Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie” as Want to Read:
I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie

by
3.98 of 5 stars 3.98  ·  rating details  ·  1,059 ratings  ·  142 reviews
I know an old lady who swallowed a pie, a Thanksgiving pie, which was really too dry.

And with that the feast begins! After the pie the old lady swallows a whole squash, all of the salad, and the entire turkey! As Mother and Father watch in shock, the two children are delighted to see the old lady growing fatter and fatter. And, in the end, the old lady makes a surprising...more
Paperback, 32 pages
Published September 16th 2002 by Puffin (first published October 1st 1997)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,400)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Ginna
Jul 13, 2013 Ginna added it
Shelves: fall
This is a great book to talk about good manners and consideration for others when sharing food.
I would do an activity in small groups as follows:

I will have cutouts of food representing the food on the story and set up a "Thanks Giving" table for each small group.
Then, I will ask the children to go ahead and serve the plates and have "pretending" dinner with their peers
After that, I will have a conversation about what they just did, how they handle the situation, if they took turns, if they ate...more
Heidi
Though I'm not a fan of the scribble illustrations, they were easily overlooked by the humor of what this old lady would eat next. A good rendition of the swallowed a fly song, though I think I almost like this one better because of the food/Thanksgiving humor. The repetition is always good for a storytime, and this twist is enough to keep the interest of most children. Though it goes along with my idea of a Dessert theme, the overall presence of Thanksgiving in this book makes it seem like it m...more
Leah Puckett
I know an old lady who swallowed a pie is a cute thanksgiving themed book. It has repetition and rhyming words. It also had a consistent pattern. The longer the list of things the old lady ate the bigger the old lady got. The illustration does add to the funny story line.




Learning Experience:
For this book I will have an old lady puppet, it will have an opening to insert food as the story goes along. This book will be read in small groups and each child will be handed an object from the story to a...more
Aleece
I spin on the classic "I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly" however this was not like that book at all. There are much better spin offs out there like "There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Clover" and "There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Bat." I found that I really did not like the illustrations either, they were sort of disturbing and the Old Lady ate all of the Thanksgiving food and the other adults seem angry at her for eating all of the food. It just didn't work for me.
Camille Ryckman
Brief summary An Old Lady who swallows up common thanksgiving foods and gets so big she is used as a balloon in the Macy Day Parade
Annotation A cute adaptation of I know an old lady who swallowed a fly. This book has great illustrations and allows the reader to follow the story and how much the Old Lady eats with how big she keeps appearing on the page.
Age appropriateness This would be a good book for 4-7 year olds
Connection to six early literacy skills This is great for narrative skills. Becaus...more
Teddie Trombley
This book is a spin off of the original book I Know An Old Lady Who Swallowed A Fly and if you have never read these books you should because they are really funny. The book I Know An Old Lady Who Swallowed A Pie is the Thanksgiving version and it is about an old lady who keeps swallowing things and the reason why she has to keep swallowing things is so she can help the item that she swallowed before it so she wont die. For example in this spin off she firsts swallows a whole pie but it is so dr...more
Cassie
Many picture books exists which follow the cumulative pattern of "There's was an old lady who swallowed a fly", but this one takes the cake... errr, Pie. Not only are the illustrations eye catching, thanks to Skippyjon Jones creator Judith Schachner, but the new twist on the old song is fun and the ending is a pleasant surprise.
Samantha
Dec 16, 2011 Samantha rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: People who hate "I Know An Old Lady Who Swallowed A Fly"
Recommended to Samantha by: Alexandria
*sigh* Finally! A book about an old lady swallowing things that actually makes a little sense. Except for that pot...I still don't understand that one AT ALL. But, (view spoiler)

So much better than that stupid fly version. This one has to be the best so far. =)
Brianna Hawkins
this a baby book but its really funny and it keeps going on and on of what she eats and what she does check it out!!!!!!

smmary by Brianna Hawkins
book by Alison Jackson!
Courtney
Jackson, A. I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie. NY: Scholastic, Inc. (1997).

