Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Temptation Bay (Windfall Island #1)” as Want to Read:
Temptation Bay (Windfall Island #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Temptation Bay (Windfall Island #1)

3.48  ·  Rating Details ·  157 Ratings  ·  87 Reviews
Anna Sullivan brings us the first book in her witty new contemporary romance series set off the coast of Maine.

Temptation Never Tasted So Sweet...

Maggie Solomon has always been one of Windfall Island's favorite daughters. A beautiful, passionate charter pilot who loves this remote Maine island, Maggie has never cared much for outsiders—until her latest passenger arouses t
Paperback, 384 pages
Published December 17th 2013 by Forever (first published January 1st 2013)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Temptation Bay, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Temptation Bay

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
The set up
Maggie Solomon is a charter pilot living in Windfall Island, Maine. Her life changes the moment she picks up her latest client to transport him to the island from nearby Portland. Dexter (Dex) Keegan, a Boston-based private investigator, is posing as a lawyer in order to investigate the possible ancestors of a baby abducted over 80 years ago. They stand to be entitled to a family fortune. Maggie and Dex have an immediate chemistry but she's highly resistant.

The issues
The island has a
Jacob Proffitt
Sep 12, 2013 Jacob Proffitt rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: romance, steamy
This was an ARC acquired through Netgalley.

The book is an extremely strong showing for a new author. Though fictional, the setting feels real enough that I had no trouble picturing the island of Windfall and its inhabitants—both shaped by the cold North Atlantic location. The characters are strongly evocative, with a good balance of the unique and the universal to make the reader feel that they know people just like this (even though you might wish you didn't).

I rather enjoyed the romance, too,
Les Romantiques
Posted on Les Romantiques - Le forum du site
Reviewed by Rinou
Review Copy from the Publisher

I didn’t know Anna Sullivan before NetGalley suggested her first book to me (and the first installment in a series whose second is scheduled for next year). Romantic suspense is one of my favorite genres, but in spite of certain qualities I was never really pulled into the story.

Maggie is the owner and pilot of the air transport company of Windfall Island. Her father, high-ranking military man, always repr
Take one sexy hunk, working undercover to solve a mysterious kidnapping that took place almost a century before, bring him to the close-knit community of Windfall Island and kick in one beautiful, hard-headed and independent local favorite and watch the fur fly! Maggie is distrustful of outsiders, protective of her island and her attraction to Dex is something she is determined to fight. Meanwhile, every woman on the island wants Dex’s attentions, but there is just something about Maggie that ...more
Marilyn Rondeau
Dec 14, 2013 Marilyn Rondeau rated it really liked it

Even though Maggie Solomon hadn’t been born on Windfall Island, she was one of the island’s favorite people. Beautiful, passionate and loyal, Maggie loved Windfall and it’s inhabitants with all her heart. As a charter pilot who just happens to bring ‘outsiders’ onto the island she was happiest when she brought them back to the mainland. However, her latest passenger Dexter Keegan was more than just a passenger arousing the natural curiosity of the island natives, as well as arousing feelings in
Romancing the Book
Oct 11, 2014 Romancing the Book rated it it was amazing
Reviewed by Allison
Book provided by NetGalley for review
Review originally posted at Romancing the Book

This book has several things going for it: It’s set on an island in Maine (which I love), the author has created very strong characters, and I liken the story as having a “Nora Roberts-esque” voice. I LOVED this book, and I’m dying because the next book in the series is not out until next March!

Maggie Solomon has lived on Windfall Island since her teen years, when her overbearing Navy officer fa
Sep 11, 2013 Brooke rated it liked it
Shelves: arcs
Wow. I am TOTALLY sucked into this story and SUPER BUMMED that I didn't realize it's the first in the series and not a stand alone at that. Now I can't WAIT for Ms. Sullivan to finish writing the series!

I love a good romance and I love it even more when there's a crime/mystery intertwined in the story that the leading couple is working to figure out. Temptation Bay had everything my heart could desire in a good story and then some.

Dex is a private investigator who comes to Windfall Island to inv
"Temptation Bay" was appealing - small town romance; sassy, smart heroine; hero with a sense of humor (actually they both had a good humor); a strong mystery; and heat that sparked off the page.

Dex is on Windfall Island to find a missing heiress, but his work is a secret. Maggie is an islander who owns a plane service on the island and flies him over. There's an immediate physical attraction but they bump heads, particularly over the truth about his stay on the island. Maggie is spunky, quick-wi
Sep 26, 2013 Laylaw rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: arc-review
*This honest review was done in exchange for an Arc*

Temptation Bay had a great start to the book, I was hooked on the story of prohibition, a mysterious baby, a boat explosion, and rum runners. Gripped from the get go- Maggie is a pilot on a small island who handles all the charters and has the business of everyone coming and going.

