A Fatal Likeness (Charles Maddox, #3)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

A Fatal Likeness (Charles Maddox #3)

3.14 of 5 stars 3.14  ·  rating details  ·  238 ratings  ·  113 reviews
A mystery that explores the dark lives and unexplained secrets of the poet Percy Bysshe Shelley, and his wife Mary, author of Frankenstein.

In the dying days of 1850 the young detective Charles Maddox takes on a new case. His client? The only surviving son of the long-dead poet Percy Bysshe Shelley, and his wife Mary, author of Frankenstein.

Charles soon finds himself being...more
Hardcover, 384 pages
Published August 20th 2013 by Delacorte Press (first published January 1st 2013)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Jane Eyre by Charlotte BrontëThe Woman in White by Wilkie CollinsThe Seance by John HarwoodThe Moonstone by Wilkie CollinsThe Cater Street Hangman by Anne Perry
Spunky Victorian Girls in Trouble
14th out of 64 books — 23 voters
Fallen by Lauren KateLeopard Moon by Jeanette BattistaDeadly Little Secret by Laurie Faria StolarzThe First Desire by Nancy ReismanChosen by P.C. Cast
133rd out of 266 books — 71 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,176)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
There is no problem, however intractable, that cannot be resolved by the steady application of logic and observation

I love Netgalley, it allows me to choose books I would never otherwise have read. After requesting this title, I really thought I made a mistake. Whodunit's is not really my genre, I new nothing about the romantic poets, and I belatedly noticed that this was the second book in a series. Despite all of this I really enjoyed it.

I was interested in learning more about Percy Bysshe She...more
Diane S.
Love the atmosphere of this time period, the wonderful characters, slowness of the plot to develop and the richness of the details and the setting. This is the second book in this series featuring, Charles Maddox, and in this one he takes on the Shelley family and their scandal ridden past. A case that goes into the past of this famous family and into the past of his uncle.

Solid writing, just not sure I was wholly convinced by the plot, though it was certainly interesting following where the aut...more
Aug 02, 2013 Joanne rated it 1 of 5 stars
Shelves: arc
A Fatal Likeness
By Lynn Shepherd
Summery courtesy of Goodreads.com
A mystery that explores the dark lives and unexplained secrets of the poet Percy Bysshe Shelley, and his wife Mary, author of Frankenstein.

In the dying days of 1850 the young detective Charles Maddox takes on a new case. His client? The only surviving son of the long-dead poet Percy Bysshe Shelley, and his wife Mary, author of Frankenstein.

Charles soon finds himself being drawn into the bitter battle being waged over the poet’s lit...more
Suzie Grogan
The research and imagination that has gone into this book takes it well beyond the Victorian crime genre that it might otherwise be slotted into. As it examines a mystery at the heart of the life of the poet Percy Bysshe Shelley much of the 'action' takes place much earlier in the 19th century. Unlike the book it succeeds, Tom All Alone's, Charles Maddox Junior does not drive the story as viewpoint switches between characters via letters, notes and journal entries, which reveal his great uncle -...more
Last year my hand was seized by an omniscient narrator, and she pulled me back into nineteenth century London and she showed me such dark and wonderful things. And now she has seized my hand again, and shown things that are even more extraordinary.

We arrived in a dark, cold London street, and straight away I saw a familiar figure. Charles Maddox, the detective who had been pulled into an investigation that had uncovered dark goings-on at Tom-all-Alone’s. He was a little older, and a little wiser...more
After reading this, I feel really sorry for the Shelleys. They don't deserve this, not after so long, not when they can't defend themselves. I know this is fiction, but most of my acrimony comes from reading the author's notes at the end. It's the license Shepherd took with the "eloquent silences" in Mary Shelley's journal and justifying one step sister's jealousy of another as cause for believing that one of them is capable of murder that bothers me. Shepherd really believes that she didn't hav...more
Alana White
Jan 28, 2014 Alana White rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: Fans of literary historical fiction.
1850/1816 London. One man, four women. The man is Romantic poet Percy Bysshe Shelley. The adolescent women who protect him at all costs are the interrelated Fanny Godwin Imlay; Shelley’s first wife, Harriet Westbrook; his second wife, Mary Godwin Shelley; and Mary’s stepsister, Claire Clairmont. Lord Byron is here, too, as the natural father of Claire Clairmont’s baby.

The fictional protagonist, Charles Maddox, carries the weight of this disquieting tale. Summoned by Shelley’s son in the fall of...more
I read an advance copy of this novel received through LibraryThing's Early Reviews program. I had originally signed up to receive a copy because I had just read Frankenstein for the first time a few months ago, and I was intrigued by the idea of reading a mystery spun around the author and her husband. The copy of Frankenstein that I read contained biographical information about the pair, but nothing that really addressed anything personal about who they were.

I also read Lynn Shepherd's book The...more
Paula Cappa
Why is this book worth reading? Isn't that the point of all these book reviews? Here's a question I'd like to ask the author Lynn Shepherd. Why is this book worth writing? Truly, why would you write this story? To be honest, I liked this book and I did not like this book. While it's well written and well researched (Shepherd is a talented writer), the author has made some wild speculations about the Shelley family, Mary and Percy Bysshe Shelley. The Shelleys (I've read numerous biographies) had...more
Janette Fleming
In the dying days of 1850 the young detective Charles Maddox takes on a new case. His client? The only surviving son of the long-dead poet Percy Bysshe Shelley, and his wife Mary, author of Frankenstein.
Charles soon finds himself being drawn into the bitter battle being waged over the poet's literary legacy, but then he makes a chance discovery that raises new doubts about the death of Shelley's first wife, Harriet, and he starts to question whether she did indeed kill herself, or whether what r
Included at the end of A Fatal Likeness is an author's note that goes into detail about the research and idea for the book. I must say, I appreciate the conception, along with the research and development. The perspective is a visionary undertaking. Undoubtedly, the constructing of this piece was no easy task!

However, simply compiling information and arranging neat pieces with good editing does not make a story great. In my opinion, A Fatal Likeness lacks the electricity it truly needs to jolt...more
Our hero Charles Maddox is back, and once again embroiled in some very unsavoury matters. This time he is dragged into the orbit of Mary Shelley. It is not a comfortable place to be. Mary's only surviving son, called Percy after his father, calls upon Maddox's professional services. Maddox pays a visit to the Shelley residence; he meets a man ruled by his wife, a shrine to the Dear Departed Percy Bysshe Shelley, and a case requiring him to act as spy. Someone has some papers concerning the late...more
There were many times during the first third that I thought I was going to abandon this book as the plot seemed to be stalled and I wasn't emotionally involved in the characters. What kept me going was a fascination with the lines between the author and protagonist's points of view and the ethics of using real people as characters in fiction.

Charles Maddox, our main character, remains a cypher for me. Perhaps the first book he appears in fixes this, but I would not be able to tell you about his...more
It took me a while to finally review this book because it was a bizarre read for me. I had high hopes for this book but I gave it one star for the sole reason that I didn’t like it.

I am not a connoisseur of the Romantics. Of course I know who Mary Shelleyis, always wanted to read Frankenstein Frankenstein(and will read it next month). Haven’t read her husband’s work (Percy Bysshe Shelley), but know of his existence. But I wasn’t aware of the mystery surrounding their lives.

I requested this book on NetGalle...more
Riley Dawson
I'm still not sure why I kept reading this book. The characters were silly caricatures of real people, the plot was totally convoluted and I didn't feel any of the suspense I was supposed to, and I just did NOT like the writing style. This gets a full two stars because I somehow still managed to read it all, maybe because as a lit major I was morbidly curious about what Shepherd would have to say about the Shelleys.

What bothered me the most about this book is that I really HATED the constant asi...more
Nicole Soutar
I forced myself to finish it, I wanted to stop half way. Very confusing story, and I think unless you have some background knowledge of Mary and Percy Shelly (which I did not) it is hard to follow. Not my kind of book, though I normally enjoy historical fiction.
Although I liked the first book, this was a painful, plodding mystery that unfolds through an endless series of decades-old letters that you are forced to read. Ugh.
Couldn't get into the story.
didn't hold my interest.
I found this book to be an intriguing mix of mystery, literary fiction and historical detail. Set in Victorian London, the story revolves around Charles Maddox, a former London Metropolitan police detective who is hired by the son of poet Percy Bysshe Shelley to acquire what the Shelley family believe are inflammatory papers that are in the hands of Claire Clairmont, step sister of Shelley’s wife, Mary Wollstonecraft Godwin. While searching for the papers Maddox learns much about the Shelley fam...more

A Fatal Likeness by Lynn Shepherd tells the story of Percy Bysshe Shelly, the leading Romantic Poet of England. It is 1850 and Charles Maddox, a detective, has been asked to take a case involving Percy. Shelly's son has been approached by a stranger offering to sell a cache of rare papers allegedly belonging to the late poet and wants Maddox to verify the authenticity. The story involves the marriage of Percy and Mary, author of Frankenstein. Claire Clairmont was the stepsister of Mary and witne...more
Many thanks to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this book!

Okay, first of all I have a deep, dark, dirty secret that I must admit: I've been putting off writing this review for almost a month now. I know, I know – believe me, I feel the shame. It's not like I hated the book. In fact, the plot was rather interesting, so much that I pushed myself to finish reading the book. However, there are a few aspects of the book that were quite unappealing. I think this is the reason why I've been...more
I came to this book because I love mysteries and I particularly love historical mysteries regardless of the era. In addition, I saw that "Publisher's Weekly" had given the book a starred review. I so looked forward to reading this Victorian mystery.

Seldom have I been more disappointed by a book. Almost from the opening sentence, I found the use of the present tense off putting. I wonder what the author didn't understand about the use of the present tense, i.e., that the present tense is used to...more
I wish the author had given us more of a refresher on the back story of Charles Maddox and his Uncle because though I can remember the mystery and the ending of The Solitary House I don't remember that much about the two of them or how Charles sustained the injury that is referred to at the beginning of this story. I wanted to reread 'The Solitary House' right before picking up 'A Fatal Likeness' but unfortunately, ran out of time to do so.

This most recent installment of Charles Maddox's investi...more
Based on fact, A Treacherous Likeness is very much a work of fiction and represents the third novel by Lynn Shepherd to feature Charles Maddox Senior and the second to feature his nephew Charles Maddox, both thief-takers – private detectives to you and me. With a narrative that is both compelling and beautifully written the novel affords a great insight into 19th century living and the idiosyncrasies of that period taking in the sights and sounds of inner city living – the aromatic smells of hor...more
I'll be honest with you, peeps. Despite struggling with writing style, ultimately I found this book fascinating.

Lynn Shepherd slowly and painstakingly reassembled a fatal love triangle which consisted of Percy Bysshe Shelley, Mary Godwin (lately Shelley) and Claire Clairmont. She also reintroduced various mysterious events in Shelley's life and her own very Gothic version of what was happening around him and his women.

I freely admit that I was gobsmacked by A Fatal Likeness' series of events. It...more
I really enjoyed this book, which is based on the relationship between Mary Shelley, Percy Shelley, and Claire Clairmont. It's a work of fiction, but at the end in the author's notes, she explains what parts were based on actual facts and real letters in existence.

Not having much familiarity with any of the history relating to these characters, I went into this book looking for a mystery, and hoping for some good writing. I found both, and I have to say that the writing in this book was extremel...more
Gripping & complex Victorian mystery

The plot in this book is so complex as to be impossible to summarize ( I have posted a longer version on amazon.ca). Nutshell version: Charles Maddox, a 19th century private investigator ( and star of 2 previous books by the author) takes on a request by clients Sir Percy & Jane Shelley. He is the son of famous poet Percy Shelley & Mary Godwin (Frankenstein). They want him to round up any personal documents & letters of Shelley's that may be in...more
Melinda Jane Harrison
I want to preface this review with this: There are two things a reader feels when reading about a subject they know a lot about (1) How they would tell a story (2) How much research has been used. I would never write Percy Shelley like this, but I know how well he is written and how much research was used, not only in history but in what people thought about Shelley and Circle in 1850.

That said, the author has been totally inventive and original in her retelling of certain mysteries and tragic...more
There are many unanswered questions about the short life of Percy Bysshe Shelley, who lost many loved ones to untimely deaths. Lynn Shepherd's latest Charles Maddox novel proposes some possibilities. Maddox is hired by the widow (who is the author of Frankenstein), son, and daughter in law of the famous poet, who live in fear of the publication of some scandalous material pertaining to those deaths. The Shelleys engage Maddox to ascertain whether Claire Claremont, despised stepsister to the wido...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 39 40 next »
  • Letters From a Murderer: The First Jameson & Argenti Investigation
  • Three Souls
  • Angel City (The Angelus Trilogy #2)
  • The Tenth Witness
  • The Widows of Braxton County: A Novel
  • The Fall of Saints: A Novel
  • A Dangerous Fiction: A Mystery
  • The Gallery of Vanished Husbands
  • One Great Year
  • The Loved and the Lost (The Verona Trilogy #3)
  • Eloise
  • Jubilee's Journey (Wyattsville #2)
  • The Paris Winter
  • Havisham
  • The Trouble With Charlie
  • Aunty Lee's Delights: (Singaporean Mystery #1)
  • A White Room
  • The Black Country (The Murder Squad #2)
Lynn Shepherd studied English at Oxford in the 1980s, and got a doctorate degree there in 2006. She always wanted to be a writer and in 2000 she went freelance to see if it was possible to make her dream into reality. Ten years later her dream finally comes true. Murder at Mansfield Park was her first novel.

She describes her genre as 'literary mystery', and in 2012 she since published Tom All-Alo...more
More about Lynn Shepherd...
The Solitary House (Charles Maddox, #2) Murder at Mansfield Park  (Charles Maddox, #1) A Treacherous Likeness (Charles Maddox, #4) The Pierced Heart (Charles Maddox, #5) A Treacherous Likeness

Share This Book