This story is a variation of "I Know an Old Lady who Swallowed a Fly", but has a Thanksgiving setting that would be helpful to have around for that holiday. Like its predecessor, this book is very silly and the old woman swallows a pie and other objects related to Thanksgiving.

This book is very silly and the reading level I would say is first or second grade, but younger students would love to have it read to them. T...more
Megan
This a spin off of the classic "I Know and Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly" but with a Thanksgiving twist. The kids talk about an Old Lady that swallowed the Thanksgiving Pie, but it was dry so she has some cider and then has a roll and follows that with some Squash. The whole book is of her eating, and always lists the things that she ate on the previous pages. The illustrations in this book are fun, and are targeted towards a younger audience. The book is written for early elementary age students...more
Kathryn Cunningham
Who doesn't love having Grandma over to their house for a lovely Thanksgiving feast and get together? And who doesn't love watching Grandma stuff so much food down her gullet that she blows up to the size of a Macy's Day Parade balloon? And who doesn't love singing about the whole episode to a beloved children's song melody? Watch Grandma as she gobbles down pie, cider, rolls, squash, and don't forget the turkey! You'll be having so much fun watching her feast that you won't mind that she didn't...more
Sasha Thompson
I loved this children's story. I thought it was so funny and I think that kids would laugh at this book because the old lady eats absolutely everything. The drawings in this book are also super funny because it shows the lady getting bigger and bigger as she eats more and more. I thought this was a fun read.
Rashanda Ravenel
I have definitely had the experience of feeling huge and uncomfortable after eating too much food on Thanksgiving. This would be a great story to read with children before discussing different holidays people celebrate. Students can journal about their experiences and share with the class.
Ashley Field
I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie is a spin-off of the Old lady who swallowed a fly. This is a Thanksgiving version of the book and the woman in the book indulges herself in all of the classic and traditional thanksgiving entrees and sides and drinks. Theres in no real moral of the story other than maybe not eating as much as the woman in the story, or you may end up as a balloon on a thanksgiving day float. The story is a fun and silly story that could be used in a text set for thanksgivin...more
Tiffany
This is a spin off of the book There Was An Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly. This story is a Thanksgiving story. Everything she eats is something we would see at our own Thanksgiving tables. Since there is another book, it might be interesting to compare the two and see what is the same and what is not the same. The story builds upon itself, meaning each page adds an new line of the story, but you keep repeating the other stuff too. It wold be a great activity to have props and have the students re...more
Ashley Whiteley
This is a crazy and funny book! I really loved it. The rhyming makes the book fun to read. The pictures are unique. A good book to read around thanksgiving time. It is sure to make everyone laugh!!
Dolly
Nov 22, 2011 Dolly rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: parents reading with their children
This is a fun take on the classic children's song, There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly, but this time with a Thanksgiving theme. We've read several books with this kind of theme, and our girls find them to be very humorous. The illustrations are entertaining and the ending is silly. The rhyming narrative and cumulative build make this a great story to read aloud and we really enjoyed reading it together.
Beckie Coldiron
This fun book is based off the popular, " I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie "; however, in this book the lady consumes lots and lots of popular Thanksgiving foods. I think it'd be fun to act this book out around Thanksgiving, except maybe using smaller portions. :) You could also use the writing prompt, " I know an old lady who...." or you could have students compare this story with, " I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly". Then, students could work as a large group, small group or indepe...more
Lana Clifton
The old lady who swallows something meets Thanksgiving dinner. This is a nice seasonal take and follows this hungry lady's feast in stuffing herself silly at the dinner table. The story concludes her blowing up to be a blimp on parade. This book has a repeating sentence structure, sequencing rhyming words that roll off your tongue. I read this book aloud to a group of first graders who appreciated the humor of this book. The word "fat" came up, and we soon found ourselves in a discussion about d...more
Dena (Batch of Books)
Be prepared to laugh this Thanksgiving! I Know and Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie is a hilarious romping good time.

A Thanksgiving twist on the old song, I Know an Old Woman That Swallowed a Fly, this picture book will be sure to please! The old woman stuffs more and more ridiculous things down her throat as she grows larger and larger.

