Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “By Design (Medieval #2)” as Want to Read:
By Design (Medieval #2)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

By Design (Medieval Series (Chronological order) #2)

3.86 of 5 stars 3.86  ·  rating details  ·  733 ratings  ·  32 reviews
Bound by honor...

The moment Rhys saw the stunning young woman selling her exquisitely crafted pottery in the marketplace, he was captivated. But the wealthy freemason would never have guessed that just a few days later, a misunderstanding would land Joan in the town stocks and he would become her unlikely savior. After the grueling ordeal, Rhys tenderly cares for Joan's br
Paperback, 400 pages
Published June 1st 2004 by Bantam (first published 2001)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about By Design, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about By Design

The Bride by Julie GarwoodA Kingdom of Dreams by Judith McNaughtThe Secret by Julie GarwoodRansom by Julie GarwoodHonor's Splendour by Julie Garwood
Best Medieval Romance Novels
73rd out of 404 books — 677 voters
Romancing Mister Bridgerton by Julia QuinnTwilight by Stephenie MeyerScandal in Spring by Lisa KleypasThe Hunger Games by Suzanne CollinsTo Sir Phillip, With Love by Julia Quinn
Best Romantic Beta Heroes
75th out of 453 books — 402 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,365)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
I'm feeling ashamed that I do not like this because every single one of my GR friends has rated it with 4 stars or above. I have tried and tried but I cannot bring myself to like the heroine at all. And the only thing that's progressed in the first 125 pages of the book, is the politics. Other than that it's a repetition of push-and-shove-back: they're attracted instantly, he pushes her to accept it, she shoves him back. And again. And again. And again....

But perhaps I'm just in a bad mood, beca
Read this one a few years ago and loved it. Joan and Rhys were fantastic together -- strong, independent, passionate, and stubborn. I liked the Medieval setting, with the stone masonry (Freemasons) and the potters guild, the craft fairs, etc. Glad to see Joan and Rhys get their HEA, but it didnt come easily, so I closed the book with a very satisfied sigh. After all the drama and injustice, they deserved it!

Flaws? Probably. Just can't recall them.
By Design will be enjoyed so much more if you have read By Possession first. MH is a masterful storyteller and By Design is a poignant story, often sad due to the struggles of the time period but beautifully touching and heartwarming. MH descriptions of the time and place where Joan and Rhys find each other is mesmerizing at times. MH writes with an intelligence and warmth of characters that is true escapism.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Jes Lyons
This is the first romance novel I have ever read, and I must say, the historical relevance was rather over my head when I was twelve and reading this kind of book for the first time alone and hiding it from my family.

That aside, this is a tremendously written novel with a very full plot. I haven't read it in quite some time, but I can say that the hero and heroine Rhys and Joan have stayed with me through every other romance I have read and I will always compare other's to this book.

If you like
Nancy Crayton
I love reading books that surprise me. This is one of those. I love the way that Madeline Hunter can make the period come alive and create characters that captivate me. If you are not familiar with the regency period before Edward III comes of age to take the throne from his mother, Queen Isabella and Roger Mortimer, this is a chance to become better acquainted in a wonderful story involving Rhys, a Master Builder and Joan, a woman driven to find justice for herself and her younger brother. Wond ...more
I was surprised that a book of Madeline Hunter's, an author I really enjoy, was such a miss for me. Maybe it's that I don't particularly care for medievals. Maybe it was that the supporting characters (the main characters, not so much) were acting in historically accurate ways, and I didn't enjoy it. Maybe it's that the main characters did NOT act in historically accurate ways, and that irritated me. I don't know.

In short, Rhys was a male Mary Sue, and Joan hit the TSTL mark with a resounding T
This is the second book in Madeline Hunter's Medieval series, and while I preferred By Possession, I still enjoyed By Design immensely. Joan and Rhys were a fantastic pairing, both clever and brave individuals, and the secondary characters were well realized, too. I was very happy to see Addis and Moira carry over from the first book. As a matter of fact the one thing I actually liked a bit over the first book was that, though the possessiveness was still there, Rhys wasn't generally as over the ...more
Regan Walker
Wonderful Medieval Love Story with Masonry and Pottery Making Superbly Incorporated

Set in 14th century England, when a young King Edward reigned, but was still controlled by his mother, Queen Isabella and her lover, Mortimer, Earl of March, this is book 2 in Hunter’s wonderful medieval series of historical romances (see list below), though it can be read as a “stand alone.”

It is the story of a freemason, Rhys, who longs to create beautiful cathedrals and buildings but is forced to appear to act
I enjoyed the 2nd installment to Madeline Hunter's "Medeviel series". This book featured Rhys and Joan, and I really enjoyed the journey we went on with these two. I have loved Rhys since we had first been introduced to him in By Possession. He proved to be even more beautiful inside and out in his own book. I loved the man that he was, demanding, possessive, protective, and determined, but accepting at the same time, allowing the woman he wanted to do what she felt needed doing regardless of ho ...more
BJ Rose
Joan has escaped the horrors in her past, only to indenture herself for 5 years to a London tiler. Her drunken master, however, was responsible for putting her in the stocks, since she was caught selling the defective tiles he sent with her to the market. Rhys protects her from the hecklers & rotten-fruit throwers, and ends up buying her indenture. He knows that he wants more from her than master & servant, but he also senses her fear of physical involvement. So altho he keeps her papers ...more
By Design - Ok
Hunter, Madeline

The moment Rhys saw the stunning young woman selling her exquisitely crafted pottery in the marketplace, he was captivated. But the wealthy freemason would never have guessed that just a few days later, a misunderstanding would land Joan in the town stocks and he would become her unlikely savior. After the grueling ordeal, Rhys tenderly cares for Joan's bruised body - and her bruised pride. Yet he longs to do much more ... to satisfy the fire that sparks between the
Gave up on this one when the psycho Guy Leighton comes into the story. It was already a grim story before that, but reading about a psychopath who happens to be obsessed with the heroine and keeps her in his clutches by threatening to kill her brother (he's already slaughtered her father in cold blood) is just not my idea of a romantic read.

