Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Serendipities: Language and Lunacy” as Want to Read:
Serendipities: Language and Lunacy
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Serendipities: Language and Lunacy

by
3.82  ·  Rating Details ·  1,083 Ratings  ·  68 Reviews
Unlocking the riddles of history, Eco explores the "linguistics of the lunatic," stories told by scholars, scientists, poets, fanatics, and ordinary people in order to make sense of the world. The bewildering anecdotes and scholarly rigor entertain readers with a passion for the curious history of languages.
ebook, 128 pages
Published October 6th 1998 by Columbia University Press (first published 1998)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Riku Sayuj

The Force of Falsity

Eco illustrates through multiple examples on what tenuous grounds much of our accepted history of today stands. What we believe, exists. And the belief outweighs the actual existence, or lack thereof.

Each of these stories/examples have a virtue: as narratives, they seem genuinely plausible, more than everyday or historical reality, which is far more complex and less credible. The stories seemed to explain something that was otherwise hard to understand. Hard to understand wit
...more
lisa_emily
Sep 25, 2008 lisa_emily rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: linguctuals
Recommended to lisa_emily by: mic
I read this book because a friend gave it to me- he had an extra copy- and I wanted to read more Eco, (or at least another book by Eco, as so far I have read only one) this one looked thin and non-intimidating. If you have not read his "The Search for the Perfect Language", this little book of essays may seem as though it is coming from left field, since all the essays deal with the search for the original language and the degenerate manifestations of the so-called original language. You may als ...more
Mohammad
Dec 06, 2016 Mohammad rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
تابلوي مورد علاقه از نقاش مورد علاقه روي جلد كتابي از نويسنده مورد علاقه. دو مقاله ي اول شگفت انگيز بود. اونجا كه اكو با موشكافي و با استناد به انجيل، كمدي الهي و وقايع برج بابل، سعي در كشف راز زبان نخستين بشر دارد
Rebecca
Feb 22, 2011 Rebecca rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
This book is so terrible that I don't even feel remotely bad for abandoning it about 30 pages in. Frankly, those 30 pages were a waste of my time, and I'm only glad to have read them because I can now write this review. This book represented my first foray into the smoky and confusing world of Umberto Eco (not counting a few failed attempts to get past page 1 of The Name of the Rose over the years), and I hope never to return.

The first problem is that no one knows what this book is about, not ev
...more
Simon Mcleish
Sep 15, 2012 Simon Mcleish rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Originally published on my blog here in October 2000.

Some of Eco's essays in semiotics (those in Travels in Hyperreality, for example), are to me fairly impenetrable. The five in this collection are not like that. Concentrating on aspects of the history of linguistic thought, they show a wide ranging and brilliant mind, but are written in a lass academic style. (It was the vast array of references to writers that I had never read that was daunting.) They read more like they are notes related to
...more
Dfordoom
May 01, 2008 Dfordoom rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction
The main theme running through the essays in Umberto Eco’s Serendipities is that false or deluded or distorted (or even just plain crazy) ideas can change the world just as significantly as ideas that are true. And like ideas that are true, these ideas can change the world in positive or negative ways. The medieval belief in a vast Christian kingdom in the east, ruled by Prester John, was completely false but it was a major stimulus to European exploration and expansion. He also has some stimula ...more
Yesterday's Muse Bookstore
Another solid performance by Eco, though I don't think this book delivers what it advertises. What is supposed to tie together the five essays is a theme of mistakes that led to success, or ill-founded projects that facilitated great progress. I would say the first three essays are more successful than the final two in this regard, and also more enjoyable to read. They seem to have more of Eco's trademark flare for humor, and they seem to say what they intend to say more effectively.

I understand
...more
Naomi
Serendipities felt like little bits left over from the writing of The Search for the Perfect Language , which in a sense is what it is (in the introduction to Serendipities Eco writes 'In the introduction to my Search for a Perfect Language (1995), I informed the reader that, bearing in mind the physical limits of a book, I had been forced to omit many curious episodes, and I concluded: "I console myself that I have the material for future excursions in erudition"').

