Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Guests on Earth” as Want to Read:
Guests on Earth
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Guests on Earth

3.61  ·  Rating Details  ·  4,038 Ratings  ·  693 Reviews
“Reading Lee Smith ranks among the great pleasures of American fiction . . . Gives evidence again of the grace and insight that distinguish her work.” —Robert Stone, author of Death of the Black-Haired Girl

It’s 1936 when orphaned thirteen-year-old Evalina Toussaint is admitted to Highland Hospital, a mental institution in Asheville, North Carolina, known for its innovative
Hardcover, 326 pages
Published October 15th 2013 by A Shannon Ravenel Book (first published January 1st 2013)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Guests on Earth, please sign up.

Popular Answered Questions

Amy Lotsberg It was her husband's, the guy that was a singer. Joey Nero.
This question contains spoilers… (view spoiler)
Amy Lotsberg
This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Carolyn Hill
Oct 16, 2014 Carolyn Hill rated it really liked it
Three and a half stars, rounded up. I was very interested to read Lee Smith's treatment of the tragedy at Highland Hospital in Asheville that resulted in the death of Zelda Fitzgerald, as it has been a subject that has intrigued me (as all things Asheville do). I've read about it a bit myself, though not nearly to the thorough extent Ms. Smith has, as evidenced by her "Note on Sources." Though she opens the book with the AP news report of the 1948 fire at Highland Hospital, and the first page of ...more
May 21, 2014 Sarah rated it it was amazing
Okay, I'm a little biased as I know Lee, and she's the reason I am published. She took me under her wing and helped me find an agent. But BEFORE that, I was a huge fan, and this book is one of her best. I loved it so much, especially the NC stuff as that's my home state. All of her books are great. She is my role model.
Jan 23, 2014 Liz rated it it was ok
While I found this book surprisingly enjoyable with a well-developed and likable main character, I can't give it a higher rating. The author seems to have gotten to the end and just given up entirely. The entire "climax" of the book (as defined by the back cover) takes place in the last ten pages, and we get no real sense of its significance. [Spoiler] This is a story about a woman who breaks down after the death of her mother, again after the death of her daughter, and we are supposed to believ ...more
This was my first Lee Smith book (a local author for me) but it will not be my last. She did a brilliant job of combining historical events with the fictitious characters she created. The story is told by Evalina who spends the majority of her life as a "guest" at Highland Hospital in Asheville, NC. The hospital and the famous Dr. Carroll were real, as were the infamous Zelda Fitzgerald who was a guest there as well until she died in a fire at the hospital.

Highland was a mental hospital which
Heather Fineisen
I am partial to Ms. Lee Smith but this is one of her best. The setting of a famed Asheville, NC mental hospital that treated Zelda Fitzgerald provides a southern slant on a historical review of mental illness treatment and Appalachian living beginning in the 1930's. Evalina Toussaint is a character that you will fall in love with as well as many of the other personalities at the Highland Hospital. And you may just bump into someone who seems familiar as Smith's strength is in recreating places a ...more
Diane S ☔
Nov 24, 2013 Diane S ☔ rated it really liked it
Evalina comes to the renowned Highland hospital for acute sadness. Her mother had died and she found herself in untenable circumstances, which will eventually lead her to this cutting edge hospital for mental disorders under the innovative Dr. Carroll. There she will find a home and friends that will become for her a new family and a supportive community.

Of course, this hospital became famous because of Zelda Fitzgerald, who was in and out of care here, for many years. She plays a role in this s
Jan 15, 2014 Lydia rated it it was amazing
Having grown up in Asheville and worked at Highland Hospital I find this book an excellent fictional tale of life at Highland. It is an easy read with wonderful facts about the city and Highland. Excellent entertaining story.
Feb 06, 2014 Barb rated it it was ok
Where's the Zelda?

I was disappointed by the lack of Zelda in this novel. The book jacket seems to promise something the novel couldn't deliver. While Zelda Fitzgerald is present in the story, she doesn't play any central role, only appears periodically and is never revealed as more than a caricature of herself. Based on the book blurb I was expecting more.

The books starts off slowly, the narrator, Evalina Tousaint, narrates, her recollections, despite including some very emotionally charged situ
Nan Williams
Jan 04, 2014 Nan Williams rated it it was ok
Shelves: quit
With 50 pages left, I closed the book. Why? There were too many skips in the story line, too many unanswered questions, too many sequelae that simply did not make sense within the foundation or characterization established by the author. There were also too many characters wandering in and out of the Highland Hospital as noted by another reviewer. Before closing the book, I checked the reviews here on GoodReads and saw that the ending was going to be both disappointing and anti-climactic. At the ...more

Lee Smith is a perfectly engrossing author, and one who easily captures the heart and imagination in a folksy, down-in-your-heart way. I've been fascinated with stories about Zelda Fitzgerald all summer long, as you know. This novel by Ms Smith has a different twist as it's seeing Zelda through the eyes of a young girl throughout her life who is actually raised as an orphan in Ashville's Highland House sanatorium. The really strong kicker of this book, however, is the e
Ruth Turner
Oct 03, 2014 Ruth Turner rated it liked it

Some readers were dissatisfied with the relatively small part that Zelda Fitzgerald played in this story. Not so for me. My interest was in Highland Hospital, so in that regard I wasn't disappointed.

The story is well written and an easy read and I enjoyed the first half very much, getting to know Evalina, her life, and how she came to be at Highland.

The history of the treatment of mental illness in the 1940's was interesting, (although the mention of a lobotomy, performed through the eye socket,
Nov 08, 2013 Amy rated it really liked it
Author Lee Smith has delighted readers of southern American fiction for years; her latest Guest on Earth may be her finest work to date. Smith has turned her talent to historical fiction based upon actual events to create a thoroughly captivating story. On March 10th 1948 the notorious Highland Hospital, a well known mental hospital, in Asheville North Carolina, burned and several residents perished in the fire. Among those who were not able to evacuate was the hospital’s most famous resident, Z ...more
Eric Kibler
Apr 16, 2014 Eric Kibler rated it it was ok
I'm sorry to say that I didn't like this book, the first I've read by the acclaimed Lee Smith, as much as her reputation warrants.

I liked the first half of the book, the coming-of-age story of a girl who is the daughter of a "kept woman" in New Orleans and who later has extended stays in a mental hospital. The mental hospital is more idyllic than you'd expect. She becomes a musician and encounters people like Nina Simone and Zelda Fitzgerald. The selling point of the book is that it's about Zeld
Phil Ford
Feb 12, 2014 Phil Ford rated it liked it
I found the story interesting historically and the setting was scenic, but some of the narrative was annoying to me. Our protagonist, Evalina Toussaint, comes to Highland Hospital in Asheville, NC in 1936 a young orphaned girl. Immediately she is taken under the wing of the wife of the head psychiatrist who sees the young girl's musical talent. Throughout the novel, Eva comes of age and eventually turns from patient to staff member. Zelda Fitzgerald is also a patient there, and the two ...more
Wilhelmina Jenkins
Jul 18, 2014 Wilhelmina Jenkins rated it really liked it
Shelves: novel
I have read and loved Lee Smith's books since I read Black Mountain Breakdown about 30 years ago. In this book, Smith does what she does best - portraying the complexities of the lives of women, particularly southern women, in a specific southern location. While there are real historical figures in this book, primarily Zelda Fitzgerald, and the setting of the book - Highland Hospital, a mental institution in Asheville, North Carolina - does exist, this is a work of fiction and it is Smith's skil ...more
Oct 17, 2013 Jacqueline rated it it was amazing
Shelves: owned-books
"The insane are always mere guests on earth, eternal strangers carrying around broken decalogues that they cannot read."-F.Scott Fitzgerald. So begins Lee Smith's wonderful new novel set in Ashville, NC in the 193-40's. It focuses on treatment for the mentally ill during that period and is alive with colorful characters. (Zelda, among them.) Reading Lee Smith is a true Southern American pleasure. All of her books charm you.
Oct 25, 2013 Shannon rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2013
Following her mother's death, thirteen-year-old Evalina Toussaint is sent to Highland Hospital in North Carolina, the same mental institution where Zelda Fitzgerald and eight other women died in an intentionally set fire in 1948. With an inventive blend of history and fiction, Lee Smith follows Evalina through the 1930's and 40's, as she experiences the treatments prescribed by Dr. Carroll, who runs the hospital, as well as the imagined events leading up to the tragedy that took so many lives.

Andrea Larson
Nov 06, 2013 Andrea Larson rated it liked it
Guests on Earth explores daily life at Asheville, North Carolina’s renowned mental institution, Highland Hospital, from 1936 until 1948, when the main building burned in a tragic fire, killing nine people and gravely injuring others. It centers around the life of a fictional character, Evalina Toussaint, but also interweaves the story of the hospital’s most famous patient, Zelda Fitzgerald.

This book is interesting mostly for the window it provides into how mental illness was diagnosed and treat
Amelia Gremelspacher
Oct 14, 2013 Amelia Gremelspacher rated it it was amazing
"Any life is such - different stories like different strands." Our narrator, Evalina, has spent much of her life in Highland Hospital, and institute for the insane. Famously, it is also the home of Zelda Fitzgerald who stays there on and off until the end of her life. Evalina employs the insights she has learned in treatment to share the the diverse paths of her closest fellow patients and of the staff. As a narrator, she possesses the precious ability to share what she sees within herself as we ...more
Nov 22, 2013 Candice rated it really liked it
Zelda Fitzgerald, the wife of F. Scott Fitzgerald was tragically killed in a fire at Highland Hospital (a mental hospital) in Asheville, NC on March 10, 1948. Ms. Smith tells a story of life in that institution through the eyes of a young woman, Evalina Toussaint, the daughter of a New Orleans exotic dancer, who has been sent to Highland at the age of 13 and remains there for several years. It is an absorbing piece of historical fiction as many of the characters in the book are real historical f ...more
Jan 29, 2014 Lisa rated it really liked it
The newest novel by master writer Lee Smith tells the story of life in North Carolina's Highlands Hospital, a real mental facility. Smith tells the story through the fictional character of Evalina Toussaint, first a patient starting in 1936, and later a member of the staff.

Evalina sees the good in the people in the hospital, including Zelda Fitzgerald, wife of F. Scott. Smith uses this novel to show the plight of people with mental illness.

Both of Lee Smith's parents and her son suffered from me
Diane Barnes
Jan 08, 2014 Diane Barnes rated it really liked it
Shelves: book-club-2014
This novel paints a picture and creates a world of Highland Hospital in Asheville, NC through the eyes of Evalina Toussaint, an unusual child who spent her teen years and a lot of her adulthood "inside the snow globe" as a patient and staff member of the mental hospital. Although Evalina was a fictional character, through her we meet Zelda Fitzgerald, the most famous patient of the hospital, who died there in the tragic fire in 1948. This was a beautifully written book that illuminates the autho ...more
Laura Lee
Apr 27, 2014 Laura Lee rated it it was amazing
Zelda Fitzgerald has been a hot topic in novels for the last year or so. Smith's latest book is about Highland Hospital in Asheville NC, where Zelda is a patient, on and off for about ten years. During that time a young girl is also admitted, released and admitted again. Though Zelda is a character in the book, the main character is Evalina. She also narrates the book. I found her heartbreak chilling and her life sad but triumphant at the same time. Smith is perfect at portraying the South and w ...more
Oct 20, 2014 Lyssa rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
This book was very annoying and pointless. I felt that the main character, Evalina, was only created to show the interactions with Zelda Fitzgerald in the mental hospital. Why not just write a book about Zelda Fitzgerald? Evalina loved living in the mental hospital and considered it her home and the patients and doctors her family. She was a messed up character who wasted all of her potential and expensive schooling to run after a wastrel. Her baby dies and the book never even addresses her grie ...more
Aug 18, 2014 Mark rated it liked it
Shelves: audiobooks
Evalina Toussaint was only thirteen, when she was suddenly orphaned and admitted to a mental institution in Asheville North Carolina. This was 1936 and one of the hospital's most notable patients, was Zelda Fitzgerald. She befriends young Evalina and helps her navigate her way, through this unique time and place.
The story, weaving fact and fiction, follows Evalina for the next twelve years, in and out of the institution and then concludes at the infamous fire that ravaged Highland Hospital, in 1
Gail Amendt
Jul 07, 2015 Gail Amendt rated it really liked it
"The insane are always mere guests on earth, eternal strangers carrying around broken decalogues that they cannot read" - F. Scott Fitzgerald.

This book attempts to blend fact and fiction to explore a somewhat dark topic in history, that being the treatment of the mentally ill in the early to mid 2oth Century. It is set in the real Highland Hospital in Asheville, North Carolina, a private mental institution catering to the upper classes, where the patients were referred to as "guests." Highland
Karma  Nash
Feb 23, 2014 Karma Nash rated it liked it
I am a Lee Smith lover, and I do love parts of this book, but only parts. It did not hold together for me, or flow. I understand that part of the episodic nature of the book's structure mimics the often disjoiinted impressions of the main character due to the tragedies of her life. I get that. But, still as a reader, I needed more from the book.

First, I wanted more of Zelda. She is barely here, and in very unsatisfying little vignettes almost. She seems to just flit through at times, giving no
Sep 15, 2013 Michelle rated it really liked it
Guests on Earth by Lee Smith tells the story of Evalina, the child of a New Orleans exotic dancer. In 1936, left fatherless and orphaned, her mother’s married ex-boyfriend assumes her care. While in his home, the first sign of mental illness presents itself, and she is sent to Highland Hospital in Ashville NC—a progressive insane asylum for the wealthy who call the residents guests. At Highland, Evalina forms a makeshift family of colorfully tragic characters, finds love, herself and maybe even ...more
Brenda Ayala
Oct 03, 2015 Brenda Ayala rated it liked it
Shelves: netgalley
(I received this from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.)

The descriptions and the characters were what carried this story along. I enjoyed reading about all the women Evalina knew; from Pan to Dixie, to Mrs. Fitzgerald herself. They brought color and life to a story that was otherwise somewhat bland.

The environment was a beautiful one; a far cry from the dismal atmosphere I was expecting from a book about a mental hospital in the 1940s. I was surprised by the love and amiability all th
Evelyn Foss
Apr 20, 2015 Evelyn Foss rated it really liked it
My husband thought I was reading a book he would like since he thought the title suggested a sic-fi novel. Guests on Earth was sort of other worldly at times, but mostly just Southern USA since it takes place in Asheville, NC and New Orleans.

I like Evalina Toussaint and the people she met during her times at Highlands Hospital. The book held my attention because it seemed to give an accurate depiction of mental health treatment available to the upper classes in the 30s. I also liked the charact
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
  • The Tall Woman
  • Moonrise
  • River of Dust
  • The Two Hotel Francforts
  • Love and Lament
  • Flora
  • Rainbows on the Moon
  • Lookaway, Lookaway
  • The Tilted World
  • Lightning Bug
  • Raney
  • Fanny Stevenson: A Romance of Destiny
  • The Funeral Dress
  • The Road from Gap Creek
  • The Resurrectionist
  • Crossing Purgatory
  • Faint Promise of Rain
  • Quiet Dell
Growing up in the Appalachian mountains of southwestern Virginia, nine-year-old Lee Smith was already writing--and selling, for a nickel apiece--stories about her neighbors in the coal boomtown of Grundy and the nearby isolated "hollers." Since 1968, she has published eleven novels, as well as three collections of short stories, and has received many writing awards.

The sense of place infusing her
More about Lee Smith...

Share This Book

“And are we not all “mere guests” upon this whirling earth?” 12 likes
“Now courting’s a pleasure, and parting is grief, but a false-hearted lover is worse than a thief!” 2 likes
More quotes…