93rd out of 637 books
—
634 voters
Lost Boy Lost Girl
by
Peter Straub (Goodreads Author)
A woman commits suicide for no apparent reason. A week later, her son– fifteen-year-old Mark Underhill–vanishes. His uncle, novelist Timothy Underhill, searches his hometown of Millhaven for clues that might help unravel this horrible dual mystery. He soon learns that a pedophilic murderer is on the loose in the vicinity, and that shortly before his mother’s suicide, Mark...more
Mass Market Paperback, 368 pages
Published
September 28th 2004
by Ballantine Books
(first published 2003)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Peter Straub has a way with words. Some people don’t like that. “Too wordy”, they say. Well, I don’t share that sentiment. I could immerse myself in beautiful prose all day long, thank you very much.
Now.
lost boy lost girl
A review.
Yes I am here, yes I was real. You denied me.
This is one of the finest examples of literary horror I have ever read. I would like to emphasize that Peter Straub does.not.spoonfeed.his.readers. The “literary” bit is just as important here as the “horror” bit so an apprec...more
Now.
lost boy lost girl
A review.
Yes I am here, yes I was real. You denied me.
This is one of the finest examples of literary horror I have ever read. I would like to emphasize that Peter Straub does.not.spoonfeed.his.readers. The “literary” bit is just as important here as the “horror” bit so an apprec...more
This book is the perfect illustration of why I don't read horror. The author has one mediocre idea, and forcibly bolsters it into a book with flat characters, wooden, implausible dialog and embarassing attempts at proving he did his research on youth culture by tossing in some skate shoe brand names. He's stingy with the "scary" parts, and if I want blood and gore I better stick with Palahniuk and Brite. I thought it might be fun to read something creepy for October, but I may not be finishing t...more
Aug 13, 2007
John Wiswell
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Horror readers, crime readers, supernatural readers
The unsettling account of the connections between a suicide, a missing boy, a missing girl, a serial killer and a haunted house, Lost Boy Lost Girl is a strange amalgam of parts. Even its narrative is scattered for such a short book, with a heavy emphasis on the uncle of the missing boy. His presence is so dominant (despite him being removed from nearly all of the plot, mostly learning of events after they happen) that the more intimate perspectives that come later feel out of place. Straub summ...more
Nancy Underhill was related to the Kalendar family, he got his wifr pregnant then said they lost the baby but instead kept her and abused her in the house. He killed many people in that house for there were secret passageways everywhere within the walls. The basement had an operating table a giant bed and 5 doors that led to unbelievable horror, scalps and blood everywhere. Mark and his friend Jimbo were in there and Mark got attached to the house and kept going back till one day he disappeared...more
This novel, which won the Bram Stoker Award for Best Novel, is part murder mystery, part ghost story and part family drama, with an unexpected, transcendent ending.
The story follows Tim Underhill, (a character from earlier novels by Straub), as he attempts to cope with a series of tragic, mysterious events afflicting the family of his dour brother, Phillip.
First is the seemingly inexplicable suicide of Nancy, Phillip’s wife. Next, their teenaged son, Mark, becomes obsessed with the abandoned hou...more
The story follows Tim Underhill, (a character from earlier novels by Straub), as he attempts to cope with a series of tragic, mysterious events afflicting the family of his dour brother, Phillip.
First is the seemingly inexplicable suicide of Nancy, Phillip’s wife. Next, their teenaged son, Mark, becomes obsessed with the abandoned hou...more
For some reason I avoided Peter Straub like the plague until one day in my twenties whilst stuck in Penn Station I happened upon a copy of "Lost Boy Lost Girl" and out of desperation bought it. I have never looked back and as soon as I finished it I ran out and read everything else the man has written in something like a month.
"Lost Boy Lost Girl" is a ghost story but its also a story about surviving unspeakable loss.
Successful novelist Tim Underhill (a featured player in several of Straub's ot...more
"Lost Boy Lost Girl" is a ghost story but its also a story about surviving unspeakable loss.
Successful novelist Tim Underhill (a featured player in several of Straub's ot...more
It was not scary at all. There's just this millionaire, Ronald Lloyd-Jones, who was obsessed with a serial killer named Joseph Kalendar and looked up to him so much that he kidnapped boys and tortured them in Kalendar's house since he bought the property after Kalendar left.
