Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Necessary Lies” as Want to Read:
Necessary Lies
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview
Read Excerpt

Necessary Lies

by
4.21 of 5 stars 4.21  ·  rating details  ·  17,874 ratings  ·  2,453 reviews
Bestselling author Diane Chamberlain delivers a breakout book about a small southern town fifty years ago, and the darkest—and most hopeful—places in the human heart

After losing her parents, fifteen-year-old Ivy Hartis left to care for her grandmother, older sister and nephew as tenants on a small tobacco farm. As she struggles with her grandmother’s aging, her sister’s me
...more
Hardcover, 368 pages
Published September 3rd 2013 by St. Martin's Press (first published August 1st 2013)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Necessary Lies, please sign up.

Popular Answered Questions

Jane Harris I would not agree. I believe that the book was well written. It was an engrossing, well researched story, though not a literary "masterpiece."…moreI would not agree. I believe that the book was well written. It was an engrossing, well researched story, though not a literary "masterpiece."(less)
Karen O'donnell tennenbaum Actually even in the 1990's when I was working in foster care as an RN, Social workers did not have to have special qualifications, training or…moreActually even in the 1990's when I was working in foster care as an RN, Social workers did not have to have special qualifications, training or experience or even a degree in social work. (less)
Allegiant by Veronica RothThe Transfer by Veronica RothThe House of Hades by Rick RiordanFangirl by Rainbow RowellThe Longest Ride by Nicholas Sparks
2013 Book
13th out of 189 books — 173 voters
Her Master's Courtesan by Lily  WhiteKing Cave by Scarlett DawnPoint of No Return by Tiffany SnowTurn on a Dime - Kade's Turn by Tiffany SnowBackward Compatible by Sarah Daltry
Platypire Reviews' Top Books of January 2014
18th out of 118 books — 209 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Debbie "DJ" Wilson
This novel exceeded my already high expectations, and is historical fiction at it's best. I'm always drawn to America's dirty little secrets, and here we have N. Carolina's eugenics program in the 1960's. Chamberlain does an excellent job focusing in on one specific family and the impact this program has on their lives.

The main character, Jane, follows her heart to become a social worker against her husbands wishes (and later demands) to be a housewife and baby maker. She soon learns that this j
...more
Amy
Aug 28, 2013 Amy rated it 5 of 5 stars
Shelves: reread
Can I give NECESSARY LIES more than 5 stars? I recommend reading Diane Chamberlain's short story THE FIRST LIE as an introduction to the book, but it's not essential.
The year is 1960. The place, rural North Carolina. Jane is a 22 year old newlywed, beginning her first job as a social worker. One of her more intriguing cases is the Hart family. The ailing grandmother Nonnie, her seventeen-year-old intellectually disabled daughter Mary Ella mother to two-year-old Baby William, and fifteen-year-ol
...more
Margitte
This is the story of Jane, Ivy and Mary of Grace County, North Carolina.

Sadly, it is also about the dire policies and consequences of eugenics on unsuspecting victims.

THE EUGENICS BACKGROUND
The Hart family, (consisting of grandmother Nonnie and her two granddaughters, the two sisters Mary Ella and Ivy), was, according to Margaret Sanger (a eugenics advocate) those good-for-nothing people who were fostered at the expense of good human beings. They were those genetic elements, who contributed to
...more
Angela M
I don't know why it has taken me so long to discover the wonderfully talented writer, Diane Chamberlain . But I am thrilled I have been introduced to her writing by a Gooodreads friend , who gave this book a glowing review .
The story of two welfare families working so hard and doing what ever it takes to provide bare minimum food and shelter for themselves & their families is heartbreaking . But at the point in the story where we learn of the Eugenics Sterilization Program and the impact on
...more
Sharon
Jane Forrester has recently just married her husband Robert, who is a pediatrician. Jane is desperate to have a career before starting a family of her own. Her husband doesn't approve of her working and doesn't understand why she feels the need to work.

Jane decides to take a job as a social worker and one of her first cases is the Hart family. Ivy is fifteen years old and lives with her ailing grandmother Nonnie, her elder sister Mary Ella and her baby William. Together they all live on a tobacc
...more
B the BookAddict
Mar 15, 2014 B the BookAddict rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Most readers
Recommended to B the BookAddict by: Sharon's review


What impresses me most about this novel is the writer's ability to not play the overly dramatic tone in what is a pretty dramatic story. While healthy outrage ensured that steam poured from my own ears, Diane Chamberlain's manner and tone remained grounded and matter of fact throughout. Chamberlain acknowledges that while the characters of this novel are fictional, they are, incredibly, based on real cases; cases which were the norm in 1960 North Carolina. Knowing this will send chills through y
...more
Dem
3.5 Stars

Necessary Lies was an engaging and compelling read by Diane chamberlain.

I love how the author took the tough subject of the Eugenics Sterilization Program and wove it into this Fiction story.

The Eugenics Sterilization Program took place between the years of 1929 and 1975 and saw over seven thousand of North Carolina's citizens sterilized. The program targeted the " mentally defective" "feebleminded" inmates in mental institutions and training schools and others whose sterilization was
...more
☮Karen
Extremely well written, informative 5-star historical fiction.

I was so naive about the Eugenics Sterilization Program in the U.S., I had to Google it and found out some things even more shocking than what's revealed in this book. The Nazi's eugenics programs were largely based on what America was doing to the blacks, the feeble-minded, and the poor. Even after we saw how Hitler went far beyond what anyone could have imagined, the programs continued into the 60s and 70s. There were also euthanasi
...more
☔Diane S.
3.5 I am appalled that with the large amount of books I have read, I had never heard of this eugenic program before. A white family of sharecroppers on a tobacco farm in the south, and a newly married social worker are the two threads in this story.
The thread with the sharecroppers was my favorite, the parts with Jane sometimes came off a bit awkward. The book, nevertheless, hooked me from the very beginning. All the secrets kept and waiting to be revealed on this farm, Jane and her pediatric h
...more
Carol
Set in 1960's rural North Carolina, a shocking, but enlightening story surrounding the Eugenic's Sterilization Program, their unethical practices and the abuse of State authority. I was totally unfamiliar with the program thus surprised and disgusted with the procedures yet was totally enthralled by the author's presentation and well-developed characters.

Another page-turning winner for Diane Chamberlain!

Kathryn
This is my first Diane Chamberlain, and I don’t think it will be my last. The story was based around the eugenics program of North Carolina in the 1960’s - the state-mandated sterilisation of the “mentally defective”, the “feebleminded”, people in mental institutions, people with epilepsy. For people living in the community, a petition for sterilisation could be initiated by a social worker and could be done without consent of the person involved if a guardian consented. This occurred from 1929 ...more
Connie
Living in North Carolina (actually very close to where this fictional story is set) the topic that Chamberlain tackles in "Necessary Lies" is one that continues to be in the news, and is a black mark on the history of this state. Many states had Eugenics/Sterilization programs for mainly mentally ill and institutionalized patients, however most stopped these practices after the war, often due to the comparison with Hitlers Master Race ideas. Sadly, North Carolina not only continued the practice ...more
Elizabeth of Silver's Reviews


"Ivy and Mary was here."

Those words are the beginning, the ending, and the basis of NECESSARY LIES. Those five words go full circle in this incredible, haunting book.

You will be transported to another world as you read NECESSARY LIES. A world of poverty and illiteracy as well as pity for the way the families had to live.

Jane, a physician's wife, was the new social worker dealing with the Hart and Jordan families. The families worked on a farm owned by Mr. Gardiner who had connections with both f
...more
Aoibhínn
Another wonderful gripping and engaging read from Diane Chamberlain with plenty of twists and turns throughout the novel. It was well-written and extremely thought provoking. I loved all the main characters and most of the supporting characters. All the characters were well developed, likable and really believable. I found the eugenic sterilisation programme to be quite shocking and disturbing and I can't believe that it was still being practiced in the USA until as recently as 1974. The only ba ...more
Crystal Craig
May 06, 2015 Crystal Craig rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: anyone who enjoyed 'Whistling Past the Graveyard'
I love the character, Jane Forrester. She's so independent and passionate - determined to stand up for what she believes is right. All the characters were well-developed. I went with the audio version, and I had a hard time to stop from listening. I enjoyed the setting; 1960, rural North Carolina. It had that southern small town feeling. The story covers many difficult issues, topics that are sad to read. I find when I'm reading about how cruel humans being can often be, I need a happy outcome, ...more
Kristie
This was an interesting historical fiction novel that has it's roots in a too true sterilization program. Set in Grace County in North Carolina in the 1960s, this is the story of Jane Forrester, a new social worker for the welfare department and a few of her clients, most specifically Ivy Hart.

Jane has recently gotten married, but wants to put off having children until after she has worked for a while. She feels that it is important to help people and chooses to do so as a welfare social worker
...more
Rose
One of the best novels I've read in 2013, hands down, and I'm kind of floored that I haven't heard all that much about the book apart from conversations locally (because I live in the state this is set within, even grew up and interacted in the cities it had taken place.) While this novel is historical fiction, the setting and terms of events in this novel as depicted is very real. I can't stress that enough to anyone who might pick up this novel to read.

To say I'm horrified at reading some of t
...more
Phrynne
My main reaction to this book was amazement that such awful things could still have been happening within my own life time. I was aware of the Nazi eugenic program during World War Two but not that such a thing was carried on in America right up to the early seventies. Incredible. I did enjoy the book very much. The main characters of Jane and Ivy were both very well written and I found myself cheering them on and praying for happy endings for them both. I liked the way we saw the story from sev ...more
Lela
4.5 Really good book. Liked it a whole lot. Can't believe the story behind the book! Well, yes, I can. It just infuriates me!
Lindsay (Little Reader Library)
Necessary Lies has a period setting in Grace County, rural North Carolina, USA in 1960. Newly married Jane Forrester controversially embarks on a career as a social worker, whilst most of her contemporaries are stay-at-home wives and mothers. Ivy Hart is a fifteen-year-old girl living and working in harsh, destitute conditions on a small tobacco farm, caring for her aging grandmother and older sister who has a small child; on top of this Ivy copes with epilepsy. Ivy’s family is one of those that ...more
Molly
While this book had some strong moments, its strengths were often outweighed by its weaknesses. Characters were either one-dimensional, stock characters (this is not to say that they were unlikeable or unnecessary to the story, they were just lacking in depth and originality), or so contradictory as to make it impossible to believe them.

I had a particular problem with one protagonist, Jane. While I suppose it was the author's intention to illustrate the conflict a 1960s woman might have felt be
...more
☯Cathrine
3.5 stars. I wasn't sure I would read another Chamberlaine book. I found two previous reads a bit too predictable and simplistic. This one was much better. I enjoyed it as an audio book, entertainingly read by the reader. It was well written and more engaging. I also feel that the fictional account about a true and sad period in U.S. history told the story better than the widely popular Orphan Train, which engaged in too many stereotypes with a rushed and unbelievable ending. The two books are b ...more
Jenna
Stunned this happened in my home state. Review to come...
Tania
"That's what it's all about, isn't it?" she asked. "Being able to choose what we want to do."


3.5 stars. An easy-reading novel about a difficult subject. I knew nothing about the Eugenics Sterilization Program, where North Carolina sterilized over 7,000 of it's citizens for the "public good". The author does a brilliant job creating the background - even women of means had to get permission from their husbands to go on the pill, were frowned upon if they had a job when it wasn't necessary. Agains
...more
Sofia Lazaridou
From 1929 until 1974, an estimated 7,600 North Carolinians, women and men, many of whom were poor, undereducated, institutionalized, sick or disabled, were sterilized by choice, force or coercion under the authorization of the North Carolina Eugenics Board program.

A 1937 Fortune magazine poll found that 2/3 of respondents supported eugenic sterilization of "mental defectives", 63% supported sterilization of criminals, and only 15% opposed both. Although the following events were not explicitly j
...more
Esil
I won this book from Goodreads. This was the first book I read by Diane Chamberlain, although I understand that she has written many books. I really enjoyed it and made my way through it very quickly. The genre of books I read are very diverse and this fit very nicely with my occasional taste for some of Jodi Picoult's better books or Kristin Hannah's more recent books. Although the story's backdrop was the practice of eugenics in North Carolina, what worked particularly well for me was the depi ...more
Laurie Carlson
My Take:
5+ STARS!
When I got this book for review, Necessary Lies, the first thing I did was visit this authors website. I couldn't tell you why I did, but I did. I am SO glad I did because while there I found this novella, a prequel to this book called, "The First Lie". I bought that one, read it, and I fell in love with the characters. You can find that review HERE. I knew I was going to love this book, and I did. Oh, did I ever!
After reading this book, "Necessary Lies", it demands we stand up
...more
Sue
I won a copy of "Necessary Lies" by Diane Chamberlain through the Goodreads Giveaway Contest. This a beautifully written moving novel set in the rural South, in Raleigh in Grace County, tells the story of two young women, Jane and Ivy, both faced by tragedy and obstacles in their path.

After losing her parents, fifteen-year-old Ivy Hart is left to care for her aging diabetic grandmother, seventeen year old mentally ill sister, Mary Ella and nephew, baby William as tenants on a small tobacco farm
...more
T's Book
Powerful and thought provoking.

A story primarily told by two girls/women living in North Carolina in the early sixties. As a woman this story really pulls you. Eugenics and sterilization was used and practiced during this time to prevent pregnancy in women and fertility in men deemed “unfit”. However this was the only state where social workers had the right to decided who needed it and why on their own without the consent or knowledge of the patient receiving this treatment. Many were lied to
...more
Nicole Long
Wow! Diane Chamberlain is an amazing writer. I won this book through a Goodreads Firstreads Giveaway and I am so glad that I did. So many thoughts tumbling through my mind. The story takes place for the most part during 1960, in North Carolina, and deals with the lives affected by the Eugenics Sterilization Program that existed in NC from 1929-1975. The two main characters, Jane, a brand new Social Worker and newlywed, and Ivy, a 15 year old on Jane's new caseload, will open your eyes to a time ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Brantford Public ...: Too GOOD to be TRUE? 7 32 Nov 30, 2014 08:34AM  
Brantford Public ...: BABY WILLIAM - Loved or Neglected? 5 35 Nov 22, 2014 05:55PM  
Ivy's mother and Lita Jordan's children 1 29 Nov 05, 2014 03:17AM  
Thought provoking.... 1 24 Oct 03, 2014 02:02PM  
  • Whistling Past the Graveyard
  • Garden of Stones
  • Little Mercies
  • A Hundred Summers
  • Hush Little Baby
  • Calling Me Home
  • The Circle of Thirteen
  • Someone Else's Love Story
  • Heart Like Mine
  • Spare Change
  • The Time Between
  • Looking for Me
  • A Place at the Table
  • The Promise of Stardust
  • The Homecoming of Samuel Lake
  • The Glass Wives
  • The Funeral Dress
  • Rush Home Road
93345
Diane Chamberlain is the USA Today and London Times bestselling author of 23 novels published in more than twenty languages. Diane likes to write complex stories about relationships between men and women, parents and children, brothers and sisters, and friends. Although the thematic focus of her books often revolves around family, love, compassion and forgiveness, her stories usually feature a com ...more
More about Diane Chamberlain...
The Secret Life of CeeCee Wilkes The Midwife's Confession The Silent Sister: A Novel The Good Father Before the Storm (Before the Storm, #1)

Share This Book

“Sometimes coloring outside the lines can cost you. Only you can figure out if it’s worth it.” 12 likes
“All the love in the world doesn't put food on the table.” 5 likes
More quotes…