Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “A Talent For War (Alex Benedict, #1)” as Want to Read:
A Talent For War (Alex Benedict, #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

A Talent For War (Alex Benedict #1)

3.76  ·  Rating Details ·  4,524 Ratings  ·  316 Reviews
Christopher Sim changed mankind's history forever when he forged a rag-tag group of misfits into the weapon that broke the alien Ashiyyur. But now, one man believes Sim was a fraud, and Alex must follow the legend into the heart of the alien galaxy to confront a truth far stranger than any fiction.
Mass Market Paperback, 310 pages
Published 1989 by Sphere Books Limited
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Brad
Mar 25, 2013 Brad rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: sci-fi, 2016-shelf
This just might be some of the most creative Space Opera You've Never Heard Of. Or maybe you follow the Nebulas, the best SF nominated by other SF/F authors, and you recognize that this is fan service for and by the professionals of the field, and so praise from these people usually means that the writer has Talent.

Talent for War, or not, I have to agree in pretty much all particulars. What struck me right off the bat was the heavy elements of Mystery lit. It's solid as hell, in fact.

It's merel
...more
Brooke
Mar 26, 2013 Brooke rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: science-fiction, 2013
I was hesitant about trying McDevitt again after reading Time Travelers Never Die. I'd described that book as "light and fluffy" and while I didn't think it was BAD, it wasn't the sort of thing I would purposely seek out.

However, I'm glad I gave A Talent for War a shot, because it was fabulous. It's basically a historical fiction mystery in a sci-fi setting. McDevitt has painted this really rich and captivating history about a war hero and the questions that main character Alex Benedict starts
...more
Jessica
Apr 02, 2008 Jessica rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: McDevitt Fans
Shelves: fantasyscifi
This is the first in a series by one of my favorite authors.

Alex Benedict learns that his uncle, who raised him, has disappeared along with several hundred other people aboard a space space headed for a remote location. His uncle leaves him the entire estate, along with the mystery that consumed his life before his disappearance. But Alex isn't the only one trying to solve the ancient puzzle of what happened to the Confederacy's most admired war hero and the other parties involved are much more
...more
Eric
Feb 23, 2012 Eric rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Sci-fi and mystery fans
Recommended to Eric by: Orson Scott Card
Shelves: science-fiction
I decided to read this after reading a complimentary review from Orson Scott Card, where he points out how original the concept behind this series is.

It is a mash-up between the science fiction, mystery and adventure genres, where an Indiana Jones-type antiquities dealer/amateur historian hunts for relics from a war two centuries past, which is still in our very distant future.

At points, the pacing bogged down with sections of exposition and world history, and the character development was lack
...more
lukk
Будь у меня более устойчивые к потрясениям нервные клетки, я бы только и делала, что читала такой сай-фай. Роскошная, растянувшаяся на невероятные расстояния космоопера насыщена детективной составляющей, которая ведет читателя за руку элегантно и неторопливо, чтобы в конце раскрыть карты в такой взрывной ярости и запредельной меланхолии, что попеременно руки сжимаются в кулаки и захлестывают ледяные волны безмолвия и одиночества. Я все еще пребываю в состоянии эйфории после прочтения, поэтому ме ...more
Jamie Collins
I’ve never read McDevitt before, and this was a pleasant surprise. It’s quite well written, and while the slow pacing won’t suit everyone, I enjoyed this. I picked it up without knowing anything about it, and based on the title and cover I was expecting Alex Benedict to be some sort of space marine fighting in an interstellar war. Instead, he’s an antiques dealer (I think the cover image is supposed to be someone else) and the war between humanity and telepathic aliens ended 200 years ago.

The fi
...more
Ramsey Hootman
Seriously, seriously boring.

Having read and enjoyed McDevitt's Academy series, I figured I'd be just as happy starting in on Alex Benedict. Jack McDevitt is sort of my guilty pleasure reading - fun sci fi adventures, not too deep, easy reading, with the alien civilization/archaeology bits I like.

A Talent for War has just proved boring, though. I'm, I dunno, maybe halfway through, and the only thing that's happened is that Alex's uncle died and Alex is trying to figure out where he was going whe
...more
Philip
Jun 04, 2012 Philip rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
I can't believe I slogged through this entire book. I can't remember the last time I read a more tedious book. A completely unlikable protagonist, dialog that is mostly the reading of history books, and a plot that is so bland, it barely qualifies as a plot.
Mike
Jan 31, 2012 Mike rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Of all my friends who read sci-fi, I've not met one who is a fan of Jack McDevitt. The only reason I discovered him was because my wife randomly picked up one of his books at the library when stocking up on reading material for our honeymoon. He has since become one of my favorites. A Talent for War is my most recent read from McDevitt, and it did not disappoint.

Like his other novels, A Talent for War is in a genre I would call "space archaeology". McDevitt's heroes are a bit like a futuristic I
...more
Xan
Apr 17, 2013 Xan rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Al terminar este libro tenía dudas sobre las sensaciones que me había dejado. Despues de haber leído la segunda parte se han despejado.

Mi gran error al empezara leer "Un talento para la guerra" fue pensar que estaba en un libro parecido a otras obras del autor. La serie de Alex Benedict no es ciencia ficción dura, ni siquiera space opera aunque entre dentro de la definición. Los libros de esta serie son novelas de detectives al estilo de los clásicos, con un argumento típico y pensada para entre
...more
Curtiss
Mar 18, 2013 Curtiss rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: science-fiction
A gem of a high-tech Sci-Fi mystery & thriller, in which Alex Benedict, a dealer in exotic antiquities several millenia in the future, first makes the acquaintance of his long-time partner and star-pilot Chase Kolpath, while investigating an archeological mystery bequeathed to him by his uncle.

The story revolves around the legend of a history teacher turned into an outstanding military strategist. One of the teacher's books is read two centuries after his death by the main character, and fea
...more
Sarah
Mar 14, 2011 Sarah rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This was a recommendation by a friend who actually brought it over for my husband to read while he receovers from spinal fusion surgery done earlier this month.
But since my husband isn't a huge reader, and his pain meds are interfering with his ability to focus (and he is stil on GRRM's 2nd volume in the Song of Ice & Fire series)...I snatched it up instead.

This was an absorbing read. I didn't know going into it whether there was any earlier books I should read first (luckily it was the 1st
...more
Bee
This was... fun. I'm not really sure if I prefer it to the Academy books, but I'm definitely going to keep reading the series. It's different. And I feel like he's given this more thought, or been freer in his reigning in his imagination. It's good, clean, not TOO pulpy space opera lite. Yeah, I think that nails it.

I suspect it will get significantly better.
Lars Dradrach
Apr 24, 2017 Lars Dradrach rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: e-book
Simply amazing that this little masterpiece is so relatively unknown, it belongs up with the bests.

The story expands slowly but at the same time builds a very convincing atmosphere of old empire mystic which are slowly revealed, there's a certain Star Wars feeling about it.

I simply have to pick up some of the other books in the series.
Scott Holstad
Jul 05, 2015 Scott Holstad rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
A Talent for War is an excellent mystery for a sci fi novel. Jack McDevitt has a real talent for creating new worlds, alien species, archeologies, suspense, and science fiction in general. I really like his books.

In this book, Alex Benedict finds out that his uncle Gabe dies, or rather disappears, in a star ship and leaves his estate to his favorite nephew. Alex moves home -- he grew up with Gabe -- only to find the house has been broken into and a few things have been stolen, including an impor
...more
Clark Hallman
Aug 22, 2012 Clark Hallman rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: science-fiction
A Talent for War is the first novel in Jack McDevitt’s Alex Benedict series, and it’s another good read from this ingenious story teller. The novel takes place about 9,000 years in the future. Space travel has been perfected enabling human civilizations to expand through a large part of our galaxy. However, unfriendly alien civilizations are also encountered. Alex Benedict receives a posthumous message from his uncle informing him to take over his lucrative business as an archeologist and finder ...more
Silviu
Jul 13, 2014 Silviu rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Even though the events of the books happen 9000 year or so in the future, they might as well have happened in our own back yard. The society described is to all intents and purposes indistinguishable from our own.