I think that we have to give credit for Mark and Jimbo for finding out what crept out Nancy Underhill that led to her suicide. Jimbo too for being a loyal friend to Mark even though he left Mark alone to his search for answer...more
I think that we have to give credit for Mark and Jimbo for finding out what crept out Nancy Underhill that led to her suicide. Jimbo too for being a loyal friend to Mark even though he left Mark alone to his search for answer...more
Stephen King consistently recommends Peter Straub as one of the great horror writers of our time, so I've been meaning to sit down with one of his books for awhile. When King's cover blurb proclaimed "May be the best book of his career!" I figured Lost Boy Lost Girl was a good place to start. Unfortunately, I was completely underwhelmed.
It doesn't help that the premise is a muddled one: Famous writer Tim Underhill is called upon to help his brother investigate the disappearance of his nephew Mar...more
It doesn't help that the premise is a muddled one: Famous writer Tim Underhill is called upon to help his brother investigate the disappearance of his nephew Mar...more
Mark Underhill is a typical 15-year-old boy living with his mom and dad in a typical Midwest middle-class neighborhood. His dad is an emotionally distant public school vice principal and his enduring mom works the complaints desk at the gas company. Mark likes music, skateboarding, and hanging out with his best friend, Jimbo. But Mark’s regular life takes a turn when he discovers his mother has committed a gruesome suicide in their own bathtub. From this scene on, Straub’s story attempts to ter...more
Peter Straub's easy-to-read, fast-paced writing style makes this a pretty fun read. "Lost Boy Lost Girl" is a story that mashes together a few different staples of horror fiction, with ghosts, suicides, and serial killers all converging on one another, in a story that jumps between first- and third-person, past and present.
Parts of the novel are told from the point of view of Tim Underhill, the protagonist, a middle-aged novelist attempting to explain the disappearance of his fifteen-year-old ne...more
Parts of the novel are told from the point of view of Tim Underhill, the protagonist, a middle-aged novelist attempting to explain the disappearance of his fifteen-year-old ne...more
Peter Straub once again dazzles with this horror novel. Indeed, Straub has returned to the style that made him famous.
Anyway, this is a very complex literary novel, the type that begs for a second reading. Although this might throw some readers off, it is the literary complexity that draws me to Straub. The protagonist, Tim Underhill, we’ve met before. If you’re a fan, then you’ve also encountered Tom Pasmore, and the city of Millhaven; in lost boy lost girl we meet them all again.
The thing I fi...more
Anyway, this is a very complex literary novel, the type that begs for a second reading. Although this might throw some readers off, it is the literary complexity that draws me to Straub. The protagonist, Tim Underhill, we’ve met before. If you’re a fan, then you’ve also encountered Tom Pasmore, and the city of Millhaven; in lost boy lost girl we meet them all again.
The thing I fi...more
This book is vastly underrated. It sat next to my bed for a year so I could read the last pages and feel inspired. Brilliant.
Best of all Peter signed my book at last year's Readercom. Yeah, I experienced a fan girl moment. Lovely.
UPDATE:
I just read it again this January. So, potent, so frightening, so wonderful.
Best of all Peter signed my book at last year's Readercom. Yeah, I experienced a fan girl moment. Lovely.
UPDATE:
I just read it again this January. So, potent, so frightening, so wonderful.
I wouldn't even really call this a horror. I'm pretty easily spooked but it didn't scare me at all! I kept waiting for something scary to happen but it never did.
I agree with other reviewers that the characters are pretty flat and its annoying that the two significant female characters are fridged (killed off solely to provide motivation and a plot point to male characters for non-comic book readers), one is literally a ghost who doesn't have any lines whatsoever but just provides a odd ending....more
I agree with other reviewers that the characters are pretty flat and its annoying that the two significant female characters are fridged (killed off solely to provide motivation and a plot point to male characters for non-comic book readers), one is literally a ghost who doesn't have any lines whatsoever but just provides a odd ending....more
I am currently taking a course that requires students to read one book from each literary genre. Recently, we began the Horror genre. I selected this book to read. I do not read horror novels often, but I have read a few and enjoyed them.
This book was neither scary nor suspenseful to me, so I was never able to become interested. I was also irritated by the poor and stereotypical portrayal of teen lingo. The odd insertions of the word "yo" in dialogue was annoying. Also, the emails shown in the b...more
This book was neither scary nor suspenseful to me, so I was never able to become interested. I was also irritated by the poor and stereotypical portrayal of teen lingo. The odd insertions of the word "yo" in dialogue was annoying. Also, the emails shown in the b...more
What's not to like in this book? An all male cast filled with one dimensional stereotypes. A major failing of the Bechdel test. A serial killer sub-plot that goes nowhere. An evil house that does nothing. A story about evil where the only person who dies is a suicide, and that's on page one. A story about a ghost where the ghost who finally shows up just wants to have sex...but "off screen," of course. Wouldn't want anything to actually happen in this book, would we?
