169th out of 455 books
—
351 voters
Notes from Underground & The Double
‘It is best to do nothing! The best thing is conscious inertia! So long live the underground!’ Alienated from society and paralysed by a sense of his own insignificance, the anonymous narrator of Dostoyevsky’s groundbreaking Notes from Underground tells the story of his tortured life. With bitter sarcasm, he describes his refusal to become a worker in the ‘ant-hill’ of soc...more
Paperback, 288 pages
Published
July 30th 1972
by Penguin Classics
(first published 1864)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
A genius of a book written by a mind that can effortlessly delve into the nuts, bolts and avagadros of the psyche.
Regard this extract:
Every man has reminiscences which he would not tell to everyone, but only to his friends. He has other matters in his mind which he would not reveal even to his friends, but only to himself, and that in secret. But there are other things which a man is afraid to tell even to himself, and every decent man has a number of such things stored away in his mind. The mor...more
Regard this extract:
Every man has reminiscences which he would not tell to everyone, but only to his friends. He has other matters in his mind which he would not reveal even to his friends, but only to himself, and that in secret. But there are other things which a man is afraid to tell even to himself, and every decent man has a number of such things stored away in his mind. The mor...more
In both stories his characters make huge mistakes they pay for for the rest of their lives.
Notes from Underground is about a man so bound by 19th c. societal standards that he will not allow himself to be with the woman he loves because she is a prostitute. The female character, Liza, is compelling, gentle, sadly naive, and deserving of success.
The Double, is about a lonely man trying to climb the social ladder in Moscow. He meets someone exactly like himself with the same name and likeness wh...more
Notes from Underground is about a man so bound by 19th c. societal standards that he will not allow himself to be with the woman he loves because she is a prostitute. The female character, Liza, is compelling, gentle, sadly naive, and deserving of success.
The Double, is about a lonely man trying to climb the social ladder in Moscow. He meets someone exactly like himself with the same name and likeness wh...more
I've only read Notes from Underground for class, so my review is restricted to that:
I immediately enjoyed this book more than Crime and Punishment. Maybe I should go back and read that again sometime to see if the distance of years and not being forced to choke through it would help, but that's beside the point.
Dostoyevsky really impressed me with this one. The character is so well fleshed out and he's such a cranky, arrogant jerk it's hard not to laugh as he spews all his opinions like a grump...more
I immediately enjoyed this book more than Crime and Punishment. Maybe I should go back and read that again sometime to see if the distance of years and not being forced to choke through it would help, but that's beside the point.
Dostoyevsky really impressed me with this one. The character is so well fleshed out and he's such a cranky, arrogant jerk it's hard not to laugh as he spews all his opinions like a grump...more
This is a very compelling book on mankind. I would look forward to re reading it too. I need to check the edtion which i have read...perhaps tis is not the same....
Notes from Underground & The Double by Fyodor Dostoyevsky
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
This is a very compelling book on mankind. I would look forward to re reading it too. I need to check the edtion which i have read...perhaps tis is not the same....
View all my reviews
Notes from Underground & The Double by Fyodor DostoyevskyMy rating: 5 of 5 stars
This is a very compelling book on mankind. I would look forward to re reading it too. I need to check the edtion which i have read...perhaps tis is not the same....
View all my reviews
"Notes From Underground" pretty much blew my mind. Probably one of the only classic satires that I've ever enjoyed. I can really appreciate what Dostoyevsky was doing with his double-speak and Irony in his references to the Crystal Palace and "toothache" of humanity because I like novels that make me work and if you are looking for a brain-puzzle, this is it. After awhile it does become predictable in its unpredictability--- his tools of social awareness become recognized for what they are...unt...more
Boy, oh boy, was this certainly painful to read. Not only was the constant contradictory ideology the main character kept switching about hard to read, but the amount of second hand embarrassment I went through was unbearable. (Or was that just me?)
Nevertheless, it reminded me a lot of Albert Camus's ,The Stranger. The character is obviously very conflicted and at times the reader might experience that loss at well. Either you love this character for his, ahem, uniqueness. Or, to place it mildly...more
Nevertheless, it reminded me a lot of Albert Camus's ,The Stranger. The character is obviously very conflicted and at times the reader might experience that loss at well. Either you love this character for his, ahem, uniqueness. Or, to place it mildly...more
I'm glad that I'm not the only person that found this book hard to follow at times, but since it is a collection of thoughts from a man who is trapped in his own feelings of self-worthlessness it is understandable. Dostoyevsky is a write that one needs to be able to focus to be able to read an understand clearly, if it is possible to clearly understand much of his writings. It is not to say that he is not as he seems to be able to catch the essence of the human condition, particularly being a R...more
There is little that the underground man said that I took to be true (in his fictional world that is). He had such a distorted perception of everything that even the clock seemed to personal joy in tormenting him. I think he was being most honest when he was speaking to Liza at his home. He says “I had been humiliated, so I wanted to humiliate somebody else” (115). The underground man feels as if everyone is humiliating him and looks down on him. He claims that his servant is resentful and his c...more
Jun 23, 2009
Tom Holt
added it
I will need to read this book again. In "Notes from the Underground", the main character does not know himself at all, and yet knows himself perfectly at the same time. He is a depressed man who sadistically attacks his own self-image and attempts to nurse his self-inflicted wounds with short bouts of narcissism. He isolates himself 'underground' in his shabby apartment and cloisters himself off from any real human contact. He feels inferior to nearly everyone he encounters, including his own s...more
The author of the diary and the diary itself are, of course, imaginary. Nevertheless it is clear that such persons as the writer of these notes not only may, but positively must, exist in our society, when we consider the circumstances in the midst of which our society is formed. I have tried to expose to the view of the public more distinctly than is commonly done, one of the characters of the recent past. He is one of the representatives of a generation still living. In this fragment, entitled...more
Wherein an anonymous, alienated, and astringent civil servant entertains, but does not answer, the question, What is to be done when one reaches the certainty that nothing is certain? Told in two parts – first in an excerpt from the narrator’s journal, then as a brief allegorical story – the novel is a brilliant literary exercise in the rational futility from which Kierkegaard leapt, and Camus boldly pursued. Dostoevsky would expand the narrative surrounding this existentialist dilemma in an att...more
NFTU was quite a slow starter, but it soon picked up with the second part that i enjoyed much more than the first.
it was a lot funnier than expected, i expect (for some unknown reason) for most Russian Lit, especially written in the 19th century, to be quite dry and tedious, but this was bursting with comedy and i loved it.
The Double (the second novella in this book) was even better for me, i loved the writing style and i can see how it was called 'a poem of St Petersburg' with the prose and rhy...more
it was a lot funnier than expected, i expect (for some unknown reason) for most Russian Lit, especially written in the 19th century, to be quite dry and tedious, but this was bursting with comedy and i loved it.
The Double (the second novella in this book) was even better for me, i loved the writing style and i can see how it was called 'a poem of St Petersburg' with the prose and rhy...more
I should begin by saying that I did not read The Double. Notes from Underground was plenty for me to chew on for the time being. This story is written from the perspective of an absolutely and intentionally hateable anti-hero who is fueled by his own unstable and contradictory ideas about his own self worth. It was difficult to read, like watching a train crash in slow motion, wincing your way through every slow drawn out crunch. While I did not find it pleasant to read, I do think the story was...more
Mar 23, 2012
Alex Sarll
added it
I'm no expert on either author, so this may be a commonplace - but Dostoevsky is very like Dickens, isn't he? Except this is Dickens told from the point of view of his monsters and fools (even if the monster in 'Notes from Underground' now feels pretty much like the type of modern man). There's even one of Dickens' lapses into overlong and mawkish tedium, in the brothel scene. An impressive work in many ways, and obviously of huge influence, but for everyday purposes I think I prefer Howard Devo...more
Did you ever have a moment in your life when you act in such a way that you dont recognise yourself - as if you were looking in from outside? Well old FD seems to have or rather young written alongside Poor Folk when he was 26. That very 20th century form the existential novel seems to have a forebear here in Dostoevsky's second work and first traditional novel.
It was a critical failure at the time apparently particularly amongst the left intelligentsia who had seen (and overstated I think) in D...more
It was a critical failure at the time apparently particularly amongst the left intelligentsia who had seen (and overstated I think) in D...more
Unable to recall if I'd ever read the second of these novellas (The Double), I decided to return to the world of Dostoevsky for the first time in many years. I still think of him as one of the true greats of world literature and my favourite Russian writer. He does psychological anguish better than anybody and gets right to the very 'soul' of his characters. The Double is no exception. The only thing that left me wondering a little is why Mr Golyadkin's doppelganger appears real to other charact...more
I don't know why I enjoy this book so much. I could listen to it over and over. The audio-book narrator is excellent. He really brings the "Underground Man" to life. The "Underground Man" is a very unpleasant person. I don't think I'd invite him to many parties. He reminds me of someone,though (and it's not me . . . at least not until I'm 85 and I think I'll be pushing up daisies long before I reach that age). His rants do make me smile. It's so pathetic it's hilarious. The "Underground Man" is...more
III. (Part II here: http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10...)
THE INFERNO
There are beings in the underground not to be dug up, but covered, as if to say that "all that can be seen from outside is a big hole; that, however, really leads nowhere" (Muir tr. Kafka, The Burrow). The real entrance "at a thousand paces from this hole lies covered by a movable layer of moss." This entrance is far from the decoy and has many exits, so if we come to the underground it is to things hidden, buried, not to be...more
THE INFERNO
There are beings in the underground not to be dug up, but covered, as if to say that "all that can be seen from outside is a big hole; that, however, really leads nowhere" (Muir tr. Kafka, The Burrow). The real entrance "at a thousand paces from this hole lies covered by a movable layer of moss." This entrance is far from the decoy and has many exits, so if we come to the underground it is to things hidden, buried, not to be...more
9/3/11 Lightbulb: must remember to consider Dostoyevsky's time imprisoned in Siberia as more than a footnote finding mention in his novels. Probably life-changing to his views on FREEDOM, FREE WILL and determinism! Which, potentially completely changes my assessment of this work.
-----------------------------------
Posted March 2011
(1) Why did the narrator consistently do everything AGAINST his own self interest? One finds throughout the novel that the narrator vacillates on almost every idea. Th...more
-----------------------------------
Posted March 2011
(1) Why did the narrator consistently do everything AGAINST his own self interest? One finds throughout the novel that the narrator vacillates on almost every idea. Th...more
Dostoyevsky's 'Notes from Underground,' is often called the first truly existential work of literature in the history of the west. Yet I think it is read today for the very seem reasons we always read Dostoevsky: for his command over intensity, his genuine and masterly sense of atmosphere, and his ability to psychologize those who are suffering. 'Notes from Underground,' is a true masterpiece in that it recreates the truth of genuine alienation and hatred. It laid the basis for all great works o...more
The version I read only included Notes From Underground (Bantam 1974, translated by Mirra Ginsburg).
Dostoyevsky's portrayal of the solitary man is striking and powerful. The reader feels pained for this man, frustrated by him, sorry for his pitiful existence, and can hardly stand his very being as he tries to exert his 'power' over others.
There is no question that Dostoyevsky can express inner-demons, desires, motivations, and drivers for better, or more often, worse.
His style is tough, especial...more
Dostoyevsky's portrayal of the solitary man is striking and powerful. The reader feels pained for this man, frustrated by him, sorry for his pitiful existence, and can hardly stand his very being as he tries to exert his 'power' over others.
There is no question that Dostoyevsky can express inner-demons, desires, motivations, and drivers for better, or more often, worse.
