1st out of 42 books
—
9 voters
Understanding Power: The Indispensable Chomsky
The best of Chomsky's recent talks on the past, present, and future of the politics of power. In a series of enlightening and wide-ranging discussions, all published here for the first time, Chomsky radically reinterprets the events of the past three decades, covering topics from foreign policy during Vietnam to the decline of welfare under the Clinton administration.
416 pages
Published
February 1st 2002
by New Press, The
(first published 2002)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Jul 03, 2010
Bryan
added it
Intentions Good, Views Dangerous: Understanding Power is, without question, the most comprehensive and compelling presentation of Noam Chomsky's ideas. Reading this book will change the way you see the world. If you are interested in Chomsky, it is likely that you are a noble person who genuinely cares for others and yearns for a better world. Beware, reader, and make sure you choose the right vehicle for your hope. While his intentions are for a peaceful, safe, and healthy world, Chomsky's poli...more
This book is a feat of editing. It condenses aspects of Chomsky's talks from across decades and references them at a separate website, understandingpower.com. Here are some favourite quotes:
You should not expect an institution to say, "Help me destroy myself," that's not the way institutions function. And if anybody inside the institution tried to do that, they wouldn't be inside it much longer.
If you're getting accepted in elite circles, chances are very strong that you're doing something wrong...more
You should not expect an institution to say, "Help me destroy myself," that's not the way institutions function. And if anybody inside the institution tried to do that, they wouldn't be inside it much longer.
If you're getting accepted in elite circles, chances are very strong that you're doing something wrong...more
Propaganda is to democracy what violence is to totalitarianism. - Noam Chomsky
After reading five or six Chomsky books - this is without a split-second of thought his best, most highly honored and important texts assembled to date.
I'm not sure who(m)ever edited this book, it seems to be cut with precise trimming. The rhetoric speaks with a strong appeal (fulfilling pathos, ethos and logos) to help engage the reader indefinitely. Yes, Chomsky's monologues can be a bit dry because they are so factu...more
After reading five or six Chomsky books - this is without a split-second of thought his best, most highly honored and important texts assembled to date.
I'm not sure who(m)ever edited this book, it seems to be cut with precise trimming. The rhetoric speaks with a strong appeal (fulfilling pathos, ethos and logos) to help engage the reader indefinitely. Yes, Chomsky's monologues can be a bit dry because they are so factu...more
I have strong feelings moving in both ways on this book, as whilst Chomsky does make very good points on multiple issues, his attempts at modesty occasionally fall flat as it becomes apparent that he thinks he understands the whole world order more than he does. I do feel that his analysis of the media is by and large correct - if one is funded by advertisers, those advertisers must be pleased and they will not be pleased if you run the wrong messages. I know plenty of people who simply swallow...more
This is the best single source of Chomsky's work I've come across. A triumph of editing, this book is made up of excerpts of talks Chomsky gave throughout the 80s and 90s. Loosely organized by topic, the book is highly flowing and readable. It includes an encyclopedic reference section available online that is longer than the main text of the book. This is where I recommend anyone not familiar with Chomsky's work to begin; it's the most comprehensive and accessible compilation of his thoughts. M...more
Having only read Chomsky in snippets here and there, I thought this book was a broad, accessible introduction to Chomsky's thoughts on the issues for which he is best known in pop culture (those relating to politics and power). Regardless of what one ultimately thinks of Chomsky's opinions (and he reiterates constantly that his intent is to provoke discussion, not to provide all the answers), the man is at least important to understand for modern democratic citizens. His knowledge of global curr...more
I'm always afraid of reading political things (A) because I'm scared of it being completely over my head and (B) because I'm aware that I have a tendency to uncritically accept what people say [which makes for a lot of fun if you read different points of views because everything everybody says (even the contradictory stuff) sounds 100% right:].
This book was very conversational (partly due to format, transcribed Q&A sessions and I imagine partly due to Chomsky's dislike of the idea of an 'int...more
This book was very conversational (partly due to format, transcribed Q&A sessions and I imagine partly due to Chomsky's dislike of the idea of an 'int...more
Noam Chomsky is a respected linguist who is also known as a political dissident and writer. His best-known work is probably Manufacturing Consent, in which Chomsky and Edward Herman examined “how the media ought to function and how they do function” within a framework of propaganda.
Years ago, I remember picking up something by Chomsky and finding it very academic and dry. Understanding Power, on the contrary, is infinitely readable. Discussions among groups of activists, from dozens of “Teach-in...more
Years ago, I remember picking up something by Chomsky and finding it very academic and dry. Understanding Power, on the contrary, is infinitely readable. Discussions among groups of activists, from dozens of “Teach-in...more
All right, here we go:
I'm not a political scientist -- probably this works in my favor -- so I can't level this kind of assessment with anything like authority, but for what it's worth, I think Chomsky's mostly right about most everything he talks about.
BUT. Rather than attempt once again to articulate an objection that's always struck me as sort of obvious every time I've dipped into one of his books (and I have read a few now, sure. I really like the guy), I think I'll let him make my point fo...more
I'm not a political scientist -- probably this works in my favor -- so I can't level this kind of assessment with anything like authority, but for what it's worth, I think Chomsky's mostly right about most everything he talks about.
BUT. Rather than attempt once again to articulate an objection that's always struck me as sort of obvious every time I've dipped into one of his books (and I have read a few now, sure. I really like the guy), I think I'll let him make my point fo...more
This is the second time through this book for me. I met Noam in the 70s through professor types who revered him (justifiably) for his talents in linguistics. He has a range of knowledge amazingly far reaching and is a very engaging person to have dialogue with. This book is worth the ride if only for the footnotes @ http://www.understandingpower.com/.
This is a GREAT introduction to Noam Chomsky. This book touches on everything from terrorism (u.s and across the world), intellectual thought and ideology. And the great thing is, it doesn't get boring.
The book is a set of discussions and really allows the reader to ease into and feel comfortable with the topics being raised. Chomksy's style is very down to earth, anyone who has heard his voice will know what im talking about.
Chomsky deals mostly with the United States and its actions in the wor...more
The book is a set of discussions and really allows the reader to ease into and feel comfortable with the topics being raised. Chomksy's style is very down to earth, anyone who has heard his voice will know what im talking about.
Chomsky deals mostly with the United States and its actions in the wor...more
This is an amazing collection of Chomsky's work. For me it wasn't the type of book I sat and read cover to cover in one sitting. It was one I slowly worked my way through wrapping my mind around the vast amount of information he provided. I actually read this book with a highlighter in hand as though it was a college text book! Noam Chomsky is brilliant and this is my favorite book of his that I have read. I have a couple others and I feel like this one presents his views in the most comprehensi...more
I came to know and appreciate Chomsky's ideas via some of his interviews. This was my first book by Chomsky. Its a collection of his lectures in the 90's, compiled such that you clearly follow the flow of ideas. I guess even if somebody remotely follows politics through the media, this book is must. The book provides with the basics of trying to read between the lines... not just following what “they” present. It also gave me some confidence to question the ideas behind governments, ideas that I...more
Inquietante e spaventoso. A volte si dice senza pensarci troppo "la realtà supera la fantasia", ma leggendo questo libro ci si rende conto di quanto sia vero. Sconsigliato a chi soffre di crisi depressive e di manie di persecuzione, perché potrebbe portare al suicidio. L'autore (o meglio "il protagonista") esprime naturalmente la sua opinione su molti dei punti discussi, e si tratta di un punto di vista da "anarchico". Su ogni argomento si può concordare o meno, ma i fatti che riporta sono perlo...more
This was my introduction to the most quoted author after Seakspear and the Bible. He has been called the "world's most important intellectual" by the New York Times (and that is why they won't print most of what he has to say) and was placed in Richard Nixon's top 100 enemies of the United States when Nixon was President. In the mid 60's when Vietnam was acceptable to most Americans Professor Chomsky (Noble laureate and professor of Linguistics at MIT)was leading anti-war demonstations.
This boo...more
This boo...more
A great collection of thought and critique on Power and the Structures of Power. Highly recommended. A little dated since lots of the conversations are from prior to 9-11, but still very applicable to today. Refreshing, critical analysis. I have some quibbles here and there about taking some examples out of proportion, but that does not necessarily invalidate the idea he is trying to support. I enjoy that he understands and recognizes how great it is to be able to speak our mind freely in the U....more
I was reading this at my local coffee shop about five+ years ago and some guy asked to use my cellphone. I obliged, but then he started walking towards the door with it as he was leaving a message! So I yelled out, "Hey. Where you going with my phone?" He was not pleased, or 'ungrateful' depending on your perspective, and he then noticed my reading material when he handed back the phone. He made a snide remark concerning the title of this book and how it relates to my control of my cellphone and...more
Let me start of by saying I didn't agree with everything he says in this book, but we should not only read things we agree with. We should strive to seek NEW information. This book definitely expanded my mind.
While Chomsky definitely has a cynical view of the US and the world, this book still contains great insights into all sorts of things. For instance, he talks about the military-industrial complex, tons of references to Orwell's 1984, propaganda, any people from other countries perceive us a...more
While Chomsky definitely has a cynical view of the US and the world, this book still contains great insights into all sorts of things. For instance, he talks about the military-industrial complex, tons of references to Orwell's 1984, propaganda, any people from other countries perceive us a...more
Nov 13, 2011
Evelyn
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
anarchism,
current-affairs,
media,
non-fiction,
philosophy,
politics,
religion,
history,
economics,
all-time-favourites,
read-in-2011
An eye-opening book which is accessible for almost everyone to read without too much trouble and a great introduction to many topics surrounding the politics of Power. Packed within these 400 pages, Chomsky discusses US foreign policy & US politics in general, Israel, Palestine & the Middle East, histories of labour and social movements, propaganda techniques of the mainstream media, the military-industrial complex and the UN to name just a few. He also talks about activism and the need...more
Chomsky is one of the critical deans of American political history: ironic and pessimistic; forever probing and analyzing the decrepitude, deceit, and delusion rife within the ready presentation and understanding of the United States as an exceptional force of good in the world, and a constant decrier of the various means and manipulations the government and media undertake to stoke this view; content in generally limiting himself to pointing out the flaws in the system, the hypocrisy and moral...more
To put it mildly, I was unaware of Chomsky's politics before reading Understanding Power. It provides a detailed insight into his views over the past few decades, although that is the one fault. I am the type of person who is interested in the "now," or up-to-the-minute details. It took some effort to work through Chomsky's views on events, some rather minimal ,that occured in the 70's and had little relevence for me today. However, the information is pure Chomsky, and a good asset to have read....more
This book consists of a series of transcriptions from interviews/discussions with Mr. Chomsky, concerning mostly the US domination against the world.
