21st out of 58 books
—
53 voters
Benito Cereno
"What has cast such a shadow upon you?"
"The Negro."
With its intense mix of mystery, adventure, and a surprise ending, Benito Cereno at first seems merely a provocative example from the genre Herman Melville created with his early best-selling novels of the sea. However, most Melville scholars consider it his most sophisticated work, and many, such as novelist Ralph Ellison...more
"The Negro."
With its intense mix of mystery, adventure, and a surprise ending, Benito Cereno at first seems merely a provocative example from the genre Herman Melville created with his early best-selling novels of the sea. However, most Melville scholars consider it his most sophisticated work, and many, such as novelist Ralph Ellison...more
Paperback, 160 pages
Published
December 19th 2006
by Bedford/St. Martin's
(first published 1855)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,711)
Feb 25, 2011
Paquita Maria Sanchez
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
literature
Whew. Gut-punch. I'm going to attempt to tread lightly here, as any real down-and-dirty analysis of this story would be a worse spoiler of the plot's resolution than the Barton Fink DVD menu screen (and if you haven't seen this so-awesome-there-are-no-words-movie and you decide to watch it on DVD, do yourself a favor and mute the sound, insert the disk, close your eyes, press play, and only then un-mute and enjoy. You will thank me later.)
So, yeah...foray into the realm of the audio book! I lis...more
So, yeah...foray into the realm of the audio book! I lis...more
melville! in a melville house edition!
crazy, right?
this is a nice taut little thrill-ride of a book. okay, it's got a lot of description of boat-architecture, so it isn't a complete thriller - melville does tend to go overboard (GET IT??) with the descriptions sometimes, but regardless, it is more emotionally engaging than, say, that book about the whale. and i haven't read a book more full of seamen since reading Torn.
to a modern reader, the situation is pretty apparent from the get-go, but th...more
crazy, right?
this is a nice taut little thrill-ride of a book. okay, it's got a lot of description of boat-architecture, so it isn't a complete thriller - melville does tend to go overboard (GET IT??) with the descriptions sometimes, but regardless, it is more emotionally engaging than, say, that book about the whale. and i haven't read a book more full of seamen since reading Torn.
to a modern reader, the situation is pretty apparent from the get-go, but th...more
This novella takes a bit of patience to get into, but once you do, you are greatly rewarded. There's suspense, there's ambiguity (ambiguity galore!). There's much to think about, I suspect, for quite a long time after you're finished.
The reader probably understands what has happened long before the American captain (we see most of the story through him) does, but there is plenty enough in the revelation that has you paging backwards and stopping yourself from paging forwards. Only once is the r...more
The reader probably understands what has happened long before the American captain (we see most of the story through him) does, but there is plenty enough in the revelation that has you paging backwards and stopping yourself from paging forwards. Only once is the r...more
Anno di Grazia 1799. Un incontro fra due vascelli nel mare piatto in prossimita' delle coste del sud del Cile. Uno di questi e' spagnolo ed e' malmesso. L'altro e' americano ed arriva in soccorso. L'atmosfera sul primo e' malata. Come non paragonare questo al malato declino dell'impero spagnolo ammorbato di fatalismo e rassegnazione alla giovinezza rampante piena di fiducia degli appena nati US?
Scorrendo le pagine nulla e' come sembra. In un crescendo di intensita' si arriva al climax per poi "...more
Scorrendo le pagine nulla e' come sembra. In un crescendo di intensita' si arriva al climax per poi "...more
I titoli in neretto sono altrettante canzoni (e un album) di Bob Dylan.
As I Went Out One Morning
Una mattina dell'agosto 1799 una nave statunitense, ancorata in una sperduta isola cilena per rifornirsi d'acqua, avvista un'altra nave, in pessime condizioni di manutenzione, che si rivela carica di schiavi neri quando il capitano yankee decide di salire a bordo in visita. Cpt. Delano incontra cos�� cpt. Cereno, suo collega cileno, che gli racconta di tempeste, bonacce prolungate, epidemie. Ma il c...more
As I Went Out One Morning
Una mattina dell'agosto 1799 una nave statunitense, ancorata in una sperduta isola cilena per rifornirsi d'acqua, avvista un'altra nave, in pessime condizioni di manutenzione, che si rivela carica di schiavi neri quando il capitano yankee decide di salire a bordo in visita. Cpt. Delano incontra cos�� cpt. Cereno, suo collega cileno, che gli racconta di tempeste, bonacce prolungate, epidemie. Ma il c...more
I’m probably not capable of receiving this book in the way that its first readers did. Race and racial sensitivity were not issues to be bothered with then, so the racial issues, which are pretty much all I see, would not have cluttered the story for them. The older Melville criticism I have read sees this as a story about good and evil, with (not to give too much away) one faction representing evil and the other innocence.
This is turned on its head today. Oh, the same side is evil, but in a way...more
This is turned on its head today. Oh, the same side is evil, but in a way...more
Prescindendo dalle accuse di razzismo, che a 150 anni dalla pubblicazione sanno un po' di naïf, la verità è che io questo racconto l'ho trovato noioso. La vicenda ruota attorno al personaggio di Capitan Delano, il quale, avvistata una nave negriera alla deriva, vi sale a bordo solo per trovarvi l'equipaggio decimato ed il capitano, Benito Cereno, altamente provato dalle vicissitudini del viaggio e sull'orlo del tracollo mentale. Eppure, queste stesse vicissitudini non sembrano essere come raccon...more
I've read both Moby Dick and Billy Budd, but of the Melville works I've read, it's this novella I find most impressive. There's none of the windy digressions in Moby Dick or the heavy-handed allegory of Billy Budd or The Confidence-man here. This is as close as I've found in Melville to taut, subtle writing. If I have any criticism it is that it comes dangerously close to the "idiot plot." (For this to work, one of the characters has to act like an idiot.) From here on end though, to explain wha...more
In this novella, Melville creates an atmosphere of mystery and ominous foreboding, persisting and intensifying as Captain Delano tries to understand the enigma of an apparently ill-fated ship with its debilitated captain, Cereno, his handful of Spanish crew, and hoard of black slaves. Delano is by turns suspicious and credulous, uneasy and seemingly gulled, convinced of sinister and ulterior designs and then reassured by his own optimism. The intense strain this places on the reader is artful, h...more
Genial! Como la descripción dice; es muy corto para ser una novela y muy largo para ser una historia corta, realmente lo veo mas como la ultima, el verdadero climax de la historia es el final, la verdad que es un magnifico libro, chiquitin y todo pero muy bueno.
Admitiendo que tienes muchas descripciones hacerla de las embarcaciones y todo, creo que aun así es bastante digerible, enganchador y me gusto bastante el final, cuando ya todo lo que se venia cuestionando durante mas de la mitad del libr...more
Admitiendo que tienes muchas descripciones hacerla de las embarcaciones y todo, creo que aun así es bastante digerible, enganchador y me gusto bastante el final, cuando ya todo lo que se venia cuestionando durante mas de la mitad del libr...more
This is a tricky book to rate. In some ways it seems explicitly racist and at other times seems the exact opposite. Also, the first half is a sort of mystery and the second half is sort of a meta-examination of the first.
It's a confounding text and I don't really know what to think of it. In regard to race: I've always read Melville as being more generous to minority groups than many and so I'm inclined to think this is more a tale of mutiny without any real regard to race. The africans are give...more
It's a confounding text and I don't really know what to think of it. In regard to race: I've always read Melville as being more generous to minority groups than many and so I'm inclined to think this is more a tale of mutiny without any real regard to race. The africans are give...more
A long story about a slave revolt aboard a ship, not "dramatized" but narrated (with very little dialog). Melville's narrative sentences depict characters and illustrate events so clearly that he succeeds in engaging the reader on the same level as a dramatized story. Reading his sentences is so rewarding in itself that the subject doesn't matter. To wit: some of the encyclopedic treatises on cetology in Moby-Dick are mundane but for Melville's verdurous sentences. The same goes for "Benito Cere...more
I read my first Melville novella at the end of last year, Bartleby the Scrivener, and loved Melville’s use of antique language and his highly wrought sentence structures. However initially I found Benito Cereno tough going for the same reasons. It was only in retrospect I realised crafty old Melville is employing circumlocution as a means of heightening the sense of confusion in which the book abounds.
The book has to be read twice, once from the perspective of the unreliable narrator, the ‘good...more
The book has to be read twice, once from the perspective of the unreliable narrator, the ‘good...more
Ok, the language is pretty dense and kinda boring at first, but give it some time to warm up. Benito Cereno is one of those stories that stands up on its own no matter the time period in which it was written. It has a slow and very detailed beginning because its ending is so wrapped up in those beginning details, but trust me, the ending is worth the wait. I suggest reading this at the same time as a friend, because I read this for a class and the discussions it provoked made it that much better...more
This is a very interesting book to read. It is a novella, written a few years after Moby Dick. It's based on a real-life incident, in which an American captain, Amasa Delano, encounters a strange Spanish ship named San Dominick, captained by Benito Cereno. It is partly a political book, in which race, caste, and power relations play a role. It seems to be very different than Melville's other work.
For the first two-thirds of the book, there a disturbing cloud of ambiguity and suspicion hanging ov...more
For the first two-thirds of the book, there a disturbing cloud of ambiguity and suspicion hanging ov...more
So this is one of the first treatments of slavery by a white man in America that is willing to totally subvert the whole tradition. Melville is relentless in his exposure of the injustice of slavery, and the humanity in the emotion and intelligence, of the victims of slavery. It's only novella length, so check it. There were voices in that wilderness, crying out.
A Massachusetts whaling ship is anchored off the island of Santa Maria when another ship, looking listless and forlorn, drifts toward the island. When the captain and a few men head over to investigate, they find Spanish sailors and black slaves desperate for water and supplies. The captain of this hapless lot, Benito Cereno, seems weak, aloof, and entirely unqualified to command a ship. What’s the deal?
Don’t read the back of the book or descriptions of the plot, as knowing anything about the e...more
Don’t read the back of the book or descriptions of the plot, as knowing anything about the e...more
Apr 14, 2011
Shel
added it
This story demands spoilers. A fan of Melville's works "Bartleby the Scrivener" (one of my favorite shorts) and Moby Dick I became interested in reading this after seeing it recommended as a horror story — specifically in Marvin Kaye's introduction to Dracula.
More than halfway through the story I needed a reminder, "Why was I reading this?" and "Was it really supposed to be horror?"
The story seemed a dull cross between Moby Dick and Amistad with unsettling racism.
It helps greatly to know that th...more
More than halfway through the story I needed a reminder, "Why was I reading this?" and "Was it really supposed to be horror?"
The story seemed a dull cross between Moby Dick and Amistad with unsettling racism.
It helps greatly to know that th...more
Highly disturbing. Some of the images are incredibly vivid, but the unwritten ones, the ones that Melville leads the readers to imagine for themselves, are even worse. I loved it, after I finished it-in the beginning it's hard to get into, but after Melville drops the first few clues, it starts to get really interesting. There's a surprise ending that I won't spoil here, but if you pay attention it's fairly easy to guess. After you finish reading it, I would recommend reading it again, and pieci...more
Melville's prose is dense, and can be a bit daunting at times. There is a loveliness there for those devoted enough to dig into it, concentrating on every word, perhaps rereading each paragraph a few times for clarity.
The story here is great, and tackles the huge theme of racism at a time when racism was pretty much a standard that white people rallied around as they subjugated the world around them. Although he doesn't end on a particularly uplifting note, he does show blacks as being cunning...more
Melville masterfully handles the ambiguous relationship between slavery, race, and class, putting the reader in the shoes of a white Christian do-gooder who is unable to imagine blacks taking control of whites. That said, no one is going to accuse Melville of getting to his point too quickly. Even though this novella is relatively short, it feels much longer. I think many modern readers will have little problem solving the "mystery" by the opening pages, and will therefore find the subsequent re...more
My first thought, reading the description of the sea on the very first page, was this man can write. My next was that he writes far too much; each sentence runs on about two clauses too long. As I made my way through the story, I grew more annoyed at the racism in the book. I reached the end hoping for some redemptive twist, but found none: the story is astonishingly racist, the Africans are transformed from humble servants to terrifying savages and are allowed no humanity at all, and the focus...more
Sep 12, 2011
Grace
added it
I'm always a bit taken by this story, partially due to the fact that for much of the work, it's difficult to get a grasp on what is actually happening aboard the ship. That being said, what is most interesting to me is the inability of those who are in power to understand the reasons for such slave revolts, in that they do not think that the slaves capable of having such emotions or the skill to organize such a complex revolt, which in itself speaks volumes about the relationship between these g...more
Read this while taking a "Literature of American Slavery" class and once again I found Herman Melville's writing to be difficult to get through. That being said, however, this was a fascinating story about a slave rebellion aboard a Spanish slave ship, from the point of view of a white ship captain. If you can work your way through the prose, it's a powerful work...but if you find your mind a-drifting in the sea of Melvillian wordiness, watch the Steven Spielberg movie "Amistad", a great film al...more
I was completely shocked that I liked this short novel (or long short story- your pick) so much. Meaning, I figured I wouldn't really like stuff by Herman Melville b/c he doesn't have female characters (that i know of) and um well...moby dick is really long (still haven't read that one). But I really liked this story! It was a puzzle the entire time that you are trying to figure out the whole truth. And frankly you never really do, b/c you don't ever here Babo's side of the story. Definitely a t...more
I've got to re-read this, because at the time it struck me as a 5-star novel. I was so pleasantly surprised to read something by Melville that didn't induce narcolepsy (I loved my American lit teacher in high school, but I did not love Bartleby; haven't yet tackled Moby Dick and probably never will).
This book is, in so many ways, a page turning thriller, words not often reserved for classic literature. It also sparks interesting debates about race. I'm seriously considering teaching this book,...more
This book is, in so many ways, a page turning thriller, words not often reserved for classic literature. It also sparks interesting debates about race. I'm seriously considering teaching this book,...more
The Yankee, the Spaniard and a shipload of negroes.
As I Went Out One Morning
Una mattina dell'agosto 1799 una nave statunitense, ancorata in una sperduta isola cilena per rifornirsi d'acqua, avvista un'altra nave, in pessime condizioni di manutenzione, che si rivela carica di schiavi neri quando il capitano yankee decide di salire a bordo in visita. Cpt. Delano incontra così cpt. Cereno, suo collega cileno, che gli racconta di tempeste, bonacce prolungate, epidemie. Ma il comportamento di Cereno...more
As I Went Out One Morning
Una mattina dell'agosto 1799 una nave statunitense, ancorata in una sperduta isola cilena per rifornirsi d'acqua, avvista un'altra nave, in pessime condizioni di manutenzione, che si rivela carica di schiavi neri quando il capitano yankee decide di salire a bordo in visita. Cpt. Delano incontra così cpt. Cereno, suo collega cileno, che gli racconta di tempeste, bonacce prolungate, epidemie. Ma il comportamento di Cereno...more
Just re-read. I meant to re-read Bartleby but mixed up the names so I got something a little heavier than I bargained for. Cap't Amaso Delano is pretty annoying (antiquated, offensive outrageous racial outlook emphasized for the story, plus he is kind of cocky in general), but Melville really does get you into the feelings of the story. I had forgotten how descriptive he is... you can read the entire plot in about 1/3 of the words he uses, but you would miss a lot if you skipped the detail. I st...more
This short novel is a difficult read, I'll admit to that right away. But if ever a story was worth the difficulty, this is it! The story is a rare find: mystery, suspense, and horror, but arranged in a thoughtful, meaningful work of art. At first the book drags - the first few pages are tedious with exasperatingly long and seemingly meaningless details, but once the reader begins to understand the real story - the hidden conflict beneath the treacherous mask of normality, the reading is no longe...more
Interesting for the atmosphere it creates and the extensive discriptions.These descriptions however are the drawback for not making me feel totally into it.It was a way too long narrative for only a few hour's plot. Maybe in a tranlation I would more easily bond with the cohesion of the text and understand more.Since I understand the work's artistic value,I rate it with 3 stars,although my opinion over the plot would be merely 2 stars.I will read it in my mother tongue as well,and I am sure the...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Herman Melville was an American novelist, short story writer, essayist, and poet. His first two books gained much attention, though they were not bestsellers, and his popularity declined precipitously only a few years later. By the time of his death he had been almost completely forgotten, but his longest novel, Moby-Dick — largely considered a failure during his lifetime, and most responsible for...more
More about Herman Melville...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“But the past is passed; why moralize upon it? Forget it. See, yon bright son has forgotten it all, and the blue sea, and the blue sky; these have turned over new leaves.
Because they have no memory . . . because they are not human.”
—
11 people liked it
Because they have no memory . . . because they are not human.”
“This slavery breeds ugly passions in man.”
—
3 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...































Feb 27, 2011 10:11am
Feb 27, 2011 11:18am