18th out of 259 books
—
186 voters
The Annotated Alice: The Definitive Edition (The Annotated Books)
For over half a century, Martin Gardner has established himself as one of the world's leading authorities on Lewis Carroll. His Annotated Alice, first published in 1960, has over half a million copies in print around the world and is highly sought after by families and scholars alike for it was Gardner who first decoded the wordplay and the many mathematical riddles that l...more
Hardcover, 312 pages
Published
November 17th 1999
by W. W. Norton & Company
(first published 1960)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
4,416)
CELEBRITY DEATHMATCH REVIEW*
(* entertainment purposes only)
1984 v. The Annotated Alice
Exterior shot: a pristine and stately government building which looks out-of-place in an otherwise economically depressed city, in an underdeveloped tropical country.
Interior shot: a very luxuriously-appointed office, where a late middle aged executive (EX), O’Brien (OB) and the Queen of Hearts (QH) all sit in fine leather chairs around a mahogany table.
...more
This edition has an interesting and informative introduction in which Martin Gardner refers to “the Bible and all other great works of fantasy,” which amused me. The annotations to the text are often quite interesting if somewhat intrusive; I found it best to read all of them for a chapter before beginning to read the chapter itself, having them then in my knowledge base without having to be interrupted from the flow of the story. I enjoying all the punning. I had not realized that the songs ...more
Bettie
added it
REVIEW FOR CELEBRITY DEATH MATCH ONLY
Alice, who doesn't want to get her petticoats dirty, is idly chewing on a magic mushroom and looks quite tall for her tender years; she is waiting patiently for her opponent in direct contrast to a white rabbit who is chagrined at the wasting time. A screech of tires announcesPippi Lisbeth arrival on a Harley (sweet!); she bends down to fill her hands with mud and proceeds to smear it over her barely clad tattooed form.
L - you can cal...more
Alice, who doesn't want to get her petticoats dirty, is idly chewing on a magic mushroom and looks quite tall for her tender years; she is waiting patiently for her opponent in direct contrast to a white rabbit who is chagrined at the wasting time. A screech of tires announces
L - you can cal...more
For the Celebrity Death Match vs The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo.
'I mean, wot the fuck is it wiv this Salander bitch?' Alice scowls.
'I'm telling you, I'm sick of it. Bugger the 'Annotated Alice', we're putting out the 'Unexpurgated Alice' right now. They need to be told that I did all that stuff bigger and better than she did. AND I had to give mate's rates to fucking Charles Dickens. Geez. Give me a break.'
'What? NOW?' asks Humpty nervously glancing at the wa...more
'I mean, wot the fuck is it wiv this Salander bitch?' Alice scowls.
'I'm telling you, I'm sick of it. Bugger the 'Annotated Alice', we're putting out the 'Unexpurgated Alice' right now. They need to be told that I did all that stuff bigger and better than she did. AND I had to give mate's rates to fucking Charles Dickens. Geez. Give me a break.'
'What? NOW?' asks Humpty nervously glancing at the wa...more
I recently saw a review where someone had read Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, felt completely confused, and was basically told by all commenters that "Carroll was on Opium," as an explanation for the weirdness of the writing. I suggest that original poster, instead, pick up a copy of The Annotated Alice. Both Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass were essentially written for one person, Alice Liddell. Most of the references in the books that are completely o...more
All in the golden afternoon
Full leisurely we glide;
For both our oars, with little skill,
By little arms are plied,
While little hands make vain pretence
Our wanders to guide.
Ah, cruel Three! In such an hour,
Beneath such dreamy weather,
To beg a tale of breath too weak
To stir the tiniest feather!
Yet what can one poor voice avail
Against three tongues together?
Imperious Prima flashes forth
Her edict "to begin ...more
Full leisurely we glide;
For both our oars, with little skill,
By little arms are plied,
While little hands make vain pretence
Our wanders to guide.
Ah, cruel Three! In such an hour,
Beneath such dreamy weather,
To beg a tale of breath too weak
To stir the tiniest feather!
Yet what can one poor voice avail
Against three tongues together?
Imperious Prima flashes forth
Her edict "to begin ...more
I have an earlier edition of this book, but I'm still gonna review it. This book is basically Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass, along with everything you could ever possibly want to know about its symbols, interpretations, historical context and underlying psychodynamics (like how the rabbit hole is apparently a vagina). A disturbing but plausible conspiracy theory introduced is that Dodgson (Lewis Carroll) may have mentally been a pedophile, but never committed any...more
I don't think I would have half the appreciation I now do for Lewis Carroll if it weren't for the annotations accompanying this edition of the text. Besides the grunt work of explaining Victorian terms and concepts now outdated (look up bathing machines for the example I found most strange), the annotations shed on light on the emotional dimension to the books, which seems like an absurd idea at first glance given that they're nonsense tales. But Lewis Carroll adored Alice Liddell -- innocently ...more
although fascinated by its immense historical significance and mathematical, logical and fantastical elements i didn't appreciate it as literature. wonderland is definitely the superior work, as the plotting of looking glass is tedious and forced, with its parade of disconnected episodes. i couldn't help disliking dodgson.
This beautiful hardbound edition of both Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass is made heavenly by the inclusion of luxurious annotations, original illustrations by John Tenniel, and a long-lost chapter. Editor Gardner reprints acres of trivia provided by scholars and fans in the annotations, which range from definitions or contextual clues to (like suggested answers to the famous riddle "Why is a raven like a writing-desk?"). At times, the annotations seem a little indulge...more
John E. Branch Jr.
rated it
I discovered recently that Will Self wrote a rather disparaging review of this edition, his objection being that Martin Gardner resolutely avoids any psychosexual or psychoanalytic reading of Lewis Carroll himself or of his Alice works in this volume. (I discovered it because the review is currently one of only two external links in the book's Wikipedia entry.) The criticism is valid but not a sufficient reason to condemn Gardner's work. Perhaps any annotation is a form of criticism, and the not...more
Written for the Celebrity Death Match Review Tournament
The Annotated Alice versus 1984
Alice looked around at the gray drab buildings.
"I must have wandered off the path. This is nothing like anything I've ever seen before in Wonderland. "
The city was devoid of people. Occasionally a siren would blare but there were no human and animal sounds. A poster of a intimidating man with the words BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU was on practically every...more
The Annotated Alice versus 1984
Alice looked around at the gray drab buildings.
"I must have wandered off the path. This is nothing like anything I've ever seen before in Wonderland. "
The city was devoid of people. Occasionally a siren would blare but there were no human and animal sounds. A poster of a intimidating man with the words BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU was on practically every...more
CELEBRITY DEATHMATCH REVIEW*
(* entertainment purposes only)
1984 v. The Annotated Alice
Setting: a wooded park on the outskirts of London, Airstrip One, Oceania.
George Orwell (GO) is sitting on a blanket in the sun, wearing the drab gray jumpsuit of an Outer Party member. He rises to greet his companion, Lewis Carroll (LC), who is strolling across the grass to meet him.
LC: (scanning the area suspiciously) Is it safe to meet here?
...more
(* entertainment purposes only)
1984 v. The Annotated Alice
Setting: a wooded park on the outskirts of London, Airstrip One, Oceania.
George Orwell (GO) is sitting on a blanket in the sun, wearing the drab gray jumpsuit of an Outer Party member. He rises to greet his companion, Lewis Carroll (LC), who is strolling across the grass to meet him.
LC: (scanning the area suspiciously) Is it safe to meet here?
...more
Holy hell, I must own about 21-25 copies of Alice in Wonderland and/or Through the Looking-Glass. This story FASCINATES me, mostly I think because there is more than a little crazy to it. I like thinking of these stories akin to a fantasy romp through an insane asylum. I would even go so far as to say that my interest in (and eventual decision to make a career out of) psychology stems from my early fascination with these stories. Not to mention my life-long obsession with fantasy.
I d...more
I d...more
This book is the classic story of Alice In Wonderland and Alice Through the Looking Glass annotated with lots of annotations that explains many of the allusions that may be missed by a casual reader not familiar with the British society of Lewis Carroll's time.
The annotations are very interesting and provide good information about the text that help with a deeper understanding.
I read this book because I like Alice in Wonderland and wanted to learn more.
The annotations are very interesting and provide good information about the text that help with a deeper understanding.
I read this book because I like Alice in Wonderland and wanted to learn more.
This is the book that made me a reader. I remember hiding under the covers with a lamp so I could stay up a little later and keep reading. I got in a lot of trouble over this book. I also killed my vision. Fran recently brought me an annotated copy of this book from Oxford (England), where Carroll wrote the book. It is amazing!
I really enjoyed this edition, a book I still own. But, unlike most people, I’ve never been a huge Alice in Wonderland fan. I read this book in elementary school and I liked it. Had reasons to read other editions of the Alice in Wonderland part of this book for a college English class, and was simply not wowed.
Why is a raven like a desk?
Alice é um livro que é sempre interessante. No qual, a cada leitura, descobre-se um novo jogo, uma alusão, uma brincadeira (mesmo com a ajuda dos extensos comentários de Martin Gardner). Ainda não encontrei as dezoito (?) piadas sobre morte em Alice no País das Maravilhas.
Alice é um livro que é sempre interessante. No qual, a cada leitura, descobre-se um novo jogo, uma alusão, uma brincadeira (mesmo com a ajuda dos extensos comentários de Martin Gardner). Ainda não encontrei as dezoito (?) piadas sobre morte em Alice no País das Maravilhas.
There's no radio button for tried to read but really couldn't finish, but that's what I would have checked. (I DO wish they would add a Re-reading button)
Tenniel's illustrations disturbed me as a child, for unknown reasons, and as such, Alice in Wonderland disturbed me, so I never really read it. I have had this on my mental "to read" list for more than 20 years. Martin Gardner is a legend and I thought that if he had something to do with it (the annotated part) I might finally make...more
Tenniel's illustrations disturbed me as a child, for unknown reasons, and as such, Alice in Wonderland disturbed me, so I never really read it. I have had this on my mental "to read" list for more than 20 years. Martin Gardner is a legend and I thought that if he had something to do with it (the annotated part) I might finally make...more
I would definitely recommend the Annotated Alice for anyone as lost as I was by the nonsense humor of Carroll. The book does an excellent job of explaining many of the references to outdated poems, songs and theories that Carroll parodies that are lost on modern audiences. However, the explanations at times can be exceedingly lengthy and uninteresting. To a casual (and sadly, indifferent) reader such as myself, it was quite shocking to learn that Carroll scholars actually argue about things lik...more
The first thing we have to realize is that neither Alice in Wonderland nor Through the Looking Glass hold some amazing genius or the Answer to Life. They are fairy tales, told to/written for children, no more, no less. They are actually peeks into the mind of Lewis Carroll, who in the final analysis was strange. No, scratch that--he was truly weird, and almost scary geeky. The organizations that have sprung up around the books are not called, for example, the Lewis Carroll Society for nothing. T...more
Laurel Bradshaw
rated it
The Definitive Edition of The Annotated Alice combines the annotations of Gardner's 1959 edition with his 1990 volume, More Annotated Alice, as well as additional discoveries drawn from Gardner's encyclopedic knowledge of the texts. It was Gardner who first decoded many of the mathematical riddles and wordplay that lay ingeniously embedded in Carroll's two classic stories, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass. This edition is illustrated with John Tenniel's classic, bel...more
Hard to know how to rate this. The 'Alice' books themselves are marvellous, but we knew that already. The annotations are disappointing.
Those that explain topical allusions that would have been obvious to Carroll's contemporaries, or at least to Alice Liddell and other close friends, are welcome, but at times I felt Gardner was straining to find allusions where there probably weren't any. Other notes impart no extrinsic information but draw attention to features of the text or the...more
Those that explain topical allusions that would have been obvious to Carroll's contemporaries, or at least to Alice Liddell and other close friends, are welcome, but at times I felt Gardner was straining to find allusions where there probably weren't any. Other notes impart no extrinsic information but draw attention to features of the text or the...more
I have only read Alice's Adventures in Wonderland from this text, and not Through the Looking Glass, as the first Alice book is the one I needed to read for my course.
I have always been a big fan of Alice in Wonderland, but I think I've been able to get a lot more from it reading it as an adult than I did when I'd read bits of it when I was younger. I'm able to see more of the jokes in it, and understand the deeper workings of the text than I did previously.
I think my favourite part ...more
I have always been a big fan of Alice in Wonderland, but I think I've been able to get a lot more from it reading it as an adult than I did when I'd read bits of it when I was younger. I'm able to see more of the jokes in it, and understand the deeper workings of the text than I did previously.
I think my favourite part ...more
Alice In Wonderland was a great book, and I loved it. The notes on the side were helpful, and described different traditions and references that Carroll makes. At the same time, the notes were really distracting, and I sometimes found myself focusing more on the notes than on the actual book. Overall, the side notes were really helpful.
There were also illustrations scattered throughout Alice In Wonderland and really detailed. More illustrations would have been nice, but the ones ...more
There were also illustrations scattered throughout Alice In Wonderland and really detailed. More illustrations would have been nice, but the ones ...more
The Annotated Alice is a volume containing both of Lewis Carroll’s Alice stories, which are Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass. Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland follows Alice Lidddel as she accidentally stumbles into a strange world (known as Wonderland) and explores the world, having many strange encounters, including her meeting with the Dodo, and the famous tea party with the Mad Hatter and March Hare. Through the Looking Glass is the follow up, in which ...more
Martin Gardner's annotations provide essential background for Lewis Carroll's Alice books, as well as fascinating trivia. Gardner includes originals of the poems satirized in the stories, historical background from Carroll’s life and his friendship with the Liddell sisters, and even a photograph of Alice Liddell (spoiler alert!—she looks nothing like the girl in Sir John Tenniel’s definitive illustrations from the original edition, reproduced in this book). Also included is a “lost” chapter, a...more
After watching the latest movie version of Alice in Wonderland I thought the movie was nothing like the book I remember. The clever dialogue was virtually nonexistent, and the movie plot was nonexistent in the book. There was no slaying of the Gryphon by anyone in the book and this was the main storyline and the climax of the movie.
I decided to take another look at the two Alice books, this time with Martin Gardner’s notes. I forgot much of Alice and Wonderland, and almost all of ...more
I decided to take another look at the two Alice books, this time with Martin Gardner’s notes. I forgot much of Alice and Wonderland, and almost all of ...more
I recently realized that I'd somehow managed to never read Lewis Carroll's famous works, (Adventures of Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass) and found this gem at the library.
Carroll's work stands alone as brilliant for its amazing whimsy and wordplay as well as explorations of mathematical/logical problems, metaphysical issues and oddities in the English language. I could envision an entire college course in the philosophy of literature department that tackles this boo...more
Carroll's work stands alone as brilliant for its amazing whimsy and wordplay as well as explorations of mathematical/logical problems, metaphysical issues and oddities in the English language. I could envision an entire college course in the philosophy of literature department that tackles this boo...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
The Rev. Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, better known by the pen name Lewis Carroll, was an English author, mathematician, logician, Anglican clergyman and photographer.
His most famous writings are Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and its sequel Through the Looking-Glass as well as the poems "The Hunting of the Snark" and "Jabberwocky", all considered to be within the gen...more
More about Lewis Carroll...
His most famous writings are Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and its sequel Through the Looking-Glass as well as the poems "The Hunting of the Snark" and "Jabberwocky", all considered to be within the gen...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...











view all 4 comments










