Madeline Hunter depicts 14th century England in her medieval novels as a time of bloodshed and extreme lawlessness, where only might makes right. Her main ch
This was a great read. It kept me engaged the entire book. At first as usual, MH's prose comes off as stilted and hard to follow, but eventually she gets into the story and it all starts flowing. I love Rhys from the first, but have to warm up to Joan. Once I got her backstory, I understood her better and was able to come to terms with how she is. I thought we were going to get our own medivial "Ghost" scene, you know the one where Demi Moore and Patrick Swayze get busy on the clay wheel, but it ...more
This is a very good book! I am usually wary of books taking place before 1800 or so, as they seem to fudge history far more than necessary. This book is an exception. While there are, of course, fudges, nothing stood out to me as being so completely anachronistic that it ruined the book for me (like one 11th century book I read where apparently they were familiar with penicillin and germ theory). In addition, the characters in this book are well developed, sympathetic, and the reader feels a rea ...more
Danette Steward
Good read, but don't like a book with a lot of stress and villeins.
Madeline Hunter never stops amazed me with her intricate story....

I liked the first book in the series but the second, set in the period where Isabelle and Roger Mortimer are in charge, was more interesting and powerful. I warmed to Rhys and his gentle and caring ways and his ability to back off and not push Joan for her secrets and fears. The narrative around the creativity of the two main characters in pursuing a craft was also a nice aspect of the book.
not bad. i have read far better ones though. i cant seem to fix what year the book was set though, but it doesn't seem like the regency era. the hero and heroine were sweet. they had an understanding too early though. i guess i can read it again if i nam bored and have nothing to do. i much more enjoyed the tit-bit from the other book (the seducer) that wis at the end.
Kerry Kenney
If I was in a beach house, and this series was on the shelf and I was in the mood for a romance this book would be okay, it held my attention enough so that I finished it.

I wouldn't spend money on it. This had the same "you belong to me" thing that characterized her other novels in the series and that is a turn off for me.
The best part of this book was how the author weaved in so many details and interesting facts around masonry and pottery in the middle ages. I always appreciate when an author does his or her research AND can still spin a good tale.
Read this a long time ago and never wrote down a rating, but if I recall correctly, I didn't like it. So many good ratings though, think I need to reread it.
Another excellent Medieval by Hunter! I'm dismayed that I only bought three books out of this six-book series. Can't wait to get the rest.
Madeline Hunter draws you into her story with intriguing characters. I discover her books, by winning one from her monthly contest.
Yet another lovely romance by Hunter. I loved the characters, loved the story, loved the conflict and the arcs.
Exclnt prose, soulful, rich. Mason Rhys & dispossd Lady Joan r amzg. Her yngr brthr Marcus...
still one of my favs... i often reread this one
Rhys and Joan -sculptor and tiler.
Lynn Calvin
headless woman cover
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 45 46 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Sinopsis en Español // Synopsis in Spanish 1 1 Mar 18, 2015 11:15AM  
  • Hidden Honor
  • Uncommon Vows
  • The Lily And The Sword (Medieval, #1)
  • My Beloved
  • A Bed of Spices
  • Saxon Bride
  • A Woman Scorned (Lorimer Family & Clan Cameron #2)
  • For My Lady's Heart (Medieval Hearts, #1)
  • The Warlord (Montagues, #1)
  • The Shattered Rose (Dark Champion, #3)
  • The Price Of Desire
  • Untamed (Medieval, #1)
  • Surrender to an Irish Warrior (MacEgan Brothers #6)
  • Candle in the Window (Medieval, #1)
  • Libby's London Merchant (Nesbitt, #1)
  • The Lover
Madeline Hunter is a nationally bestselling author of historical romances who lives in Pennsylvania with her husband and two sons. Her books have won two RITA awards and seven nominations, and have had three starred reviews in Publishers Weekly. In a parallel existence to the one she enjoys as a novelist, Madeline has a Ph.D. in art history and teaches at an East Coast university.
More about Madeline Hunter...

Other Books in the Series

Medieval Series (Chronological order) (6 books)
  • By Possession (Medieval #1)
  • Stealing Heaven (Medieval #3)
  • By Arrangement (Medieval, #4)
  • The Protector (Medieval #5)
  • Lord of a Thousand Nights (Medieval #6)
Ravishing in Red (The Rarest Blooms, #1) Dangerous in Diamonds (The Rarest Blooms, #4) Provocative in Pearls (The Rarest Blooms #2) Sinful in Satin (The Rarest Blooms #3) The Rules Of Seduction (Rothwell Brothers, #1)

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »