I'm Dying Up Here: Heartbreak and High Times in Stand-Up Comedy's Golden Era

I'm Dying Up Here: Heartbreak and High Times in Stand-Up Comedy's Golden Era

3.78 of 5 stars 3.78  ·  rating details  ·  344 ratings  ·  68 reviews
In the mid-1970s, Jay Leno, David Letterman, Andy Kaufman, Richard Lewis, Robin Williams, Elayne Boosler, Tom Dreesen, and several hundred other shameless showoffs and incorrigible cutups from across the country migrated en masse to Los Angeles, the new home of Johnny Carson’s Tonight Show. There, in a late-night world of sex, drugs, dreams and laughter, they created an ar...more
Hardcover, 280 pages
Published August 25th 2009 by PublicAffairs
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 626)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Gerard Collins

I'd never heard of this book, but it popped up on some list of titles under $3 available for the Kindle, so I tried a sample. I whipped through that pretty quickly, so the few bucks weren't much of a consideration as I wondered what came next.

Written by a reporter who covered the comedy club scene in L.A. for the Los Angeles Times, the book focuses primarily on a period between 1972 and 1979, when a new and distinct generation of comedic talent broke through into the entertainment industry, and...more
Michael Clayton
I enjoyed this book, but not as much as I figured I would as the nature of the content is a bit misleading. I thought it would be a history of many of the comics displayed on the cover and summary (Jay Leno, David Letterman, and Richard Lewis are huge figures in the book, for sure, but less for their careers and more for the overall contribution they had to the main story. As for Andy Kaufman, hes mentioned only briefly throughout). The book is really about Comedy Store owner Mitzi Shore and the...more
Fred
An interesting book about the rise of the Comedy Store stand-up club in Los Angeles and the strike by stand-up comedians which occurred as a result of the comedians not being paid by the owners. This is the main part of the book and it's quite interesting. Comedians organizing a union makes for an interesting labour history lesson.

The detailed history includes the accounts of many famous comedians coming to LA before they made it big. Letterman, Leno, Richard Lewis and Robin Williams among other...more
Owen
I found this book pretty fascinating. At least in it subject, is it concerned many of the folks I have watched growing up and still watch today. I was not blown away by the treatment of the subject which is why I only get 3 stars. I should disclose that I listen to it and then I don't think the narrator has ever been funny for a day in his life and I think that took something away from it. Still it was fast and hear about how comedy migrated in Diboll from New York to Los Angeles and how they tr...more
Chris
I love it when a book just jumps out at me. I was at the library and saw this book on display. I like comedy, but it's not something I would generally read about - yet there was something about this book that appealed to me, so I checked it out. And I loved it. I found the story of how David Letterman, Jay Leno, Richard Lewis, Robin Williams and a host of others got their starts in small clubs--usually for no money--fascinating. The author spent time covering these guys and the comedy scene in L...more
Brandon
Dealing with the standup comedy scene in Los Angeles during the 1970's, I'm Dying Up Here focuses on Mitzi Shore's The Comedy Store and the efforts of the comedians to make it big and attempt to get paid until they did. The book focuses on several different comedians, but the main character is the venue, with Pauly Shore's mom serving as the villain of the piece. Shore's argument was that the comics used the store as a showcase to hone their craft while the comedian's argued that the renovations...more
Jeremy
The camaraderie and rivalry between comedians is fascinating. It's almost like a bond between people who have experienced some horrible crisis together, only the comedian's crisis is played out on a stage in front of strangers.

The job of a stand-up comic is one I would never want but will always want. I'm a funny enough guy in social situations, but I've never thought I could parlay that into some sort of career. I don't want to purposefully put myself in crisis.

This book details the explosion...more
Beth Mechum
I've become increasingly interested in stand up comedy after I discovered the Marc Maron podcast. I think I even found this book through his Twitter feed. The first half of the book was exactly what I wanted - great stories and inside knowledge of stand up comedians and their relationships. The book really stalled when the conflict between the comedians and the Comedy Store with Mitzi Shore. Most of the rest of the book was about that conflict and the formation of (or the proposed formation of)...more
Bart
This is a well-reported book about a time and place that is of only esoteric importance today.

Do not read this book for deep insights into the comedic impulse or what enables a person to climb before strangers and tell unsolicited jokes. That would be a fascinating subject - maybe better for the psychology section of the bookstore - but it's not really in here.

Again, this book is a report. It chronicles the Comedy Store strike of 1979. It's germane to contemporary times, somewhat, because it fea...more
Jeanne
This is an entertaining and engrossing look at the stand-up comedy scene in the 1970s. Topics include:

• Why stand-up moved from NYC to CA (hint: Here’s Johnny!),
• An in-depth account of Mitzi Shore and The Comedy Store,
• The great comics’ strike of 1979,
• The life and death of an aspiring comedian, and
• Tidbits about big name comedians, including Leno, Letterman, Robin Williams, and Richard Lewis.

The lives of stand-up comics in the seventies were both fascinating and frightening (those precario...more
Jason Gregg
I do have a sincere interest in the comedy business and did learn several new things about the lesser known comics of the 1970's. But, I thought it focused way too much on the comedy strike of the late 70's. It became very dry towards the end when describing the paper work and the agreements of the strike. The book started off strongly giving mini bios of the big names in the business (Leno, Letterman, Lewis, etc.) and I loved that. I loved hearing how these comics had to struggle and work their...more
Chris
I'm not trying to get a blurb on the dust jacket or anything, but this was a real page turner. Focusing on the comedians' strike of 1979, author Knoedelseder does a wonderful job of illustrating the personalities of all these stand ups against the backdrop of their unionizing.

Honestly, if I have one complaint about I'm Dying Up Here is that it was almost too slight in its story. While there's a lot of new interviews here from the famous comedians who were born out of the Comedy Store, I would h...more
Catherine


I searched out this book at the library after hearing Bill Knoedelseder talk on the podcast "Am I Right". His interview on this podcast made the comedy scene of the late 1970s sound like it really was a Golden Age of some sort. Jay Leno, David Letterman, Robin Williams, and a bunch more household names came from this fabulous circle of comedians all trying to make it in this time and place, LA in the 70s. It really did seem like a magical time in comedy, and I love the insider's view you get fr...more
Joshua
Interesting and entertaining look into the heyday of the late 1970s/early 1980s stand-up comedy scene in NY/LA at places like the Improv and the Comedy Store. Cast of dozens and most I knew and remember, some I didn't. Amazing what a putz Jay Leno is now but seemed like an okay guy back then, helping to lead the comic strike--now? He's an incredibly unfunny, mainstream vanilla idiot. Yes, I'm angry what he did to Dave AND to Conan ala backstabbing but that is neither here nor there. This is a fu...more
Bryan
A great history of Stand up in New York and LA in the late 70's/early 80's. I learned a lot about some of my favorite comics from that era. Highlights for me were Richard Lewis, Andy Kaufman, and Letterman. Learned a lot about "legends" also and how they may have been the most flawed people of this ilk. (Robin Williams comes to mind)..
However, the second half of this book slowed down a little. It was very "strike centric" and bored me a touch. And the last quarter wrapped up way too quick. I wou...more
Roy
Feb 27, 2010 Roy rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: anyone who is intereasted in Leno, Letterman, Richard Lewis, or stand up comics
Recommended to Roy by: Bill Simmons
If the Late Shift, a TV movie about the battle over the Tonight Show, had been a blockbuster, this story would have made for a worthy prequel. It would have been almost Star Warsian, in the way that the villain of the original, Jay Leno, becomes one of the good guys of the prequel.

In I’m Dyine Up Here Leno is part of a young group of soon-to-be famous comedians who strike against Mitzi Shore’s Comedy Store for the right to be paid. No, not paid more, just paid, like 5 or 10 dollars a set. It’s...more
Ally
I don't really know that much about stand-up comedy, and I haven't seen that much in my life. But after the last couple of years of listening to Marc Maron's podcast, I've become more interested in learning about the behind-the-scenes stories. Maron, who worked as a doorman at the Comedy Store while honing his chops, recommended this book as an accurate and definitive account of the late 70s LA comedy scene. And boy was he right. This book is a fascinating look at the opening of the Comedy Store...more
Jamie
Reading this book I was torn. Every time I needed to pause I wished I could set aside time to read it straight through. On the other hand, I wanted to break it up so that it would last longer. I laughed, and in several spots my eyes teared up. But I have been performing stand-up comedy for two years now. I'm not sure that this book would have such a poignant effect on those who have not tried to pursue their artistic passions as a performer of some sort. Nevertheless, it was a great story highli...more
Lenny Husen
This wasn't quite as good as Comedy At the Edge, which I listened to first. However, this was excellent in its own right. I am fascinated by comedy of all kinds. To be fair and honest, the copy I was given had several chapters missing, which didn't make any difference, because I had no interest in hearing the blow-by-blow account of the strike and Steve's suicide. As it was, I thoroughly enjoyed this book and recommend both this one and the other I mentioned to anyone interested in stand-up come...more
Liz
I love stand up. It's the kind of profession where (if I were thin and didn't mind being dirt poor and mooching off my parents while talking about my vagina in front of a bunch of people who are predispositioned to not think I'm funny anyway because I'm a woman)I always think "I could do that!" But I don't have the drive or love of it near the same as the people in this book do. It's a great book --chronicles the rise of the late 1960's - 1970's stand up and ends with the battle comedians fought...more
Blog on Books
When the Tonight Show moved its base of operations from New York to Los Angeles in 1972, the world of comedy was completely upended. Instead of working out their routines at NY nightclubs, any up-and-coming comedian worth his salt had to relocate to LA as well. Why? Because, in those days the Tonight Show was considered an unavoidable rite-of-passage for any comic who aspired to bigger things like Vegas, record albums or TV and movie stardom. The stars who received Johnny Carson's nod of approva...more
James Loftus
This book isn't nearly as funny as I had hoped (there are not really any jokes in it), but I did learn a lot about the boom of popularity of stand up comedy in the late 70's early 80's that centered around the Comedy Store in LA and the related strike of the store and the unionization of the comics. The whole book was worth reading just for a really great description of the experience of one of the comics on his first time on Johnny Carson's tonight show (the be all end all of comic venues).
Rob
I picked this up at the library on a whim after reading about it on Mark Evanier's blog. I started reading a few pages when I was resting and the book I was in the middle of was in another room. I found it difficult to put down and tore through the thing. I'm not sure what it was exactly--the writing isn't particularly vibrant--but the story was compelling and I had trouble stepping away from it until I was done. Very interesting stuff.
Michelle
The book says it's about the stand-up comics of 1970s LA, but that is only part of the story. The core of this book is the strike between the comedians and The Comedy Store owner Mitzi Shore. The book is utterly compelling and paints a vivid picture of the era and the struggling comedians who performed without compensation.

There's a lot of name dropping in this book, and it's sublime. A must read for comedy nerds.
Tom
I'm a bit obsessed with comedy and comedians these days and so I really enjoyed depiction of the "golden days" of 1970s LA comedy when Letterman, Leno, Robin Williams and others were friends and struggling stand-ups--written by a guy who covered "comedy" in that era. Structured around the LA comedy strike and its tragic aftermath, it's NOT a funny book but a great primer in where today's comedy legends got their start. A friend who was "there" tells me it's spot-on accurate so can definitely rec...more
Hasan Minhaj
One of the best books on stand-up I've ever read. I know a lot of people really love 'Born Standing Up', but I think this book captures a moment in standup history many have not heard of. Hearing stories about Letterman, Leno, and Robin was awesome and terrifying at the same time. A must read for any comic, especially if you live in LA and frequent the Comedy Store.
Noah
This book is outstanding. It strikes just the right balance between history and story, with three-dimensional characters and vivid scenes, and it finds a good focal point for what could otherwise turn into a sprawling mess. If you're at all interested in the world professional comedians inhabit or in the history of the entertainment industry, I highly recommend it.
David
The story of a comedian's strike against the Comedy Store nightclub in 1979 when stand-ups such as Jay Leno, David Letterman, Garry Shandling and Robin Williams took sides and friendships were affected.

The secondary story of an untalented comic who committed suicide in front of the Comedy Store during the strike was not very compelling.
Chris
I liked this books many different ways. As an evocation of stand-up comedy as a vocation in the '70s, it feels like it's right on the money. As a tale of the Comedy Store strike, it was obviously biased toward the comics, but didn't shy away from discussing unintended consequences of the strike on both sides. It's not strictly a good guys-vs-bad guys tale, and Knoedelseder knows enough not to make it one. Rudimentary youtube searches and other internet research have turned up little about Steve...more
Amy
This book aims to capture the atmosphere in stand up comedy during the 70's with the strike at The Comedy Store and its effect on comedian Steve Lubetkin at the center. Anyone interested in stand-up, especially Leno, Letterman and Richard Lewis will enjoy this peek into their "coming up" years. My only disappointment with this book is the overly "that was a golden age that will never be captured again" tone. But, then again, it is essentially a memoir of the group/movement so I guess that can be...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 20 21 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
I'm Dying Up Here: Heartbreak and High Times in Stand-Up Comedy's Golden Era (Paperback)
I'm Dying Up Here: Heartbreak and High Times in Stand-Up Comedy's Golden Era (ebook)
I'm Dying Up Here (Library Edition): The Great Comedians' Strike of 1979
I'm Dying Up Here: Heartbreak and high times in stand-up comedy's golden era (Kindle Edition)
I'm Dying Up Here: The Great Comedians' Strike of 1979 (Audio CD)

Bitter Brew: The Rise and Fall of Anheuser-Busch and America's Kings of Beer Stiffed: A True Story of MCA, the Music Business, and the Mafia In Eddie's Name: One Family's Triumph Over Tragedy Better Than Gold Dreadnaught: King of Afropunk

Share This Book

Your website