Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Affairs of Others” as Want to Read:
The Affairs of Others
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Affairs of Others

2.78 of 5 stars 2.78  ·  rating details  ·  1,005 ratings  ·  198 reviews

Five years after her young husband's death, Celia Cassill has moved from one Brooklyn neighborhood to another, but she has not moved on. The owner of a small apartment building, she has chosen her tenants for their
ebook, 304 pages
Published August 27th 2013 by Picador (first published 2013)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Affairs of Others, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Affairs of Others

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
~✡~Dαni(ela) ♥ ♂♂ love & semi-colons~✡~
1.5 stars

It's unfortunate that I can't quote from this book (I received a free galley copy from Netgalley) because then you could get a good giggle from some of the word choices. In an effort to be smart and literary and high-brow, Loyd fills her novel with weird metaphors and bizarrely stifled phrases. The Affairs of Others is a thorough mess, disjointed with no apparent plot and little character development.

It's also told in a pseudo internal monologue, with the protagonist, Celia, telling us
Celia is a widow who doesn't know how to really move on. Five years after her husband's death, she is the landlord of a small apartment building in Brooklyn. She is very picky about whom she chooses as tenants, because she very much wants to be left alone and not be forced to interact with anyone too much.

Then one of her tenants has the opportunity to travel, but only if Celia will allow him to sublet his apartment for a few months to Hope. Celia finds herself intrigued with Hope and her desire
Really did not like this.
1. The author tried way too hard to be a "great writer" as in: let's write flowery prose that does not advance the story but shows how talented I am.
2. So everybody - and I mean EVERYBODY- want to have sex with the mopey, sad, closed off to the world, can't get over her husband's death Celia? Really? Why? By the middle of the book I was just irritated by her.
3. Not one like able character in this book.
Patrice Hoffman
The Affairs of Others by Amy Grace Loyd is the debut, literary fiction novel about a woman who loves her seperateness. After Celia's husband dies prematurely from cancer, she buys an apartment building consisting of four apartments. She becomes the landlord to three other tenants in a downtown Brooklyn building. Celia is highly practiced at remaining apart from the people in her building until Hope arrives.

Hope is an unwanted subletter who Celia sees as a threat to her being able to remain alon
Robert Blumenthal
I picked this book because it was highly praised by one of my favorite authors, Jess Walter. In the middle of my reading it, I noticed that it was generally not well-liked by many, if not most, of the readers on Goodreads. In finishing it, I can see how some readers will not find this book to be their cup of tea. It is told in the first person narrative of a woman who lost her deeply-loved husband to cancer when she was in her thirties. The narrative, subsequently, is immersed in grief and self- ...more
Not a good book. Before I’d gotten through the first ten pages, I could tell the author’s writing style was not to my liking. And although some reviewers have said they didn’t like the writing style because it was too “literary,” I have to say that I love literary fiction and that’s the main genre I read. So it’s not that the writing style is too literary, it’s that it’s too formal and stiff, almost self-consciously arty, as if it’s trying for literariness (whatever that is) and trying much too ...more
Amanda Byrne
When I first saw the title of this book, I misread it as The Lives of Others and got super excited - the 2006 German film is one of my all-time favorites and...well, none of that matters now. Suffice to say, it's not a book based on the movie.

That said, the first quarter of the book was reminiscent of Wiesler's surveillance of Georg Dreyman - Celia maintains her precious distance from her tenants, yet couches her observations of their comings and goings, their fights, their odd tics, as a need t

This book has a fantastic beginning, especially the first several pages. Brilliant. It's strong for a while, very good buildup. And then, everything goes to hell. The motivations of the main character, Celia, stop making sense. They are extremely uncharacteristic. I was loving her voice in the beginning. She was widowed in her early thirties, and even 5 years from now, she is almost speaking through a veil. She avoids connections and clutches the stories o
Bonnie Brody
Celia Cassill has been widowed for five years and still keeps her husband close to her heart and psyche. With the money he left her, she bought a brownstone in Brooklyn that houses four apartments, hers and three others that she rents. She carefully picks her tenants and wants to maintain good boundaries and her own solitude. However, things do not happen that way. One of her tenants, an elderly man named Mr. Caughlin disappears and Celia is involved with trying to find him along with the police ...more
I wanted to like this book. I really did. And in some ways, I suppose, I did, but not enough to make me feel like this is a completely worthwhile read. Don’t you hate it when that happens?
As literary fiction, I didn’t expect car chases and the like, so it is not that which made this a bit of a dull read. The problem, I feel, is that while we get a lot about the protagonist’s inner workings, we still don’t really come to relate to her in any substantial way. Yes, the writing is lovely, with some
Very unique style of writing. Sentences and words flow in an odd rhythm unlike any I've read before. Every time I sat down to read, it took me a page or two to get back into the swing of the story. And there's not really much story to speak of. I enjoy a good character-driven book, but this one lacked any real thread looping then all together. Sure, there's the building itself, and the missing tenant, and the remaining crazies. But not much else. Nothing that lent any solidity. It was all vey li ...more
Kate Padilla
I akin this book to a symphony.

It starts out slow, testing the reader and the story. The further you read, the more depressing it gets, but before long the tempo, and mood, increases and you leave with a sense of hope you would have never guess existed halfway through.

This is a book I need to think more on before writing a full review, however. Right now, just a day after finishing it, I can say without hesitation that it is beautifully written, and wonderfully executed. My more in-depth thought
Jo Verity
I picked this book off the 'new in' shelf at my local library. I had no idea what to expect although the cover blurb/premise was promising - a small apartment house and the intertwined lives of landlady and tenants. There was a good story in there somewhere but Loyd's writing style got in the way. It seemed to me that she was trying too hard, forcing it. In places it was overwritten. Not for me, I'm afraid.
Can't remember where I saw that this book got a good review, but I thought it was terrible! I found the story contrived and the characters unbelievable. The only part I liked was the descriptions of New York City!
Laura Serico
Oy. Grief atop piles of grief on Grief Street, Brooklyn. Not the best book to read at the start of a beach vacation.
Barbara Ell
I received this book free from Picador for my honest review.

The book is OK. I like the writing, the details and what was going on. However, I had problems with the characters. Celia seemed to float along with however the wind took her. She "self-medicated" but sometimes one never knew whether or not she had taken any pills because she didn't act any differently. Maybe because of this, then the other characters seem 2-dimensional. Hope seems a bit more, but never truly developed. I think the cha
Amelia Gremelspacher
"My husband died a difficult death. I went with him, or a lot of me did.", August 27,
This review is from: The Affairs of Others: A Novel (Kindle Edition)
Celia is now in her thirties and notices that, "The body of a woman aging. It's a landscape that, even as it vanishes, asks a lot of the eyes." She is a widow, a contingency for which her younger self has not planned. Celia has taken her small savings and bought a converted Brooklyn brownstone in which to live out her days. She has finished it
Since The Affairs of Others is a first-person narrative told through Celia’s point of view and with her observations and opinions, one’s enjoyment of the novel hinges on whether one finds Celia a credible narrator. A young, financially independent widow with sadomasochistic tendencies and a penchant for hiding from the world may cause some readers to cringe at the self-pity and self-imposed seclusion while also causing them to feel horrible for doing so. For Celia’s actions, especially regarding ...more
Jai Francy
If there was ever a woman that needed a hobby, it’s the protagonist in this book. The character development in this book, especially the main character, is extremely thin. The relationships between all of them shallow. If much of what one knows about the main character after completing any book is her cleaning schedule, the name of the cleaning lady and the approved cleaning methods and products – there is a problem with character depth.

The main character, Celia, is not able to move on with her
Theresa Smith
What beautiful prose existed in this book was overshadowed by a constant degeneration into rambling that seemed to have no end. I continued reading out of a vain hope that this book may turn a corner, give me a reason to like Celia enough to have endured her ramblings, but this was never realised. Such a shame, the cover and blurb did much to draw me in, but sadly the content failed to deliver. The moments of true poignancy were just too few and far between to justify the investment of having bo ...more
Christopher Litsinger
This book can be summarized thusly:
A young woman's husband dies. Hope moves into the apartment above her (yes, really, her name is Hope). Only when she learns to love Hope is she able to move forward in life.
Oh, and there's some "racy" sex scenes that seem to be mostly there to convince you that the author is hip enough to do that. They're pretty boring.
So, yeah, there's that.
Also, for the first few chapters of the book, the protagonist seems way too old for her description. Maybe this is inten
Renita D'Silva
Beautifully written, a clever, nuanced tale.
This book was a mixed bag for me. I do think Ms Loyd is a talented writer. However I found the plot of her book was not very believable, nor the characters interesting or likeable.

The book started out with great promise - a landlady and her tenants living in a small apartment building in Brooklyn. Change comes when a new tenant arrives to sublet. As it is a small building the owner knows her tenants fairly well. She has chosen with care the people she rents to, so the introduction of this new t
Mike Cuthbert
This is a tightly packed domestic monologue by an only slightly disturbed woman in her thirties who has already had a husband die and is lost as a result. She inherited enough money to buy an apartment house and the “others” of the title are a strange lot of older folks, younger disturbed males and females and Celia, the landlady who is the narrator. Nothing much happens externally in the novel. Mr. Coughlan, an old seaman, disappears and Celia is distressed because he is one of her favorites. A ...more
Jeffrey Matthews
This book had a LOT of metaphors throughout. Some of the single lines make really great quotes, the kind that would be on a poster or an email tag line. It was interesting to see how people's lives affect each others; some enhance. Some degrade. None stay the same. In this book most were enhanced or changed for the better. Some good revelations and some great moments of closure. However Celia is on another level...
Normally, I'd say a novel lives by its beginning and a poem by its ending. Strangely enough, this novel does the reverse. I was more than annoyed with it in the middle but the ending seemed graceful and kind. The caginess displayed by the narrator seemed overblown to me. It wasn't until its true source was revealed near the end that I came to really sympathize with her. Several of the characters come off a bit like caricatures (Les, Angela) but I fell in love with the old ferry captain after he ...more
Elizabeth K.
Feb 26, 2014 Elizabeth K. rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Elizabeth by: Review on The Millions blog
Shelves: 2014-new-reads
This started off okay, when I was hopeful that it was going to be about awful people having a comeuppance, but it turned out that no, the book was about the awful people. While it is true that poor decisions can be the basis for interesting stories, it's not automatic. All the poor decisions depicted here are tiresome.

Overall, I'm embarrassed it was set in New York.
Terri Jacobson
Celia Cassill has been a widow for 5 years. She owns a small apartment building in Brooklyn, and is obsessed with maintaining her privacy and seclusion. When one of her tenants sublets his apartment to a woman divorcing after 20 years of marriage, Celia and her privacy come under scrutiny and everything changes. A well-written book.
Celia is a young widow who bought a Brooklyn apartment house when her much loved husband died. She has hand picked her tenants for their quietness and her perception that they will keep to themselves, as will she. She maintains her isolation by self-medicating and engaging in anonymous sex with strangers. For five years that strategy has worked, and she has remained numb, but when her upstairs tenant sublets his apartment to the enchanting and tragic Hope who may be involved in an abusive relati ...more

OK, had to read it again! Here's my review: I'll start with the positives: yes, I will probably read this author's next book, the reason why is because of the hauntingly beautiful, evocative writing this debut author exhibits. I found myself marking sentences and paragraphs as I went along, reading them over, sometimes aloud, as poetry (Kudos to you for that, Ms. Loyd!). That said, I actually read the entire book twice, because the storyline was so dense with the characters' actions and details
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Tumbledown
  • Enon
  • Subtle Bodies
  • Antonia Lively Breaks The Silence
  • Tinderbox
  • Love and Lament
  • The Measures Between Us
  • The Explanation for Everything: A Novel
  • Lookaway, Lookaway
  • Love All
  • Stay Up With Me
  • Early Decision: Based on a True Frenzy
  • The Why of Things: A Novel
  • Very Recent History: An Entirely Factual Account of a Year (c. AD 2009) in a Large City
  • The Virgins
  • The Woman Who Lost Her Soul
  • Visible City
  • The Suitors
Amy Grace Loyd, author of The Affairs of Others, is an executive editor at Byliner Inc. and was the fiction and literary editor at Playboy magazine. A recipient of both MacDowell and Yaddo fellowships, she lives in Brooklyn, New York.
More about Amy Grace Loyd...

Share This Book