly well, actually, and how Carey conjured up...more
Ruth Peden
Peter Carey is a booker prize winner and best selling author. Jack Maggs is a variation on Great |Expectations, in which dicken's tale is told from the viewpoint of an australian convict.
Jack Maggs was raised and deported as a criminal, and has returned from Australia in secret and at great risk. What does he want after all these years, and why is he so interested in the comings and goings at a plush town house in great queen street?

The story was ok however the use of occasional swear language,...more
Alec
Splendidly written, fine characters and so on, with a powerful greyness of morality which contributes to a great deal of tension around the ending. All the things one expects from Peter Carey, who's growing on me with every book I read (despite some really dull titles).

The downsides? A rushed ending, too much reliance on Dickensian tropes and jokes (it's basically Great Expectations with Magwitch at the centre instead of the edges), and a vague feeling of, well, just not being anything beyond a...more
Caroline Herbert
If you have any fondness for Dickens' Great Expectations (and even if you don't), you will love Jack Maggs. Very loosely based on the Dickens classic, this book tells the story from the convict's point of view. Carey starts from that interesting angle and immediately immerses us in a richly realized world. The writing style is somewhat similar to Dickens in that he illuminates the inner life of characters that at first seem minor, but have big roles to play. We move among many different narrativ...more
Esther
2.5* I can't decide whether the tie to "Great Expectations" helps this book or not. If I could have read it without thinking about how it was different from or similar to the Dickens plot, I think I would have enjoyed it more. Not to say that I didn't enjoy it. Carey is an excellent writer, and this book, of the ones I've read, was the easiest to read by far. My advice to those wanting to read this - think of it as a study of Jack Maggs as a character, rather than reading with the shades of "Gre...more
James
Have you ever read Great Expectations? The main character Philip Pirrip ,known as Pip, runs into a convict in the opening scene of the novel. This is Abel Magwitch who meets young Pip at a graveyard. Magwitch tricks the seven-year-old boy into believing that he has an accomplice who is a terrible young man who would tear out and eat Pip's heart and liver if Pip did not help them. Pip, terrified, steals a pork pie, brandy and a file from his house and brings them to Magwitch the next morning. The...more
Kristina A
I will say this for Peter Carey: the man can write an ending. I wrote extensively in my review for Oscar and Lucinda about the stunning achievement of the ending of that book. While the ending for this one is not as disturbing, it is nevertheless very well done. Carey brilliantly brings together the strands of the story -- some of which you didn't even realize were building to anything! -- in order to craft something truly haunting and at the same time satisfying.

Now, this novel was no Oscar and...more
Cathay
I picked up this book for 50 pence from a London public library (in Westminster). The cover was disturbing enough that I set the book back down for a moment or two, but reconsidered since a) I needed a book to read and b)the story was intriguing. I also thought it appropriate since it took place in London, and was based upon a true story.

This was a very interesting story about Mr. Maggs, who had been exiled to Australia due to his crimes. He returned to London and the adventure begins...
Paul
Carey is a great storyteller with an impressive command of language and history. I was already convinced of this by his True History of the Kelly Gang. In Jack Maggs he offers a retelling of Great Expectations from the perspectives of the convict/benefactor and those around him, with some significant liberties taken. Carey evokes the fearful social conditions of London in 1837 as thoroughly as Dickens did, and adds to our appreciation of the setting by introducing Dickens himself as a not-terrib...more
Ann Michael
Jun 14, 2010 Ann Michael rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Dickens readers
Recommended to Ann by: Alice!
I love Dickens, and Carey has sampled freely from Dickens' work and his life (the character of Tobias Oates contains parallels to the life of Charles Dickens, for example; and Maggs is clearly based on Magwitch of Great Expectations). But Carey's novel is original nonetheless, and written with a lively, period-flavored but not over-the-top style. The mysteries and coincidences and twists are enough to pull the reader along into the tale, and the flawed characters are compelling.
Timothy Moriarty
I quit Maggs about halfway through. I wanted to like it; it's got a Dickens-like ring to it, though leaner language, much more narrow scope, very slight attempt at humor or warmth....hell, I tried not to compare it to Dickens, but whether I succeeded or not is an open question. I just know I grew bored, then actively irritated. No characters to latch onto, everyone's motives very murky with no light in sight - just not much life to it and very little interesting detail of the period, unless you...more
Penny
Jack Carey is a booker prize winner and best selling author, Jack Maggs is a variation on Great expectations, in which Dicken's tale is told from the viewpoint of the Australian Convict.

Jack Maggs was raised and deported as a criminal, and has returned from Australia in secret and at risk. What does he want all these years, and why is he so interested in the comings and goings at a plush town house in Great Queen Street?

The story was ok however I always find the use of occasional swear language,...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Jack Maggs
Jack Maggs
Jack Maggs (Hardcover)
Jack Maggs  (Paperback)
Jack Maggs (Paperback)

22595
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.

Peter Carey was born in Australia in 1943.

He was educated at the local state school until the age of eleven and then became a boarder at Geelong Grammar School. He was a student there between 1954 and 1960 — after Rupert Murdoch had graduated and before Prince Charles arriv...more
More about Peter Carey...
Oscar and Lucinda True History of the Kelly Gang Parrot and Olivier in America Theft: A Love Story My Life as a Fake

Share This Book

Your website