76th out of 522 books
—
1,282 voters
September Girls
by
Bennett Madison (Goodreads Author)
When Sam's dad whisks him and his brother off to a remote beach town for the summer, he's all for it-- at first. Sam soon realizes, though, that this place is anything but ordinary. Time seems to slow down around here, and everywhere he looks, there are beautiful blond girls. Girls who seem inexplicably drawn to him.
Then Sam meets DeeDee, one of the Girls, and she's diffe...more
Then Sam meets DeeDee, one of the Girls, and she's diffe...more
Hardcover, 342 pages
Published
May 21st 2013
by HarperTeen
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
HarperCollins YA 2013 Paranormal/Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror/Thriller books
52nd out of 113 books
—
224 voters
More lists with this book...
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
May 25, 2013
Blythe
rated it
1 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Recommend? LOL. You're funny, Goodreads. You're funny.
Shelves:
1-star,
2013-reads,
almost-fell-asleep,
arc,
caught-in-a-bad-romance,
disappointments,
doesn-t-deserve-the-hype,
highly-anticipating-2013,
hooray-for-masochism,
i-totally-saw-that-coming,
judge-a-book-by-the-cover,
losing-my-faith-in-humanity,
snark-bait-ooh-ah-ah,
synopses-that-lie,
take-your-insta-love-and-leave,
under-the-sea,
unmet-potential,
no-stars-for-you,
read-reviewed

September Girls has inspired me...
...to create a 'no-stars-for-you' shelf, that is. With unbelievably awful writing, a main character who is as big of a dick as the one he feels the need to constantly remind us he has, and a plot with less aim than me that one time I decided to play a round of Call of Duty, September Girls is undoubtedly one of the worst books I have ever read in my life, and the fact that it is now a published novel is nothing short of a puzzle to me.
But hey, don't take my wo...more
Apr 28, 2013
Steph Sinclair
rated it
1 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Absolutely no one. Not even your goldfish.
Recommended to Steph by:
Myself because apparently I lack self-control
Shelves:
2013-release,
young-adult,
mermaids,
pretty-covers,
harpercollins,
print-arc,
edelweiss,
ebook,
e-arc,
2013-reads,
ahhhhh-my-eyes,
alternating-povs,
can-t-believe-i-finished,
confused-the-hell-outta-me,
didn-t-care-for-it,
disappointment,
door-stopper,
glad-it-s-over,
hated-it-with-a-firey-passion,
kill-it-with-fire,
le-sigh,
lots-of-fail-going-on-here,
lol-what,
made-me-angry,
no-just-no,
no-stars-for-you,
ranty-review,
rubbish,
stop-it-already,
strange,
that-cover-misled-me,
to-giveaway,
what-kind-of-ending-was-that,
where-s-my-chocolate,
who-published-this,
why-why-why-did-i-read-it,
youve-got-to-be-kidding-me,
slut-shaming-ftw,
male-pov
Actual rating: NO STARS
I can't believe I survived. Should I laugh? Cry?
Definitely both.

Full disclosure: I went into this book with a suspicion that I might not enjoy it after my bookish twin panned it. But since I requested this book and was sent a paper ARC from the publisher, I thought I'd try to go in with an open mind and try it out.
That was probably not the best decision I've ever made in life.
It goes without saying that this review will be long, contain spoilers and quotes that might possi...more
I can't believe I survived. Should I laugh? Cry?
Definitely both.

Full disclosure: I went into this book with a suspicion that I might not enjoy it after my bookish twin panned it. But since I requested this book and was sent a paper ARC from the publisher, I thought I'd try to go in with an open mind and try it out.
That was probably not the best decision I've ever made in life.
It goes without saying that this review will be long, contain spoilers and quotes that might possi...more
Apr 29, 2013
Debby
rated it
1 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
ABSOLUTELY NO ONE. JUST RUN GUYS.
Recommended to Debby by:
Myself, because I'm stupid.
Shelves:
harpercollins,
pretty-cover,
own-egalley,
waiting-on-wednesday,
reviewed,
2013-reads,
bad-romance,
characters-i-want-to-shake,
could-have-been-better,
cover-fraud,
disappointing,
how-did-i-finish,
le-sigh,
love-triangle,
mermaids,
pov-multiple,
romance,
paranormal,
stand-alone,
young-adult,
kill-it-with-fire,
worst-ever,
despicable,
infuriating,
hated-every-minute,
stab-stab-stab,
sexism-galore,
slut-shaming-hooray,
zero-stars,
run-just-run
NO STARS

No. No no no no no. No no. No. This book is one of the worst I have ever read. Hell, it may well be the worst. Save yourself the inevitable frustration and disappointment of reading this book. Please. Do yourself a favor. Let me tell you why. Cue my longest review ever.
After only 15%, my gut told me to throw my e-reader across the room and give up. But I am not one to easily DNF books, and I really felt I should review this one. So I kept on going. But this isn't going to be pretty guys....more

No. No no no no no. No no. No. This book is one of the worst I have ever read. Hell, it may well be the worst. Save yourself the inevitable frustration and disappointment of reading this book. Please. Do yourself a favor. Let me tell you why. Cue my longest review ever.
After only 15%, my gut told me to throw my e-reader across the room and give up. But I am not one to easily DNF books, and I really felt I should review this one. So I kept on going. But this isn't going to be pretty guys....more
See more reviews at YA Midnight Reads
This review and book has inappropriate language for young readers. I am in no way intending to discriminate the author.
0.01 star DNF at 34%
Thank you HarperTeen for sending me this copy. No compensation was given or taken to alter this review.
'"Dude," he said. "This summer we're gonna get you laid, bro. It'll do you some good."
"I don't see what we has to do with it," I said. "Isn't getting laid like something you generally do on your own.?"
Let's take...more
This review and book has inappropriate language for young readers. I am in no way intending to discriminate the author.
0.01 star DNF at 34%
Thank you HarperTeen for sending me this copy. No compensation was given or taken to alter this review.
'"Dude," he said. "This summer we're gonna get you laid, bro. It'll do you some good."
"I don't see what we has to do with it," I said. "Isn't getting laid like something you generally do on your own.?"
Let's take...more
Where to begin? There's a weight to certain books that reminds a reader why he or she reads. It's not always there, but when it is it makes your fingers burn, your heart heavy...it tires your eyes. That's where this book has left me, heated, exhausted, yet needing more...another dive back to the listless days of surf and sand. Madison has a distinct way of weaving poetry and metaphor that lends magic to his prose; that's what I enjoy most about his writing. There's always an eerie, fascinating u...more
Apr 23, 2013
Skyla
marked it as not-interested-due-to-reasons
I can't be bothered to read this anymore. I am tired of arguing with people. I have no opinion so now everyone leave me the fuck alone.
I don't want to hear anything more about this book. I don't want to see it in my feed and I don't want to talk about it anymore. If it is mentioned in my presence again I will start deleting people. I am so tired of the bullshit.
I don't want to hear anything more about this book. I don't want to see it in my feed and I don't want to talk about it anymore. If it is mentioned in my presence again I will start deleting people. I am so tired of the bullshit.
Edit 21/5/13: GUYS! QUICK! THE BOOK COMES OUT TODAY, GO BUY IT!!
I'm worried it may sell out because of all the glowing reviews.
I am pleasantly surprised.
No, actually.
I went into this book thinking I wouldn’t be able to make it past the first chapter. I thought for sure that within fifteen minutes I would have put it back on my bookshelf to sit there forever but that was not the case. There actually wasn’t anything wrong with it for the first few chapters…except that it was immensely boring but I...more
I'm worried it may sell out because of all the glowing reviews.
I am pleasantly surprised.
No, actually.
I went into this book thinking I wouldn’t be able to make it past the first chapter. I thought for sure that within fifteen minutes I would have put it back on my bookshelf to sit there forever but that was not the case. There actually wasn’t anything wrong with it for the first few chapters…except that it was immensely boring but I...more
I gave this book the old college try, I really did. I stuck it out for more than half, and it never grabbed my interest. Tragic, right? Because that cover is beautiful. I wanted this book to be the same way, and sadly, I did not enjoy it at all. It felt slow and strange and just...odd.
Not only that, but Sam's voice didn't feel genuine, to the point that for me, his character didn't feel real. Also, the "love" story between he and DeeDee seemed to come out of nowhere and have no basis at all for...more
Not only that, but Sam's voice didn't feel genuine, to the point that for me, his character didn't feel real. Also, the "love" story between he and DeeDee seemed to come out of nowhere and have no basis at all for...more
Jun 04, 2013
Christal
rated it
2 of 5 stars
Shelves:
arcs,
ya,
2013-rlftci-book-count,
2013-nbrc,
disappointing,
mermaids,
male-lead,
urban-fantasy
See this review and others like it at BadassBookReviews.com! Check out our Read With Caution feature for a cautionary review of this and Erin McCarthy's True.
September Girls was a very strange novel. I think it will leave definitely leave readers divided. Some will love the coarseness of the characters and the open-ended mystery, while others will be frustrated with the lack of answers and general "unfinished" feeling of the novel. But hey, it has a gorgeous cover.
I personally did not love Septe...more
September Girls was a very strange novel. I think it will leave definitely leave readers divided. Some will love the coarseness of the characters and the open-ended mystery, while others will be frustrated with the lack of answers and general "unfinished" feeling of the novel. But hey, it has a gorgeous cover.
I personally did not love Septe...more
You can find more of my reviews at Forever 17 Books.
DNF
Welp. I thought I would still give this one a try, despite the many poor reviews that have been circulating around the blogosphere. I was first attracted to the pretty cover and awesome title. I mean, I was born in September so I'm a September girl, right? Unfortunately, I found myself lacking any connection and flounced after 37%.
Sam is whisked away to a beach town by his father and brother for the summer, after his mother walks out on them...more
DNF
Welp. I thought I would still give this one a try, despite the many poor reviews that have been circulating around the blogosphere. I was first attracted to the pretty cover and awesome title. I mean, I was born in September so I'm a September girl, right? Unfortunately, I found myself lacking any connection and flounced after 37%.
Sam is whisked away to a beach town by his father and brother for the summer, after his mother walks out on them...more
This book was so obviously written by a man...An island full of beautiful, blonde skanks that are all after the male protagonist...? Not to mention all the sex-speak, "ho-s", and the self-pleasuring--Yes, definitely written by a man! and the female characters, including his mother were completely unfathomable. Even in the end it was unclear, is the mother suppose to be more understandable because of "The Mermaids?" maybe, I don't know.
With that said, I honestly didn't think it was as bad as the...more
With that said, I honestly didn't think it was as bad as the...more
This was my initial thought regarding this book ---> The best thing about this book is the cover.
While my overall feelings about SEPTEMBER GIRLS have not necessarily changed, they have been altered a bit and here's why...
I had a fantastic conversation about this book today with the equally fantastic Diana Peterfreund (FOR DARKNESS SHOWS THE STARS) who shed some new light on this for me.
What originally attracted me to this book was a combination of hype, synopsis and serious cover love. I was...more
While my overall feelings about SEPTEMBER GIRLS have not necessarily changed, they have been altered a bit and here's why...
I had a fantastic conversation about this book today with the equally fantastic Diana Peterfreund (FOR DARKNESS SHOWS THE STARS) who shed some new light on this for me.
What originally attracted me to this book was a combination of hype, synopsis and serious cover love. I was...more
September Girls is told from Sam's point of view. He is a 17-year-old boy, and the book covers everything you would expect to go with that - cussing, a lot of it, sex/masturbating, fantasies, talk about women, especially their boobs, real stuff 17 year old boys think about and do for the most part. He is also dealing with his family falling apart. When I saw the cover I was expecting romance, love, mermaids, etc. That isn't what it is about. I never really got the clear picture on the whole merm...more
You should know that I'm an out liner. I always have to write something good, something bad and explain in a few words why I did or didn't like it. I know dumb, but it helps me write out my full review. I went back and re-read September Girls just to get a different feel for it and find something positive about it. I honestly couldn't find one thing.