This work, although on one l
...more
Jonfaith
Dec 23, 2011 Jonfaith rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Somewhere in an earlier Alomodovar film, maybe Flower of the Secret, a character describes a scenario for a film, one which actually A would eventually create as Volver. I really like that, the inclusion. Eco anticipates his Cemetery of Prague with a devilish delight in this one, little surprise as nearly all of PC, outside of the protagonist, is grounded in historical evidence. I liked this dizzying book, though the final section did leave me grasping, if not gasping.
Dottie
Oct 19, 2007 Dottie rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: own
Eco is fast becoming a favorite. This small gem was right up my alley/s -- and is happily ensconced in my core library.
Ben
Jan 03, 2016 Ben rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
fascinating ideas unevenly treated
Douglas Summers-Stay
Jan 09, 2017 Douglas Summers-Stay rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction
I've often thought of language as being something like stone with fossils in it, where old metaphors can sometimes be found that have turned into words. But this book made me realize that it's more like living earth-- there is no embedding stone at all, but every part of language is composed of old poems and stories and jokes and similes in various states of growth and decay.
The book is a sequel or extension of The Search for the Perfect Language, which is my favorite of Eco's nonfiction books.
...more
David Conrad
Not all of Eco's arguments are persuasive, and some amount to assaults on straw men, but admirers of his easy fluency with medieval and Renaissance texts should enjoy his mischievous combination of praise and mockery for the bizarre projects of ancient intellectuals.
Maggie
Nov 12, 2007 Maggie rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction
second reading: january 2010. omgosh! U. Eco is such a fine writer. the purpose of this particular book is to show how soooo much advancement in human culture BEGINS with wrong thinking. we have to start "somewhere" so the wrong starting point doesn't have to mean the wrong path/conclusion but this method does have to acknowledge necessary corrections along the way ... and in this post-modern world where "anything goes" this book reminds us -- with excellent examples and clear thinking/good writ ...more
Shoma Patnaik
I think Umberto Eco is writing for an audience more erudite than I here. This book does not try to cater to lay people and you really do need to have some interest in linguistics to even begin to enjoy it. That said, it is less dry and dreary than I expected.

The five short essays, while decidedly academic, are interesting with a touch of humour (I liked Eco's contemplation on the language that would be spoken were Dante, Abulafia and Adam to convene in heaven) and cover the various aspects of l
...more
Richard Duncan
Tough read.

Enjoyed the first chapter, on how errors and mis-understandings have lead to important changes in our history and our understanding of the world (that is what Eco calls "serendipities,") and would have liked to see that expanded on. The third chapter (actually the book is a collection of essays/lectures) was somewhat related, but looking more at the world of ideas. More challenging, but still interesting.

The other chapters, though, were about subtle questions of language - the search
...more
Estelle
Umberto Eco is best known for his book, "The Name of the Rose" which was made into a movie starring Sean Connery. He was, however, a literary critic and university professor. For this book, he has his philosopher's hat on.

It is a fascinating collection of five essays about language revised from lectures Eco gave in the 1990s. The lectures can be read separately, but they are related and make a good set. In them, Eco speculates on aspects of language, including the efforts over the ages to searc
...more
Albert
Jul 01, 2010 Albert rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Umberto Eco, like the inventors of "perfect languages" he describes, takes language to be the ultimate metaphor for every system (political, philosophical, religious) mankind can aspire to cobble together. This allows him at the end for calling Joseph de Maistre (who did indeed despise the French Revolution) a "reactionary" for claiming that "The only certainty is that every people people has spoken, and it has spoken precisely insofar as it thought; in fact it would be absurd to believe that th ...more
Jim
Nov 24, 2008 Jim rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
A very interesting & intriguing series of essays (and lecture notes) which will hopefully entertain & enlighten those with a passion for the curious history of languages and ideas.

Not always easy on the lay reader (as those familiar with Eco's previous works will doubtless attest) and my bi-ceps certainly remember getting a good work-out lifting my faithful Dictionary on a regular basis - although hopefully my vocabulary (and dinner party conversation) is the better for it!

In fact, many
...more
Lorna
We know about the power of true ideas to effect change. But what about the power of false ideas? In this fascinating short work, Umberto Eco (author of novels including The Name of the Rose, and in addition Professor of Semiotics at the University of Bologna) examines some of the great wrong-headed ideas of previous centuries and the influence they have had. There's the vision of the Christian kingdom of Prester John beyond the Arab world; the belief in the original perfect language, or the atte ...more
David R.
Nov 26, 2012 David R. rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: unclassified
Eco's day job is professor of Semiotics at Bologna University, and this book (a set of five lectures) shows him to fine effect. However, it lies at a significant level of academic prose and the subject can be suprisingly difficult to fully grasp. I'm assuming I would need three or four passes to do so, reminding me of my struggle with Hofstedler's "Godel Escher Bach" many years ago. That said, I came away with some perspective on both "falsity" (in its sense of how culture progressed in the teet ...more
Charlie
Dec 07, 2009 Charlie rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This book is a compilation of lectures presented by Eco over a few years, so despite pretty quality editing, it doesn't quite flow together as a book. On the other hand, Eco is absolutely brilliant, so even a mildly disjointed series of his thoughts makes for stupendous reading. My main complaint was that his editor overestimated me as a reader. The text abounds with foreign-language phrases (primarily Latin) with no translations or footnotes to help me along. I don't think that I risked believi ...more
Tom Dale
Aug 27, 2011 Tom Dale rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Having struggled to get beyond the first section of this book for what is alarmingly revealed to me by Goodreads as all but a year, and then having completed it in the space of a day or two, my conclusion is this:
this is not a book to read last thing at night, first thing on a sunday morning, when drunk, ill or exhausted, irritated by children, employers or clients, or in any other way distractable from what is without doubt a mental task of no small order.

Eco is rarely light reading and this
...more
Utsav
Sep 11, 2013 Utsav rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: on-kindle, book-club
I'm not quite sure how to rate this one. It had a bunch of very interesting arguments that make for excellent discussions with a willing sparring partner, and then at times it dipped into some exercises in pointlessness that had me throwing it down in frustration. Eco seems to believe in biblical inerrancy and Dante Inerrancy (or not, I couldn't tell if he was being sarcastic), so there went a lot of credibility for me.

Nobody needs to read this, but if the subject interests you and you can get p
...more
Jessica
Aug 15, 2007 Jessica rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: people interested in semiotics
A history of linguistics that is maybe not meant for the layman. Interesting and dense, but sometimes difficult to follow, especially if you bought it without paying much attention and while thinking that you were getting (and hoped to get) Eco's Misreadings for a light in-flight read. Eco makes a habit in all of his writing of using large chunks of text in a variety of languages without offering translations.

Chapter 3 : From Marco Polo to Leibniz: Stories if Intellectual Misunderstandings, was
...more
Heather Browning
I found this extremely difficult to get through, particularly the first couple of chapters, and I almost gave up. If it hadn't been such a short book, I may have. The writing style is difficult to follow - crammed with detail to the point where it's easy to forget or overlook the broader point he is trying to make. Rather than really exploring any of the ideas he presents, Eco seems to prefer to survey the history of them. Perhaps it's just my inclinations as a philosopher rather than a historia ...more
Eva Nickelson
Jul 24, 2011 Eva Nickelson rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction
I freely admit that most of this book was over my head. I have an interest in languages in the sense that I use a limited language set to convey ideas. There were a plethora of philosophers and writers that were mentioned (Borges being one that I have actually read), and while I may have missed quite a bit by not reading more of them, Eco conveys the different theories about where our languages originate and what purpose they both help and hinder in our beliefs of the world. It was definitely a ...more
Milla
May 26, 2011 Milla rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction
Every time I pick up one of Eco's books I'm surprised just how different they are from each other. I've been disappointed so many times by authors who seem to have something to say and then end up repeating the same things over and over again book after book. I'm not an expert on history or literature but at least to a regular reader simply the amount of knowledge that Eco seems to have on the subjects he writes about, down to the smallest details, is amazing.
Stephan Frank
Hmm. A bit disappointing, as I have come to expect more from Eco.
Probably, these essays could work much better as short lectures, accompanied maybe by a question and answers session.
While the topics are generally fascinating, their treatment does not reach very deep in many cases. Sure, there are a few interesting facts mentioned here and there, but those remain preciously sparse, and are surrounded by a lot of "fluffy" text full of speculations and repetition of one central theme.
Nicholas
I greatly enjoyed the 'The Force of Falsity' with its many examples of how falsehoods end up have great consequences and historical impact. 'Languages in Paradise' was interesting but I admit to not knowing all of the references Eco made in the essay. I had never been aware of the inconsistency between the story of the Tower of Babel and Genesis 10. The search for the original sacred language is a fascinating concept in itself.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Uses of Literature
  • The Cambridge Encyclopedia of the English Language
  • Into the Looking-Glass Wood: Essays on Books, Reading, and the World
  • Selected Non-Fictions
  • Why Translation Matters
  • Dante: Poet of the Secular World
  • The Anatomy of Influence: Literature as a Way of Life
  • Fragmentation and Redemption: Essays on Gender and the Human Body in Medieval Religion
  • Gothic: Four Hundred Years of Excess, Horror, Evil and Ruin
  • After Babel: Aspects of Language and Translation
  • The Machine in the Garden: Technology and the Pastoral Ideal in America
  • Where the Stress Falls: Essays
  • New Horizons in the Study of Language and Mind
  • The Sense of an Ending: Studies in the Theory of Fiction
  • Is That a Fish in Your Ear?: Translation and the Meaning of Everything
  • Poets in a Landscape
  • Reading Rilke: Reflections on the Problems of Translation
  • The Redress of Poetry
1730
Umberto Eco was an Italian writer of fiction, essays, academic texts, and children's books, and certainly one of the finest authors of the twentieth century. A professor of semiotics at the University of Bologna, Eco’s brilliant fiction is known for its playful use of language and symbols, its astonishing array of allusions and references, and clever use of puzzles and narrative inventions. His pe ...more
More about Umberto Eco...

Share This Book



“The cultivated person's first duty is to be always prepared to rewrite the encyclopedia.” 8 likes
“I concluded that although instruments, whether empirical or conjectural, exist to prove that some object is false, every decision in the matter presupposes the existence of an original, authentic and true, to which the fake is compared. The truly genuine problem thus does not consist of proving something false but in proving that the authentic object is authentic.” 0 likes
More quotes…