American Dream: Three Women, Ten Kids, and a Nation's Drive to End Welfare
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

American Dream: Three Women, Ten Kids, and a Nation's Drive to End Welfare

4.03 of 5 stars 4.03  ·  rating details  ·  484 ratings  ·  79 reviews
In this definitive work, two-time Pulitzer finalist Jason DeParle cuts between the mean streets of Milwaukee and the corridors of Washington to produce a masterpiece of literary journalism. At the heart of the story are three cousins whose different lives follow similar trajectories. Leaving welfare, Angie puts her heart in her work. Jewell bets on an imprisoned man. Opal...more
Paperback, 422 pages
Published August 30th 2005 by Penguin Books (first published 2004)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Oliver Twist by Charles DickensLes Misérables by Victor HugoCorpalism by Arun D. EllisThe Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark TwainA Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens
Underclass
54th out of 259 books — 88 voters
All the President's Men by Carl BernsteinThe Glass Castle by Jeannette WallsBlack Like Me by John Howard GriffinThe Perfect Storm by Sebastian JungerThe Bookseller of Kabul by Åsne Seierstad
Books by Journalists
50th out of 361 books — 47 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,278)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Lobstergirl
Jan 03, 2010 Lobstergirl rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: people interested in real life effects of social policy
This book - about the effects on three Milwaukee families of Clinton's drive to radically alter welfare in the 1990s by making women work - grew on me. I think perhaps it could be better organized; it flops around chronologically and topically, and the subject matter would be better served by something more linear. The book focuses on three women, but there are enough relatives, ancestors, husbands, boyfriends, lovers, and crack addict buddies that clarity and simplicity in the narrative become...more
Michael
It took me two weeks to read this book, which is a bit unusual. I kept putting it down at first, not because it's bad, but because it was bothering me so much. American Dream is a book about public policy, but it's told in a narrative fashion. The author--the 'poverty reporter' for the New York Times, traces the lives of three young women living in Milwaukee during the 1990s during the end of the federal welfare program. I've previously read a very comprehensive policy book on anti-poverty progr...more
Jcigna
This book told the tale of Three Welfare Mothers right before welfare reform. What I learned from this book is to not extrapolate from their tales what it means to be on welfare and a mother. They are not characters, they are three individuals who don't represent anybody but themselves.

DeParle does a fantastic job at describing and humanizing three women who were demonized by congress and pundits; the archetypes which led to welfare's upheaval. But we must realize that they were not the normal...more
Larry Bassett
I have been a welfare worker in 1969 and 2007. This book is true to life.

My assessment of the lying/cheating aspect of welfare based on my experience as a worker is this: Welfare is like gambling. You can give incorrect information or omit to give some required bit of information. If you are not "caught," you will get more money. Welfare is usually below subsistence level. If you are a mother and your children are suffering (whatever your definition is), you might elect to withhold or provide fa...more
Anjali
I picked this book off my reading list for Bryan Stevenson's Race, Poverty, & Criminal Justice class. I don't usually read non-fiction, but I may make future exceptions for books recommended by Bryan Stevenson.

Jason DeParle is a journalist who covered welfare for the NY Times. The book describes the political events surrounding the passage of the welfare bill in the 1990s and follows its effect on three Black women who were receiving welfare at the time. I found the political sections kind o...more
Tim
This really was journalism at its best, weaving small scale personal stories into a broader narrative. I opposed the "W-2" welfare reform effort to eliminate welfare in Wisconsin, and I think this book justifies my opposition: the program was obviously corrupt from the start (I suspect "privatization" efforts often are) and the purpose of the program was not ending poverty, just ending welfare. Yet the book is pretty honest in also justifying the drive to end welfare as a (possibly) legitimate g...more
Leif Erik
Assigned in my Poli-Sci Public Issues class. Interesting account of welfare reform, taking in the big picture and the human scale. You definately get a sense of what welfare is actually about, as compared to the demonizing & sob stories that normally surround the issue. The facts on the ground will challenge your assumptions no matter what ideological baggage you carry.
mike
Excellent book. I read this closely several years ago and came away unimpressed, perhaps because I was hoping it'd be as great as Nicholas Lemann's "The Promised Land" (1991), one of my all-time favorites.

Now, after further reflection — and having typed-up 40,000 words of notes from "American Dream" — I'm substantially raising my opinion of this book. I think it ranks right up there with "The Promised Land" and Elijah Anderson's great book "Code of The Streets" (1999).

DeParle in 2004 was not n...more
Amber
Oh man, was I conflicted about this book. It is intricately researched and reported, and I learned a ton about the trajectory of welfare reform, which I was too young to remember as it happened. And the author does a fantastic job following the lives of three women on welfare in Milwaukee, weaving their stories with changes in both national and state-level policy.

Despite how well constructed it is, though, the book ultimately disappointed me. In the scheme of Americans, I'm probably slightly lef...more
Rebecca Brooker
In all honesty, this is a disheartening but interesting look at welfare in the US from its inception through the Clinton administration's eager drive to put welfare mothers into jobs. Readers get a brief history of the purpose of the system, its entanglement with the post-slavery era, a vivid look at three mothers who survive - to some extent - the changes in welfare under Clinton, and an inarguable look at a broken system that will be difficult to change. DeParle's writing weaves facts with per...more
Ellen Pierson
Jason DeParle came to the Welfare beat with years of journalistic experience and a perspective that one would probably more or less expect from a New York Times reporter. The story he compiled after a decade of research – a decade during which his subjects persevered on and off the welfare rolls despite disappointments and setbacks – defies easy ideological classification. It says something when the Times and the National Review both praise your book. Mainly, it says that the challenges of entr...more
Erin
This was a really interesting book about welfare..it gave a brief history of how the program started..it was originally meant as a transitional program for white widows with children to use temporarily until their husband's social security kicked in..eventually it was transferred to an entitlement program for minorities and became the worst drain on the American taxpayer possible. During the Clinton administration, Republicans forced him to create a path to work for welafre recipiants with time...more
Charlotte
The author has written an interesting and informative book about welfare and welfare reform. The author brought the understanding of welfare reform to life by interweaving discussion of policy and politics with stories about the lives of three women in Milwaukee on welfare. The three women who the author followed were sympathetically yet realistically portrayed as complex human beings trying to do the best they can within the circumstances they live in.

This book has managed to reaffirm my belie...more
Abby
Dec 20, 2007 Abby rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: people interested in welfare and social justice
Shelves: non-fiction
A detailed, if somewhat outdated, account of welfare and welfare reform/dissolution.

The author has been covering poverty in the U.S. for the New York Times for years (15?), and therefore has personalized and contextualized knowledge of the issues. This book alternates between the politics of welfare and the stories of 3 Midwestern women, which is a really nice method for humanizing the policies and explaining how these women are subject to economic forces beyond their control. The stories of the...more
Katie
A complex, in depth and even-handed look at the transition from AFDC to TANF nationally and locally. DeParle balances extensively researched statistics and interviews with policy wonks and politicians (as poverty correspondent for the NYT he is very well connected) with the story of 3 women and their families on welfare in Milwaukee. I found it particularly interesting because so much of the book involved WI and Milwaukee.

His conclusion is that TANF did push women off welfare and on to (mostly l...more
Chrisiant
Good comprehensive and accessible narrative non-fiction. Having been roughly 9 years old when the big Welfare Bill was passed in 1994, I don't have a clear sense of how it happened or the relevant political fights that were going on at the time. Several chapters outlined that process, in a clear and relatively colorful way (for a description of a legislative fight).

I found lots of striking information in the stories of the three women: their sense of themselves as strong, scrappy problem-solvers...more
Peggy
A bit repetitive at times, but this book did a good job of showing me, a largely bleeding heart liberal, exactly HOW welfare reform failed. For one, the author makes a point that many welfare recipients were secretly working on the side anyway, because neither welfare alone nor a minimum wage job alone was enough for these families to make it. So for all the "success" claimed by the politicians in terms of the reform pushing folks off of welfare rolls and into jobs, the book makes the argument t...more
Ocean
as someone who works in the welfare field, this book taught me a lot. i learned a lot about the controversial welfare reform going on in the 90's, largely blamed on bill clinton (although this book shows the actual process of that whole mess, & it's a lot more complicated than just clinton.) the author also profiles an extended family who was on welfare before the reforms & then was kicked off the rolls. this part is where the book shines. unlike many pieces i've read about welfare recip...more
Michele :)
I absolutly loved this book. As a single mother in Wisconsin who has struggled to make ends meet for the last 9 years this book really spoke to me. DeParle follows four young women and their children for an extended period of time in Milwaukee, Wisconsin through "welfare reform". The book critically examines issues of job training, education, economic support, and other daily struggles poor mothers and thier children face. DeParle is close enough to the women he followed to be able to shed some...more
Amanda
This is both a good study of the welfare-to-work program from a journalistic perspective, but also a window into just how hard it is to be a member of the truly working poor. The story centered on three (mostly) single moms trying to raise their families and survive after Clinton's push to "end welfare as we know it". I felt varying degrees of empathy and exasperation for the characters - on the one hand, you see how hard these women work just to hold things together and prioritize the things in...more
Kate
Very complete look at welfare reform, and the problems several women encountered in Milwaukee trying to leave welfare in the 1990s immediately after President Clinton and the Republicans overhauled AFDC.

Also goes into the history of the program, how it came to be overwhelmingly tangled in the issue of race, behind the scenes maneuvering in Washington within the Clinton Administration and between the right-wing Congress.

I'm making this sound like a sort of dry book but it's not at all; I read i...more
Elyssa
This book should be listed among my all-time favorites. I learned more about the welfare system and its history from American Dream. In the beginning of the book, the author shows the complex relationship between slavery/race and today's welfare system. This was a major paradigm shift for me and reframed the way I view the welfare system.

The author goes on to beautifully weave the personal stories of three welfare recipients with the transformations of the welfare system, particularly the imple...more
Katy
For the past ten years I have worked with a lot of kids and families on welfare and in poverty, without actually living that way myself. I keep searching for a new perspective on it - something that will click in my mind and give me a new direction for how I can help, educate, inspire, whatever it is that I should do to make a positive difference.

This book didn't really clear any of that up for me, but what it does do is look at the actions of some (i.e Clinton administration), which may have t...more
David Quinn
Overall a good and interesting book if a bit uneven. The sections on the politics of welfare in the first half of the book were necessary and illuminating but a bit dry. The stories of the three women were generally good but felt somewhat rushed and muddled at times. The final third of the book was excellent, particularly the author’s insights into the impact of welfare reform on the people profiled.

Some other books (all of which I preferred) that overlapped the themes in this book which I’d rec...more
Kirsti
"This is a reporter's endeavor: no names have been changed, characters melded, or quotes invented."

The reporter for the New York Times's poverty beat spent several years chronicling the lives of three women affected by the "end of welfare as we know it." Some of the policy-wonk stuff gets a little dull, but just about everything about the women and their families is fascinating, even the everyday stuff. I didn't know that nursing aides get injured at twice the rate of coal miners and earn less t...more
Sarah
This book examines the impact of welfare reform initiatives, particularly Clinton's drive to "end welfare as we know it". DeParle follows three women through the years prior to and following the passage of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act of '96. The women live in Milwaukee so much of the focus is on the Wisconsin "welfare-to-work" programs. The stories were captivating and provided an excellent illustration for the points the author made about the larger system. I would defi...more
Alexandra
Read this book to get a better understanding of how social welfare policy is shaped and the effect of that policy on real people. I got a little lost in some of the chapters devoted to the political backdrop for the 1996 welfare-to-work revolution because I just couldn't keep all the players straight. However, the majority of the book is highly accessible, readable, and illuminating. The chapters on the three women whose lives the author uses to track the impact of this legislative overhaul are...more
Mark Sorial
When I was assigned to read a book and do a project on it, I randomly went to the library and blindly picked a book to do it on. Little did I know that this book would honestly have a huge impact on my perspective on struggles of life and the fact that we as humans overlook things that seem small to us but in reality a big deal to others. This book is about three individual women struggling to raise and support their kids as well as themselves in a time of complete distress in their lives. It is...more
A'Tru Dreamx
This book was a good read especially to be written from the sociologist perspective. As with any writing in that field the statistics can be a disruption to the story. I ultimately loved the story and the research conducted. I would've given it more stars, but was very disappointed with the ending. This book is a must read for anyone wanting a glimpse into the real world of underclass, minority, poor women. It is not always a lack of want, but lack of access. I appreciate the author for his stud...more
Dawn
This is a fantastic book about welfare and welfare reform. It is a great blend of statistics and case-study method. The author begins with a family's more distant history (as slaves) and continues to track the same family/friend group through generations. It is uncommon to find a book on the subject of welfare that is so balanced--the author's main goal is to inform, and he is compassionate yet not over-the-top bleeding heart. It gave me a great deal of perspective on the daily lives of people o...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 42 43 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Promises I Can Keep: Why Poor Women Put Motherhood Before Marriage
  • No Shame in My Game: The Working Poor in the Inner City
  • Flat Broke with Children: Women in the Age of Welfare Reform
  • Rachel and Her Children: Homeless Families in America
  • The Working Poor: Invisible in America
  • The Other America: Poverty in the United States
  • American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass
  • Class Matters
  • Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life
  • The Lost Children of Wilder: The Epic Struggle to Change Foster Care
  • The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy
  • On Their Own: What Happens to Kids When They Age Out of the Foster Care System
  • Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City
  • The Trouble with Diversity: How We Learned to Love Identity and Ignore Inequality
  • Off the Books: The Underground Economy of the Urban Poor
  • All God's Children
  • Tell Them Who I Am: The Lives of Homeless Women
  • Unforgivable Blackness: The Rise and Fall of Jack Johnson
Jason DeParle is a senior writer at The New York Times and a frequent contributor to The New York Times Magazine. A graduate of Duke University, DeParle won a George Polk Award in 1999 for his reporting on the welfare system and was a two-time finalist for the Pulitzer Prize. He lives in Washington, D.C., with his wife, Nancy-Ann, and their two sons.
More about Jason DeParle...
American Dream

Share This Book