The writing and illustrations are perfect together and combine to make one quirky and hilarious book.

More reviews on my blog: Books for Kids
Audeena
Genre: Traditional/Fantasy
Copyright Date: 1997

I liked the traditional version "There was an old lady who swallowed a fly". So I decided to read this at Thanksgiving time to my preschoolers because it talked about a Thanksgiving Pie. The only part that I didn't like is the part in the book that says "perhaps she'll die". I opted to omit that verse from my reading. I was afraid that would be what the students would focus on and not that she was swallowing Thanksgiving dinner! Other than that I thi...more
Cheryl
Good Thanksgiving book
Aggie
It's cool I guess i like the ending :)
Ina
This is one of my favorite versions of "I Know an Old Lady..." as well as one of my favorite Thanksgiving books. The illustrations are wonderful, of this lovely lady, who eats everything in sight and grows bigger with every page turn. The book is a great read aloud, with rhythm and rhyme and just the right amount of repetition. The kids all noticed her changing figure, and looked forward to each page turn, commenting on how big she was getting and speculating about what she might be eating next....more
Alyssa
Genre: Picture book

Reading Level: Early, ages 4-9
Topics & Themes:Thanksgiving
Curricular Use: Read aloud/Independent reading/shared reading you could make an activity out of this.

Literary Elements:rhyming, repetition.

Illustrations: The pictures correlate with the text. The pictures are vibrant and colorful. Overall, excellent. This book is an excellent book to use during Thanksgiving time. It teaches the basics of Thanksgiving and what it is really all about.
Robyn
I grew up singing that old song "I know an old lady who swallowed a fly" but when I thought about using it for a story time, I realized just how disturbing it really was. This adaptation of the song is focused on an "old lady" who swallows a PIE baked for Thanksgiving. It becomes a great rhyming/sung story of Thanksgiving overindulgence...however, at the end she does NOT die! This was a hit every holiday when I would read it to preschoolers. Cute illustrations and fun rhyming story.
Erin
This has been a Thanksgiving favorite for our son for the past two years. This retelling of the old lady who swallowed a fly features Thanksgiving items instead (a roll, squash, an entire turkey). The illustrations are a lot of fun, with the old lady ballooning out as she consumes more and more things, and the family reacting as you'd expect them to. I do wish the author had done away with the "perhaps she'll die" line because it's quite creepy to hear your toddler saying that.
Dawn
I have never had my kids give a book a negative review until tonight after we finished this one to Jordan. She said she did not like this book because the illustrater made the legs of one of the characters look like scribble and the author kept saying that the lady was going to die.
As for me, I was not very impressed. The last page was kind of a let down.
However, we did like the other book about the old lady that swallowed a bat which she read last year.
Christiana Tarpley
wow- this lady ate a lot of food!!

This book is great for the Thanksgiving season. The lady eats so much food she feels as if she could die. (great text-self connection- I know I've felt that feeling!) Great book to teach sequencing- the lady ate one thing after the next to go with the previous item ate. This is also a cause and effect book because for example she kept eating another item in order for it to go with another item and the process continued.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 46 47 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • 10 Fat Turkeys
  • 'Twas The Night Before Thanksgiving (Bookshelf)
  • Whopper Cake
  • There Was An Old Lady Who Swallowed Some Leaves!
  • Thanks for Thanksgiving
  • If You're A Monster And You Know It
  • One Is a Feast for Mouse: A Thanksgiving Tale (Mouse (Holiday House))
  • Goodnight Goon: A Petrifying Parody
  • An Old-Fashioned Thanksgiving
  • To Market, To Market
  • My Little Sister Ate One Hare
  • Plump And Perky Turkey, A
  • A Turkey for Thanksgiving
  • Pumpkin Trouble
  • The Ugly Pumpkin
  • The Lady with the Alligator Purse
  • The Gingerbread Boy
  • Mrs. McNosh Hangs Up Her Wash
If the Shoe Fits Eggs over Evie The Ballad of Valentine (Picture Puffins) Desert Rose and Her Highfalutin Hog When the Wind Blew

Share This Book