I found the story to be told in a bland and somewhat dull speech. It read like a textbook, which could be argued that is appropriate seeing most of the book is composed of history lessons. Also, the words were chosen carefully so that no trace of humor could be found anywhere within.

The
...more
Michael Jones
Mar 11, 2012 Michael Jones rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Michael by: Orson Scott Card
I read this book on recommendation (via his blog) from Orson Scott Card. It actually took me a while to get through it - not a lot of time for reading books that I have to use my eyes to read, now that I have to commute by car and not by bus - and it's the kind of book that requires some attention to things of a historical nature (although most of Alex Benedict's "history" is in our far distant future), and names of people and places are important to keep track of. The stories I usually read are ...more
Dan
Jan 24, 2009 Dan rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2009
It took a little too long for things to really catch on in this one. The main problem seems to be that McDevitt piles mystery upon mystery, until you forget why the characters are researching whatever it is they have in front of them. They have one lead on a person, which leads to another person, which leads to another few, and it goes deeper and deeper until they finally have something on the first person, and both the reader and (amusingly enough) Alex Benedict both says, "Who?". Along the way ...more
Amber
Aug 24, 2012 Amber rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I read the first three Alex Benedict novels and really liked them, and now I have three more to read and it's been a few years, I thought I'd start over from the beginning.

This first one, written some years before the author made it into a series and switched the POV to Alex's associate Chase Kolpath, is told by the main character as if it happened in his past.

It's not light reading, it's smart and entertaining, part scifi, part mystery, part a tribute to history, with some action/adventure pe
...more
Paul
Jul 16, 2012 Paul rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Alex Benedict lives in a time of a tenuous Confederacy of human-inhabited planets. The various planetary governments maintain their relationship to one another largely due to the shared military threat posed by the alien Ashiyyur species. Otherwise, the humans from different worlds hold each other in political distrust, a situation exacerbated by slow travel and communication technologies.

Benedict inherits from a deceased uncle an intriguing, albeit maddeningly undefined, historical puzzle. Were
...more
Glen
Sep 27, 2014 Glen rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
It must take a particular type of reader to enjoy this book. I found it unutterably boring.

The story is a not-really-murder mystery, although people do die. I enjoy mysteries, but only when the plot and characters are engaging. Here, they are not. There are two principal characters, and dozens of secondary characters. You never learn enough about any of them to care about them.

The story itself is the main character's journey though a long line of faint clues, starting with the disappearance of
...more
Lauri
Jan 03, 2015 Lauri rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Kahjuks ei olnud ikkagi nii lahe kui mõne saidi mõõdutundetut haipi ja ülistamist uskuma jääda. Algus oli päris hea, keskpigast alates aga hakkas sumbuma kuhugi sogasesse mulinass eja lõpp läks juba päris käest ära. Lõpp tuli üldse ülepeakaela, sisaldas endas ühte päris võimast "jumalat masinast" ja oli alguse mõistatusega proportsioonidest väljas. See tähendab, see mõistatus sumbus eelpoolnimetatud tühja mulinasse. Sellisest pisiasjast et enamus tegelasi - kaasa arvatud järgmiste romaanide mina ...more
Conal
May 06, 2013 Conal rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
A Talent for War by Jack McDevitt is the 1st book in the Alex Benedict series by this author. It fits the classification of several different genre’s including space opera, adventure, mystery and historical fiction. I enjoyed the characters quite a bit and some of the world building was spectacular though there were a few times where the locations got a little confusing. Alex Benedict is an Indiana Jones type of character and he makes his living off exploiting antiques from different finds withi ...more
Simon
May 25, 2010 Simon rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
A very good example of "future history". Two parallel storylines, set a couple centuries apart, yet both thousands of years from our own.