In a book of dull and offensi...more
In a book of dull and offensi...more
Okay,so I really don't know what to think about this book. The plot was very intricate, so points for that. And it kept moving, which kept me reading, but it took a little while for it to get going. At the end it seemed like there was some stuff that wasn't fully resolved. For example, does Mark really just vanish into some spirit world? I would have liked a tad bit more explanation on that front about how it happens. Or does he get killed? Or go crazy? And what about his mom's suicide? What was...more
Picked this book up in the library because the title intrigued me and I had nothing with me to read. Couldn't put it down. A fascinating story with an intriguing and satisfying ending.
There are many disturbing elements to this story, but for me personally, that simply adds to the overall effect. I know some people who hate disturbing books to the point where they will throw the book out in the trash, and while I don't like seeing mistreated books like that, it's your book so whatever. That's fin...more
There are many disturbing elements to this story, but for me personally, that simply adds to the overall effect. I know some people who hate disturbing books to the point where they will throw the book out in the trash, and while I don't like seeing mistreated books like that, it's your book so whatever. That's fin...more
2 1/2 stars....I'm not sure how I've never read one of Peter Straub's books before, since I grew up reading Stephen King. Well I have to say that I was just not that impressed.
Sure there are creepy parts and a little suspense, but there were a few times when I got confused because he flips the time line around a little. I also found the book sluggish until about 3/4 of the way in.
I also found that some of the dialogue between the 2 teenage boys was unnatural and forced. Teenage boys just don't...more
Sure there are creepy parts and a little suspense, but there were a few times when I got confused because he flips the time line around a little. I also found the book sluggish until about 3/4 of the way in.
I also found that some of the dialogue between the 2 teenage boys was unnatural and forced. Teenage boys just don't...more
I’d never read a Peter Straub book before, but I’d always wanted to because I’d heard that
Ghost Story
was supposed to be pretty darn scary. The only problem with Ghost Story was that it was 567 pages, which is a whole different type of scary when you’ve got the reading speed of a brain-dead koala.
For me, 567 pages is an awfully big commitment to an author I’m not sure I’ll like. So when I went to the library recently and found myself in the Straub section, I pulled out the thinnest book of the...more
For me, 567 pages is an awfully big commitment to an author I’m not sure I’ll like. So when I went to the library recently and found myself in the Straub section, I pulled out the thinnest book of the...more
I can remember exactly where I was when I read THE TALISMAN and BLACK HOUSE, co-authored by Straub with the genius Stephen King. I was in my bed in my small apartment, too afraid to get up to go to the bathroom or to get a drink. My two cats were staring at me with even more disdain than usual...anyway, the tension Straub and King created in those books was only matched by descriptions of the kind of evil that makes you afraid to get out of bed. This book, however, simply wasn't scary. In the ha...more
There were parts I liked like how Straub creates a creepy tone from the get go reminding me a little of Bram Stoker"s Dracula' Guest (short story). There is an ominous sense of foreboding in the setting from the get-go. The novel was also framed in layers where the reader pulls back one layer only to find another waiting, building an eerie suspense. Well done. However, it was anticlimactic. I loved the ending but by the last layer, I was expecting more character definition and action in the anta...more
I had my heart in my throat for a good deal of this book. It is a mystery, it is a psychological thriller and it's a story about family and love of a child. I don't think I could read it now, as a mother, but when I read it a handful of years ago, I adored it and was thrilled to find out that there is a sequel.
If you wish to read this book, do NOT under any circumstances read any part of In the Night Room by Straub first - do not look at the back cover, because you never know what they'll put th...more
If you wish to read this book, do NOT under any circumstances read any part of In the Night Room by Straub first - do not look at the back cover, because you never know what they'll put th...more
The ebook version I read was 236 pages, so the story moved along rapidly. The notable events and discoveries jump back and forth in time, but the author does an admirable job at keeping you queued in to when the occurrences take place. I read this quickly since I wanted to see how it would conclude. I read the last 25% in one sitting because I couldn't put it down. :-)
As for the ending it did seem it bit abbreviated but on the other hand it answered most or all of the mysteries which is good.
I...more
As for the ending it did seem it bit abbreviated but on the other hand it answered most or all of the mysteries which is good.
