Another Insane Devotion: On the Love of Cats and Persons
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Another Insane Devotion: On the Love of Cats and Persons

3.46 of 5 stars 3.46  ·  rating details  ·  136 ratings  ·  43 reviews
"I am not a cat person . . .yet Peter Trachtenberg is such a wonderful writer, and this book is so damn good, that I found myself carried along by its lucidity, its generosity, its deep wisdom. In the end, of course, Another Insane Devotion is about much more than cats." -- Nick Flynn, author of Another Bullshit Night in Suck City

From “a genuine American Dostoevsky” (The W...more
ebook, 272 pages
Published November 13th 2012 by Da Capo Press (first published October 9th 2012)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 452)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Another Insane Devotion is very well written. Trachtenberg is a wonderful stylist. But then there is Trachtenberg's life and attitude. He's a narcissist and screw up who, because he's such a narcissist, kvetches a lot about what a screw up he is.

A mix of a story of a devotion to cats and the break up of a marriage, this book reminded me of two other books by people who have made messes of their lives: American Sucker by David Denby and Double Down by the Barthleme brothers, Frederick and Steven....more
I wanted to find this book lyrical and profound; Trachtenberg is a wonderful writer, and the idea of using cats as both example of and figure for the force, mystery, and pain of love seems inspired to me. But the book itself seemed pretentious and pastiche-y to me (alluding to every intellectual touchstone from Derrida to Swann's Way); the insights into cat behavior and domestication banal; and the navel-gazing of telling the story of his vexed marriage seemed self-indulgent and pompous. Trachte...more
Carmen Rodrigues
As Trachtenberg journeys home to find his beloved cat Biscuit, he takes us on a separate, lyrical journey through crumbling homesteads and lost pets until we arrive at the heart of his story--a marriage that is as beautiful as it is unsteady. In this raw space, Trachtenberg’s memoir shines best, proving itself a brave exploration of attachment, commitment, and the vulnerable interactions that make us human.
This is an amazing book. Trachtenberg succeeds in combining his love of cats and his love of a woman, and the perils of all these relationships, and does it in a way that is not contrived. His history with cats, and of cats, is as vivid and compelling as his portrait of a failing marriage. The title says it all: "insane devotion." Make that plural. Love works in many ways. The book is also a travel memoir, as the author travels to Italy to retrieve an orphaned cat, as well as his wife, whose lov...more
This is an enjoyable and meandering memoir about a lost cat -- but it's also about falling in love, getting married, and then falling out of love. And there are pleasant references to Proust and philosophers and history and art and poetry and trips to Italy...

I'd recommend this book first to anyone who loves cats, and second to anyone who likes thoughtful, rambling memoirs.
A gorgeous book that you must read if you've ever loved an animal or a person. Yes, you.
Feb 04, 2013 Jenna rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: cat lovers
I'd give this about a 2.5, somewhere between "it was okay" and "I liked it."

First the good: the story of Biscuit was compelling, and I read, or at least skimmed, until the end because I wanted to know what happened. I was also struck by the disappearance of Gattino, and find myself still thinking about him even after I've finished the book. I learned a lot of random but interesting facts about cats. As a cat lover, I found the history of feline domestication, the science of cat vocalizations, a...more
I'm in awe of Peter Trachtenberg's writing: his elegant prose, poignant storytelling, and easy erudition. I don't say this because he's a friend and colleague. He's just damned good. His writing never feels like "research," reportage, or quoting and name-dropping for the sake of gravitas or the appearance of authority. If he talks about Nietzsche or Proust or Aretha Franklin, it is not to impress but because it is part of his life, the philosophy and art that he lives with and that speak to him...more
This book isn't for everyone- only for people who enjoy words, who ponder how seemingly disparate pieces of life fit together, and who listen to the honest, sometimes ugly, truth of life and appreciate it. This is a book for realists. While so much of it is about cats, if you come away thinking this is a book about cats you've missed the point. Ironically, one of the most honestly human books I've read.

All of that gushing done, I do wish that more of the life narrative was shown; more actual co...more
I wanted to laugh and cry in equal parts while reading... This is a book about love, life and cats. Each is displayed in its own flawed perfection. As the way most people either love or hate cats, I suspect you will either love or hate this book, and very little I will say will change that...
Really, really didn't like it.
This was my first by him & I hope my last.
Not enough abt cats & too much general whining.
Don't like his writing style, it was slow going,not easy to read, and I don't mean b/c of vocab. Just obstreperous.
Sorry, guy. You started out really well, but went way too far into contemplating your navel and frankly, you're not any more interesting than I am.

Aside from that, I'm glad your cat came home.
Kathleen Maher
Peter Trachtenberg's book about his cats, his girlfriend who becomes his wife, and her cats, the family they make together, and how it changes, is fascinating and often fun. The book deftly includes so many aspects of his devotion--to cats and persons--both religious and personal, that I was amazed--a word I try not to use lightly.
The trustworthy structure moves well while including various Biblical, Gnostic, and historical references; also poetry, art, and a coherent but graceful moral reckonin...more
Stephanie A.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
A beautiful, sprawling essay about too many things to mention here. In the end, it doesn't really matter what Trachtenberg is writing about, because, like the best essayists, he makes familiar territory fresh--makes almost any topic interesting. I could have cared less what happened to the cat (sorry, Biscuit), but I couldn't stop turning the pages.

Do not buy this book if you're looking for a literary version of Homeward Bound (*cough* see previous reviews *cough*). If that's the kind of stuff y...more
Barbara Barth
I purchased this book after an intriguing review in the Minneapolis Star Tribune. I cannot believe the reviewer invested any time beyond reading the description on the jacket cover...

I may have enjoyed the book if the Trachtenberg had limited his ramblings to cat burbles. But he would have had to market it as a pamphlet instead of a book! I disliked the detours into Trachtenberg's sex-capades with women (known only by their first initials to spare them further humiliation?). His use of profanity...more
Sherri Mc
I generally do not read non-fiction. I am especially cautious of reading a book if an animal plays a major role in the story. I hate to read anything where a animal is in peril. I took a chance on Another Insane Devotion.

I was not disappointed. It was like reading Milan Kundera with cats added to the mix of relationships that needed untangling. The language was straightforward and economical, but replete with insight. There were some tough spots to read for a tender-hearted cat lover like mysel...more
great stylist, bad novelist, douchebag of a person.

There were some lovely passages wherein he describes his cats but this whole 'women as cats' metaphor is frankly idiotic and stretched to absurdity.

On a semi-unrelated note, I really can't stand people who let their cats outdoors in the city because it's 'natural' - do people really believe cats are smart enough to understand the dangers of a modern city? Or that they're able to navigate through an epidemic of feral cats without catching anythi...more
This author is so worried about his missing cat that he travels from North Carolina where he is working to New York to search for her. (The cat sitter has reported that she is missing.) As filler he writes of his relationship with his wife, religion, philosophy, history, sex, and anything that piques his interest. He writes of his personal relationships with a curious blend of intimacy and detachment which is quite engaging. Like all true cat lovers, this guy is slightly neurotic.
Great scientific insights on the feline species, and I loved Trachtenberg's historical, artistic, and literary references. Even if I didn't know a thing about most of the paintings and stories he was talking about, I felt like I learned something. And while he says a lot about his relationships with various cats and women, he didn't do a very good job distinguishing them from each other. I was never quite sure which girlfriend or cat he was referring to.
This personal memoir isn't really about cats. It's about a man who has cats. He writes about his ex-girlfriends and wife, referred to by initials instead of name. The observations are clever, but I have no interest in the love life of an irresponsible guy who loses his cats.
My daughter picked up this short book for me because of the pretty cover. It wasn't what it purported to be - instead it was a story about a selfish guy who ignores his wife and loses his cats. Sometimes the writing was insightful; a lot of it was philosophical; but never did this memoir make me want to know the writer better. Meh.
Edward Sullivan
Not just about cats but they are central to the narrative and that's what I found most interesting in this engaging memoir. Devotees of feline companionship should much to enjoy here.
On the back of the book jacket, an author who reviewed the book wrote: "...imagine your sweetest, most perverse storytelling friend asks to meet because he has a confession to make. When you arrive he informs you that he loves his cat more than life itself, or exactly that much, and then he opens his shirt and shows you the cat tattoo and then he begins to tell you of his love, and in a puff hours vanish and it's absolutely riveting."

Okay, I really enjoyed this book, but I wouldn't go that far....more
I have mixed feelings about this book. At times I loved the author's insights into love and cats and enjoyed his humor, often chuckling aloud. But I was irritated by his writing style. He referred to his wife and girlfriends by their initial, constantly jumped topics and timeframes and made unrelenting references to famous authors and philosophers. I knew without him telling me that he was a liberal arts college professor. (No disrespect to liberal arts colleges.) I kept thinking that I would ha...more
I had to literally force myself to finish this one. I had hoped for interesting things and funny stories about cats, but was not counting on the deliberate exhibition and memoir of the author's sexual libido.
A marvelous book--a little slow in the start, when it's hard to see what exactly the author is up to: is this memoir; is it essay; is it a suspenseful story about whether the narrator finds his lost cat? It's all of the above, and as the strands become interwoven, and as it becomes more and more clear how deep a heart and how fine and erudite a brain the author possesses, one becomes entirely entangled in them. It's the sort of book that explains to us our weird, irrational affections and why it...more
Lisa Pool
I give this book 2 stars for the story and 4 stars for the writing. If you are a cat lover and enjoy great writing then this is the book for you. If you don't like cats or have trouble with heavy writing then skip this book. While it is the author's missing favorite cat biscuit the story is about - you never get to know or care about this cat. It is his wife's cat that also goes missing that really got to me. There is a picture of him on his missing poster that broke my heart.
Wonderful. Not an "aren't cats charming book," but a wry philosophical self-introspection off the author's true relationships with his wife, previous lovers, himself, and, of course, the cats in his life. When his cat disappears, he realizes his efforts to find it are more than the efforts he's put into saving his marriage. Beautifully and intelligently written, it's easy to lose yourself into this book. I'm looking forward to reading more books by Peter Trachtenberg.
Stacey D.
My favorite parts of Trachtenberg's essay on love and cats were about the cats.
I found some of his musings on love tedious and unnecessary and I was easily distracted when reading those sections. It was also a bit difficult to vacillate between the two subjects, when the main questions were, "Was Biscuit ever found?" and "What happened with your marriage to F.?" All relationships are difficult, but the rewards, even the smallest of rewards, are what keeps us all going.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 15 16 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Goodreads Librari...: Please add this book to my author page 13 191 Jan 11, 2013 03:48AM  
  • The Tiger in the House: A Cultural History of the Cat
  • No Kidding: Women Writers on Bypassing Parenthood
  • The Way the World Works
  • Frankenstein's Cat: Cuddling Up to Biotech's Brave New Beasts
  • Lost Cat: A True Story of Love, Desperation, and GPS Technology
  • Son of a Gun: A Memoir
  • The Character of Cats: The Origins, Intelligence, Behavior, and Stratagems of Felis silvestris catus
  • Too Good to Be True: A Memoir
  • The Story of Ain't: America, Its Language, and the Most Controversial Dictionary Ever Published
  • Flagrant Conduct: The Story of Lawrence v. Texas
  • The Answer to the Riddle Is Me: A Memoir of Amnesia
  • 十個詞彙裡的中國 (China in Ten Words)
  • This Is Running for Your Life: Essays
  • I Am Maru
  • Missing Out: In Praise of the Unlived Life
  • Casper the Commuting Cat: The True Story of the Cat who Rode the Bus and Stole our Hearts
  • Swimming Studies
  • Blood Horses : Notes of a Sportswriter's Son
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.

Peter Trachtenberg is the author of the memoir 7 TATTOOS, THE BOOK OF CALAMITIES: Five Questions About Suffering and Its Meaning (Little Brown, August 2008), and ANOTHER INSANE DEVOTION (Da Capo, October 2012), a book about the search for a missing cat that's also an encode...more
More about Peter Trachtenberg...
7 Tattoos: A Memoir in the Flesh The Book of Calamities: Five Questions About Suffering and Its Meaning The Casanova Complex: Compulsive Lovers and Their Women Casanovakomplekset : tvangselskeren og hans kvinner O complexo de casanova

Share This Book

“She hops expectantly into the sink. I turn on the tap for her; she laps without a glance in my direction, like a duchess so used to being ministered to that she no longer notices the servants and sees only a world where objects dumbly bend to her wishes, doors opening, faucets discharging cool water, delicious things appearing in her dish.” 2 likes
More quotes…