The book is not perfect; the main characters in the "normal" storyline are flat. They serve only as mouthpieces and narrators for the far more complex "historical" characters developed and explored in the other storyline.

McDevitt is a master plotter. The historical mystery unfolds at just the right pace, and is shaded with classical Greek history so as to lend
...more
Charles
Dec 22, 2008 Charles rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: sf
Took a while to get going and left me feeling vaguely dissatisfied. Partly, that's because the back cover said this historical legend (like, George Washington combined with Mazer Rackham AND Ender) was going to be revealed as a fraud, which is totally not what happened. And since I was getting steadily more annoyed at the hagiographic depiction of the guy when I never got the pay-off of discovering him to be a lousy guy or whatever, it was frustrating. Also, the mystery was a little clumsy.

All t
...more
Tristan Wong
Jan 24, 2011 Tristan Wong rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
While not the greatest (this will be short as well), it had a great personality and the backstory of the war between the Ashiyyear and the Dellacondas jumped out at me and kept me through the story in and out on Alex Benedict's adventure. While the writing was sub-par (too much mundane information that didn't exactly characterize Alex in any interesting way) and the dialogue a bit hammy and expository for its own good, it had a special story that really caught your attention... especially when t ...more
Craig Brown
Jun 08, 2011 Craig Brown rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This is a tough review to write, I almost quit reading the book once or twice and there were numerous times I couldn't put the book down. The book dwells on a war that took place 200 years ago and historical analysis of the war. It is the historical analysis that drags some. The excitement comes with the mystery of some artifact that is being searched for and why that artifact is so important. There are some parts that can be figured out prior to the conclusion, but while I thought I was correct ...more
CatBookMom
I found this book to be very thought-provoking: about the nature of war, about what is recorded in history, about heroes and the legacies and mythos they leave behind. While there is a great deal of what might be called hard science-fiction, there is also a lot about historians and about the process of research, and about what may be found in the stories of ordinary people who live through extraordinary or notable events.

I highly recommend this book.
Mike
Apr 16, 2015 Mike rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: scifi, xcharity-2016
I'll be very generous in giving 3 Stars to this tale of a wimpy "Indiana Jones" in search of an artifact in space. No reason why it had to be a scifi novel, could have been done anywhere. Takes a long time to get going but the ending was satisfactory. Easy writing style kept my interest enough to finish. Hope the sequels are better.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Goodreads Librari...: Data issues and add cover 2 12 May 04, 2017 09:07AM  
  • Night Train to Rigel (Quadrail, #1)
  • Coyote Frontier (Coyote Trilogy, #3)
  • The Eternity Artifact
  • The Disappeared (Retrieval Artist, #1)
  • Fire with Fire (Tales of the Terran Republic, #1)
  • The Quiet War (The Quiet War #1)
  • Starship: Rebel (Starship, #4)
  • Cosmonaut Keep (Engines Of Light, #1)
  • The Myriad (Tour of the Merrimack, #1)
  • Prador Moon  (Polity Universe, #1)
  • The Seeds of Earth (Humanity's Fire, #1)
  • Moonwar (The Grand Tour, #6; Moonbase Saga, #2)
  • The Battle at the Moons of Hell (Helfort's War, #1)
  • Galactic North
73812
Jack McDevitt is a former English teacher, naval officer, Philadelphia taxi driver, customs officer and motivational trainer. His work has been on the final ballot for the Nebula Awards for 12 of the past 13 years. His first novel, The Hercules Text, was published in the celebrated Ace Specials series and won the Philip K. Dick Special Award. In 1991, McDevitt won the first $10,000 UPC Internation ...more
More about Jack McDevitt...

Other Books in the Series

Alex Benedict (7 books)
  • Polaris (Alex Benedict, #2)
  • Seeker (Alex Benedict, #3)
  • The Devil's Eye (Alex Benedict, #4)
  • Echo (Alex Benedict, #5)
  • Firebird (Alex Benedict, #6)
  • Coming Home (Alex Benedict, #7)

Share This Book