His style is tough, especial...more
Apropos of the wet snow - so beautiful - sometimes I'm him, sometimes her - but that was before.
The frightened and wounded expression on her face was followed first by a look of sorrowful perplexity. When I began calling myself a scoundrel and a blackguard and my tears flowed (the tirade was accompanied throughout by tears) her whole face worked convulsively. She was on the point of getting up and stopping me; when I finished she took no notice of my shouting: "Why are you here, why don't you g...more
The frightened and wounded expression on her face was followed first by a look of sorrowful perplexity. When I began calling myself a scoundrel and a blackguard and my tears flowed (the tirade was accompanied throughout by tears) her whole face worked convulsively. She was on the point of getting up and stopping me; when I finished she took no notice of my shouting: "Why are you here, why don't you g...more
This book is broken into two parts. The first part is a rambling narrative that I almost couldn't get through because it seemed to be going nowhere. However, the contraditory anti-hero produced so many profound statements that I knew I had to suffer through to catch the hidden gems. The second part suddenly broke into a story that captivated me. Overall, the narrator made me sick, but it was the kind of sick I couldn't look away from.
Fav. quotes:
"Men like that, men of action, doers, quite genuin...more
Fav. quotes:
"Men like that, men of action, doers, quite genuin...more
Well Notes From Underground left me with a different combination of thoughts and emotions.
Basically, the book is about a bitter, misanthropic recluse that most critics call "The Underground Man" and it follows his rants, raves and rambles about his view on life and the universe and a series of socially awkward events that happen to him.
Firstly, I think I should say that the book is in two parts. And the first part for me is where most of my criticisms lies. In short, he rambles waaaay to much....more
Basically, the book is about a bitter, misanthropic recluse that most critics call "The Underground Man" and it follows his rants, raves and rambles about his view on life and the universe and a series of socially awkward events that happen to him.
Firstly, I think I should say that the book is in two parts. And the first part for me is where most of my criticisms lies. In short, he rambles waaaay to much....more
Unlike his famous books that everyone raves about, I own this collection in hard cover from when I belonged to Doubleday Book Club when I was in Jr. College back in the middle 70s. I love this short story collection, definitely written by a true master, and although he was Russian and most of their stories have a tendency to be doom and gloom, this collection is not like that, far from it. Check it out, you will enjoy it.
It began as a strenuous read. Dostoyevsky's absurd rhythym emerged with each devastating episode and I felt compelled to suffer through it curious to learn what turning point would come. The second act proved to be more spastically dark than the first but ultimately revealing. To have read it once is enough for me, however I am glad to have read it. It was sadomasochismistic and self loathing in Times New Roman.
Portrays a man who is socially unacceptable because of irrational ideas and lack of human insight. Despite his good opinion of himself, is quite childish despite his supposedly mature understanding and knowledge of the world. He lives in the "underground" divorced from real life. The book is an analogy of our own "still brn" lives. Read while in college...
Here's to a truly selfish man who longs for happiness but looks for it in suffering! Dostoevsky excelled in describing the indescribable, portraying the mind of a conscious lunatic. Though I don't agree character's worldview, I can relate to him and be disgusted at him at the same time. It helps us to look in the mirror and correct ourselves.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoyevsky (Russian: Фёдор Михайлович Достоевский) was a Russian novelist, journalist, and short-story writer whose psychological penetration into the human soul had a profound influence on the 20th century novel.
Dostoevsky was the second son of a former army doctor. He was educated at home and at a private school. Shortly after the death of his mother in 1837 he was sent to S...more
More about Fyodor Dostoyevsky...
Dostoevsky was the second son of a former army doctor. He was educated at home and at a private school. Shortly after the death of his mother in 1837 he was sent to S...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“I am alone, I thought, and they are everybody.”
—
160 people liked it
“We have all lost touch with life, we all limp, each to a greater or lesser degree.”
—
26 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...











view all 3 comments



