She is hauling special forces-turned cop-turned PI Dex Keegan to the island for a mysterious reason. He has a front as a lawyer and doesn't provide Maggie with his re
Windfall Island, Maine is the setting for the mystery of what happened to Eugenia Stanhope, a baby kidnapped in October 1931. PI, Dexter 'Dex' Keegan comes to the island posing as an attorney but does not tell the close mouthed community what he is looking for. Maggie Solomon comes into his confidence when he figures he will not solve his case and make a name for himself without help. As they get closer to the truth, a break into his room at the local inn, a mysterious rock slide and finally an ...more
Dec 06, 2013 Wendy rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: dec-13
Temptation Bay is the first book in a new series about the kidnapping of a baby, an heiress, in 1931 and the investigation to find her descendants.
Sexy Dex Keegan, PI, was hired by the Stanhope family to question the inhabitants of Windfall Island and he is flown in by charter pilot Maggie Solomon. Windfall is Maggie's home, where she has her business and she is very protective of it's tight knit community. Realizing he is getting nowhere with the residents of the island Dex asks for Maggie's he
♡ Sassy ~ Amy ♡
This is the first book in a new series… It was a great introduction to a new author!

The main undercurrent of a plot is that Dexter Keegan comes to the Island to find the descendants of the kidnapped Stanhope heiress… BUT someone doesn't want them found…

Dexter comes to the island via helicopter flown by Maggie who owns the tiny airport on the island… Dexter Likes Maggie right away & she is pretty smitten with him, but he's an outsider hiding something…

It was a good story that I couldn't pu
Aug 31, 2015 Jo rated it it was amazing
A century old missing person case, a remote island off the coast of Maine, a sexy female favorite daughter and the handsome ex-cop turned private investigator makes Temptation Bay a action packed romance.

I want to thank Anna Sullivan, the author of Temptation Bay and Goodreads First Reads for my copy of this book.
Feb 27, 2015 Misty rated it really liked it
Loved this one! Cannot wait to hit book two.......great story with great characters. Loved the cliff hanger ending
Jul 27, 2014 MsChris1161 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: own, reviewed
This book was crazy good! I took a chance on a new author when offered the opportunity to give an honest review in exchange for the ebook from NetGalley. I am so glad I did!! There is so much to like about TEMPTATION BAY I hope I can put it into words to make you understand this is a Must-Read!!

The premise is that Private Investigator, Dex Keegan, comes to Windfall Island to investigate the unsolved or cold case of a missing heiress who was kidnapped at 8 months old about 80 years ago. He shows
Jul 28, 2014 Sue rated it liked it
In Temptation Bay (Windfall Island #1) by Anna Sullivan, private investigator Dex, posing as a lawyer, heads to Windfall Island in search of a long lost heir. Before he even gets to Windfall Island, he is distracted, attracted and intrigued by Maggie. Helicopter pilot Maggie calls Windfall Island home, and is very protective of the place and the people there. As soon as she sees Dex, she is conflicted because she is attracted to him, but doesn't trust him.

Dex's mission on Windfall Island is top
Dec 17, 2013 Kathy rated it liked it
3.5 stars.

Anna Sullivan's Temptation Bay is an entertaining first installment in the Windfall Island series. It is a lovely romance but I must confess it is the mystery aspect of the storyline that I found most intriguing.

At first I really was not sure if I was going to like either of the main characters. Maggie Solomon has built a successful charter service and while she is independent and fiercely loyal to her friends, she is incredibly stubborn and rather bristly. She has an extremely conten
Nov 02, 2013 Stacy rated it liked it
This first part of what I assume is to be a two-part arc was interesting and certainly entertaining. Maggie, emotionally distant due to growing up with a horrendously self-centered father, is determined to succeed at what she loves, flying, to spite her father. Windfall Island is her adopted home, with a few close friends as her family of choice. When she charters in an outsider asking questions about the history of the island, she and the rest of the residents instantly go on defense. But this ...more
May Mostly Romance
I received this book from GCP via NetGalley.

Anna Sullivan is the debut author and Temptation Bay is the first book in the series.

Before I begin reading, I think small town romance. But the blurb suggests a little bit of suspense involving the disappearance of a child almost a 100 years ago, I think it would be a great combination.

The prologue is not disappointing. It told the story from the age of prohibition when a group of smugglers found a baby girl. That scene makes me want to know more ab
Judy  at Musings and Ramblings
This is the first book in a new series by author Anna Sullivan. Never heard of her? Me neither, but never fear, this isn't a brand new author. She has been writing for years under the pseudonym Penny McCall. So feel free to jump right in with an experienced author who knows how to spin a story.

Maggie Solomon is a pilot. She has loved flying since she was a child and worked hard to own and operate her own charter business. When her father, a general in the Navy, sent her and her mother to live o
Nov 08, 2013 Margaret rated it really liked it
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Katie Fink
***Thanks to NetGalley and Forever (Grand Central Publishing) for providing me with a copy in exchange for an honest review***

4.5 stars

Maggie Solomon is a charter pilot headquartered on Windfall Island, a small island off the coast of Portland, Maine. Maggie doesn't much care for outsiders--until she meets Dexter Keegan, a handsome man who says he's a lawyer, on a chartered flight to Windfall at the end of tourist season. He is trying to find out something about the island, and Maggie tries to f
Lis Carey
Nov 01, 2013 Lis Carey rated it liked it
Shelves: fiction
Maggie Solomon has built a life and a business for herself on Windfall Island, the prickly, insular community descended from salvagers and wreckers, off the coast of Maine. Her mother grew up there, and left to marry Navy officer Phillip Solomon, but Maggie, their only child, a girl, and not willing to enter the Navy, was a sad disappointment to her father. Instead, she's returned to her mother's birthplace, become a part of the tightknit community, and built a charter business and a small ...more
Nov 11, 2013 Jan rated it really liked it
In 1931 at the height of Prohibition's rum running, a crew from Windfall Island picks up a load of liquor to run into the island under the noses of the Feds. Unbeknownst the them, they also pickup up a passenger, 10 month old heiress Eugenia Stanhope. The baby obviously comes from wealth, jeweled necklace and primo baby blanket and clothing. The party ship she was on exploded with all aboard lost shortly after the smugglers reached shore. The baby as well as her nurse are presumed lost.

The story
Hubbys Subbie
Jan 20, 2014 Hubbys Subbie rated it really liked it
Shelves: review-copy
I loved my visit to Windfall Island, and hope to return soon! This book has character--lots of characters! While our hero and heroine are both great, my favorite character in Temptation Bay has to be the island itself (of course, I'm including the islanders in "the island"). They are witty, loving, resentful, curious, stubborn, and most importantly, survivors.

Maggie fits right in with the islanders because she is all of those things. Her banter with Dex is humorous and authentic. Dex is everyth
Book of Secrets ☕
TEMPTATION BAY is the beginning of a new series about the kidnapping of the Stanhope heiress in 1931 and the investigation to find her descendants. New clues lead PI Dexter Keegan to tiny Windfall Island off the coast of Maine, and charter pilot Maggie Solomon is the one who flies him in. Maggie, nor the rest of the islanders, are happy about an outsider poking into their business, so Dex’s investigation proves difficult.

I really enjoyed the mystery and the setting. The prologue had me intrigued
Shannon L. Gonzalez
Dec 16, 2013 Shannon L. Gonzalez rated it it was amazing
Temptation Bay by Anna Sullivan
A spunky love story riddled from a mysterious past!

Temptation Bay alludes to what would tempt a person, be it the seduction of love, money, alcohol, gambling or secrecy. This romance touches on all of these temptations and more but with a twist. It is not your average romance. In fact it is filled with passion, but not the kind you are thinking. Small aircraft pilot and airline owner Maggie Solomon is passionate about her planes, copters and cars, not to mention th
Denise Van plew
Sep 13, 2013 Denise Van plew rated it really liked it
First glance is into a tale from long ago which tells of ships,a party,bootlegging and a event gone wrong and the result is a prize more precious than anyone hoped to find by one of the little town's inhabitants-a baby. Then you are flown in present time back to this now charming quaint little place of generations who steadfastly stayed and tourist season drawing to a close. So than meet Maggie who owns and flies her own plane bringing with her someone who will try and get behind the tough ...more
Liza Wiemer
Sep 17, 2013 Liza Wiemer added it
Shelves: net-galley
Temptation Bay is a sassy, intriguing, snarky, delicious mystery and romance novel rolled into one terrific read.

During Prohibition, Windfall Island's population deals with a epidemic of measles. People die, many of them children. When a baby is found in a boat, she becomes the daughter for someone on the island. The mystery begins and PI Dexter Keegan comes to Windfall Island to solve it. He's flown in by tough-as-nails Maggie Solomon and there's no denying their chemistry.

What I liked about t
Kat Morrisey
This is another book where the book centers around a couple, and although their story is complete by the last page, the overarching "mystery" is not fully solved. And I am finding that I am really starting to enjoy books like this.

This story centers on Maggie who is loved by all those in her small town, but keeps to herself in many regards, especially when it comes to matters of the heart. She has a contentious relationship with her dad and this is part of that reason.

I did find that, after aw
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Madison Mega-Mara...: Temptation Bay by Anna Sullivan 1 1 Nov 02, 2013 03:33PM  
  • Redemption (Soul, #1)
  • Hard to Handle (Love in the Balance #2)
  • Blazing Nights (Night Games #1)
  • Take Over at Midnight (The Night Stalkers, #7)
  • Safe in His Arms
  • Crave (The Dining Club #3)
  • The Fireside Inn (The Billionaire Bachelors, #1)
  • Mostly Murder (Claire Morgan #6)
  • Dead Sexy Dragon (Dragon Heat, #1)
  • Gravediggers
  • The Way Home (One-Eyed Jacks #2)
  • Fallen Desire (Fallen Desire, #1)
  • My Spy: Last Spy Standing (HQ: Texas, #2)
  • Yuletide Protector (The Precinct Task Force, #6; The Precinct #22)
  • Wild Child (Boys of Bishop, #1)
  • Sugar & Salt (Sugar House, #1)
  • Play by Play (Play Makers #1)
  • Dead Sexy

Other Books in the Series

Windfall Island (3 books)
  • Hideaway Cove (Windfall Island, #2)
  • Secret Harbor (Windfall Island, #3)

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »