36th out of 469 books
—
979 voters
Food Politics: How the Food Industry Influences Nutrition and Health
We all witness, in advertising and on supermarket shelves, the fierce competition for our food dollars. In this engrossing exposé, Marion Nestle goes behind the scenes to reveal how the competition really works and how it affects our health. The abundance of food in the United States--enough calories to meet the needs of every man, woman, and child twice over--has a downsi...more
Paperback, 472 pages
Published
September 30th 2003
by University of California Press
(first published 2002)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Boy... if you have any conspiracy-theorist-leaning tendencies at all, this book will really get you going! I think most of us are aware of ties between food corporations and our government's food regulations and safety standards to some degree, but this book will show you just how deeply ingrained it all is. It really is kind of disturbing that the FDA and the USDA have responsibilities both to the health and safety of U.S. consumers, AND to the agricultural industry. Those are definitely a conf...more
This author discusses how food companies need to continually find new markets for their products and as a result, they have to convince people to eat more regardless of the nutritional value of their products. As a result of this over-consumption, Americans are becoming more and more obese. In this book, Nestle also talks about how the food industry has influenced the USDA recommended Food Guide Pyramid. She says that people are only getting their nutritional advice from the food industry. Altho...more
Food Politics as a fairly deep study of the politics of the food industry in the Unite States. The book can best be catagorized as text book caliber in both look and feel. Despite the in depth research, the author, Marion Nestle (no relation to the food corporation), does her best to make the information accesabile and understandable to both the professional and the casual reader alike.
To be fair, you shouldn't read this book casually. I am not a food professional but I have read on the topic ex...more
To be fair, you shouldn't read this book casually. I am not a food professional but I have read on the topic ex...more
I actually didn't finish this book, which for me is a very rare thing. I got about 3/4 of the way through but then had to stop and return the book to the school library, where it was about 3 months overdue already! One of the reasons I checked the book out was because no one else ever had, though, so I doubt the book was missed. I thought the beginning was very good and everything was explained in terms simple enough to understand, but by the end my interest was dragging. Also, I had those AP En...more
There is really only one thing driving the food industry – the hunger for more profit. This is such an obvious fact that it hardly needs to be restated, however, it is best to keep obvious facts at front of your mind. This particular fact tells us a lot about what is wrong with food today.
As hard as it is to believe food is incredibly simple. We need food to give us energy and to provide us with nutrients. So, if we were to be rational in our eating we would eat food that is balanced with our en...more
As hard as it is to believe food is incredibly simple. We need food to give us energy and to provide us with nutrients. So, if we were to be rational in our eating we would eat food that is balanced with our en...more
This book was a difficult read. The information about the history of each change to the food pyramid (something none of us should use as a dietary guide anyway) was particularly boring and tedious to get through. Much of the book was hard going to read and not written in an engaging or interesting way. It is dull, dull, dull. It has none of the intelligent writing style and ease of reading of so many other books I have read on this topic. The content of the book was also very problematic.
Yes, th...more
Yes, th...more
Food is indeed political. At least this is a message that I’m being hit with a lot recently. Jamie Oliver’s Food Revolution on TV, a show that takes on America’s bad eating habits and tries to change them, also documents an incredible amount of resistance to this change. “We don’t wanna sit around and eat lettuce all day!” says the local radio show host in Huntington, West Virginia (a city which, according to the Centers for Disease Control, is the unhealthiest city in America). It seems that pe...more
I wasn't expecting to learn much from this book, having already poured through books like Fast Food Nation, The Omnivore's Dilemma, School Lunch Politics The Surprising History of America's Favorite Welfare Program, Organic, Inc. Natural Foods and How They Grew and Toxic Sludge is Good For You Lies, Damn Lies and the Public Relations Industry, but I feel that this book has a lot to offer above and beyond what other books discuss about food politics.
Although at times the book can get a bit hard t...more
Although at times the book can get a bit hard t...more
If only more could read this book: This book touches upon issues that everyone is aware of but chooses to ignore. The author makes this obvious but in an non-condescending way which is much appreciated. He ties the biases of the food industry in with other industries such as the pharmaceutical and tobacco industries. Drawing the connections between these three and the governmental regulatory agencies that work with/against them respectively (USDA, FDA, ATF), the author illustrates just how much...more
I have always wondered how much Big Ag pushed their agenda thru research and this book certainly sheds some light on it. I guess the old adage is true, follow the money. It's no wonder why so many people are confused on what's healthy and what's not. There is only two ways to grow revenues - gain market share or gain caloric intake to increase demand. Too bad business has sold their ethics to achieve these goals. This book really sheds the light on how they do it. The book is a little "researchy...more
Aug 21, 2011
Kathy
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommended to Kathy by:
Borrowed from Ben at the farmer's market
Ben, who works at the Farmer's Market at HeadHouse Square, lent this book to me, following a discussion we had on books about food politics.
This book approached food politics from the perspective of food advertising and governmental influence. I knew fairly little about these arenas, and Nestle's writing, in addition to her personal experiences with oversight committees, enlightened me on the myriad ways in which the food industry has influenced dietary advice in nuanced ways.
Now, I can't watch...more
This book approached food politics from the perspective of food advertising and governmental influence. I knew fairly little about these arenas, and Nestle's writing, in addition to her personal experiences with oversight committees, enlightened me on the myriad ways in which the food industry has influenced dietary advice in nuanced ways.
Now, I can't watch...more
"Marion Nestle’s entire book Food Politics was basically a reaction to her experiences with the USDA and the FDA, and how the food industry was able to manipulate all the recommendations to send the message that people should be eating more, especially eating more meat, dairy, and refined foods. The only thing the government got past these powerful lobbies were recommendations to eat sugar and fat sparingly; the meat industry felt they could take advantage of those particular recommendations, an...more
Apr 29, 2013
Darren
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
cookery-food,
gen-ebooks
At times you might be forgiven for thinking that surely food can be left free of politics, when so much else in the world is tied up with political string. Sorry, but politics plays a big place here too!
Whether it is public policy and politics dictating what we should eat and drink on health grounds, or should that be "health" grounds, geopolitics with us being encouraged to favour produce from country X instead of country Y for various reasons or just plain business politics, with companies lob...more
Whether it is public policy and politics dictating what we should eat and drink on health grounds, or should that be "health" grounds, geopolitics with us being encouraged to favour produce from country X instead of country Y for various reasons or just plain business politics, with companies lob...more
Really enjoyed this book, but it had to go back to the library before I could finish it. Some of it is very dense, with a lot of jargon and acronyms and changing government agencies. My two big take-aways so far are: 1) the incredible amount of funding nutrition and dietetic programs get from food companies and agencies. I knew doctor's offices and hospitals get money (and free pens) from pharmaceutical companies, but didn't think (naively) that it happened to nutritionists, dietitians and their...more
This book is definitely worth the read for an understanding of how FDA recommendations and warnings (or lack thereof) came to be. Interesting, there's no mention of the often-weak science that led to the preferred recommendations, but that's a different topic addressed by other books. Nestle takes it as a given, but the political aspect is still worth challenging, even if she fails to challenge other things.
I love that she cited the history of the Nestle company (unrelated to the author) marketi...more
I love that she cited the history of the Nestle company (unrelated to the author) marketi...more
Super interesting read. Also a bit long and very detailed regarding historical events. This book was written by a former member of the FDA and as such is very empathetic to them. Most things I learned, I had some sort of sense for prior to discovering exactly how it worked. For example, the first section of the book is devoted to creating the food pyramid, how the government (due to agricultural interests) can never explicitly tell the public to eat less of anything. If they do proclaim "eat les...more
The idea that profit-maximizing behavior by food companies might harm your health and your waistline is a more mainstream idea now than it was back in 2002 when Food Politics was first published. Skyrocketing obesity rates seem to have focused a lot of peoples' attention, and while there's no real consensus on what (if anything) we should do about it, corporate behavior is definitely on the radar screen. In one level it should be obvious that corporations exist to maximize profits and there's no...more
I can honestly say that this book changed my life, even though I didn't finish it.
Flash back to late April 2008. Shane and I are in the car en route home from Harrisonburg, where we've been visiting friends. It's a gorgeous spring day in Virginia, and I decide to pass the time driving home reading about the food industry. I make it about five pages in, then slam the book shut and tell Shane that the food industry pisses me off.
Those five pages were the first significant step in the direction of...more
Flash back to late April 2008. Shane and I are in the car en route home from Harrisonburg, where we've been visiting friends. It's a gorgeous spring day in Virginia, and I decide to pass the time driving home reading about the food industry. I make it about five pages in, then slam the book shut and tell Shane that the food industry pisses me off.
Those five pages were the first significant step in the direction of...more
Feb 11, 2009
Amy
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
People concerned with health & nutrition and who are struggling to get and/or remain healthy.
This information in this book is priceless. It is shocking how the food industry functions, and our society seriously needs to start thinking for themselves, instead of buying into all the propoganda the media is throwing our way, if we ever want to be healthier and prevent more obesity and chronic disease. HOWEVER...this book definitely reads like a text book. It is not an "easy" read. It is slow going for me, but I value everything I've read. I highly recommend Michael Pollan's "In Defense of...more
I hold Marion Nestle is high regard, and Food Politics is my favorite of her books. Rereading it this week, I am reminded why: she is smart as can be, writes clean, tight prose, supports her arguments thoroughly, and never overstates her case. As science writers goes, she is virtually peerless.
And her case is an important one: Food Politics examines the enormous power of the food corporations to influence our govt regulatory agencies, nutrition advice, and our eating decisions.
Health claims on...more
And her case is an important one: Food Politics examines the enormous power of the food corporations to influence our govt regulatory agencies, nutrition advice, and our eating decisions.
Health claims on...more
I didn't actually finish this -- just had to return it to the library at last. It's pretty slow and repetitive, at least in the first half. I learned there pretty much what I already knew:
1. The gov't's advice to citizens about how to eat healthily is heavily influenced by food industry lobbying. Also, the food industry influences laws about food and nutrition. Duh. But she does give good examples in the book and shows it to be a serious problem considering North Americans serious dietary issues...more
1. The gov't's advice to citizens about how to eat healthily is heavily influenced by food industry lobbying. Also, the food industry influences laws about food and nutrition. Duh. But she does give good examples in the book and shows it to be a serious problem considering North Americans serious dietary issues...more
Jul 08, 2007
Gwen
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Anyone interested in agriculture or the food industry
UPDATE: I finished the book. It's ok, but a bit dense for a casual reader, I think. If you're an academic really interested in how food companies affect public policy it's great, but if you're just reading it for fun, all the minute details of policy changes get a little boring. I skimmed a lot of the chapters and just read the most interesting parts. I found the chapters on marketing in schools to be the most interesting.
I'm only two chapters in but it's fascinating. Some of the first two chapt...more
I'm only two chapters in but it's fascinating. Some of the first two chapt...more
It's really scary to realize that the government agencies that are supposed to protect us from contaminated food and dangerous food additives/supplements really have no power. While Food Politics is a little technical, it has plenty of charts, examples, and descriptions of historical battles over the regulation of food. It was amazing to see how food companies use their muscle to get away with so much. It's worth a browse, at least. I think food regulation (especially with last summer's Spinach...more
If you ever wanted to find out how "sausages" (laws and regulations) are actually made and implemented, and if you have a strong stomach for rage and disgust, this book is for you. Marion Nestle (no relation to the food corporation) has revealed how the food industry successfully suppressed government attempts to offer the simple, sane advice, “eat less.” If you had any doubt that agribusiness is not our friend, here is the truth from a nutrition expert who has also served as a regulatory inside...more
The emphasis here is on the word "politics". There is a lot of discussion on how food corporations defend their interests in Washington with lobbyists and lawyers.
I turned to this book after reading books by Eric Schlosser and Michael Pollan which I found fascinating. By comparison Food Politics reads like a graduate school textbook, no joke. There is some very important information delivered but I have to say it is a rough slog because the writing is dry and a little repetitive.
I turned to this book after reading books by Eric Schlosser and Michael Pollan which I found fascinating. By comparison Food Politics reads like a graduate school textbook, no joke. There is some very important information delivered but I have to say it is a rough slog because the writing is dry and a little repetitive.
A very through and well cited book. It reads like a 400 page research paper which makes for a very dense and dry read, though incredibly informative. I found myself disagreeing several times with the author's point-of-view on food and some of her nutritional conclusions, but I considered them to be minor issues, though it makes me hesitant to recommend. The author very effectively illustrates how the food supply is primarily influenced and directed by the government to benefit big business, inst...more
Marion Nestle is one of my favorite food writers, and "Food Politics" is probably her best-known work. If what you're looking for is a better understanding of the politics of food, there's no better starting point. It explores the influence that business, lobbyists, and organizations have over the government regulation of our food and our nutrition. If that sounds dull, the book is not. It's information-packed, but it's worth your time. Food Politics is one of those books that makes you marvel a...more
A re-read which was just as depressing as the first time.
Industry interests (i.e., profit) trump ethical concerns about people's health, and Nestle demonstrates how the US government goes along with this.
Comprehensive and thick on details; probably not the most approachable because of it, but it's fascinating for anyone who has any interest in the subject in the first place.
Industry interests (i.e., profit) trump ethical concerns about people's health, and Nestle demonstrates how the US government goes along with this.
Comprehensive and thick on details; probably not the most approachable because of it, but it's fascinating for anyone who has any interest in the subject in the first place.
We need food to live yet there are compromises in what we consume. That's disturbing. This book gives a deep understanding of the challenges that arise because of the conflicting interests of the different parties.
Since no food or supplement is 100% good or 100% bad, who's to blame if our health suffers? The responsibility gets shifted to us. How well equipped are we to make considered decisions? Reading this book helps you understand the issues.
Since no food or supplement is 100% good or 100% bad, who's to blame if our health suffers? The responsibility gets shifted to us. How well equipped are we to make considered decisions? Reading this book helps you understand the issues.
"A courageous and masterful exposé." - Julia Child
So says the back cover, and I can't disagree.
But I'm not going to go around recommending this to people. It's dry as a bone, feels like a textbook, and would be very difficult for anyone not already interested in these issues to get through (Michael Pollan she's not). On the other hand, if you *are* already interested in this stuff, much of it feels obvious, and like Nestle is beating a dead horse, repeating herself, or knocking down straw men....more
So says the back cover, and I can't disagree.
But I'm not going to go around recommending this to people. It's dry as a bone, feels like a textbook, and would be very difficult for anyone not already interested in these issues to get through (Michael Pollan she's not). On the other hand, if you *are* already interested in this stuff, much of it feels obvious, and like Nestle is beating a dead horse, repeating herself, or knocking down straw men....more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...









view all 8 comments


