Sam's mother has just walked out of his life and his father is having a midlife crisis. His dad decides to quit his job, sell everything and take hi...more
Sam's mother has just walked out of his life and his father is having a midlife crisis. His dad decides to quit his job, sell everything and take hi...more
Apr 01, 2013
Brandi Kosiner
added it
What I Liked: I liked the sense of family on Sam's side. The interactions and conversations with his brother and Dad really felt realistic.
The setting was also well done. I felt the descriptions were well done and made me feel part of the scenery and story.
The pain and set up of Sam's mom and her abandonment. I think that a lot can relate with the theme and feelings or knows someone who could. Sam is a deep character in a lot of regards and emotional in others. Caught up in his hurt and ang...more
The setting was also well done. I felt the descriptions were well done and made me feel part of the scenery and story.
The pain and set up of Sam's mom and her abandonment. I think that a lot can relate with the theme and feelings or knows someone who could. Sam is a deep character in a lot of regards and emotional in others. Caught up in his hurt and ang...more
Originally posted at Gypsy Reviews
I received an eARC from HarperTeen via Edelweiss. Thank you!
Congratulations September Girls, you have gotten my first 1 star rating ever. I don’t give these out to any old book, I give these even more rarely than I give 5 star reviews. Just fantastic with your portrayal in women as hos, lots of descriptions about women mainly pertaining to their chest area and including lots of naked women because naked women are everywhere! With a dash of horny boys and charact...more
I received an eARC from HarperTeen via Edelweiss. Thank you!
Congratulations September Girls, you have gotten my first 1 star rating ever. I don’t give these out to any old book, I give these even more rarely than I give 5 star reviews. Just fantastic with your portrayal in women as hos, lots of descriptions about women mainly pertaining to their chest area and including lots of naked women because naked women are everywhere! With a dash of horny boys and charact...more
Feb 18, 2013
Annabel ♥
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Shelves:
arc,
for-review,
adore,
four-stars,
amazingness,
in-my-shelf-completed,
inspiring,
idea-is-genius,
review
*An ARC was provided by Water Street Books for review purposes*
Wow. What a beautiful book, to say the least. I don't think I've ever read anything so unique and powerful before.
This book has alternating point of views, which I really enjoyed. I don't usually read books with a guy's POV--not as a rule or anything, but usually I just end up reading books narrated by girls. The few times I have read a book with a guy's POV, I've liked it. Well let me just say that I loved Sam's point of view. He wa...more
Wow. What a beautiful book, to say the least. I don't think I've ever read anything so unique and powerful before.
This book has alternating point of views, which I really enjoyed. I don't usually read books with a guy's POV--not as a rule or anything, but usually I just end up reading books narrated by girls. The few times I have read a book with a guy's POV, I've liked it. Well let me just say that I loved Sam's point of view. He wa...more
Apr 26, 2013
Julianna Helms
marked it as never-ever-says-big-brother
OMG THIS IS THE BEST COVER I'VE EVER SEEN.
Edited 26 April 2013
Yeah no. The reviews have made me realize just how much of a flopping crappiness this book is. Another case of the cover being beautiful and the book a rambunctious decree of death on humanity. (*cough* Mara Dyer) But yeah. Noooo. Not reading this. I wish I could have the original cover art to hang on my wall, though, without the title and author.
Edited 26 April 2013
Yeah no. The reviews have made me realize just how much of a flopping crappiness this book is. Another case of the cover being beautiful and the book a rambunctious decree of death on humanity. (*cough* Mara Dyer) But yeah. Noooo. Not reading this. I wish I could have the original cover art to hang on my wall, though, without the title and author.
This review and more on Sab The Book Eater
Don’t let the pretty cover fool you – this book is far from fluffy and sweet. September Girls has a lot of cussing and sex… or talk of sex. I can’t say there was a lot of sex because Sam, the main character, barely got some and he complained about it a lot. I’ve never read so many F bombs or such vivid descriptions of people making out in a YA book. I understand how a lot of readers can get turned off or even disgusted by this. It’s a young adult book, a...more
Don’t let the pretty cover fool you – this book is far from fluffy and sweet. September Girls has a lot of cussing and sex… or talk of sex. I can’t say there was a lot of sex because Sam, the main character, barely got some and he complained about it a lot. I’ve never read so many F bombs or such vivid descriptions of people making out in a YA book. I understand how a lot of readers can get turned off or even disgusted by this. It’s a young adult book, a...more
2.5 Stars
September Girls was a story that had an interesting and dream-like quality, much like the lazy summer that Sam lives in for the duration of this book. Sam and his brother seem to be completely thrown off by their mother's hiatus from the family, so they end up in a place their dad loved as a teen and find that the island holds some pretty bizarre secrets. I loved the way the girls and the events were described by Sam, but I did not love the narrative in their voices. It seemed out of pl...more
September Girls was a story that had an interesting and dream-like quality, much like the lazy summer that Sam lives in for the duration of this book. Sam and his brother seem to be completely thrown off by their mother's hiatus from the family, so they end up in a place their dad loved as a teen and find that the island holds some pretty bizarre secrets. I loved the way the girls and the events were described by Sam, but I did not love the narrative in their voices. It seemed out of pl...more
Sam's Mom left months ago. His older brother is away at college, so he's left trying to hold things together at home. After his brother comes home for summer break his Dad announces they are going to the beach for the summer. Just like that. When they get there, they start to notice something strange about all the girls. They are all beautiful, and all seem the same. And they all keep staring at him. Then he meets Dee Dee. She is like the rest of them but also different. What is it about this to...more
Apr 26, 2013
Bobbie
added it

After Steph from Cuddlebuggery somehow suffered through this crap. And wrote this awesome review, there is no way. No way. I am going anywhere near this book.
I was sent an Advance Reader's Copy of this book for free won compliments of Goodreads & the publisher/marketing. This author is talented & the story was pretty interesting & well-written. Unfortunately, I won't be able to recommend it to any of the YAs I know, because it has so many swear words! They are everywhere, all the time, & pretty much gratuitous! Ick!
That said, the story is about Sirens. (It's sort of like Hans Christian Anderson's telling of the Little Mermaid where sh...more
That said, the story is about Sirens. (It's sort of like Hans Christian Anderson's telling of the Little Mermaid where sh...more
You should know that I'm an outliner. I always have to write something good, something bad and explain in a few words why I did or didn't like it. I know dumb, but it helps me write out my full review. I went back and re-read September Girls just to get a different feel for it and find something positive about it. I honestly couldn't find one thing.
Sam's mother has just walked out of his life and his father is having a midlife crisis. His dad decides to quit his job, sell everything and take his...more
Sam's mother has just walked out of his life and his father is having a midlife crisis. His dad decides to quit his job, sell everything and take his...more
Love, love, love this book. YA fiction is notoriously devoid of boys--both as readers and as writers and as characters--but here we have Sam, one of the realest young men I've seen depicted in YA fiction ever. Which technically isn't a huge challenge to defeat, since so many of the male characters in YA fiction are created as idealized versions of how we'd like teenage boys to be. But Bennett Madison has given us a real one, and his voice is by turns poetic and then ironically utterly sarcastic...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Apr 17, 2013
Molli (at Once Upon a Prologue)
marked it as tried-to-read-but-couldn-t-get-into
UGH.
No really.
First of all, I am all for swearing. I swear a LOT in real life. But I think that several times EACH PAGE might be a little too much. I was psyched for this one at first because a guy writing YA? HOLLA. But noooooooooooo. Just NO. Just because you are writing a guy's POV doesn't mean they can't have some depth to them. And the way the MC thought about girls? UGH, NO.
Plus, the narration really didn't grab me, and the weird switches to the "Girl's" POV between chapters was odd. So...more
No really.