Everyone should read this book, because Mr. Chomsky provides us with a lot of facts that are not well known, lots of important history facts that are not taught at schools (surely on purpose).
Every single statement is followed by a reference to other books or US Government declassified documents, just to prove the truth of the statements.
It is a mus...more
Everyone should read this book, because Mr. Chomsky provides us with a lot of facts that are not well known, lots of important history facts that are not taught at schools (surely on purpose).
Every single statement is followed by a reference to other books or US Government declassified documents, just to prove the truth of the statements.
It is a mus...more
This book was my introduction to Chomsky, and ever since I have had the utmost respect for his work. This is a long book, but if you can read just parts of it I know it would enlighten you (more than you may ever want to be). It covers so much of U.S. foreign and domestic policy that I can't even begin to say what you'll discover. I was particularly interested in the Latin American atrocities because I had never known about them until I read this book.
Great questions, amazing answers. This is my first chomsky book and I'm totally blown away. He mainly focuses on power relations and hegemony here but also offers an interesting take on activism and alternative economies. Although I don't agree with everything he says (his views on technology sound pretty bleak and his opinion on corporate planning seems rather simplistic) he offers interesting insight into the world of international affairs. I've fact checked a few things because certain events...more
Everytime I read Noam I get more depressed. But, I can't help myself. The problem is not that we are in such difficult situations as a body-politic but rather that we don't know what a deep hole we are in and we keep shooting oursevles in the foot. {Please ignore mixed metaphore, thanks.) Because Noam is never completely pessimistic you just keep reading hoping for some light at the end of the tunnel.
Maybe next time we won't get into an endless war with no point and no money. Maybe next time our...more
Maybe next time we won't get into an endless war with no point and no money. Maybe next time our...more
Observations:
1) Chomsky has an amazing memory.
2) Even if only 10% of this book were true, it would be incredible from the point of view of shattering illusions about government, media, etc.
3) I suspect much more than 10% of this book is true.
My illusions have been shattered.
I love that despite all of the reasons to be cynical, Chomsky remains hopeful and pragmatic.
1) Chomsky has an amazing memory.
2) Even if only 10% of this book were true, it would be incredible from the point of view of shattering illusions about government, media, etc.
3) I suspect much more than 10% of this book is true.
My illusions have been shattered.
I love that despite all of the reasons to be cynical, Chomsky remains hopeful and pragmatic.
I am becoming a serious Chomsky addict. This is a collection of talks with the emphasis on dissidence and organising for change. Chomsky is excellent on the analysis of power and on the importance of the individual. He is completely down to earth and has a wonderful focus on the abilities of people to understand and engage with the world. Encouraging stuff, despite all the appalling issues raised here. I love his direct approach and his commitment.
Dec 04, 2008
Emily
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
anarchists, US history buffs, Republicrats and Democians, journalism majors, people who think
A must for anyone who wants to really educate themselves on how the government, media (and the corporations who control both), really work in this country. Noam is very smart man, to say the least. Most of his speeches were collected in the 1980s, so it's a little dated, but for most part scarily prescient.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Avram Noam Chomsky is an American linguist, philosopher, political activist, author, and lecturer. He is an Institute Professor and professor emeritus of linguistics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Chomsky is credited with the creation of the theory of generative grammar, considered to be one of the most significant contributions to the field of linguistics made in the 20th century. H...more
More about Noam Chomsky...
Chomsky is credited with the creation of the theory of generative grammar, considered to be one of the most significant contributions to the field of linguistics made in the 20th century. H...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“...the qualifications that I have to speak on world affairs are exactly the same ones Henry Kissinger has, and Walt Rostow has, or anybody in the Political Science Department, professional historians—none, none that you don't have. The only difference is, I don't pretend to have qualifications, nor do I pretend that qualifications are needed. I mean, if somebody were to ask me to give a talk on quantum physics, I'd refuse—because I don't understand enough. But world affairs are trivial: there's nothing in the social sciences or history or whatever that is beyond the intellectual capacities of an ordinary fifteen-year-old. You have to do a little work, you have to do some reading, you have to be able to think but there's nothing deep—if there are any theories around that require some special kind of training to understand, then they've been kept a carefully guarded secret.”
—
3 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...











view 2 comments

















