Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Her Best-Kept Secret: Inside the Private Lives of Women Who Drink” as Want to Read:
Her Best-Kept Secret: Inside the Private Lives of Women Who Drink
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Her Best-Kept Secret: Inside the Private Lives of Women Who Drink

3.46 of 5 stars 3.46  ·  rating details  ·  346 ratings  ·  61 reviews
In the first book to document that American women are drinking more often than ever, and in ever-larger quantities, journalist Gabrielle Glaser explores the reasons behind this hiding-in-plain-sight epidemic—and why the most common remedy for it, enrollment in AA, is particularly ineffective.

Gabrielle Glaser began noticing a shift in culture after the birth of her third c
ebook, 256 pages
Published July 2nd 2013 by Simon & Schuster
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Her Best-Kept Secret, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Her Best-Kept Secret

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,029)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Jenny Sullivan
Being a member of AA, I was very interested to read this book. I did enjoy much of the historical account of drinking, especially how it pertains to women. The marketing of wine to the American Housewife was hilarious. I see people posting about needing wine, or other booze, at the end of the day, to deal with kids, husbands, etc- and it is totally accepted. The fact that this author went to TEN meetings of AA is a ridiculously small amount to be writing about it as she did. 90 meetings in 90 da ...more
Read my full review:

My opinion: As a former addictions counselor who specialized in adolescent female addictions, I must be honest in stating that this is THE WORST book on special populations addictions I have ever read. It was much more of a 196 page drama central magazine article, AA bashing bonanza, and advertisement for an alternative treatment program, which in the way Ms. Glaser wrote about the program I had to wonder if she doesn't have an investment in the organiza
Joy Matteson
Ms. Glaser has done three years of research on the relationship between women and alcohol. She has interviewed multiple women for this book, and did extensive background research on Alcoholics Anonymous, and taken the time to gather many statistics on the effects of alcohol on women. I think many people know that alcohol can affect women much more quickly and detrimentally than men (which is unfair! Ugh.), but Ms. Glaser also tells you why this is the case.
I can tell many people will not like t
First of all, we should all be thanking Gabrielle for this most important work. It's about time. For those of us who have been working for years to reveal the truth behind the lies of 12 step programs, this work is long overdue. Glaser's perspective comes from a journalistic viewpoint. She has no horse in the game other than the truth. The journalistic truth. The care for women. Hopefully, this will give steppers pause with their typical "you're killing alcoholics by turning them away from AA," ...more
Long overdue exposure of the revolving door con came that "rehab" is in the U.S. - especially for women. Also accurately reports on the failure of AA to protect women, as well as its terrible "success" rate for anyone.

Along with Fletcher's recent "Inside Rehab" it seems we're finally getting some accurate reporting on what actually works to offset 75 years of AA's mythology and failure.
This is an interesting study of how we treat alcoholism and women in this country. Women are drinking more than ever.That's good news/bad news. Good news is that women drink because they can, it's more socially acceptable, a good thing. Bad news is that their bodies can't handle it and out of control drinking is on the rise. The author makes the point that men's recovery (AA model) doesn't always work for women. Women are different from men, doh. 12 step approaches may not work.
There is a large
Cara Fox
Came across this book and thought it would be an interesting read after a series of joking conversations with other mom friends about how we drink so much more since we became moms, or (for those of us who work) drink so much more on the days we are home with our kids. This was a quick and interesting read, although not what I expected going into it. It was a pretty thoroughly researched account of the history of alcohol and women - how attitudes and perceptions of women who drink have changed o ...more
This is a great book for an introduction. In other words, it does NOT get heavily into the science and the studies it references. You'll have to do that on your own if you want more detail, but unlike at least half of addictions books it DOES include those evidence-based references.

I've seen other reviews upset that the author "bashed" AA. Honestly, I don't think she did... she merely explained why some people don't find that the ideal solution AND explained, with citations, why. She never says
I love books that push my envelope. Never questioning judges, courts, treatment advertisements; I thought faith based 12 step programs were the only options an abuser of alcohol had to find and maintain sobriety. Having to create some kind of higher power and give up oneself to that higher power was counterintuitive. Because of Glazer's impeccable research, a new world of recovery has become available to those living this nightmare all the while blaming themselves and suffering the guilt of bein ...more
Interesting history of how AA deals and.has dealt with women who have a drinking problem opposed to men. The double standard infiltrates every area of our lives. Trying to juggle careers, marriage, raising a family, keeping the household organized and the stressors of the world, many women, it seems, have turned to alcohol. Not all become alcoholics of course but it has become an issue in our society. Interesting read.
AA isn't for everyone, but it works for a lot of people--including a lot of women (one of them being me). Also, it's everywhere, and unlike Glaser's pricey "Twenty-First Century treatment," it's absolutely free. More about the book and the issue in my piece for the Atlantic:
Not a well written book. The author cites a lot of anecdotal evidence that women are drinking more, e.g. mentions that her friends, all of whom seem to be upper middle class Caucasian women, drink so much Chardonnay that they have to discard the bottles secretly.
Then, she denigrates AA, saying that too many men in the program take sexual advantage of new female members -- possibly true, but why not simply suggest AA groups specifically for women? Such groups do exist. Also, she recommends some
Tipsy Lit
Right out the gate I need to make a confession. When I was approached for this assignment I thought it was an adult contemporary novel which is my genre of choice. Happily I agreed to review a novel called, “Her Best Kept Secret” by author Gabrielle Glaser. Imagine my surprise when the book showed up and the full tile was, “Her Best Kept Secret – Why Women Drink – And How They Can Regain Control. This story provides endless entertainment for my girlfriends who know I love my wine and write eroti ...more
I originally checked out this book at the library thinking it might be a funny spin on why women drink, unfortunately, I was in for a (pleasant) surprise in that it actually dove into statistics of women drinking and AA.

Basically Her Best-Kept Secret...takes the reader on a journey from the early 20's to current time. Early on women were scorned if they touched alcohol. That if a man drank beer it was to relax after a long day working and macho, but if a woman drank beer she had a problem and wa
A smart, open-minded analysis of the psychology and history behind women and alcohol consumption in the United States. I found Glaser's approach informative and refreshing. Though I consider myself educated and informed, I have never come across a smart look at alcohol. I've always felt that the story we tell ourselves as a society about alcohol is too emotional, isolating and damning to many. A well-researched, thought-provoking book that raises important questions about the status quo.
Many of you might not know this about me, but when I have a problem that I don’t know how to deal with my first response is to research it as in-depth as possible. That makes it a bit awkward when I blog about everything I read (this is my journal reading journal as much as it is your review site). At the same time it’s great because I get to share interesting books, like Her Best-Kept Secret, that I never would have read. And I force myself to explore and synthesize in-depth a lot of topics.

Interesting historical perspective on women and alcohol, with some critique of AA toward the second half of the book. Well, not a critique of the 12 steps exactly, but a bit of historical context on women's role (or lack thereof) in the formation of the program, the lack of good studies done on the effectiveness of the program (which the author admits would be hard to do, given the "anonymous" part of AA--but she questions why it's the go-to program given that reality), and the fact that it's mo ...more
Tara Hun-Dorris
This is a short, easy read. I like the author's general question of why we don't treat addiction with evidence-based approaches as we do other chronic diseases. However, I do not trust her use of numbers/data, and the research probably could have been more in-depth.
Interesting read. Should have been longer. I've been intrigued for some time the fascination of women with wine. Interesting history on prohibition and the women that were in Favor of it (and against it). Also, unique take on women in AA which the book basically made seem like a molest fest against women.

It wasn't super "self help" which was good because it was not why I was drawn to it. I wanted to read about the societal impact of what appears to be a relatively new fascination of women and w
Kate Buntenbach
Gabrielle Glaser should have stuck to the historical aspect of women and alcohol because that is as far as her knowledge goes. Her assertions are ridiculous and she is definitely not an authority on addiction. This book will likely do more harm than good for any woman struggling with alcohol. AA is certainly not the only path to sobriety but her arguments against it are complete bullshit and anecdotal at best. This book did not provide any great alternatives to AA so I am left just scratching my ...more
Dale Stonehouse
This is a very important book as a stepping stone to fully exposing 12-step programs for what they have always been - an attempt to restore addicted people to making a contribution to a growing economy. More than that, it exposes the shabby treatment women receive too often in AA groups, up to and including sexual abuse and rape. Even absent this evidence, the traditional approach to substance abuse has never worked for those for whom trauma in childhood or as adults is the root cause and the ad ...more
This book starts off as "Lean In" with a glass of wine. I was most interested in this first quarter which discusses why women's drinking is becoming so common. It discusses the history of women's association with alcohol (fascinating!) and continues to discuss societal pressures on women today, i.e. especially those charged with full child-rearing responsibilities and those trying vainly to balance work-and-home, and how these pressures compare to those of yesteryear (leading them to drink). Thi ...more
Initially I expected this book to be judgmental of women who drink, but on the contrary it was a very insightful examination on exactly that cultural bias. From the early advertisements to sell wine to women to the unwelcoming response they receive when seeking help, Her Best-Kept Secret covered the full range of the female perspective on alcohol consumption and abuse. As a woman who chooses to imbibe responsibly and in moderation, I was both shocked and fascinated by the reported indiscretions ...more
I think it discusses some of the reasoning why many women drink to excess these days, though I feel that the answers she give are only accessible to wealthy women. What she should have gone into are other approaches to 12 step programs as well as research and other books people can read. I also felt like she didn't provide enough empirical evidence regarding how the working mother's role is still 100% working and 100% mother.

Found some interesting ideas in here. I'm a little disappointed at the narrow niche of women who drink that is portrayed - primarily middle or upper class women who use wine to excess. The author makes some disturbing points about AA and gives a nice plug to a couple who run a 5-day retreat in California. But overall, this only looks at a sliver of the alcohol problem and perhaps the easiest sliver to treat.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from Goodreads Giveaways in exchange for posting my honest review.

Her Best-Kept Secret wasn’t what I thought it would be from the description on Goodreads. I made it through the first three chapters and then decided not to finish reading the book. From what I did read, I felt that the author is presenting the history of alcohol and Americans, citing many statistics along the way, with an emphasis on what she feels is proof of a steady rise in alcoh
Drawing from statistics, news trends and social mores, Glaser explores how dramatically the relationship between women and drinking has evolved in the last century. She dedicates plenty of pages exploring how AA may not be the most suitable treatment option for females and too few pages delving into more effective approaches, but the book still contains lots of worthwhile insights.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from Goodreads Giveaways in exchange for posting my honest review.

Her Best-Kept Secret wasn’t what I thought it would be. I made it through the first three chapters and then decided not to finish reading the book. From what I did read, I felt that the author is presenting the history of alcohol and Americans, citing many statistics along the way, with an emphasis on what she feels is proof of a steady rise in alcohol consumption by American women o
It was an interesting read, and pulls together various things that you know, but maybe hadn't connected. It seemed like more than half the book was on AA and how it didn't work for many women out there (a historical perspective). A worthwhile read.
In this book, Glaser examines the growing trend of women who admit to problematic drinking habits. She looks at the history of Alcoholics Anonymous & at how many women have found AA to be ineffective and in some cases, harmful, and she provides several other alternatives to AA, including a prescription medication which decreases cravings by blocking the endorphins produced from alcohol. The drug does not prevent drinking completely, but tends to decrease the number of drinks per day.

It's an
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 34 35 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Price of Silence: The Duke Lacrosse Scandal, the Power of the Elite, and the Corruption of Our Great Universities
  • The Fantasy Fallacy: Exposing the Deeper Meaning Behind Sexual Thoughts
  • Drink: The Intimate Relationship Between Women and Alcohol
  • Tangled Webs: How False Statements are Undermining America: From Martha Stewart to Bernie Madoff
  • Being of Power
  • Slaying the Mermaid: Women and the Culture of Sacrifice
  • The Burden of Sympathy: How Families Cope with Mental Illness
  • A Deadly Wandering: A Tale of Tragedy and Redemption in the Age of Attention
  • Can't Remember What I Forgot: The Good News from the Front Lines of Memory Research
  • Hard News: Twenty-one Brutal Months at The New York Times and How They Changed the American Media
  • The XX Factor
  • Claudia Silver to the Rescue
  • Moral Combat: Black Atheists, Gender Politics, and the Values Wars
  • Am I Thin Enough Yet?: The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of Identity
  • Economix: How and Why Our Economy Works (and Doesn't Work), in Words and Pictures
  • Our Great Big American God: A Short History of Our Ever-Growing Deity
  • Medieval Underpants and Other Blunders: A Writer's (and Editor's) Guide to Keeping Historical Fiction Free of Common Anachronisms, Errors, and Myths [Third Edition]
  • Generation Roe: Inside the Future of the Pro-Choice Movement
Gabrielle Glaser is the best-selling author of Her Best Kept Secret: Why Women Drink and How They Can Regain Control.

Glaser grew up in Tangent, Oregon, the Grass Seed Capital of the World (pop. 440). She spent her teenage summers driving John Deere combines on her family farm, listening to an unusual mix of local radio programming: the BeeGees, Marvin Gaye, Johnny Cash, and NPR. She was an indiff
More about Gabrielle Glaser...

Share This Book