First of all, I am all for swearing. I swear a LOT in real life. But I think that several times EACH PAGE might be a little too much. I was psyched for this one at first because a guy writing YA? HOLLA. But noooooooooooo. Just NO. Just because you are writing a guy's POV doesn't mean they can't have some depth to them. And the way the MC thought about girls? UGH, NO.
Plus, the narration really didn't grab me, and the weird switches to the "Girl's" POV between chapters was odd. So...more

Thanks to HarperTeen for providing a copy for review!
ACTUAL RATING: 0/5, DNF
Honestly, I didn’t even plan on reading this book. Just from the synopsis I wasn’t sure I’d even like it. But I got an ARC in one of my Harper packages, so I figured, why the hell not? Sigh. Now I know why.
I would never call anyone’s hard work crap, because I know writing a book is hard and time-consuming and probably devours a little piece of your soul; but it’s been a very long time since I’ve read anything this terr...more
Oh, it's case of the deceiving cover again. I mean, the cover was absolutely gorgeous and the synopsis was definitely intriguing! But the actual story was, I found, very different from what I expected.
So the first thing was the writing. It was a bit awkward sometimes and the cussing was...extreme. Every few sentences and almost every paragraph had a cuss word and it got super old super fast. The way it was written was also a bit awkward and while there was an air of mystery surrounding the stor...more
So the first thing was the writing. It was a bit awkward sometimes and the cussing was...extreme. Every few sentences and almost every paragraph had a cuss word and it got super old super fast. The way it was written was also a bit awkward and while there was an air of mystery surrounding the stor...more
May 20, 2013
Dayla
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Shelves:
arc,
edelweiss,
addicting,
awesome-ya,
beautiful-writing,
coming-of-age,
contemporary,
down-to-earth-supernatural,
family,
fast-read,
good-character-development,
great-descriptions,
great-pacing,
great-writing,
island,
magic,
mystery,
mythology,
not-perfect-but-fun,
older-ya,
powerful-women,
romance,
sassy,
sex,
strong-protagonist,
surprising,
tough-chicks,
young-adult
Review first appeared on my blog: Book Addict 24-7
I received a copy from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review
Bennett Madison's September Girls is a provocative young adult novel that features a teenaged boy dealing with a family that is falling apart. When his father suggests an impromptu trip to a beach town as a way to start-over, he is more than a little skeptic.
September Girls isn't a book that will be loved by everyone, thanks to the cussing and the sexually frustrated thoughts of a...more
I received a copy from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review
Bennett Madison's September Girls is a provocative young adult novel that features a teenaged boy dealing with a family that is falling apart. When his father suggests an impromptu trip to a beach town as a way to start-over, he is more than a little skeptic.
September Girls isn't a book that will be loved by everyone, thanks to the cussing and the sexually frustrated thoughts of a...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SLCLS Genre Study: YA ARC | 3 | 26 | Jun 04, 2013 05:23pm | |
| }~>O MERBOOKS...: September Girls by Bennett Madison | 2 | 52 | Jan 30, 2013 11:57am |
Bennett Madison is the author of the Lulu Dark mysteries and, most recently, The Blonde of the Joke (Harper Teen 2009). His next young adult novel, September Girls, will be released in May 2013.
More about Bennett Madison...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Jeff is the annoying kind of Scrabble player who plays a lot of obscure two-letter words that shouldn't count but for whatever reason are considered legitimate. My father is the annoying kind of Scrabble player who takes hours with his turn and then plays deliberately misspelled words that no one has the heart to call him out on. I am the perfect Scrabble player, both serious and considerate. Obviously I lost by a lot.”
—
6 people liked it
“We have learned by now that our beauty does not count as a possession. The only thing we truly own is our legend.”
—
5 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...


















































































May 24, 2013 06:17am
Jun 12, 2013 01:45pm