I...more
I was hugely disappointed in this book. It is the story of a young teen that becomes obsessed with an empty house on the other side of the alley where he lives. It is a house that horrible murders took place many years prior. His mom knows the secret of the house and she ends of committing suicide and then the boy disappears. There is a serial killer on the loose and the assumption is he was now a victim of this man. There were parts of the story that were quite interesting but it did jump aroun...more
A quick and enjoyable read, with a bit of bitter aftertaste when it's all said and done. The story is engaging for most of the novel and there are parts that are genuinely scary, but it's wrapped up in a very unsatisfying way. On top of that, I couldn't help but think that parts of the story line were "borrowed ideas" from three of Orson Scott Card's stabs at the horror genre... "Treasure Box", "Homebody" and the wonderful "Lost Boys" all come to mind. Only difference being that Card's novels an...more
The story seemed intriguing but I kept feeling like the author didn't give any credit to his readers. The reader is constantly being told things explicitly rather than letting anything be left to the imagination ["Jimbo hesitated, and now I know exactly why. He had to think about going further" (p. 224)].
Another annoyance is that the narrator switches even within a paragraph so the author can tell you exactly what every single person is thinking and feeling. "In Jimbo's frank stare, Tim could se...more
Another annoyance is that the narrator switches even within a paragraph so the author can tell you exactly what every single person is thinking and feeling. "In Jimbo's frank stare, Tim could se...more
This is a short story that could have worked at 20-something page count, but instead was stretched to 300. The best thing about it was meeting the familiar characters from Koko, but that's pretty much it.
Lost Boy, Lost Girl is divided into three parts - presentation of the mystery and introduction of the characters and setting - the investigation - the conclusion. Narrated in the third person, the narration constantly switches between the characters and sometimes parts are relayed through one c...more
Lost Boy, Lost Girl is divided into three parts - presentation of the mystery and introduction of the characters and setting - the investigation - the conclusion. Narrated in the third person, the narration constantly switches between the characters and sometimes parts are relayed through one c...more
Lost Boy Lost Girl is my first book by this author. This would be my last but I'm going to give one of his other books a chance.
The first 30 pages of the book are very slow. And then it gets very confusing. Something will happen, and then something else will happen, and then it'll go back to the first thing that happened and write it over again in another character's perspective-- barely adding any new information to the story.
As you know from the description, Mark's mother commits suicide and t...more
The first 30 pages of the book are very slow. And then it gets very confusing. Something will happen, and then something else will happen, and then it'll go back to the first thing that happened and write it over again in another character's perspective-- barely adding any new information to the story.
As you know from the description, Mark's mother commits suicide and t...more
What a great spooky story!
Writer Tim Underhill travels back to his small hometown, Millhaven, to attend his sister-in-law's funeral. While there, he learns that she committed suicide. He comforts his distant brother and his 15 year old nephew as best he can, then goes home. Shortly after returning to New York, Tim must again travel back to Millhaven because his nephew has disappeared. As he attempts to unravel the mysteries of his sister-in-law's suicide and his nephew's disappearance, Tim disco...more
Writer Tim Underhill travels back to his small hometown, Millhaven, to attend his sister-in-law's funeral. While there, he learns that she committed suicide. He comforts his distant brother and his 15 year old nephew as best he can, then goes home. Shortly after returning to New York, Tim must again travel back to Millhaven because his nephew has disappeared. As he attempts to unravel the mysteries of his sister-in-law's suicide and his nephew's disappearance, Tim disco...more
Ok, so this is definitely a book that improves with re-reading. When I first read it, I only rated it three stars. This time, it blew me away! I had forgotten how creepy and atmospheric the novel is, particularly several scenes inside and abandoned (and possibly haunted) house. Last night I had to put it down to go to sleep during a particularly creepy bit, and I actually found myself turning off the light and then immediately pulling the covers over my head because I was feeling so spooked. Gav...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| South Shore Readers: Discussion: Lost Boy Lost Girl | 10 | 15 | Nov 01, 2012 06:17pm |
Peter Straub was born in Milwaukee, Wisconsin on 2 March, 1943, the first of three sons of a salesman and a nurse. The salesman wanted him to become an athlete, the nurse thought he would do well as either a doctor or a Lutheran minister, but all he wanted to do was to learn to read.
When kindergarten turned out to be a stupefyingly banal disappointment devoted to cutting animal shapes out of heavy...more
More about Peter Straub...
When kindergarten turned out to be a stupefyingly banal disappointment devoted to cutting animal shapes out of heavy...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...










view all 4 comments































