38th out of 382 books
—
1,100 voters
Democracy in America
In 1831 Alexis de Tocqueville, a young French aristocrat and ambitious civil servant, made a nine-month journey throughout America. The result was Democracy in America, a monumental study of the life and institutions of the evolving nation. Tocqueville looked to the flourishing democratic system in America as a possible model for post-revolutionary France, believing that t...more
Paperback, 992 pages
Published
July 1st 2003
by Penguin Classics
(first published January 1st 199)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
8,426)
Update: My brother just told me that Kurt Vonnegut says that anyone who hasn't read Democracy in America is a wimp. So I guess that makes me almost not a wimp. Well!
Post from a few weeks ago: I've been wanting to read de Toqueville's, Democracy in America for some time, and I've finally bit the bullet. The translation is beautifully done. De Toqueville's sentiments are eloquent and thought provoking. Wonderful.
How's that for summer reading! Part of me wishes we still ta...more
Post from a few weeks ago: I've been wanting to read de Toqueville's, Democracy in America for some time, and I've finally bit the bullet. The translation is beautifully done. De Toqueville's sentiments are eloquent and thought provoking. Wonderful.
How's that for summer reading! Part of me wishes we still ta...more
I'm going with 4 stars here, it isn't always the easiest book to read, but worth it. There is a lot of wisdom in this book, a lot of insight. While history hasn't borne out all his predictions, there have been enough. Sadly also, it looks as though more of the things he said may still prove to be true.
In today's atmosphere, the thoughts here compared to the reality we live in and that "may" be coming to pass....well, it's worth some thought. When America broke away from t...more
In today's atmosphere, the thoughts here compared to the reality we live in and that "may" be coming to pass....well, it's worth some thought. When America broke away from t...more
I read selections this time around, as I did years ago.
de Tocqueville toured and studied America not long after the French Revolution. He was hoping to glean ideas for his own country. I think what he found couldn't necessarily apply. He says we had no democratic revolution, because we began democratically. This makes sense, as our Revolution was simply an effort to keep that independent flavor, rather than lose it to our parent country.
Among the many things he observ...more
de Tocqueville toured and studied America not long after the French Revolution. He was hoping to glean ideas for his own country. I think what he found couldn't necessarily apply. He says we had no democratic revolution, because we began democratically. This makes sense, as our Revolution was simply an effort to keep that independent flavor, rather than lose it to our parent country.
Among the many things he observ...more
I read this in response to my frustration with what I saw as our inability to bring democracy to other places in the world. Chapters 1-42 and 55 - 57 are the most insightful. Others tend to drag. In 1830s de Tocqueville comes to America to figure our why a democratic revolution in France lead to anarchy and despotism, while a democratic revolution in America lead to freedom. What he finds is still relevant to our trying to bring or give democracy to others.
Two things emerge- fir...more
Two things emerge- fir...more
Considered a must-read classic about US history and US political culture. In fact, the most over-rated book in all of history. Complete waste of your time. I'd give it zero stars if I could. Alexis spent all his time hanging with his plantation-owner buddies in the South who ran the US gov't at the time, then wrote a book about how great Democracy in the US was. Except for a couple of pages, he ignores all the main issues of US political and economic history: slavery, racism, exploitation,...more
blue-collar mind
rated it
Recommends it for:
lucid people who find representative democracy a bit puzzling
Shelves:
read-a-bit-here-and-there
I love doing that time travel thing, when you find an author who can bring you to his or her time, and you are like Samantha in Bewitched talking to Franklin while wearing her sensible 60s housewife clothes.
I read my little copy of this book for a few minutes every other day or so, much like (it occurs to me) religiousists read the bible, although I always remember that my choice was written by a youngish white European of no particular esteem who went to check out America, rather than a ...more
I read my little copy of this book for a few minutes every other day or so, much like (it occurs to me) religiousists read the bible, although I always remember that my choice was written by a youngish white European of no particular esteem who went to check out America, rather than a ...more
De Tocqueville was Nostradamus with regards to his predictions for America to date. He foresaw the rise of America as a world leader economically, militarily, and culturally. He saw that the greatness of America was not due to our superior class of citizens, but rather that the average American citizen was empowered to take action to improve conditions for himself, his family, and his community and did not rely on decisions to be made for him by a distant authority. The American citizen was empo...more
I was going to read a book about "Democracy in America," but hadn't actually read the original. How silly is that? This two volume book by Alexis de Tocqueville is about America in 1831. It should be required reading for anyone in the federal government. It's apparent that the American brand of democracy cannot simply be exported to another country. The peculiar history of the United States (and how many other people get to start with a new continent)--its individual states, commo...more
Be warned: the title of this book is a little misleading. De Tocqueville did not just write about democracy in America, but about democracy in general and its effects on people's habits, "mores," and beliefs. In fact, it is more of a survey on democracy rather than on America, but since America was one of the few examples of a fully formed democracy in the world at the time he wrote and he had toured extensively beforehand, many of de Tocqueville's observations are colored by his views...more
So much of relevance still in this book - about how we think within the context of our social, political and economic circles. A very useful tool for considering many of the current conversations taking place which must make us question whether we are heading in the right direction or just basing our actions upon assumptions which we have not adequately examined.
Albert Einstein said:
Concepts that have proven useful in ordering things easily achieve such authority over us that we forget...more
Albert Einstein said:
Concepts that have proven useful in ordering things easily achieve such authority over us that we forget...more
(Let me apologies in advance, Matt -- for cluttering your review with my rather superfluous comments. I really, really don't mean it to be offensive.)
I always find your reviews to be a riot - and brilliant. You, Chris, Eric, Thomas -- Geoff_W. -- Jimmy -- you guys have been my guiding lights for weeks now... maybe months -- in this rather doomed and belated project I have of trying to find my front with my hands tied behind my back. That said…, my one talent in life (and it is no sma...more
I always find your reviews to be a riot - and brilliant. You, Chris, Eric, Thomas -- Geoff_W. -- Jimmy -- you guys have been my guiding lights for weeks now... maybe months -- in this rather doomed and belated project I have of trying to find my front with my hands tied behind my back. That said…, my one talent in life (and it is no sma...more
You know what's not cool? Buying a 320 page book and finding out that you have the wrong copy, which means that you only have a week to find the right copy and finish reading it, and you buy the right copy, which turns out to be 720 pages. That is not cool. That is the definition of un-coolness. Especially when you end up reading 100 pages in one night...
HOWEVER, you know what is cool? Tocqueville's writing style! (Yes, he's French...he writes like Montesquieu...) Check out this chap...more
HOWEVER, you know what is cool? Tocqueville's writing style! (Yes, he's French...he writes like Montesquieu...) Check out this chap...more
Exploring the New World ...
... of Sociology.
I had expected that deTocqueville's classic would be a study of political technique, like an expanded version of The Prince or The Art Of War. Instead Democracy in America (Harper Perennial Modern Classics) is an original and powerful exploration of Sociology (generations before Max Weber).
deTocqueville draws on his experiences touring the United States in 1830 to make observations and speculations about the influenc...more
... of Sociology.
I had expected that deTocqueville's classic would be a study of political technique, like an expanded version of The Prince or The Art Of War. Instead Democracy in America (Harper Perennial Modern Classics) is an original and powerful exploration of Sociology (generations before Max Weber).
deTocqueville draws on his experiences touring the United States in 1830 to make observations and speculations about the influenc...more
Growing up I was thankful that nowhere in my liberal arts education was I assigned to read Tocqueville’s “(On) Democracy in America”. The idea that it was written by a Frenchman always worried me, not for any particular political reasons but more so because I was afraid the connection would not be made between the author's intentions and the translation produced. Of course, there is no way to determine if the author's thoughts are properly conveyed but the translation comes across clear and re...more
Maureen
rated it
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
everyone
Recommended to Maureen by:
Neil
Shelves:
history
Did you have to read this book for Political Science 101? I did, and I still have my copy of it. In this election year, it would be worth taking a look at this book again. It seems to me that, particularly in the past eight years, we have strayed off the path of the ideals that this book represents. Anyone interested in democracy, equality, and the role of the military in government should own a copy of this book. Make sure it is the unabridged one.
This book is (of course) very dated now, but it gives the reader an excellent idea of how America came to be, and also shows how American "values" have not changed over time. Clearly Tocqueville is a bit enamored with the America that he sees, but he manages to do a thorough and not always positive review of what constitutes the country. Much of it is contrasting Americans of the time with the rest of the world. As an American, this is a valuable book to read for a better understanding...more
Democracy in America has been said the be the best telling of the American Spirit (even though it was written before the Civil war) and I believe that is correct. Tocqueville's classic should be taught in every high school in America. Indeed, if I was a government teacher it would be mandatory if I had to purchase the books myself and give them away. For those that may not be familiar, Tocqueville was a Frenchman that traveled the United States and wrote a book in 2 volumes about it. He disc...more
I'll start by saying that I'm not sure what gives a 25 year-old rich French kid on a pleasure cruise through the New World the credibility to make completely unsupported assertions on the political and social climate of early America, and have them be accepted as gospel. After slogging through 300 or so pages, I'm exceedingly grateful that this abridged version exists, because I can't imagine ever wasting the time on the complete edition. I was interested in reading a book that has been hailed...more
So damned important that I forced myself to read the whole thing. Important for the myths that it created about America as well as the truths it observes. Nothing necessarily radical or progressive here, but still hugely influential. Should be read because every asshole politician likes to cite it. The Penguin Classics version is the one you want because it is unabridged.
This is one of the most quoted books ever and now I understand why. Written in the early 1800s, Alexis de Tocueville, a French visitor to America, studied America as an emerging nation and wrote an amazing tribute to the benefits of a free society based on a constitution that allows equality of all men. He critiqued American government, business, eduction, institutions and the arts, as well as Americans in general. His perspectives give new light to the things we take for granted every day. T...more
My biggest reservation about this is that Tocqueville seems to be using such broad strokes. Even in the middle of the 1800's I find it hard to believe that there is a definitive American character which you can just codify and examine at will. That being said, he does make some really smart observations about the problems of individualism versus collective action and how Americans tend not to really examine the sorts of hypocrisies which both of these kinds of action and belief entail. I think i...more
Vielleicht kein sehr lesbares Buch, ähnlich wie Madame de Staël(alter, langer Schinken). Aber Tocqueville sieht um 1830 in einem ihm fremden Land die Zukunft voraus: Er beschreibt eine Gesellschaft, in der Freiheitsrechte und eine freie Presse bestehen, in der es das Ideal der Chancengleichheit gibt, die demokratisch organisiert ist. 170 Jahre später sind wir fasziniert von Amerika, weil diese Gesellschaft einen schwarzen Afrikaner an die Spitze ihres politischen Systems gestellt hat. Das hat To...more
(Reprinted from the Chicago Center for Literature and Photography [cclapcenter.com:]. I am the original author of this essay, as well as the owner of CCLaP; it is not being reprinted here illegally.)
The CCLaP 100: In which I read for the first time a hundred so-called classics, then write reports on whether or not they deserve the label
Essay #35: Democracy in America, by Alexis de Tocqueville (1835)
The story in a nutshell:
Although these days we take it f...more
The CCLaP 100: In which I read for the first time a hundred so-called classics, then write reports on whether or not they deserve the label
Essay #35: Democracy in America, by Alexis de Tocqueville (1835)
The story in a nutshell:
Although these days we take it f...more
I read Volume 1 in this edition, and Volume 2 in the edition translated & edited by Harvey C. Mansfield and Delba Winthrop published in 2000 by The University of Chicago Press, ISBN 0226805328. I found Volume 1 to be more intriguing, but portions of Volume 2 were very enlightening. Both took a long time to finish because of the author's style of writing, and because the typeface in both is smaller. I am amazed that Tocqueville was able to grasp so much from observing people, society, governme...more
Boyce
added it
This is one of those "ought to read books." I've owned it for 34 years and finally I'm reading it. It's long. It was translated from French into 1830s English. Brilliant, insightful, and clearly written. de Tocqueville compares American democracy, circa 1830, to France and England. He is an aristocrat and his advocacy of democracy is begrugeing, but he saw it as the only viable future. Sample insight: universal jury duty exposes American of all classes to the legal system, the rule of ...more
This is... well, ridiculous. I'm sure that some people can see the loveliness in the writing style and all that, but to be quite honest, I can't, and neither do I have the patience for this. Only reason I managed to read any at all is because I have an equally ridiculous essay (okay, not entirely true, the topic isn't that bad), but a lot of this is unnecessary. Two stars because I'm sure there was at least a little point in there somewhere. And other people seem inspired by it. Or quote him at ...more
This is not a book to read cover to cover all at one time. It is, however, a book you will eagerly anticipate reading 25 pages at a time. He provides a wonderful insight into the American way of thinking prior to The Civil War and, quite frankly, helps us understand why we Americans think the way we do about our government and political system today. It is easy to forget that only about a hundred years ago our republican form of government was only an experiment..
I've always heard a...more
I've always heard a...more
How can you not like Tocqueville? For a book written nearly 200 years ago, it's a pretty awesome and accurate account of American political life. Tocqueville is like a Nostradamus when it comes to how the US government would turn out...what he sees as innate flaws do end up playing a negative role, and what he sees as strong assets are attributes that continue to work today. The language also isn't too drab/old school...it's obviously not a thrilling page turner, but his ideas and hypotheses abo...more
I originally hated this book and be extension, de Toqueville: it was college and the format in which we read this did little to better understand or even like the book. Like many things, I picked my original college copy up and read it after having traveled throughout Europe, engaging in a variety of political conversations. In short, I have come to enjoy this book, agreeing with another reader that all should read this. De Toqueville captured the essence of the American people and government...more
First let me say I did choose to read this on my own. I read it because of club I'm in. It was not easy reading and I plodded through.The 4 stars is for of the message. However it was quite insightful as to the history of democracy in our country through the eyes of a Frenchman.
The author saw the potential of democracy along with the downfalls. He could have been a prophet. I'd like to see what he would say of the US now.
There was a lot of slogging but he had an amazing perception. ...more
The author saw the potential of democracy along with the downfalls. He could have been a prophet. I'd like to see what he would say of the US now.
There was a lot of slogging but he had an amazing perception. ...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| wow not bad | 5 | 29 | Feb 23, 2009 10:00am |
Alexis-Charles-Henri Clérel de Tocqueville (July 29, 1805 – April 16, 1859) was a French political thinker and historian best known for his Democracy in America (appearing in two volumes: 1835 and 1840) and The Old Regime and the Revolution (1856). In both of these works, he explored the effects of the rising equality of social conditions on the individual and the state in western societies.
...more
More about Alexis de Tocqueville...
...more
Share This Book
3 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money.”
—
72 people liked it
“I do not know if the people of the United States would vote for superior men if they ran for office, but there can be no doubt that such men do not run.”
—
28 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...











view all 8 comments














































