Harm
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Harm

3.05 of 5 stars 3.05  ·  rating details  ·  130 ratings  ·  31 reviews
From one of science fiction’s greatest living writers comes an unforgettable near-future novel in the hortatory tradition of Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451, Orwell’s 1984, and Dick’s A Scanner Darkly. Both a searing indictment of a fear-drenched political climate and a visionary allegory that shines a piercing light on timeless human verities, HARM is a powerfully compact maste...more
Hardcover
Published by Duckworth Publishing (first published 2007)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 243)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Sławomir Molenda
Fabułę MROK-u dobrze streścił wydawca na tylnej okładce, także tylko powtórzę w ogromnym skrócie. Przewodnim motywem jest przetrzymywanie bez wyroku pewnego Brytyjczyka muzułmańskiego pochodzenia. Trafił on do więzienia po tym, jak napisał satyryczną książkę, która zawierała krótką, żartobliwą rozmowę o zamordowaniu premiera Wielkiej Brytanii.
Na jej podstawie uznano go za terrorystę i w więzieniu poddawano brutalnym torturom, aby zdradził swoje powiązania. Podczas przesłuchań traci on świadomość...more
John
Jan 29, 2008 John rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: People who didn't stop Lord Foul's Bane in the first 50 pages, dystopianists
Shelves: library-request
I am a fan of the few books that Aldiss has written or edited. He has an excellent eye for description and detail.

In HARM, he looks at current political events with a critical eye towards all of humanity. Blind faith (Christian) is assailed, as is pedantic, arrogant science. His anti-hero, Paul, a British Muslim, is a character about whom no past is known. Suspicious in his form on Earth (does the government have a reason for watching him), and vile in his form on Stygia, where he is a perpetual...more
Res
Ack gack torture squick. Couldn't even make it through a chapter.
M.G. Mason
Brian Aldiss is known for being a Socialist who injects political statements into his writing. And by a "Socialist" I mean the true definition, not the quasi-paranoid accusation that gets banded around (and barely resembles actual Socialism) by the lunatic fringe of the Republican Party. In the last ten years there has been no greater rallying call for Socialism than the mistreatment of Muslims in the west following 9/11 and on the back of it, the "Freedom for Palestine" movement.

This is the sto...more
John Kenny
Like Aldiss’ 2002 novel, Super-State, HARM is a remarkably timely book, dealing as it does with matters we are only reluctantly beginning to examine in any kind of detail. With Super-State, climate change was the main focus. With HARM, Aldiss is looking very closely at the line beyond which the ‘West’ should or should not cross in ‘its’ ‘war on terror’. Of course, both books, typical of Aldiss, are about so much more, but it’s the examination of what governments decide is the acceptable course o...more
David Agranoff

Brian W. Aldiss is best known for two films based on his work Frankenstein Unbound directed by Roger Corman based on his novel, and AI directed by Spielberg based on his short story called Super toys Last all Summer Long. In genre terms he is considered one of the masters of British science fiction. His series Helliconia Spring, summer and winter are considered broad classics of imaginative large scope Sci-fi. Personally I have only read Frankenstein and Dracula Unbound both of which I enjoyed....more
Michael
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Daniel A.
First off, let me say that Brian W. Aldiss' Harm was—and is—an incredibly difficult book to have finished, despite its deceptively short length. As a bitter commentary on the War on Terror and its present and possible abuses, however, HARM remains a vital contribution to the best traditions of science fiction from one of the British masters.

Heartbreakingly depressing yet with a powerful message to convey, HARM provides a warning to the reader, presumably a resident of the ostensibly civilized We...more
Jonathan Hockey
An interesting book. Raises some important questions about the dangers involved if the relationships between the western world and the muslim community become more strained in the years to come. The use of two worlds, a world where the main character Paul, is being tortured for his writing of a book inciting the murder of the prime minster by the HARM organisation trying to determine his terrorist threat. Another world he retreats to when left unconscious in his cell, on an "itchy" insect planet...more
Stephanie Griffin
Feb 25, 2012 Stephanie Griffin rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: nobody.
I just don’t get this book. HARM, by the science-fiction writer Brian W. Aldiss, is about a man who is being tortured and in his delirium imagines that he is living on a planet over a thousand light-years away from Earth. Or is it the other way around: he is living on the planet Stygia and when he sleeps he dreams of living another life on a faraway planet?
This is a short (240 pages) book. I tend to want to think that Aldiss was sketching out a story and decided to stop before it was fully flesh...more
Christy
Wow. This is a vivid and devastating vision of the ways in which U.S. and British politics have been taken over by fear and paranoia. One part of the novel, set in a detainment prison, speaks directly to the institution of camps like Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib within cultures that are supposedly civilized. Paul Fadhil Abbas Ali, a Muslim British writer, has been imprisoned on suspicion of association with terrorists and encouragement of terrorist actions (like assassinating the prime minister). W...more
Norman
This book is part SciFi, part commentary on the socio-ethnic ramifications of the modern hunt for those that are different (ie, the War For Terror). The main character seems to have a split personality, where he is living 2 very different lives.

One is in the not too distant future, where he is a British Muslim. As a British Muslim, he has written a book where the Prime Minister gets assassinated. Due to how the government takes this, he is taken prisoner, and tortured for being a terrorist, even...more
Ade Couper
Brian Aldiss is one of the greats of science fiction, along with Clarke, Bradbury & Azimov. This is a great book.

It isn't, however, an easy read, dealing with 2 issues which interest me, namely human rights & also mental health. Paul Ali, a writer of Muslim heritage has been arrested & is being tortured - for writing a scene in a book where two drunk characters discuss assassinating the Prime Minister. To escape from these atrocities, Paul's dissociative personality disorder creates...more
Allan Dyen-shapiro
Aldiss, the old science fiction master, is quintessentially English even in tackling what's essentially an American topic--the Patriot Act and the assault on liberty under the Bush administration. He transports this fight to England, where a fully assimilated Muslim author makes a very English bad joke about the country's leader and is imprisoned as a suspected terrorist and tortured. The torture drives him insane and into a science fiction world.

This book needed to be written. We had Orwell to...more
Mike
Dec 14, 2007 Mike rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Any pollyanna
Shelves: fiction-sci-fi
I found this book to be quite disturbing.

Reading it was like going to the carnival and looking into one of the mirrors that distorts its reflection to see if I could learn anything from it, only to find that the reflection showed everything ugly, petty, and foolish.

The title is "Harm", it might just as well be "Dark". It deals with our current religious "clash of cultures" (which are nothing more than thinly disguised resource wars) and all of the associated idiocy.

If you read sci-fi as a ple...more
Stephen Thomas
ENTOMOPHOBIA

Although Harm is a reasonably good read it’s not one of Aldiss’s triumphs (of which there are a good number). The interweaving of the two stories; that of Ali’s incarceration and interrogation and that of his alter-ego on the colonial planet Stygia, isn’t entirely successful. Although I understand Aldiss’s intentions I wasn’t convinced enough for the book to work as well as one would hope. I was far more interested in the colonists’ lives on the distant planet than I was in the unfor...more
Robert
This book is both grim and bleak. It's cleverly and powerfully written but not in the least subtle. It looks at the British political and societal scene as of right now and pretty much damns everybody: the political class for reactionary abuse of power, repression of its citizens and persecution of minorities. Immigrants for not culturally integrating. The religious for abdicating reason. The scientific community for abandoning ethics. Human nature is found to be fundamentally pretty disgusting....more
Suzana Vuksanovic
This is an amazing book. Brian Aldiss himself never fails to amaze...
In this book, Brian Aldiss - the sci fi writer - takes on the world of post 911 - complete with Abu Ghraib-esque prisoner.
This prisoner, an English-Muslim, seems to take refuge in an alternate personality in order to survive his ordeals. That personality, one which has landed and been reconstituted by a space-faring ship on a new planet - has it's own dillemas and life-situations to resolve. Strangely parallel to the events...more
John Wagner
This book seems like it would be two great short stories. There are two distinct storylines, which never seem to flow naturally into one another. Part of that has to do with the relatively short length of the book--there's never enough time to fully flesh out either story arc, and certainly not enough time to mesh them together. The book, as is, would be a great outline for a much longer, more detailed book.

That said, there are plenty of things to like about it. Aldiss has a good read for the dy...more
Spinwallah
it started out well, but the story certainly gets lost in the message
Tim Wake
A 2nd generation british immigrant is tortured for offhand remarks in a comic novel, in a black prison run by a british government ministry, in a kafkaesque farce of abuse and torture, while a parallel plot takes place in an escapist science fiction universe that the protagonist retreats to for escape, which mirrors the iniquities of the real world. Could take or leave it, neither storyline could stand on their own, and their interplay provided the only meat of the piece.
Bruce Sanders
A mediocre Kafkaesque tale of an innocent British Muslim tortured by British security on the one hand and his alter ego on another planet trying to survive and make sense of the fear, ignorance, and barbarity of the population trying to colonize that planet. Allegorically speaking there was probably more to this book than I realize, but it just didn't hold my interest.
Tippy Jackson
meh. Dark and bleak is right. Not at all subtle, but it could use some subtlety. Don't really give a shit about his characters. And of course, the poor tortured victim is a writer who innocently dared to make a statement. Not an actor, newscaster, musician, poet, philosopher, politician, artist or anyone else, but a writer. Just sayin'.
Michael O'Donnell
Not one story but two. Even though the characters are linked the two did not come together. As a SCI FI the current story is too close to date without a plausible link. The story is bleak but extremely well written. The other world experience is brilliantly Aldiss. The real world not so brilliant.

Colin
I couldn't finish this, even though i thought it had interesting political commentary on post-9-11 government repression. Everytime i read a rape scene where the woman thereafter says, "I love you," it just ruins it somehow...I couldn't pick the book back up after that.
Eric
The creation of a new world to serve as a haven for a man under torture, a new world where the man himself is under torture from different angles... Interesting composite of current affairs and science fiction.
Joshua Loveland
this is quite interesting. im only halfway through, though. iwill add more later. i appreciate authors tackling important issues even if it doesn't become their best work.
Colleen
Although a huge Aldiss fan, this was too dark, bleak for me right now. Maybe another time. I normally love dark, bleak!
Jason Fischer
Delightfully mind-bendy. A solid dystopia/fantasy.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
33297
Pseudonyms: Jael Cracken, Peter Pica, John Runciman, C.C. Shackleton, Arch Mendicant, & "Doc" Peristyle.

Brian Wilson Aldiss is one of the most important voices in science fiction writing today. He wrote his first novel while working as a bookseller in Oxford. Shortly afterwards he wrote his first work of science fiction and soon gained international recognition. Adored for his innovative liter...more
More about Brian W. Aldiss...
Non-Stop Helliconia Spring (Helliconia, #1) Hothouse Helliconia Winter (Helliconia, #3) Helliconia Summer (Helliconia, #2)

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »